News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by pjc50 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:17AM (#10812106)
The "Internet of Rentiers" argument is exactly right. Things are made unnecessarily cloud-y for monetisation reasons.

In some ways this is the end of the software piracy wars. Software as a single purchase that you buy once and use forever without restriction is basically over. Besides, it needs updating to cope with both security threats and changing ecosystems. So that requires ongoing effort. But users don't want to pay for it in the first place.

So the solution we've arrived at by default is for the software to remain inside the datacentre fortress where the user can't pirate it, and make the user bring their data inside the fortress instead where it can be ransomed. Quite a lot of SaaS is "free!" but with monetised privacy invasion or the questionable gimmicks of free2play games.

IoT makes it possible for this untransparent renting business model to be brought to physical objects. If you buy an appliance once and then use it for 20 years, to the capitalist you're a bad customer. Why do that when you can pay for annual fridge software updates and a new fridge every 5 years when it stops being "smart"?

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by nostrademons on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @02:11PM (#10813691)
This started at least 20 years ago. I remember my dad complaining when I was a pre-teen about how everything was moving towards disposable or recurring-fee models, and you couldn't buy anything that was built to last and hold onto it for a lifetime anymore.

It's kinda ironic - during the Bush II presidency everyone was talking about the "ownership society", but the trend today has been toward the "renters' society", where consumers own nothing, the means of production are increasingly centralized in a few specialized producers, and everybody pays out of pocket for momentary needs. It's accelerating, too: car ownership => leases => Uber, suburban homes => urban apartments, vacation homes => timeshares => prepackaged "experiences", careers => gig economy, pay for printers => pay for ink, books => the Internet, videos & DVDs => Netflix, CDs => Spotify, exercise bikes => gym membership, building companies to last => hitting quarterly numbers.

I wonder sometimes why consumers put up with it, but most seem to actually prefer renting things for the short term rather than buying them for the long term. It's like the time preferences of society have compressed radically, and where people would used to think about investing in things that last for 30 years, they now focus on what they need in the next 30 minutes.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by shasta on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @02:35PM (#10813834)
I guess you can argue that it's not worth the cost, but at least half of the trends you listed are in the direction of increasing utility for the consumer. Spotify or a pile of CDs? Are you kidding?

The main problem with this trend is not that it's happening, but the way that a few companies are able to position themselves as gatekeepers. This will lead to abuse or at least monopoly pricing. Unfortunately, competition isn't really a good solution. I don't want a second Spotify.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by nostrademons on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @02:50PM (#10813928)
I think the replacement of products with services inherently tends toward monopoly, and your last sentence illustrates why: once a business is focused on servicing the immediate need rather than providing tools to service the immediate need, then customers will naturally gravitate toward whichever service fulfills that need best.

When you sell a physical product, there are inherent inefficiencies in distribution & usage that allow for some differentiation; this allows multiple firms to exist in the same market. When you sell a service, your distribution goes straight to the consumer at the moment they have a need, and you have the opportunity to tailor your service directly to the customer. It becomes more efficient to buy up small companies that offer slightly-differentiated variants of your service and incorporate them into your own offering than to maintain separate firms.

Interesting. This seems like a tradeoff of efficiency vs. freedom: the more you outsource a task, the more convenient things become for yourself, but the less agency you have over the terms under which that task is conducted.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by shasta on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:16PM (#10814084)
I don't know... maybe there could be another big competitor to Spotify. I can imagine the record labels would want one. The threat of there eventually being such a replacement probably puts a cap on how much leverage Spotify has. I don't think the data Spotify owns (my playlists? listening preferences?) is particularly valuable, but maybe I'm wrong about that.

Another factor is that selling physical products often results in a market for lemons, where the buyers can't figure out which product will last longest and so purchase based on other more visible factors. Buyers can try to trust brands, but many brands will cash in on their brand by switching to greatly reduced quality at the same cost.

