It has always been my belief that if government is going to provide loans it should set limits on the cost of the education it is taking the risk for. It already sets limits on medical care through reimbursement rates, how hard would it be to limit course costs? The means test should be on what you are receiving, not necessarily who is receiving it.
1. If your parents earn enough to finance you studying, you won’t get a loan
2. The loan is limited to 800$ a month
3. If you fail too many courses, the loan is cancelled.
But:
4. You only have to pay back in months in which you earn over 30k€ per year
This allows the loans to be a lot less risky.
I’d argue this is a much better system than what I read about the US tuition system, especially for the students.
(Obviously, the large supply of free governmentally paid universities help drive the price down, too.)
As an American, it would be difficult to engineer a worse tuition system than ours.
If they could, they wouldn't be allowed to. As soon as a hint of racial/sexual/anything disparity is shown in who is getting the loans, there would be a massive uproar to "incentivise" the non-proportionately-represented class with loans. Then you're back to square one, as the loan process is then "not" to be used as a corrective measure for society's ills.
No due diligence.. guaranteed loan.. cannot be discharged in bankruptcy. Makes sense to me. If the gov't could discriminate on who it loans to for risk assessment then that's a different story.