News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:30AM (#10771831)
1. Infinite supply of loans. Dept of Ed isn't even allowed to deny a loan to a person.

2. Culture since the Clinton era of "everyone should go to college". Massive cultural stigma for those who don't.

3. Colleges continue to justify costs based on lifetime earnings delta of people with degrees. Sadly, this data is backwards-looking and not indicative of what today's students should expect.

The most heinous thing though is that student loans are exempted from American bankruptcy laws. The gov't will give you a loan, without doing any diligence on your ability to repay, but make it impossible to discharge your debt if you go bankrupt.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by jenshoop on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:02PM (#10772028)
Spot on. There's also been an increasing competitive push between universities to deliver "country club-esque" experiences to students, which further drives up cost. (Separately, let's not forget about the chaos of the educational publishing industry and the insane price points they command for modestly updated editions each year.) But I think items 1 and 2 above -- and a lack of education about what loans are and the value of a higher ed degree to the potential student -- are the true culprits here. There's a cultural expectation that all students will matriculate to college, and many high schools measure their success in terms of college attainment. Meanwhile, there's a lack of counseling/education for students, so few know that they're expected to repay loans and fewer explore the options (college and non-college) in front of them, and counselors would be working at cross-purposes with the secondary institution's goals if they advised against attending college. As demand for higher ed continues to grow, for-profit higher ed institutions continue to spring up to suck up federal loans and lower acceptance standards.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by at-fates-hands on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:36PM (#10773695)
>> let's not forget about the chaos of the educational publishing industry and the insane price points they command for modestly updated editions each year.)

I had a friend of mine who I knew when I was working at Thomson Reuters back when they still had their educational publishing wing of the company. He was in sales and said educational publishing is one of the biggest rackets nobody has heard of.

He said he would do his due diligence and meet with professors and educators regularly during the year and let them know what the publishers were doing, but in the end, he said it was always a 50/50 roll of the dice if a professor or school bought the books he had been pitching them since they got the last version of the textbooks they ordered.

He said it mainly came down to name recognition, and Thomson had that - but he also said it was similar to how agents woe professional athletes. Lots of perks, free dinners and baseball tickets to the professors making the decisions. He said as a sales person, they had a "client account" card where they could wine and dine clients and had a monthly stipend between 5K-10K specifically for this purpose.

He said you'd be surprised how greedy these professors get once they know they can influence what books are going to be purchased for the following year and from what company.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by zo1 on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:35PM (#10774423)
>"There's also been an increasing competitive push between universities to deliver "country club-esque" experiences to students, which further drives up cost."

That was my impression of University/College. Having only experienced what was shown in movies and the media, I was under the impression that college meant getting your own "apartment with a roommate". Unfortunately, in the non-US university I attended, it meant "4x6" meter room, two beds, two cupboards, two desks, and two-roommates.

Then again, the entire year's tuition did only cost about $3500, about 9 years ago.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by brbsix on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:02PM (#10774893)
At least in my experience at a UC, the media portrayal was fairly accurate. It seemed like there was a never-ending onslaught of concerts, "multicultural events", sporting events, "community center" activities, safe spaces, Greek events, etcetera (all of which receive school funding in some form or another). I appreciated the occasional guest speaker, but looking around I couldn't help but notice money pouring from everywhere, namely for things that had nothing to do with academics. Far too many administrators with too much time on their hands.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by meric on Monday December 21, 2015 @07:20PM (#10774652)
I thought the same too. I didn't even have a room, and travelled to class by train from home.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by morgante on Monday December 21, 2015 @07:04PM (#10774570)
> so few know that they're expected to repay loans

What?

Literally every student I talk to knows full well that loans are meant to be repaid.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by dredmorbius on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:39AM (#10776398)
Lots of loans are "meant" to be repaid (that's a literal, not a scare quote).

But if it turns out that it cannot be, virtually all are dischargable in bankruptcy.

Student loans are a very, very rare exception. Also a rather recent one.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by noonespecial on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:26PM (#10773636)
The loans are the key to the whole mess. So long as the loan is guaranteed to all and non-dischargeable through bankruptcy, the cost will tend to rise to match the total expected lifetime earnings the education enables.