Replacing a product with a service can better align the incentives. If, instead of a refrigerator, you purchased a service contract for refrigeration for X years, then the supplier will want to provide a refrigerator that doesn't break.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by wfo on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:09PM (#10819406)
Unless the company goes out of business, or you decide all of a sudden you aren't okay with the new "cloud-enhanced food profile" your refrigerator builds about you with the newest cloud-pushed update that records everything you eat and sells it to advertisers. Or until the market is flooded with the cheaper, ad-supported fridges that play out loud ads for sponsored products whenever you run out of something.

There's something, I don't know, honest about building something that works, and works well, and just selling it to people who then own it.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:25PM (#10814146)
We had that competitor, it was called Napster and that sort of entity scares the crap out of anybody with a rental model.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by frik on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:21PM (#10814109)
> Spotify or a pile of CDs?

The audio quality of streams are often sub par.

What about Youtube and then buying MP3 files from Amazon/etc? And Audio-CDs are still the best for lossless audio.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by frik on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:03PM (#10814004)
Very good points. I wonder why many consumers act like that.

I understand that companies prefer to rent or lease because of tax avoidance and/or lowering overhead (fixed costs) (because of inflexible accounting programs, blabla).

On the otherside, as a consumer (and if you have the money and your interest is longterm), why not just buy it? Why rent/lease something? In the long term you are better of buying it. Renting/Leases are always more expensive in the long run.

Also owning something is a lot more rewarding, relaxing, (and it can be used many years later) than handling some leased/rented subject with utmost care.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by nostrademons on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:29PM (#10814167)
I've got a hypothesis, but it's kinda out-there. It has to do with shifting time priorities across society.

The generations that grew up in the 50s-80s could be reasonably confident that the world a decade later would be more or less what it was before. Fashions would change, social movements would get started, more home appliances would be introduced, but as long as nuclear war never happened, the basic economic underpinnings of society wouldn't change too much. And so it made sense for them to buy things for the long term, because the purchase they made now would still be relevant & useful in 20 years.

Starting with the Netscape's IPO in 1995 and perhaps exacerbated by the fall of communism in the early 90s, that changed. Even before they came of age, Millenials had witnessed the dot-com boom & crash (in which many of their elders lost their life savings); obsolescence of PCs every 2-4 years; 9/11; the rise of MP3 sharing and then its clampdown; the rise of cellphones, their replacement by smartphones, and then the 1-2 year upgrade cycle of continually getting a new smartphone; the 2008 financial crisis; manufacturing jobs moving from the U.S. to Japan to India to Bangladesh to China to Southeast Asia; and the rise of sharing-economy companies providing services that you previously needed to buy a product for. Many have also been personally burned by investments in skills that were supposed to be a sure thing, like taking on $100K in student loan debt and not being able to get a job afterwards or landing your dream job and then being fired or laid off 3 months later.

The combined effect of all these is to send the message that the future is not worth planning for. There will be better products on the market in 2 years. There will be new services. That skillset that's so hot right now may be completely obsolete. The education that everyone says is crucial to your future won't get you a damn thing. The financial investment that's up 400% now may crash to zero tomorrow. You may have to move to a new city to find work, or to follow a significant other who needs to find work.

When the future becomes radically unpredictable, it makes sense to buy for the here-and-now, because the durable product you carefully invested in may be useless anyway.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by pjc50 on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:56PM (#10814326)
This sounds very plausible to me. The world is uncertain enough that it's safer to pay for it month by month rather than risk a stranded investment in the wrong thing. The only "stable" investment is real estate, which has therefore shot up in price. Physical "durable" goods are by comparison very cheap.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:43AM (#10816978)
That's flawed reasoning. The uncertainty should cause you to save before you spend and to own rather than rent on a contract that you can't get out of. After all, even if you have a stranded investment it will not cost you more for the next x months. But a rental agreement will usually have termination conditions that need to be met and if you can't get out of it then you're much worse off than if you owned the item outright.

The biggest money maker for such subscription type purchases are impulse purchases. Buy now on cheap credit, pay a premium for a long time on top of the value of the item. And for those type of purchases if you were to do them with money saved over time you probably wouldn't buy them at all. (And your life would be better, not worse, all this stuff is really owning us.)

