News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by seangrant on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:50PM (#10779917)
Back when I ran a consulting/web dev biz I had a client who came to me with an idea like this. I didn't like the sounds of it and didn't pursue it. Glad I didn't. There's a myriad of technical legal issues to go through. Uber ("rideshare") vs taxis are majorly different from Flytenow ("flightshare") vs commercial airlines.

The FAA will never allow "flightsharing" on the commercialism that Uber is at. It's simply too dangerous.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by wolfgke on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:16PM (#10780106)
> The FAA will never allow "flightsharing" on the commercialism that Uber is at. It's simply too dangerous.

There are lots of people who have no problem doing dangerous things or even love it (say, dangerous sports). If they are cleared up about the risks involved I openly support allowing people to do dangerous things if they love to.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by krainboltgreene on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @11:33PM (#10781972)
> If they are cleared up about the risks involved I openly support allowing people to do dangerous things if they love to.

Even if that risk is flying a large object in the sky at high speeds?

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by mathgeek on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:24PM (#10780157)
There are also lots of people who would find a loophole and sue the government for not properly regulating such a service.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by feld on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:54PM (#10779949)
I don't buy the "dangerous" argument at all. Show me the danger.

edit: I'm referring to the danger of adding a passenger to an already scheduled flight by a private pilot, which is what I thought this flytenow service was about. (Assuming there's not a weight issue and someone isn't trying to intentionally crash the plane...)

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by johnpaulett on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:05PM (#10780030)
Fatal Accident Rate (Table 5 [1]):

  Commercial Aviation (per 100,000 flight hours): 0.022
  General Aviation (per 100,000 flight hours): 1.11
  Motor Vehicle: (per 100 million miles): 1.5
General Aviation (which Flytenow falls under) has a fatality rate 2 orders of magnitude greater than commercial airlines (Delta, Southwest, Skywest, etc)

1: http://enhs.umn.edu/current/injuryprevent/aviation/magnitude...

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by ryan-c on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:19PM (#10780135)
Comparing 100,000 flight hours to 100,000,000 miles seems strange to me. If you assumed an average speed of 50MPH, that would be:

    Commercial Aviation (per 100,000 flight hours): 0.022
    General Aviation (per 100,000 flight hours): 1.11
    Motor Vehicle: (per 100,000 driving hours): 0.075
This is data from 2000 though.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by asift on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:14PM (#10780090)
What if I find 1.1 deaths per 100,000 flight hours to be a perfectly reasonable risk relative to the benefits I receive from using such a service? I can't make that decision for myself?
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by lordnacho on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:13PM (#10780073)
Are 100K flight hours comparable to 100M miles in a car?
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nostromo on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:13PM (#10780077)
You're misreporting that data.

From the same table the overall risk of death (Fatality Rate) is the same for both forms of flying:

   Fatality Rate (Commercial Aviation): 1.9

   Fatality Rate (General Aviation): 1.91
The reason the "Fatal Accident Rate" is so different is because when a jetliner crashes, dozens or hundreds of people die. So a single accident is very deadly.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by jacquesm on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:24PM (#10780156)
No, you're mis-interpreting the data. The commercial aviation record is as low as it is in spite of the large number of people on board. So the chances of accidents in general aviation are many times higher for any given flight using the one or the other mode.

In other words - and to make it really simple - if you are given the choice of going with a commercial carrier or with a general aviation craft to the same destination in a single flight then you would do wise to take the commercial carrier.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nostromo on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:34PM (#10780232)
You're correct in the narrow sense (a commercial flight is less likely to crash) but wrong on the big picture (a commercial flight is safer for passengers).

Here's the thing: we don't care about the number of crashed airplanes, we care about crashed people (the number of deaths). And the number of deaths is about the same per passenger mile flown.

Passengers are no safer in either form of flying, according to this source.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nkurz on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:04PM (#10780388)
It's worth getting to the bottom here, but like 'jacquesm' I think you are misinterpreting the data.

And the number of deaths is about the same per passenger mile flown.

