Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story?
by ArkyBeagle on Sunday December 27, 2015 @03:19PM
(#10798625)
I think your question is about 50 to 100 years later than Smith. He, so far as I know, did not distinguish between capitalism and free markets. His work was nearly ahead of its time as written anyway.
The "time limited" thing sounds more like 19th Century Progressive thinking informed of Ricardo. It sounds basically like George to my ear. And dependent on how all the math works, I can see no reason it would not be an improvement on perpetual ownership.
A quote from Wikipedia[1]: "Smith defined "capital" as stock, and "profit" as the just expectation of retaining the revenue from improvements made to that stock. Smith also viewed capital improvement as being the proper central aim of the economic and political system"
So, in capitalism this is implemented as private property. (A perpetual, transferable, exclusive right to some resource) If we f.ex. changed the implementation from perpetual to time limited non-transferable, we could do so in a manner that would retain the expectation of retaining just enough revenue from improvements.
Would this still be capitalism?
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_capitalist_theory (The actual source was a broken link)