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by nostrademons on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:01PM (#10819048)
I think the problem with owning is because prices have been very unstable over the last 15 years. Nominal inflation has been very low, but in certain categories of goods (housing, education, consumer electronics, even cars) prices vary wildly. There's no guarantee that you'll be able to sell a good for anywhere close to what you paid for it.

When I bought my Honda Fit in early 2009, for example, new cars were selling for less than used cars. Many of the new car owners had bought at inflated prices in 2007, sometimes $2000 over MSRP, and with Hondas holding their value well, they were hoping to get something close to what they paid for it. Meanwhile, the economy had cratered, and dealers were trying to move the inventory off their lots ASAP because nobody was buying. I ended up buying my car for under invoice price, about $3-4K off of the inflated prices that buyers a couple years before had paid and a good $500-1000 under what used car sellers were asking. Needless to say, the used cars weren't selling.

Similarly, I have several friends who bought houses a couple years out of college who ended up taking a $50-100K capital loss on them when they went to sell them. The high end of that is close to what I've paid in rent over my entire life, and doesn't take into account interest payments on the mortgage, which themselves were close to my rent.

It only takes a couple incidents like this to turn people off of owning things forever.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by pjc50 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:30AM (#10817084)
I suspect we also need to look at carrying costs. Let's go back to the list from the comment above:

car ownership => leases => Uber suburban homes => urban apartments vacation homes => timeshares => prepackaged "experiences" careers => gig economy pay for printers => pay for ink books => the Internet videos & DVDs => Netflix CDs => Spotify exercise bikes => gym membership building companies to last => hitting quarterly numbers.

Gig economy and short-term companies are arguably not a choice but exogenous. The job for life has been replaced by "at will" redundancies.

Home downsizing is clearly down to rising cost; saving up gets less and less feasible. But the move from suburbs into the centre is cultural.

Home gym => gym membership I suspect is also down to increasing real estate cost. A gym is much cheaper than the incremental mortgage cost of an extra room.

Media libraries => Spotify/Netflix is about increasing choice. They're not entirely replacing the library (people are buying more vinyl for totemic ownership), but replacing the radio and TV channels. Replacing someone else's limited range of choices with a much wider one. It then gets put on in the background as wallpaper.

(dear god this site needs a formatting reminder and preview button)

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Thursday December 31, 2015 @07:29AM (#10817335)
You can resize the input box, that goes a long way towards keeping an overview over what you wrote for larger comments. Hover over the lower right hand corner of the edge of the box, then a resize mouse pointer should appear.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by frik on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:44AM (#10817516)
That's browser dependent, and only a few let you do that. Try that on a mobile browser...
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by vram22 on Saturday January 02, 2016 @10:36AM (#10826455)
Wow, didn't know that, thanks. Just tried it, it works in Chrome.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:42PM (#10814231)
This trend was already well underway in the 70's. Especially in things like consumer electronics, vehicles and furniture. Cheap credit drove it in the US, miniaturization (Moore's law) and cheap overseas labor added to it and drove it abroad.

You can see it clearly in things like tool and machinery quality. 60's stuff is nigh on indestructible and still in use today, 70's stuff is gone as if it never existed.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by tezza on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @04:06PM (#10814368)
Hmm. 1960s was a particularly fashionable decade so less of it was thrown away. Lots of Art Deco stuff survives (1920s) for the same reason although the manufacture was quite poor.

Also Plastics technology improved and started to be widely used during the 1960s. This took into the 1970s to be widespread.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by chongli on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @04:14PM (#10814399)
On the otherside, as a consumer (and if you have the money and your interest is longterm), why not just buy it? Why rent/lease something? In the long term you are better of buying it. Renting/Leases are always more expensive in the long run.

I don't see how you can say that is the case for everything. Look at Netflix. Most stuff people watch only once. Why buy a bunch of discs to collect dust on your shelf?

