News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:01PM (#10760897)
"The argument on rents is important because, if correct, it means that there is nothing intrinsic to capitalism that led to this rapid rise in inequality, as for example argued by Thomas Piketty."

Isn't rent seeking the defining characteristic of capitalism? (compared to other ways to implement a market economy)

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by sputknick on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:05PM (#10760919)
Nope. Capitalism is about capital going to where it is most productive. Rent Seeking is about capital going to where it's told to go based on rules.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by epistasis on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:13PM (#10760967)
That's a pretty unusual definition of rent seeking; what sort of other axioms are you assuming in order to get to that? Here's another definition:

>When a company, organization or individual uses their resources to obtain an economic gain from others without reciprocating any benefits back to society through wealth creation.

http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rentseeking.asp

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:19PM (#10761010)
A market economy redistributes capital according to demand. I don't really see how capitalism is necessary to achieve that from a market.

I take capitalism to mean a market economy in which capital is traded as private property in a manner where the property holder gets to extract rents from ownership.

As a contrast, I've been thinking of a system where property laws are altered so that property rights imply rent going from the propery holder, not too. I think this can be done in a manner so that the market manages to distribute capital to where it is needed, even more effective than the current system, while also have a few interesting side effects toward social justice and welfare.

Land value taxes are the obvious example. But take copyright. What if those rights could only be claimed as long as you pay for them? It could for example make it much easier for streaming services as either there is an entity paying for the exclusive right, whom you could negotiate streaming rights with, or there is none, implying the work is in he public domain.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by fineIllregister on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:39PM (#10761158)
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:49PM (#10761214)
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:13PM (#10761342)
The Georgist ideal is problematic because it exalts "land" as being this special component of the general welfare over another factor of production. Yet, all production of capital goods and consumer goods must start from nature-given resources (thus land) mixed with labor. A land value tax would then be a penalty on the entire time structure of production.

I'd wager a government levying an LVT would negate its benefits since such an undertaking would give it sufficient velocity to expand its actions and thus be able to collude with the private sector in all the other, more damaging I'd think, forms of rent-seeking.

The progressive income tax has become a failure due to the wealth elasticity of demand being higher amongst those with more assets (thus being least sensitive to it), along with them finding it easier to avoid it. I don't see an LVT as faring much better.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:07PM (#10761605)
A LVT would counter some of the externalities that enable rent extraction from assets. I'm not arguing for an LVT though, I think it's more interesting to focus on rents, an externalities, in general. What if all assets were rented, at market value (or some aproximation), and all externalities accounted for in assets (things like cap and share comes to mind).

When it comes to government they should have no rights to the rent extracted, the commons should not be seen as a state asset. In principle it should be distributed as a dividend (which, in turn, could be taxed)

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by ArkyBeagle on Friday December 18, 2015 @10:54PM (#10762546)
Land is special. On a non-geologic time scale, "they're not making any more of it."

Land rent taxes can't be passed on to the tenant. Land taxes serve to aid in the arbitration of land as a resource. And presumably, we stop taxing labor, and possibly even production in general.

One can always hope.

"Progress and Poverty" is a fine book and explains it all quite well.

Every time you read about the horrors of San Francisco property prices, think to yourself "if they had good Geoist land taxation, that wouldn't happen."

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Saturday December 19, 2015 @08:55AM (#10763551)
On a non-geologic time scale, "they're not making any more of it."

But that's the same with all other production. You're rearranging matter.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by tripzilch on Monday December 21, 2015 @05:50AM (#10770531)
No. Land is also a piece of surface area of the Earth. It is also a piece of the finite geometry of our living space, a sphere with a strong gravitational force directed inwards.

While it's not legally exactly the case that when you own a piece of land, you actually own the entire projected cone of matter inwards to the centre of the Earth. No, but ownership of the land (surface area) is intrinsically tied to the geometric volume of that cone (it's just at a certain depth politics steps in, and even further down, physics). Outwards it's the same, up to a certain height it's yours, then politics, and finally physics. Good thing there's this gravity well preventing us from projecting our deeds into the universe.

You can actually rearrange the matter, scrape off the top soil, sell it to someone else, and you still own the exact same piece of land. That soil changed ownership, maybe it had something valuable in it, then so did that. But the piece of land you own, is still the same, it didn't even shrink. (not even a little bit if you define its size to be the angular area).

It's not even made of matter in a sense, it's more like a piece of space. To the extend that you gain certain rights over the stuff and matter that somehow ends up in that space, even if it wasn't there before.

It's also got to do with energy, eventually all the energy here came from the sun, right. That conical slice of the Earth that you symbolically bought, also gives you the rights to the solar radiation energy that beams into it. In a very real sense, it's like you own a fixed percentage of the Earth's yearly energy budget.

