Instead elaborating, I'll just make an analogy: We do not need to run, or to lift weights, nor exercise at all. We have transportation and tools. But, those activities are still highly valuable, even though we do not use them for work nor need them in everyday situations, because our body evolved to need them.
So, math puzzles may not be directly useful, but they prepare the brain for other utilitarian activities. Ok, maybe we do not need puzzles, but math tasks in general is one of the best if not THE best exercise for abstract logical thinking.
At least exercise keeps you healthy even if you hate it.
For example, if somebody says 40 million people in the US are [afflicted with|believe|whatever] something, I automatically think "that's about 1 in ten" and my bullshit filter makes a judgement.
So getting precise numbers is perhaps not so important (maybe it never really was), but being able to estimate quickly it good.
And, FWIW, you'd be surprised how well you can do at the grocery store if you estimate your bill simply by rounding every item to the nearest dollar. Easy to track, comes out remarkably close.
here's an old paper excerpt[1] about the "use-it-or-lose-it" nature of your brain:
> The protective effects of an active cognitive lifestyle arise through multiple biological pathways, new research suggests. For some time researchers have been aware of a link between what we do with our brains and the long term risk for dementia. In general, those who are more mentally active or maintain an active cognitive lifestyle throughout their lives are at lower risk. New research throws some light on what may be happening at the biological level.
[1]: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/04/120425094358.ht...
I think you are conflating 'Math' and 'mental arithmetic'. While the 2nd may help towards the first, it is neither a requirement nor an abstract thinking task on its own.
The joke's on them. I carry a supercomputer with wireless access to the collective knowledge of humanity in my pocket.
More seriously, if we assume we only have limited time and capacity to learn things, these tools surely free us from learning mundane "tricks" and allow us to further explore more interesting subjects. Sure, an understanding of arithmetic is important, so that we can verify our tools are working. But once that's obtained, let's move on.
It's weird to me that a class of people who like to puff about how intelligent they are are so proud of refusing to function at an incredibly basic human skill.
I can calculate 16x180 in my head, but I would still pull out my smartphone to do it if the result is in any way important. Not because I'm lazy, but I know that the device won't make some silly mistake while doing it.
The irony that the loss of ability to concentrate is partly a result of smartphones is not lost on me.
If you do both, or at least estimate the result, you can check the results.
I don't think you'd make a silly mistake when using a calculator, but I think other people might.
I think (although I have nothing to support me) that most people cannot use percentages in any meaningful way. If you say "I have a tv that currently costs $300, and I'm going to give you a 10% discount. What will it cost after the discount?" then they can show you the buttons they'd push to get that result. But if you ask them a slightly different version "I have a washing machine that currently costs $800. I've already given you a 10% discount. How much did it cost before the discount?" then I think you'll find a bunch of people who don't know what buttons to push. (Or worse don't know that they don't know and who'll get a close but incorrect answer.)
So, that's not the kind of mental math trick talked about in the article, but calculators are tools and tools are most useful to people who know how to use them and most calculators and calculator apps don't make it easy for people who don't know math.
I would consider a trick something like, multiply large number by really large number in your head. That is a waste of time.
Something that I saw on HN not too long ago that really benefited me was something I should have been taught in school. I probably was - but as I mentioned. It was taught in a rush and I had forgotten it, if it was even taught at all.
What is 36% of 25? I'll be honest. I find that's a pretty tricky one to do in my head. I can estimate it to 8 by taking 33% of 24 (close enough, right?). So I'd estimate it to be a bit over 8. Honest guess.
Well the trick I learned on HN is to reverse it. Since % is really multiplication, the commutative property applies. Take 25% of 36 instead and bam! The answer is a flat 9. No estimating needed.
Now the "I'm an idiot" part comes from the fact I always did percentage as multiplication of a decimal. I should have intuitively put 2 and 2 together and figured out the commutative property applies. I hadn't. :)
Given the popularity and support the tip received - I'm going to guess I'm a good example of the average person. The average person was taught percentages in a way that they can convert to decimals but don't think about the math in decimal form. So they miss out on something that is obvious once someone stops and points it out.