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @04:21PM (#10814440)
But they wouldn't and that's exactly the rub. You'd trade them or re-sell them. Ever tried to re-sell a once-viewed netflix movie? No? That's because you can't. The doctrine of first sale does not apply to services, only to goods. And a movie packaged as a service is a lower cost to deliver and a bigger chance of another sale.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by chongli on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @04:38PM (#10814533)
Sure, but I also don't try to re-sell a chewed stick of gum. Netflix is <$10/mo. For that you can watch hundreds of hours of TV and movies. Are you saying you would buy all of that content individually and later resell it all? Who has time for that? Never mind the losses you take in the process; you'd likely lose way more than $10 anyway.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by frik on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:03AM (#10816758)
Where does it end?

Do you use a flat-rate meal delivery service or eat everyday at the same all-you-you-can-eat restaurant?

Instead of buying ingredients to cook a meal at home or going to different restaurants?

Consuming a flat-rate service from a single vendor is alright for the internet connection, but for many other things it asks for troubles in the long term.

Back to movies:

DVD/BlueRay gives a lot better experience than streaming. The movie is in higher resolution, with many more audio options and not forget the bonus/extra content that alone is worth something and often quite interesting and funny.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacobr1 on Sunday January 03, 2016 @10:33PM (#10833867)
> Do you use a flat-rate meal delivery service

Yes - Blue Apron. Although not exclusively. But I don't exclusively consume media content from Netflix either.

> DVD/BlueRay gives a lot better experience than streaming

First, I often don't care about the video quality of the content I'm consuming. Sure if it is a sci-fi action film I want surround sound and 4k or whatever. But most the time, a degraded qualify for a standup act or period drama doesn't really matter nor is it noticeable to me. Also I can't really tell the difference as much on a tablet or phone rather than my big screen.

Second, the streaming services are cost constrained right now on the quality front, but it seems like that is improving and likely to change at some point in the not too distant future. And some of the services let you get higher quality, right now, just with additional cost.

Third, streaming is right now much more convenient in meaningful ways. It doesn't have the hassle of dealing with physical media (acquiring it, storing it, sorting through it, loading it, discarding/reselling). It provides access to a larger library of content on demand. It allows for seamless resumption of paused or interrupted viewings on different devices. Access if available for any internet connected location. Content is often available faster, such as within minutes of broadcast, rather than waiting for a delivery or next day to head to a store.

Fourth, with the exception of a few beloved films, most the content I watch isn't something I ever intend to watch again. Purchase just doens't make sense in that context.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:24PM (#10814137)
Because people have been conditioned to think in terms of their monthly pay they like to allocate it by the month rather than to save and then spend one time. Saving requires long term thinking and planning, monthly allocation requires a horizon not much longer than a month. Also: instant gratification.

Of course they get burned but that won't stop them from repeating the same mistakes over and over again.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:25PM (#10814145)
> I wonder why many consumers act like that.

Because in the short term all these things are convenient and attractive.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:43PM (#10816001)
The thought's started occurring to me that a world in which money changes hand but title doesn't, in which the provider always has a hand in how product is used, or may or may not be resold, or must be re-updated, you no longer have a capitalist market society. Money changes hands, but goods don't.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by mtgx on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @12:19PM (#10813059)
If only they would keep updating the Internet of Things for many years, but I'm more worried most IoT devices will be forgotten within 2 years (although even $500 smartphones don't seem to get that much, so probably less), and you'll need to "buy the new generation device to continue to get software support".

This isn't made any easier by component suppliers, such as chip makers, which also tend to support their chips for very little time. Last I checked, even Qualcomm, the dominant player in the mobile chip maker, was supporting its SKUs for only 18 months. Basically, the whole ecosystem has decided to support their hardware as little as possible.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by sanotehu on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @01:25PM (#10813417)
I completely agree with this sentiment. Unfortunately there's no motivating factor for the companies that produce these things to continually update products that are "in the wild".

