So I agree that the article is a bit provincial, but I also agree that a very in depth understanding on issues and their complexity is often required, and very difficult to achieve from the outside.
Incidentally, this is why, at least in my experience, federal programs are so inefficient compared to state programs which are, in turn inefficient compared to local ones. This isn't to say that they don't all have their place, especially when it comes to enforcing consistent standards in a large geographical region, but it's definitely the people closest to an issue that have the biggest impact.
I agree that problems are way more complex, in general, then they tend to first appear, but that naivety is sometimes good, because it's insulating against the thinking that created the problem.
Maybe the Ugandan kid will learn a great deal about the US and its gun situation, but still maintain that "outsider looking in" viewpoint, and that's unique, in a good way.
But this is not always the case. The list of problems caused by well meaning outsiders trying to solve a problem is too long to list. Pouring money into corrupt dictatorships who then use those funds to enrich themselves is a time honored solution (see: IMF). Or even better, there's a bad guy in this country? Let's give them some freedom, that should work out (see: Vietnam)! Or maybe we ought to limit ourselves to humanitarian aid? If that's the case we can set up camps that will then house and abet one side of a conflict (see: Rwandan genocide).
There is a place for outside groups to try and effect change, but that needs to be carefully balanced against understanding of complex problems. Lots of money and resources is not always a good thing and can even cause harm when not used in the right way.
If this article were more about what you're saying, and less negative, I might not have made my comments.
I can't remember where I first heard this, but it made the point very clearly.
The thesis is that when you look at someone else's problem - someone that you don't know, understand, know their culture, see the situation leading into it, or the ripples coming after - that it looks simpler and more obvious than it really is. It's a variation of the "grass is always greener" mindset.
All of those sticky, messy details are hidden away. Some of them because they're cultural things the participants take for granted while others are glossed over because they distract from the story being told.
If you want to solve problems, great! Do it!
But make sure you understand the problem before you offer your solution.
I want the Ugandan to come to the US and try to solve gun control before he's 30. He'll fail if his idea sucks, but I want him to come try.
Maybe that's the point. People who want to solve complex problems need to be committed. Not for a few months or a few years, but maybe lifetimes. Because that's what's required to properly solving something.
I think this is what the OP is suggesting is happening with young western idealists - their naive solutions are making the situation worse.
That's pessimistic thinking, and not supported by experience. Definitely possible, though, so let's not even bother.
Its entire thesis is that the kid in the US thinks prison reform is hard because she understands the culture, the problem a little better. She thinks solving FGM in Africa is easy because "they should just stop mutilating each other". There's a tendency to run away from problems in our country because you don't realize that the problems in other countries are no easier once you get on the ground.
I'm refuting the article's pessimism by explaining the concept that innovative ideas often come from the perspective of an outsider who isn't thinking like the folks who created the problem think.
It's a significant part of start-up culture, isn't it, the theory of disruption? This article resonates because of how easy it is to be pessimistic and critical of new ideas, and everyone here is an expert at it.
You've highlighted quite well why startup culture has never successfully solved a sociopolitical problem; startups are a flash in the pan and real issues take longer than its shelf life to solve. I'm all for optimism but thinking you're going to solve a real social problem to, say, 'disrupt homelessness' by writing an iPhone app is the height of tech-infused naive narcissism. Using tools which are wholly unsuited to the job and expecting quick and easy solutions without years of hard work when the problems you are facing are genuinely difficult is not optimism.
Nothing about the article was pessimistic. Rather it is optimistic. It is a gentle suggestion to people who want to fix the world that as tempting as it is to look far away, where the issues are clear and crisp from a distance, you should consider starting closer to home, because you'll find the problems are equally as difficult but you don't have to learn an entirely new language and mode of existence before you begin.
If nothing else, I found the article particularly interesting, given it's anti-"flash in the pan" (as you call it) mantra, for this specific (startup oriented) audience.
"Doing X is not actually as hard as everybody thinks it is, which is why nobody else is trying, and there's an opportunity."
But that's different in important ways from:
"Why can't you just do X?"
Because in most cases you're not "just doing X", you're attempting X knowing that it'll be hard, but you're pretty sure that it's not doomed to fail like everyone else thinks it is.
Why can't a 22 yr. old college graduate from Uganda be the one to finally break the logjam in the US about gun control? Maybe different perspectives will find solutions to problems we haven't come up with. The Ugandan man/woman might get hired by one of those "nonprofit groups" and actually solve this problem once and for all. Who knows?
Why can't a 22 yr. old college graduate from the US be the one to finally figure out how to get cheap water to remote villages in Uganda? Why must it be someone from Uganda? A then-40 something "college dropout" (we all know how irrelevant that is) from the US (Bill Gates) went to Africa and started working on the malaria problem. Do you think he did it all by himself? A bunch of 22 yr. old college grads helped him, along with a lot of others.
Is this satire? It might be satire, because of how reductionist this article actually is, by claiming the problem is "simply" intractable.