Similarly, that other thing, Time, I suppose you'll agree that you can't quite trade time in the very same way as you can trade physical goods. You certainly can't trade someone's time by "rearranging matter" :) Also a particular slice of time only happens once, you can't make more of it. And even if you somehow "buy" someone's time, you don't really get it, your life doesn't extend, your day doesn't gain extra hours. What you really bought are the services that person will perform within their slice of time. At least you can sell land :)

But seriously, while the above is a bit of philosophical dressing, land really is special. Maybe it makes more intuitive sense, living in a country that is packed tight, every square metre planned (even the "trimmings" and leftover bits between roads and such are registered and classified as "rest space"), compared to the USA where there's so much empty space between everywhere. Although, maybe not, obviously in a densely populated city like (say) NYC, space is at a similar premium.

There's some parallels with goods that humans came up with ourselves, such as domain names or IPv4 space, and probably some even better examples I can't think of right now. There's a limited amount of those. But the limit is artificial. We did make more IP addresses with IPv6 and we did make more domains with the new gTLDs. Or maybe with limited-edition collectibles. You can't make new ones because they'd be forgeries, but really only because we say so.

The thing with land is, this is the amount we have, and we know it, and all we can do is symbolically cut it up in parts and symbolically assign those parts to ownership.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:34PM (#10761119)
Society would have to give up property rights, in order to not have "rules" forcing capital to "go where's it's told."

Contracts, holding shares, property... These are pretty dang fundamental, but you're just brushing them all off as "rules." It's absurd to try to study Capitalism SEPARATE from those rules.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by danharaj on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:15PM (#10760979)
That is a laughable definition. Let's just define our favorite economic system as "the system where the best things happen".

Capitalism is merely a kind of economic system where the means of production are controlled privately for the purpose of profit.

Observed consequences of capitalism are commodity production, competitive markets, sophisticated financial markets and instruments of debt and credit, wage labour, capital accumulation, and rent seeking.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:19PM (#10761013)
Rent-seeking is relatively agnostic of any particular economic order. To some extent, the Marxist-Leninist planned economies were nothing but that.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by danharaj on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:21PM (#10761029)
I didn't say rent seeking only occurs in capitalist systems, only that it is a consequence of the premises.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by ArkyBeagle on Friday December 18, 2015 @11:09PM (#10762583)
"... for the creation of consumer surplus."

Adam Smith describes mercantilism, which is nearly pure rent-seeking and capitalism. which is oh so much less so.

If you have a royal patent on all beaver pelts from the New World - to where your corporation can order the sinking of ships carrying contraband beaver pelts - then this is nearly pure rent-seeking.

Rent seeking grows like weeds at the edges of capitalism, but it is not, strictly speaking, capitalist but rather that which capitalism replaces.

This may seem pedantic but it's actually pretty useful.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Saturday December 19, 2015 @07:10AM (#10763367)
Did Adam Smith differentiate between free market economies in general and capitalism in particular? It seems to me that much of his work is about the former rather than the latter,taking capitalism as the only instance.

A quote from Wikipedia[1]: "Smith defined "capital" as stock, and "profit" as the just expectation of retaining the revenue from improvements made to that stock. Smith also viewed capital improvement as being the proper central aim of the economic and political system"

So, in capitalism this is implemented as private property. (A perpetual, transferable, exclusive right to some resource) If we f.ex. changed the implementation from perpetual to time limited non-transferable, we could do so in a manner that would retain the expectation of retaining just enough revenue from improvements.

Would this still be capitalism?

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_capitalist_theory (The actual source was a broken link)

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by ArkyBeagle on Sunday December 27, 2015 @03:19PM (#10798625)
I think your question is about 50 to 100 years later than Smith. He, so far as I know, did not distinguish between capitalism and free markets. His work was nearly ahead of its time as written anyway.

The "time limited" thing sounds more like 19th Century Progressive thinking informed of Ricardo. It sounds basically like George to my ear. And dependent on how all the math works, I can see no reason it would not be an improvement on perpetual ownership.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by wycx on Saturday December 19, 2015 @09:04AM (#10763576)
...plus regulatory capture and anti-competitive behavior.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by malandrew on Sunday December 20, 2015 @04:24PM (#10768351)
If productivity is defined as capital going to where it can generate the most new additional capital, then both statements you made are identical. The rules distort reality so that some activities are productive in excess of their marginal utility instead of productive proportional to their marginal utility.

Housing rents in pretty much all markets are productive in excess of the real life utility from the housing that earns that rent due to the myriad restrictions that prevent supply from growing proportionally to demand.

Lawmakers should as a general rule try manage both supply and demand curves so that the intersection between the two moves towards the origin or stays relatively the same.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by Mikeb85 on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:35PM (#10761123)
> Isn't rent seeking the defining characteristic of capitalism?

I wouldn't say the defining characteristic, but it certainly happens a lot, and is what Marx and now Piketty warn about...