So to cut my rambling short: simple math is rarely simple for the average person. The average person, from my experience, is worse at math than they would probably like to admit. (And I'm also an average person.)
Solving 25% of 36 then multiplying by 100 (effectively removing the "%" part of 25%) gets 900. It's also a bit indirect, so many people would overlook it (myself included).
If you were to ask me what 36 * 25 was in most any other context I'd do 40 * 25 = 1,000 - 4*25 = 900.
Although, thanks to your prompt, I'm likely to remember to see if I can cheat with percentages. :) Smaller numbers and fractions are more intuitive for me.
Edit:
To the poster below, you only need the multiplication tables and basic addition. I don't see the big deal.
18 * 10 = 180
10 * 6 = 60
8 * 6 = 48
= 288
16x180
...
= 288
I think he overestimates the capabilities of himself.He also misidentified the tricky part of the problem as multiplication and addition. Holding intermediate place values is far more likely to cause issues, as we can see from his mistake.
If we allow for simple mistakes, everyone here can do that multiplication in their head without issue. But that was babuskov's exact point. Calculators help with silly mistakes of this sort and they're present nearly everywhere.
I agree: holding values is quite difficult in many cases, but the whole discussion is about this example specifically. You only need to remember 3 values in this case, which should be easy for most people.
And no I do not overestimate myself. I usually suffer from imposter syndrome.
16 * 16 = 256
16 * 2 = 32
256+32 = 288
16 * 18 = (17-1)*(17+1) = 17^2-1 = 289-1 = 288.
Provided of course you know your squares.
16x18 = 17x17 - 1 = 289 - 1 = 288
Te squares up to 20x20 everybody should know by head.The only problem is that answer. Seeing 288 (2x12^2) immediately made me spend time double-checking the factors in the multiplicands.
If you do mental math, it makes exercises way more fun if you know more interesting numbers. The 16x18 example is an example.
For another example, consider
42x49
When primed by 16x18, one might consider writing it as (45-3)x((45+3)+1) = 45^2-3^2 + 42 = 2025 - 9 + 42 = 2058
(This works for many pairs of numbers that are relatively close together, only requires one 'large' multiplication, and that one is simple, as stated in the article)But of course, half-way through, one may realize it is
6x7 x 7x7 = 7^4 - 7^3
Now, 7^3 = 343 (easy to remember in combination with 3^5 = 243), but 7^4 = 2401, for me, doesn't pop out (when you say 2401, I know it's 7^4, but not vice versa)Meanwhile 49 is close to 50, so we have
42x50 - 42 = 2100 - 42 = 2058
That is faster, but somewhat dull.Meanwhile, as far as we know, the savant calculator just takes the dull road, adding 40x40, 40x(2+9), and 2x9, doesn't get distracted, and produces the right answer in a tenth of the time I take. He has less fun, though, because I take detours to visit tourist attractions.
It also can make taxi rides more fun.
16*200=3200
16*20=320
16*180=3200-320=2880Having the first 30 squares committed to memory has been pretty useful for me.
18 x 16 = (17+1)(17-1) = 10(17²-1)
Also, a lot of the time these sorts of things aren't going to be used directly, but are more of an indicator of what to type in to a calculator. Knowing how to do something in your head informs how you do it on a calculator even if you don't actually use the trick yourself. A lot of people who are bad at maths don't even know where to start, so having a device to do the actual sums doesn't help them.
I'm not suggesting that you be totally braindead and not invest in learning the basics of mental arithmetic. I'm saying that going deeper than that initial basic investment isn't as useful today and doesn't make as much sense as in the past.
For example, I'd consider the 75^2 example in this blogpost very cool, but not worth for me to deliberately remember and so I'm not going to commit it to memory.
For example, 79*71 = 75^2-4^2 = 5625 - 16 = 5609.
If you know your squares up to 100 and your multiplication tables up to 20, you can solve a great deal of two digit multiplication problems without having to reach for a calculator.
