Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by billyhoffman on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:37PM
(#10852543)
[sigh]
Here’s WSJ from January 2013:
Apple Inc. has cut its orders for components for the iPhone 5 due to weaker-than-expected demand, people familiar with the situation said Monday. Apple’s orders for iPhone 5 screens for the January-March quarter, for example, have dropped to roughly half of what the company had previously planned to order, two of the people said.
So WSJ says 50% drop in orders for the January-March quarter. Yet when you look at Apple's actual results for that January to March quarter iPhone experienced a YoY increase.
Journalists should be very careful when quoting component manufacturers. Apple often buys all the components a manufacturer can make (and then buys them a factory to make more, and then buys all the machines in the world that can be used to make the parts, etc). Apple quite literally can make or break a component manufacturer (GT Advanced comes to mind...), so manufacturers willing to talk to the press usually have an angle or axe to grind.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by baldfat on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:32PM
(#10852990)
> Fool me once WSJ...
YoY INCREASE does not mean Apple hit their expected target goal. Apple expected to sell MORE phones then it did. It still sold more then the year before but they sold less then expected.
As has been pointed out, New year predictions of falling iPhone demand due to supply chain reports is now an annual tradition. One day it will be true, but in the sense that if you keep crying wolf eventually, one day, there might well be a wolf. I suppose the Journal can claim that they are only passing on reports, which is their job as journalists, but if they want to do so with any honesty or integrity the least they can do is point out the times they Passed on reports of exactly same thing in previous years.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by ronnier on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:29PM
(#10852450)
Largely mobile phones are feature complete. There's very little that can be added that makes it worth upgrading at this point. Unless there's some game changing new feature, expect people to upgrade less as they are completely satisfied with their phones and will keep it until it breaks.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by criddell on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:40PM
(#10852567)
I think the carriers in the US did a lot to create the 2-year upgrade cycle. Now that some are breaking out the phone subsidy from the monthly service charges, the incentive to upgrade is reduced.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by criddell on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:52PM
(#10853195)
My old contract was something like $80 / month. Every two years they would tell me I could upgrade to a new phone for very low cost. It was foolish to not upgrade because the monthly fee stayed at $80 whether I upgraded or not.
When the option is upgrade and keep paying $80 / month or keep your old phone and the rate drops to $60 / month, the incentive to upgrade is reduced.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by ketralnis on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:08PM
(#10852779)
My phones seem to get slower over time independent of any OS upgrades. My last one got so bad that I had to replace it when it started timing out when launching new applications, and I declined major OS updates.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by davej on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:50PM
(#10853174)
I feel like phones are slightly larger than optimum at the moment. At least for my preferences. I guess it's tougher to fit high spec hardware into a phone with a smaller footprint.
I bought into Steve Jobs' idea phones should be usable one-handed. I think the sweet-spot for that is 4 inches or less. A premium phone at these dimensions doesn't exist anymore, the last one was probably the iPhone 5S.
I went from iPhone 3GS -> iPhone 5 -> Sony Xperia Z3 Compact and honestly the Z3 Compact is larger than I would like (4.6" screen). I'm honestly considering getting a 5S for my next phone because I don't want a phone as big as the iPhone 6.
I noticed recently that the One Plus 2 Mini is going to have a 5" screen, that seems insane for a "mini" phone.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by matwood on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:38PM
(#10853575)
I'm the opposite. I have a 6s now and am thinking about moving to the 6s+. I use my phone more like a tablet, plug head phones in to talk and have wireless headphones for the gym.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by davej on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:14PM
(#10854678)
I'm an average sized male (5'11") with average sized hands.
Even if you have large hands it's difficult to use modern phones one-handed. Try reaching the top left/right corner of your phone (one-handed) without having to adjust your hand position.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by mikeash on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:37PM
(#10853566)
It fascinates me how important they are. If battery energy density and cost improved by two orders of magnitude, it would completely change the world. We've seen that sort of improvement in integrated circuits in just 15-20 years but the significance of that is microscopic compared to what batteries would do.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by jandrese on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:28PM
(#10852440)
This doesn't seem surprising. The market for smartphones is starting to get saturated and we should expect the growth of demand to slow as we start to crest the top of the S curve. It's pretty clear that Apple is still going to sell a ton of iPhone 7s, probably at a new record rate, but the level of growth just won't be the same.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by Spooky23 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:11PM
(#10853358)
I went to the Apple Store in my not-so-big town before lunch this morning to return an item I purchased at Christmas time.
Being 11am in January, there was nobody in the mall -- I grabbed a Starbucks (1 customer sitting down) and headed over to do my return. There is a rather long queue in front of the store and 2-3 Apple people taking names to let you in the store. Inside, there are probably about 100-150 customers. It's literally like standing on a train platform -- packed. In the 20 minutes that I was waiting, I counted about a half dozen iPads, 5-6 Macs and about two dozen iPhones walking out the door.
Apple is still on fire -- when I worked retail in the 90s, January-April was death. Hardly any midweek business whatsoever. They probably did more business in a half hour than the CompUSA I worked at in 1998 made in a day in January.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by MCRed on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:20PM
(#10853430)
The Wall Street Journal, in the early 1990s, reported that Apple had been bought by Sun Microsystems. They never retracted the story. This may be a generally credible newspaper, but this article sounds just like the constant stream of Apple Doom-And-Gloom I've been reading going back 30 years.
There is a reliable indicator of Apples expected sales-- and it's forward looking. This is the CapEx expenditures, which Apple forecasts out in its reports. When they expect to sell a lot of new phones, they buy more equipment to be able to make those phones. Apple hates to have lack of supply when they release a new product and there is huge demand (And Apple never has huge warehouses of unsold products they have to unload like other companies do.)