In short the loan system is transferring the benefits of the education away from the students and allowing the institutions to take it for themselves instead.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by api on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:23PM (#10773984)
"In short the loan system is transferring the benefits of the education away from the students and allowing the institutions to take it for themselves instead."

That is by far the most concise summary I've ever read of the nature of the problem.

Would you say that the same thing is true to a lesser extent in the housing market? It's not as bad, but there's a huge amount of loan subsidy there that's driving the price of housing crazy.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:30PM (#10774037)
It's a nice analogy, but at least in the housing market you're equally likely to be a winner (sell before crash) as a loser (buy before crash).
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by api on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:47PM (#10774131)
Is there a general principle here? Do loan subsidies lead to a condition in which the loan recipients are able to reap the benefits intended for loan originators through progressive inflation and risk transfer?
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by noonespecial on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:25PM (#10774998)
I think what we've got here is a misalignment of the participants' roles courtesy of unintended consequences.

The recipients have become the schools, deriving all of the benefits with no risk. The originators have escaped their traditional role as gatekeepers and risk takers. That leaves the students for all of the risk to concentrate on while they receive few of the benefits.

Essentially becoming sharecroppers of their own minds.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:32PM (#10773676)
The cost will tend to rise to match the total expected incremental lifetime earning, discounted to the present value.

Personally, I think we've already passed that point. Would love to see some more research here.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by fancyketchup on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:49PM (#10774142)
Wait, really?

The incremental lifetime earning from a Bachelor's degree is something like 0.5 to 1.5 million dollars[1]. The cost of attending college could double at least once before the ROI goes negative.

[1] https://cew.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/colleg...

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:24PM (#10774346)
Here's a study that puts it closer to $500 for women and $800k for men:

https://news.ku.edu/2015/06/19/ku-study-gives-more-accurate-...

But these studies are all flawed because they are based on historical data when 4-year degrees were scarcer. In an era when many graduates can't get a job or end up with one that does not require a degree (i.e. barista) it's obvious that their ROI prospects are grim.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by fancyketchup on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:05PM (#10775749)
Ok, that's fine. It's still within the range I mentioned above. But, I'll just note for the record that you rounded $587k down to $500k, and $840k down to $800k.

> But these studies are all flawed because they are based on historical data when 4-year degrees were scarcer. In an era when many graduates can't get a job or end up with one that does not require a degree (i.e. barista) it's obvious that their ROI prospects are grim.

I don't think that's at all obvious. We are rapidly approaching the moment [1] when over half of the U.S. population has some sort of college degree, and already 2/3rds have at least "some college" education.

Applying to a front-line retail job with a Bachelor's degree no longer marks you as desperate and over-qualified. You are assuming that an employer will hire a person with only a high school diploma when she can just as easily hire a person with an associate's or bachelor's for the same wage. That will put downward pressure on wages for those without a college degree.

It may very well be the case that sending "everyone" to college does nothing more than depress the wages of those with only a high school education. However, that is not an argument against the positive ROI of college. Spending $100k to avoid $200k in lost wages is still a positive return.

Finding a job with a B.A. or B.Sc. may be difficult, but finding a job with only a high school diploma is even more so.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_...

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by neil1 on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:06PM (#10774235)
You're forgetting about opportunity cost and the salary plus job advancement that you could achieve in the time you are in college
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by fancyketchup on Monday December 21, 2015 @10:46PM (#10775681)
The page I cited actually breaks down lifetime earnings by age (a.k.a. "annual income"). It's true that non-college graduates get an earlier start on savings, but the overall trend is that their annual income starts to decline as they get closer to retirement age (they peak in their mid to late 40's).

You have to assume totally unrealistic investment gains in the first four years to make up for the $500k less total income.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by landonshoop on Monday December 21, 2015 @01:07PM (#10772390)
Hear, hear. Agreed on point 2. I believe we are seeing this stigma evolve right before our eyes.

College has been improperly marketed. I've mentioned this on other threads, but my view is that college should be used as a forum to learn, not a means to get a job. The reality though is the opposite.

The pressure against this reality is mounting. I feel we're nearing the point where one is better off going straight into the workforce to receive on-the-job training instead of pursuing a college degree. In other words, the market forces are starting to take effect.