People teaching hand-writing today concentrate on speed and readability rather than beautiful writing. Some cursive forms are good for speed and readability. Taking notes is still an important skill for students, and computer note taking systems aren't always good enough.
There's not much research, but the little bits that exist suggest that taking notes helps people learn.
Some systems, like Briem, are fast and look neat enough but can end up as hard to read zig-zags. http://briem.net/
This (weirdly expensive book) has details of how writing systems have changed over the years. http://www.amazon.co.uk/Handwriting-Twentieth-Century-Rosema...
Think of a piece of software where the hot paths get their result directly inlined for perf. Basic arithmetics occupy the "hot path" of your math curriculum until at least high school or beyond. This has a huge influence on reducing the amount of information you need to temporarily hold in your brain at once, leaving room for more important calculations such as exploring the solution space creatively, where one extra piece of information can make or break an insight.
Similarly, you can certainly look up a frequently used word in the dictionary every time if you need to. But you might as well memorize the definition once and for all. Now it's a question of where to draw the line. For creative professions such as math/engineering/art, I'd definitely prefer hard-coding some calculations in my brain for the previously mentioned reason.
Nicely articulated! And I believe the same applies moving ever higher up. Really, theorems in mathematics could be viewed in this manner -- do the proof once or twice for understanding and hard-code the result for use later in some larger context.
People need 0-9 for basic algorithm, 10 is useful for decimals / notation, 11 is easy to learn and 12 is debatable, but potentially handy for base 12 systems which are fairly common. Beyond that we can learn fairly simple algorithms to do this sort of thing.
It is a highly valuable skill in STEM fields in my opinion. Sometimes knowing a rough number can tell you what to expect, and can immediately indicate whether something is wrong (or could go wrong).
In jest: two types of Excel-users. Those that use the model and those that don't trust the model.
Learning cursive is so easy it's kind of amazing to me that some people, especially Americans, feel there's no ROI. Legibility on the other hand seems very easy for some and very hard for others.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cursive#/media/File:Cursive.sv...
vs.
Kate Gladstone DIRECTOR, World Handwriting Contest CEO, Handwriting Repair/Handwriting That Works http://www.HandwritingThatWorks.com
I take notes in sermons/talks ... on my mobile [cell-phone].
Yes it is! There's even a video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZCm2QQZVYk&t=35s
"The greatest shortcoming of the human race is our inability to understand the exponential function."
One example is I regularly get a spreadsheet with product and packaging weighs which we process for levy payments. It could be the weights of the carton, EPS padding, plastic bag sleeves for kettles; all the bits you throw away. My assistant didn't see a problem with a tiny plastic bag weighing 4Kgs, it should have been 4g. That was instantly obvious to me but clearly not to the supplier or my assistant. This is the ability to estimate and get a feel for the figures and although I find it frustrating I accept that many people have a big problem with thinking like that.
It's also somewhat valued in the business / consultant crowd for talking through assumptions and making estimates of problems.
Instead of thinking of it as a skill, think of it as an exercise.
There are hundreds if not thousands of things trying to distract, mollify, enrage, and lull us into a "don't think, just act" attitude... having mental fortitude to counteract or ignore those is important.
If you're not able to do mental calculations while in the middle of conversations/presentations you'll get left behind by everyone who can.
But in more "normal" social contexts, what tends to happen is one of the people involved sit with a digital calculator and input the things other people ask for. It's a bit slower, but the results are just as good.
Does writing cursive refer to any writing at all, or do you mean a specific font? Writing in capital letters is sloooooow.
If you cannot write, how would you write on a whiteboard, make mental notes, and so on?
The human brain is not a machine that becomes more "optimized" the "less services are running", the more knowledge the better, even in fields that might seem only barely tangential to where your main interests lie
I don't mean to be so negative though. I certainly think it's very fascinating and interesting just from a pure mathematical perspective. However we also have to consider the utilitarian perspective when asking "why" many people aren't good at something like this anymore.