Deaths per passenger mile is indeed the relevant metric, but this is not the number which is equal. Instead, the deaths per airplane mile are about equal. Since the commercial flights tend to have many more passengers, the passenger miles denominator will be greater by this ratio.

From a passenger's perspective, commercial flights are thus safer than private planes by this same ratio. I don't think the linked article gives enough information to calculate the ratio of passenger miles for GA and commercial, but 50x seems like it would be in the ballpark.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by apkostka on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:52PM (#10780326)
Why would we care about the number of crashed people? You said it yourself, the number of deaths for commercial flight is higher because there are more people on board. If I'm on a plane, I don't care about how likely I am to be one of the people who died in airline crashes this year, I care about how likely it is that this plane is going to crash.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nostromo on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:02PM (#10780376)
I understand it's not intuitive, but the statistics are clear: If you have 100 times more people on commercial flights, then the flights would have to be 100 times less likely to crash to have the same risk to each passenger.

Let's break this into two specific questions (assuming the source is correct):

1) How likely is it that a specific flight will crash?

Answer: it's more likely that a private flight will crash than a commercial flight.

2) How likely is it that I will die on a private vs commercial flight?

Answer: your likelihood of dying is the roughly the same for both private and commercial flights.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by apkostka on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:33PM (#10780543)
I'm not sure you're reading the replies here. Nobody is arguing that your likelihood of dying is significantly higher on a private flight. We're arguing that the thing you should care about is whether the specific flight that you are on will crash, which has a significantly higher likelihood in general aviation.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nkurz on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:04PM (#10780680)
Nobody is arguing that your likelihood of dying is significantly higher on a private flight.

I might be wrong, but this is indeed what I am arguing, and I think 'jacquesm' is saying the same. 'nostromo' says your likelihood of dying is the roughly the same for both private and commercial flights, and I don't think this is true if the metric is getting from point A to point B without dying.

If my memory of previous research is correct, a passenger on a private plane has approximately the same risk per mile travelled as a passenger on a motorcycle[1], which is something much greater than the risk per passenger mile of a normal automobile, which is in turn something significantly riskier than traveling the same number of miles by a commercial jet.[2]

We're arguing that the thing you should care about is whether the specific flight that you are on will crash, which has a significantly higher likelihood in general aviation.

Yes, each flight you take in a private plane is significantly more likely to end in a crash than each flight you take on a commercial airline. Your chances of being killed if the plane is involved in an accident are greater in a private plane (fatalities per accident are greater on the commercial flight, but risk to each passenger is lower). Therefore, your chances of dying per flight taken are greater in private flight than in commercial aviation. Is this the same as what you are saying?

[1] Edit: Found a seeming good source at http://www.nianet.org/ODM/presentations/Overview%20SVO%20Ken..., page 8. Looks like I was slightly wrong to say that motorcycles and GA are comparable risks. If we trust their estimates, motorcycles are about 2x more dangerous per hour than GA, and 3x more dangerous per mile.

[2] I put the specific numbers from in my other comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10781106

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nostromo on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @05:32PM (#10780822)
Keep in mind the context of this conversation is about regulation, not about individual decision making.

From an individual stand-point, you are correct: "will my flight crash?" is a question that the individual would ask. But from a regulatory stand-point, the question is, "what is the safest way to transport people?" and those questions are not the same statistically.

This is similar to Taleb's "black swans" conundrum. You're comparing likely events with small ramifications to unlikely events with large ramifications.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by nkurz on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @06:41PM (#10781106)
Page 8 of this NASA document is the most trustworthy single page source I've found so far: http://www.nianet.org/ODM/presentations/Overview%20SVO%20Ken...

This chart gives (among other things) fatalities per passenger mile for 2005-2012 as a multiplier of the per passenger risk of death when traveling by automobile.

  Passenger auto:     1x
  Commercial Airline: .006x
  Motorcycle:         40.2x
  General Aviation:   12.0x
This would suggest that if all else is equal, and you are scheduling a trip from point A to point B, your chances of dying are about 1000x worse if you travel by private plane than by commercial airline, about 10x worse if you travel by private plane rather than driving, and that it would be about 4x safer to take a private plane rather than riding a motorcycle to your destination.