I recently bought a Volkswagen 2013 model and have been playing around with its bluetooth. Unfortunately the good stuff is only available in this years models - which is a hardware upgrade as well as a software upgrade. (Think Android Auto, automatic mirroring of the smartphone onto the car console, etc)

The only situations in which the Internet of Things will work is where it is acceptable to replace the Things on the same cycle as we replace phones - every year or every other year. For the vast majority of appliances, this is not the case.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @12:34PM (#10813149)
I love technology (and it pays me well!), but I'm rather disgusted at how much is basically just throw-a-way now.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by CaptSpify on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:36PM (#10814864)
On the flip-side, I love how much is so cheap, it's easily disposable, which leads to experimentation. Take Arduino/Raspberri-pi for instance: There's some cool stuff being done with those, that nobody would blow $300 to try out.

I agree with your point though. I wish tech was more "recyclable/upgrade-able" than "disposable".

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by brightball on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @10:52AM (#10812501)
100% correct. Side by side on sites that advocate for piracy or free everything with no advertising, you'll find complaints about the subscription business model.

The subscription business model is the end result of piracy. For some applications, it's a legitimately better model. For most...it's basically just a business decision.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by TTPrograms on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @12:08PM (#10813009)
I don't think piracy is the main driver of the subscription model. Certainly its a factor, but it's not like non-subscription models aren't viable anymore. Preventing piracy has a negligible impact on revenue for most products. There's a combination of factors that make it more appealing.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by tonyedgecombe on Thursday December 31, 2015 @08:29AM (#10817471)
I think it depends on who you sell to, I have very few problems with piracy but I know people with different types of customers who have horrendous problems.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by ourmandave on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @01:47PM (#10813548)
I must be unimaginative but I can't figure out what a Smart Fridge would do that a normal one doesn't already (besides the incredibly useless remind me to get milk or whatever).

Will it become as annoying as my printer that tells me when it's time to order genuine non-warranty voiding ink (just click here!)?

Or detect if I haven't used OEM parts or a factory certified repair service?

Edit: Wait, I thought of one. A Weight Watchers tie in that detects how many times I've cheated and locks the door.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by mgkimsal on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @02:55PM (#10813959)
How about a fridge that can detect when some food is going bad? "your eggs will be off in the next 3-5 days. here's some recipes that fit your lifestyle and taste, and will let you use the eggs vs throwing them away".
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jkestner on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:11PM (#10814054)
More realistically, the manufacturer will generate extra revenue by telling you that the eggs are probably now bad, and hooking you up with suppliers so you buy more. See: Amazon.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by CaptSpify on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:31PM (#10814847)
That's why we need these systems to be open and modifiable. If I could do that same thing, but point it to "awesome-egg-recipes.com" instead of "amazon.com", it'd be an awesome service. I do foresee your take on the matter being the one that wins out, unfortunately.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jkestner on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:37PM (#10815144)
So how do you induce the incentives to create such open systems? Why does Roku exist to connect any TV to nearly any service, but not the same thing for IoT? Is it the insistence on making money through services rather than the lower-margin hardware? (Noting that Roku also makes money through channel placement and probably affiliate fees.)

I'm afraid that the only way it's going to happen is if the government wades in. But first enough people have to give a shit about these systems, and that'll require them actually being useful to a majority of consumers.

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by CaptSpify on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:22PM (#10815754)
> So how do you induce the incentives to create such open systems?

Unfortunately, I have no idea. Obviously I can say "only buy systems that are open", but it'll take a lot of people to make a significant impact. Hopefully, when things die, we can say "I never had that problem with $vendor because their systems are open!"

Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by jacquesm on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @01:56PM (#10813587)
That only works if you're the only occupant of the premises.
Re:Cloudy with a Chance of Lock-In by samstave on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @03:54PM (#10814313)
>The "Internet of Rentiers" argument is exactly right. Things are made unnecessarily cloud-y for monetisation reasons.

Yeah, well there is also the argument that I can run an environment of literally thousands of machines and a very complex stack with a crew of literally four OPs guys.