But do we need to fast track this shift in mentality? If so, how? How much do we leave up to the invisible hand to flesh this issue out and how much should the onus lie on third parties (e.g. the end of federal government loan subsidies, corporations, etc)?

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by blisterpeanuts on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:51AM (#10771975)
+1 for the role that guaranteed, subsidized student loans play.

University financial counselors are very well versed at helping students obtain the maximum amount of loans, along with an obligatory brochure cautioning them not to over-borrow.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by zxcvvcxz on Monday December 21, 2015 @07:36PM (#10774753)
> 3. Colleges continue to justify costs based on lifetime earnings delta of people with degrees. Sadly, this data is backwards-looking and not indicative of what today's students should expect.

Not only that, it's downright bullshit.

I remember seeing once a comparison. Non college degree average salary: let's say it's 30K. College degree: 40K. Instead of college, take those 4 years and at least $50K of educational expenses and invest in the S&P 500. Do nothing. Earn more over your lifetime that the more sophisticated 40K college graduate.

Or better yet, take that 50K, use the plethora of free online learning resources and become an entrepreneur. For a large portion of the population, college is simply not worth it.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by CognitiveLens on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:57PM (#10775195)
Actual data from the US: https://cew.georgetown.edu/cew-reports/goodjobsareback/

of the 2.9 million "good jobs" (i.e. full-time, high paying with benefits) created since 2010, 2.8 million have gone to people with college degrees.

It fun to say that you don't need a degree to get a good, high-paying, satisfying job, and there are plenty of anecdotal examples to reference, but the data clearly indicate that the odds are not in your favor if you choose an alternative path, at least in the US. I suspect that software engineering and some related industries might be a little more degree-agnostic, but that's far from the norm.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by Retra on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:33PM (#10775049)
What 50K? Are you telling me I could've applied for 50K in government-issued student loans and then turned around and spent that on a free online school and started a business?
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by devbug on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:03PM (#10772039)
One argument I've encountered that holds water, at least with regards to being unable to discharge student debt: you can't repossess someone's mind. (Technically you can, but that'd be a messy affair.)
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:49PM (#10772292)
That's a terrible argument that I've never heard an actual policy-maker or politician make. Besides, unsecured debts are all around us, credit cards being the most common.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by slg on Monday December 21, 2015 @01:14PM (#10772425)
But it is much harder to get other forms of unsecured debt. An 18 year old with no job and no credit history is going to have a hard time getting a credit card with a $5k limit let alone a $100k loan. The lack of being able to discharge the loan in bankruptcy needs to go hand in hand with the guaranteed availability of the loan. Instead of changing one of those things, we are are better off coming up with a new system like no upfront tuition and income based repayment plans.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by crabasa on Monday December 21, 2015 @01:25PM (#10772485)
> An 18 year old with no job and no credit history is going to have a hard time getting a credit card with a $5k limit

Wow, citation please? Credit card companies set up pop-up stands and give away free t-shirts to students who apply for their credit cards. The VAST majority of the applications are happily approved.

Update: excellent citation kileywm. I guess my perception was a bit dated.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by kileywm on Monday December 21, 2015 @01:45PM (#10772625)
The Credit CARD Act of 2009 [1] made it considerably more difficult for an 18 year old to get a credit card, but I should add that circumstances change when an 18 year old has a co-signer. At any rate, pop-up stands and such have been curtailed by this provision:

"(5) Eliminates excessive marketing to young people. Consumers under the age of 21 must prove that they have an independent income or get a co-signer before applying for a credit card. The Act also prevents credit card companies from mailing offers to consumers under 21 unless they "opt in," and prohibits companies from wooing students with T-shirts, free pizza and other free gifts at university-sponsored events."

As an anecdote, my experience (within the past decade) reflects the parent post's perception. My first credit card had a very low limit of < $1000, and was surely because I was then young, a student with no stable income, and had a lack of credit history.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_CARD_Act_of_2009

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by thedufer on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:48PM (#10774485)
When I was 21 I was only able to get a secured credit card. That didn't change until I got a full time job. I would've loved to know where I could get something better; I just wanted something low limit to build my credit score without tying up $1k (a lot for a college student).
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by rconti on Monday December 21, 2015 @02:06PM (#10772768)
Granted it was 15 years ago, but when I got my first credit card out of high school, the limit was $300.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by jxramos on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:50PM (#10786130)
indeed, $5K seems a long stretch, $500 range is more appropriate for first time credit.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by akgerber on Monday December 21, 2015 @02:59PM (#10773076)
As an anecdote, after intentionally avoiding credit cards through college, I was rejected from several when I applied for my first after graduating in 2010— and was only approved for a 'student' card (despite having graduated) at a bank where I had a savings account.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by nommm-nommm on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:53PM (#10774515)
Thats not legal anymore. Its no longer legal to advertise credit cards on college campuses.

