Re:The Reductive Seduction of Other People’s Problems
by Laaw on Tuesday January 12, 2016 @01:38PM
(#10889343)
I'm getting the sense we both understand each other, even if we disagree, which is really all I can hope for on the Internet, in the limited space and time we're given to talk about issues on HN (the "reply" button disappears for a reason).
If nothing else, I found the article particularly interesting, given it's anti-"flash in the pan" (as you call it) mantra, for this specific (startup oriented) audience.
You've highlighted quite well why startup culture has never successfully solved a sociopolitical problem; startups are a flash in the pan and real issues take longer than its shelf life to solve. I'm all for optimism but thinking you're going to solve a real social problem to, say, 'disrupt homelessness' by writing an iPhone app is the height of tech-infused naive narcissism. Using tools which are wholly unsuited to the job and expecting quick and easy solutions without years of hard work when the problems you are facing are genuinely difficult is not optimism.
Nothing about the article was pessimistic. Rather it is optimistic. It is a gentle suggestion to people who want to fix the world that as tempting as it is to look far away, where the issues are clear and crisp from a distance, you should consider starting closer to home, because you'll find the problems are equally as difficult but you don't have to learn an entirely new language and mode of existence before you begin.