(rent seeking of course being the movement of capital to where it can obtain economic gain without any benefit to society)

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by dnautics on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:02PM (#10761297)
I think it's a defining characteristic of Capital-ism - as in the belief that seeking the accumulation of capital for its own sake is strictly positive for society (which is closer to what Marx meant) but these days capitalism seems to lean more "free market"-ism, which doesn't care much for rent-seeking.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by crdoconnor on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:06PM (#10760924)
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:17PM (#10760996)
What do you intend to say by this?
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by zo1 on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:11PM (#10760957)
Well, you could argue it's a component of a capitalist system. But not really the defining characteristic.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @04:36PM (#10761136)
Maybe I put too much emphasis on the structure of private property. I sort of connect trading of private property rights as rent seeking almost by definition. If there were no profits in such trades, we would call them swaps no? And capitalism being explicitly about making property tradable is by implication about rent seeking.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by zo1 on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:46PM (#10761800)
If you assume a completely non-coercive scenario: Each side values what they're getting more than they do what they're giving out. So I wouldn't go so far as saying that it is a straight swap. Furthermore, in order to define/measure it as such we'd have to have some sort of objective measurement of the values exchanged.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:32PM (#10761428)
How is making property tradable "about rent seeking"? It's about pursuit of profit, sure. But rent seeking? How so?

Or are you defining pursuit of profit to be "rent seeking"? If so, your definition is in error; that's not what is meant by the term.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:24PM (#10761674)
Property as in traded for its speculative value (buy some land, wait for demand to raise, sell it). As opposed to traded as part of a service (buy plastic, turn it into a toy, sell it)

Capitalism promotes the former type of trade. For example inventing patents and copyrights as tradable property. these types of propert have no intrinsic value besides the rent extraction.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by zo1 on Monday December 21, 2015 @03:29AM (#10770182)
>"For example inventing patents and copyrights as tradable property."

Those are elements of a state-enforced monopoly (over patents/copyrights). Either way, the latter example you cite is (I'd argue) just as prominent as the former. It's called value-creation (or addition?), and is the core of a supply-chain.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:37PM (#10761750)
I can buy a piece of land, wait for the price to go up, and sell it. Or I can buy a piece of land, improve it, and eventually sell it. So I'm not sure why you single out the former as the defining thing that private property rights causes.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:53PM (#10761830)
Because you don't need private property for the latter. You can just skip the buy and sell part and jump directly to improve and get paid
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:04PM (#10761886)
I can improve land I don't own? I don't see how I'm going to manage to get paid in that scenario...
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:15PM (#10761934)
I'm not sure I follow. If someone sees value in getting the improvement done and are willing to pay you to do it. you can offer your services and accept payment.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:16PM (#10761357)
"Trading of private property rights" is redundant, because it's literally just trade. That's not rent-seeking.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:16PM (#10761638)
Yes and no. Trading services does not involve property, so no. But yes goods and capital can be bundled up as property when talking about trade. I do think there is a distinction somewhere, not exactly sure where yet. Such that even trade in goods is excluded from the kind of property rights I'm thinking of. I guess the line goes somewhere between scarse and abundant. But even then I guess we have to separate scarse as in unique talents, and scarse as in accumulated resources.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:47PM (#10761805)
Start at the beginning. Here's a tin mine. But it wasn't always there; it's there because a prospector found a tin deposit, presumably as the result of a large amount of effort. It's there because somebody invested in equipment to make it economically viable to extract the tin. So viewing that as "rent" seems a bit off.

Same thing with farmland. There's a farm there because somebody made a farm there; it wasn't always farmland. Somebody cut down the trees, cleared the brush, broke the ground, and started planting. It wasn't easy. Later, somebody (a series of somebodies) bought the equipment for the farm to be economically viable in the current environment.

Real rent is when the king or somebody gives you a monopoly on selling boot blacking (or whatever), so you can charge whatever you decide, and everybody has to pay it or go without boot blacking. I don't see a farm or a mine in the same category. (I do see a house for rent in an area with zoning restrictions in the category of economic rent, though.)

I guess I also didn't give a concrete place to draw the line, though...

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by wycx on Saturday December 19, 2015 @10:36AM (#10763815)
At least in Australia, the tin mine scenario would go like this:

an exploration company would peg an exploration lease-the monopoly right to explore for minerals on that land. They pay the (state) government for the privilege.

when an economic deposit is discovered, the company can apply for a mining lease-the monopoly right to exploit the tin deposit. The pay the government for the lease, and also a royalty on the minerals.

Whilst you can say that the mine was not there, and someone had to invest capital to exploit the deposit, the minerals themselves were always there, and once extracted are gone forever.

Perhaps the price at which the government sells monopoly mineral rights relative to the profits sets the boundary between rent seeking and not?

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:33PM (#10761999)
I guess I'd like the prospector to get reasonably compensated for the services, but think indefinite exclusive rights to be passed on for untold generations is excessive, and thus rent.

In the case of he farmer the cost/value calculation is probably such that a 10-20 year contract would be enough for the investment to pay off.

So it seems I'm arguing that perpetua, inheritable, property rights can be excessive, and thus create rent

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vezzy-fnord on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:42PM (#10761779)
Trading services does not involve property, so no.

It does. Everyone has self-ownership, and as such services can only be sold in the units contracted. A contract for a single indefinite unit service (slavery) would be logically consistent, but a property rights violation and therefore invalid.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by ArkyBeagle on Friday December 18, 2015 @10:47PM (#10762528)
I would say - using Adam Smith - that that which is rent-seeking is not actually capitalism.