My first credit card as a student came with a $500 credit limit for what its worth. I wasn't able to get a $5k limit until I was out of school and working in my field and made a dent into my student loans.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by recursive on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:35PM (#10775053)
I've been full-time as a software developer for >10 years, and still haven't been able to get a credit card with a $5k limit. Fortunately, I don't need credit for anything.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by at-fates-hands on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:40PM (#10773717)
I guess this is the lesson: pay for your college with credit cards and avoid student loans. One can be discharged with bankruptcy, the latter cannot.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by vinceguidry on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:57PM (#10773825)
That's only feasible if you have limits large enough to put the whole balance on.

Also, the interest will kill you unless you actually plan on declaring bankruptcy, in which case say goodbye to any chance of buying a house in the next seven years.

I would think that in your early twenties, defaulting on student debt and declaring bankruptcy would have roughly the same net impact on your life.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by dsfyu404ed on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:05PM (#10775747)
Don't forget that the intent to declare bankruptcy makes it fraud... but intent is hard to prove if you don't tell the internet about it.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by commandar on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#10772167)
That could be said for any form of unsecured debt.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by blisterpeanuts on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:22PM (#10772164)
Not yet, anyway.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by eanzenberg on Monday December 21, 2015 @02:17PM (#10772821)
>> The gov't will give you a loan, without doing any diligence on your ability to repay, but make it impossible to discharge your debt if you go bankrupt.

No due diligence.. guaranteed loan.. cannot be discharged in bankruptcy. Makes sense to me. If the gov't could discriminate on who it loans to for risk assessment then that's a different story.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by Shivetya on Monday December 21, 2015 @02:23PM (#10772855)
that plus they don't necessarily restrict the loans with regards to the education you are receiving. it is one thing to go into a field that is experiencing good growth it is another to enter one that is saturated or quickly saturating.

It has always been my belief that if government is going to provide loans it should set limits on the cost of the education it is taking the risk for. It already sets limits on medical care through reimbursement rates, how hard would it be to limit course costs? The means test should be on what you are receiving, not necessarily who is receiving it.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by kuschku on Monday December 21, 2015 @04:13PM (#10773551)
In Germany, it’s simple:

1. If your parents earn enough to finance you studying, you won’t get a loan

2. The loan is limited to 800$ a month

3. If you fail too many courses, the loan is cancelled.

But:

4. You only have to pay back in months in which you earn over 30k€ per year

This allows the loans to be a lot less risky.

I’d argue this is a much better system than what I read about the US tuition system, especially for the students.

(Obviously, the large supply of free governmentally paid universities help drive the price down, too.)

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by jimbokun on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:55PM (#10774177)
"I’d argue this is a much better system than what I read about the US tuition system, especially for the students."

As an American, it would be difficult to engineer a worse tuition system than ours.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by kuschku on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:47PM (#10774483)
That’s not really true. You have student loans and state colleges – two very useful tools which make a college education possible for many poor people, too.
Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by zo1 on Monday December 21, 2015 @06:38PM (#10774435)
>"If the gov't could discriminate on who it loans to for risk assessment then that's a different story. "

If they could, they wouldn't be allowed to. As soon as a hint of racial/sexual/anything disparity is shown in who is getting the loans, there would be a massive uproar to "incentivise" the non-proportionately-represented class with loans. Then you're back to square one, as the loan process is then "not" to be used as a corrective measure for society's ills.

Re:The $10,000-a-year college education has arrived (1981) by tn13 on Monday December 21, 2015 @07:37PM (#10774759)
I totally understand this aspect but what I do not understand is why anyone would ever pay $150K for a media studies degree or a degree in baking. Are Americans that stupid to pursue meaningless education at such price ?