Of course, all else is not necessarily equal. A daytime motorcycle ride in full gear in good weather is definitely safer than an unexpected night flight in the fog with a low hour private pilot. A trip on a well-maintained corporate jet with an experienced pilot is almost certainly safer than snowy roads in a rear-wheel drive automatic. And of course, statistics don't answer the question of what should and should not be acceptable risks.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by rdtsc on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:10PM (#10780056)
Because Googling is arduously hard here is some sauce and some commentary to the sauce:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-05-15/more-peopl...

Also:

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/17/opinion/The-Dangers-of-Pri...

"""The National Transportation Safety Board found that in 2011, 94 percent of fatal aviation accidents occurred in what’s called general aviation. That category includes private small planes flown by amateurs as well as professionally piloted corporate flights in high-powered aircraft, such as the Gulfstream IV jet that crashed in May in Bedford, Mass., killing all seven people on board. By contrast, commercial aviation had no fatal accidents that year. Statistics from the N.T.S.B. show that general aviation aircraft average nearly seven accidents per 100,000 flight hours, compared with an average of 0.16 accidents per 100,000 hours for commercial airlines. """

Sauce straight from the horse' mouth:

http://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/data/Pages/AviationDataSt...

It is actually 100x more dangerous than commercial aviation. Is that what you meant by "showing me the danger"?

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by seangrant on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:01PM (#10780001)
You don't see the danger in pilots running a commercial aviation business with a personal license? They're not like cars where you can willy around and if things go wrong usually it's at 30mph...
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by SapphireSun on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:09PM (#10780049)
Yea, when I was going through pilot training it took me a while to realize why it was so dangerous compared to cars. The biggest reason, in my opinion, is that in a car, you can stop and get out and you're ok. In a plane, you can't stop and get out, you're trapped. If you bail out, now you have an unguided missile.

Private pilot licenses have much lower standards than commercial operations. Commercial has tighter maintenance and training requirements, and is consequently much more expensive to run.

Until around the 1960s to 1970s, air travel was very very dangerous. People died quite regularly. It was the implementation of serious safety practices and regulations that changed the risk to be safer than riding in a car, and public perception. Since aviation makes the country go, and people have an innate fear of flying, the FFA is both concerned for the increased loss of human life and the loss of trust in flying that would translate to the commercial sector if this went through.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by pc86 on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:53PM (#10780334)
GA is nowhere near as safe as automobile travel.
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by feld on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:57PM (#10780353)
I wasn't looking at it from that perspective. I was looking at it as a rideshare service. Example: a pilot already has a flight scheduled and you can join if there is room available. Not one where they are trying to make a living off of chartering people around.

Adding humans to these existing flights does not make them more dangerous, but creating more private charter flights may very well be more dangerous. There is some good data linked above that indicates they are equally dangerous.

YMMV I guess.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by HeyLaughingBoy on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @04:43PM (#10780582)
So Jim in Vermont is going to New Haven, CT tomorrow to see his sister. Jeff has a business meeting in the same city and figures he can save some time waiting around in airports if he flies with Jim and pays half the costs.

At takeoff time, weather around the CT coast looks iffy. Jim would rather stay home and see his sister next weekend instead. Jeff can't get a flight on such short order, and tells Jim he really needs to make the meeting or a big contract is lost. He offers to pay Jim 2x the full flight costs to make his meeting.

What Jim will do in this situation is likely very different than if he hadn't agreed to take Jeff along.

Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by feld on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @06:50PM (#10781143)
:( poor Jim and Jeff
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:08PM (#10780045)
Re:“We are left with no choice but to shut down Flytenow” by DonHopkins on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:18PM (#10780124)
Ha! Point taken. The video is not available but here's the song:

Mojo Nixon — You Gotta Be Insane To Fly In Small Private Planes

http://redmp3.cc/1334534/mojo-nixon-you-gotta-be-insane-to-f...