The idea that the s products are "lackluster" is silly... they have been following a tick-tock strategy for 5 years now and it has been working effectively, but every tock year we hear about how "nothings different" (because apparently to these people if the case is the same the internals must be too.)
Usually, despite the claim Apple was sold, you don't see this level of poor journalism in the WSJ. But I guess that's the nature of the "news game" now.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by FreedomToCreate on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:10PM
(#10852792)
They build it up and then they tear it down. Eventually they will be right, but something is telling me (Christmas sales forecasts) that Apple is about to demolish another quarter.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by mixmastamyk on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:24PM
(#10853461)
I wouldn't be surprised if most bought the 6 last year due to its larger size and hence have no need to upgrade to the 6s this year. I did and enjoy the 6s, because I upgraded from the 5 (even that jump was slightly underwhelming). I bought it for the camera and screen size.
Re:Apple Scales Back Orders for Its iPhones
by thecosas on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:40PM
(#10853591)
I'm pretty sure this same story has been told for each major rev of the iPhone. "s-years" tend to be stronger because it is a proven product design, etc., so more people buy them.
Here’s WSJ from January 2013:
Apple Inc. has cut its orders for components for the iPhone 5 due to weaker-than-expected demand, people familiar with the situation said Monday. Apple’s orders for iPhone 5 screens for the January-March quarter, for example, have dropped to roughly half of what the company had previously planned to order, two of the people said.
http://www.wsj.com/article_email/SB1000142412788732359620457...
So WSJ says 50% drop in orders for the January-March quarter. Yet when you look at Apple's actual results for that January to March quarter iPhone experienced a YoY increase.
http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2013/04/23Apple-Reports-Seco...
Fool me once WSJ...
Journalists should be very careful when quoting component manufacturers. Apple often buys all the components a manufacturer can make (and then buys them a factory to make more, and then buys all the machines in the world that can be used to make the parts, etc). Apple quite literally can make or break a component manufacturer (GT Advanced comes to mind...), so manufacturers willing to talk to the press usually have an angle or axe to grind.
YoY INCREASE does not mean Apple hit their expected target goal. Apple expected to sell MORE phones then it did. It still sold more then the year before but they sold less then expected.
The only 'expectations' in these stories are completely fictitious and are made up by people outside Apple.
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/apple-iphone-and-china-fear...
As has been pointed out, New year predictions of falling iPhone demand due to supply chain reports is now an annual tradition. One day it will be true, but in the sense that if you keep crying wolf eventually, one day, there might well be a wolf. I suppose the Journal can claim that they are only passing on reports, which is their job as journalists, but if they want to do so with any honesty or integrity the least they can do is point out the times they Passed on reports of exactly same thing in previous years.
First Foxconn subsidy news is wrong:
The $12 million in payments referred to in this article were actually issued for the 2014 calendar year.
http://newpaper.dahe.cn/hnsb/html/2016-01/06/content_1352344...
http://hn.ifeng.com/a/20160106/4169476_0.shtml
And then this comment says news websites has formed this as habit at the start of the year:
Doesn't this happen every year? Headlines from March 2015: "Apple's iPhone Juggernaut Slowing Down Across The Globe"
(http://www.forbes.com/sites/chuckjones/2015/03/16/apples-iph...
However it may never be true that supply chain rumors are an accurate indicator.
When the option is upgrade and keep paying $80 / month or keep your old phone and the rate drops to $60 / month, the incentive to upgrade is reduced.
Or until it becomes too slow after an OS upgrade.
I bought into Steve Jobs' idea phones should be usable one-handed. I think the sweet-spot for that is 4 inches or less. A premium phone at these dimensions doesn't exist anymore, the last one was probably the iPhone 5S.
I went from iPhone 3GS -> iPhone 5 -> Sony Xperia Z3 Compact and honestly the Z3 Compact is larger than I would like (4.6" screen). I'm honestly considering getting a 5S for my next phone because I don't want a phone as big as the iPhone 6.
I noticed recently that the One Plus 2 Mini is going to have a 5" screen, that seems insane for a "mini" phone.
Even if you have large hands it's difficult to use modern phones one-handed. Try reaching the top left/right corner of your phone (one-handed) without having to adjust your hand position.
It would be interesting to see precisely who much software and hardware improvements contributed to increased battery life.
Being 11am in January, there was nobody in the mall -- I grabbed a Starbucks (1 customer sitting down) and headed over to do my return. There is a rather long queue in front of the store and 2-3 Apple people taking names to let you in the store. Inside, there are probably about 100-150 customers. It's literally like standing on a train platform -- packed. In the 20 minutes that I was waiting, I counted about a half dozen iPads, 5-6 Macs and about two dozen iPhones walking out the door.
Apple is still on fire -- when I worked retail in the 90s, January-April was death. Hardly any midweek business whatsoever. They probably did more business in a half hour than the CompUSA I worked at in 1998 made in a day in January.
There is a reliable indicator of Apples expected sales-- and it's forward looking. This is the CapEx expenditures, which Apple forecasts out in its reports. When they expect to sell a lot of new phones, they buy more equipment to be able to make those phones. Apple hates to have lack of supply when they release a new product and there is huge demand (And Apple never has huge warehouses of unsold products they have to unload like other companies do.)
The idea that the s products are "lackluster" is silly... they have been following a tick-tock strategy for 5 years now and it has been working effectively, but every tock year we hear about how "nothings different" (because apparently to these people if the case is the same the internals must be too.)
Usually, despite the claim Apple was sold, you don't see this level of poor journalism in the WSJ. But I guess that's the nature of the "news game" now.