News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 18, 2015 @06:47PM (#10761805)
Start at the beginning. Here's a tin mine. But it wasn't always there; it's there because a prospector found a tin deposit, presumably as the result of a large amount of effort. It's there because somebody invested in equipment to make it economically viable to extract the tin. So viewing that as "rent" seems a bit off.

Same thing with farmland. There's a farm there because somebody made a farm there; it wasn't always farmland. Somebody cut down the trees, cleared the brush, broke the ground, and started planting. It wasn't easy. Later, somebody (a series of somebodies) bought the equipment for the farm to be economically viable in the current environment.

Real rent is when the king or somebody gives you a monopoly on selling boot blacking (or whatever), so you can charge whatever you decide, and everybody has to pay it or go without boot blacking. I don't see a farm or a mine in the same category. (I do see a house for rent in an area with zoning restrictions in the category of economic rent, though.)

I guess I also didn't give a concrete place to draw the line, though...

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by wycx on Saturday December 19, 2015 @10:36AM (#10763815)
At least in Australia, the tin mine scenario would go like this:

an exploration company would peg an exploration lease-the monopoly right to explore for minerals on that land. They pay the (state) government for the privilege.

when an economic deposit is discovered, the company can apply for a mining lease-the monopoly right to exploit the tin deposit. The pay the government for the lease, and also a royalty on the minerals.

Whilst you can say that the mine was not there, and someone had to invest capital to exploit the deposit, the minerals themselves were always there, and once extracted are gone forever.

Perhaps the price at which the government sells monopoly mineral rights relative to the profits sets the boundary between rent seeking and not?

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by CuriousSkeptic on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:33PM (#10761999)
I guess I'd like the prospector to get reasonably compensated for the services, but think indefinite exclusive rights to be passed on for untold generations is excessive, and thus rent.

In the case of he farmer the cost/value calculation is probably such that a 10-20 year contract would be enough for the investment to pay off.

So it seems I'm arguing that perpetua, inheritable, property rights can be excessive, and thus create rent