News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by cbsmith on Monday December 14, 2015 @05:18PM (#10734403)
That doesn't seem like a fair view of the analysis.

If the real value was in the hub, and these other lights were getting a free ride on it, then the opportunity would be to charge more for the hub.

What is far more likely to be the case is that the support costs around problems caused by random third party components messing with the Zigbee network were exceeding the value of providing that support, particularly when you factor in that the customers they really wanted to grow wouldn't be using anything other than Hue's.

So, while blocking out 3rd party devices decreases the perceived value of the hub, the drop in perceived value is far exceeded by the drop in support costs. Easy win.

It's still hostile, but to a distinct use case, rather than their entire customer base.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by gherkin0 on Monday December 14, 2015 @06:26PM (#10734763)
It's a total dick move on Philips's part to "update" incompatibility into existing products that people already own and have spend money and effort to integrate. These people bought product with the expectation of compatibility, now they're out their investment because of Philips's selfish business decision.

Even they have elevated support costs, Philips's made their bed by offering compatibility in the first place for many years. If they want to remove it, they really should introduce a new model ("Introducing Hue 2.0: Now with less bulb compatibility!") and leave the existing customers unaffected.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by jzwinck on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:37PM (#10735402)
> It's a total dick move on Philips's part to "update" incompatibility into existing products that people already own

Last year, Shimano (the bikes-and-fishing people) released a firmware update for their electronic shifting system which prevents 2012 (10-speed) parts from working with 2014 (11-speed) gear mechanisms. Literally, if you upgraded your bike from 10 speeds to 11, it worked when the hardware was released, but not after you installed the (irreversible) firmware update. This is with everything coming from a single brand!

You can read a little about that here: http://fitwerx.com/converting-shimano-ultegra-6770-di2-to-11...

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by qq66 on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:51PM (#10736008)
A firmware update for a BICYCLE? I obviously haven't ridden in a while.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by RightWingRabble on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @12:10AM (#10736071)
Wireless shifting. It's supposed to save us from the tyranny of the shift cable.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by gherkin0 on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @12:21AM (#10736096)
And when your batteries inevitably die out on the trail and you're stuck in some random gear, you'll bless the day you bought into this ~innovation~.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by gknoy on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @12:33AM (#10736128)
I'd be surprised if they didn't recharge it by pedaling. ;)
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by gherkin0 on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @12:45AM (#10736156)
That only covers half of the wireless equation.

...unless they ran a wire up the the controls to carry power :)

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by throwaway7767 on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:07AM (#10736876)
> I'd be surprised if they didn't recharge it by pedaling. ;)

I'd be surprised if they did. A dynamo adds a noticeable load on the bike, and the people buying this are already optimising for small improvements. Adding a dynamo to power it would probably be a net negative for performance.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by jrockway on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @09:30AM (#10737893)
A dynamo doesn't actually add that much load to the bike, but they're heavy and invasive, the exact opposite of what an electronic shifting system aims to be.

I run a dynamo generator for lights on my bike. The datasheet says it steals about 7 watts of power. I'm a relatively weak cyclist, but I can put out 230W continuously for an hour. The dynamo doesn't matter unless you're racing.

That said I still have good-old-classic 10 speed mechanical shifting. It works so well I don't see the need to add another computer-based gadget to my life.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by wiredfool on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @07:44AM (#10737435)
They should generate power from the motion of the shift levers.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by throwaway7767 on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @08:03AM (#10737514)
> They should generate power from the motion of the shift levers.

How much power would that really generate? You can't make them too stiff, since part of the reason people like electronic shifting is that it's easy to do when your hands are numb from cold.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by jzwinck on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @01:00AM (#10736198)
Actually no--the Shimano and Campagnolo systems (the first two to market, and the only ones anyone really has yet except some pros) are wired. Look up "Shimano Di2." The battery lasts about 1000 miles before it needs to be recharged, and it can be charged via USB.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by gambiting on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @03:23AM (#10736595)
To be fair, it's the same as top of the range sports cars having automatic transmissions(like Bugatti Veyron). Top of the range automatics are just faster than any human could possibly be, so they are a natural choice at that level. From what I understand, all professional cyclists use electronic shifters because they are more precise and faster - one click always means one gear, while with a manual sometimes you can miss a gear or jump two at once.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by cbsmith on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @12:47AM (#10736158)
Don't get me wrong, there is definitely such a thing as firmware crippleware, but being strict about compatibility with other devices isn't necessarily such a case, particularly in this case where random devices are disproportionately likely to cause all kinds of mischief.

In general, being more compatible increases the value of a device. When it doesn't, you've got some bad market forces at play.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by jpatokal on Monday December 14, 2015 @06:45PM (#10734857)
I'm sure page 67 of the Philips Hue T&C states in 3-point font that Philips Hue is only compatible with itself and they reserve the right to pull the plug on third-party product compatibility at any time.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by rhizome on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:50PM (#10735438)
On the face of it, why do they do more than that? Just use the warranty to recommend certain bulbs and let the hobbyists run riot knowing the company doesn't back them up for this stuff. But at least it still can work.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @03:04AM (#10736546)
wonder if that is open to a class-action suit.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by mcv on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:46AM (#10737030)
I would think so, but then again, I also thought the class action suit against Sony's removal of OtherOS on the PS3 would have been a slam dunk. This is no different: the removal of a popular feature well after purchase.
Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by crystalmeph on Monday December 14, 2015 @05:28PM (#10734481)
That's basically saying that you can't expect anyone to profitably provide support for a device that anchors an "open" system. There will always be bad actors who screw up the network for everyone else (especially when you're talking about a wireless network), and "civilian" (meaning non-tech-savvy) customers will usually call the network hub manufacturer for support, because that is where they will see the problem, regardless of where the problem actually originates.

Put another way, if your analysis is correct, it presents a fundamental weakness in any standardized architecture that relies on a central managing device, which could prevent the development of a robust ecosystem with many vendors.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by cbsmith on Monday December 14, 2015 @05:53PM (#10734622)
No, that's not what I'm saying.

There will always be bad actors. Often you design a system to handle them in ways that minimize support costs.

Consider the case of 802.11 or USB or ZigBee. In general, most of the value of providing a device that works with any of those is a function of how well it works with any other device. The support costs are also a function of how well the device interoperates with other devices.

That pretty much kills the value of making a device that only works with a manufacturers own devices, and provides strong incentives to work with as many as possible as well as possible.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by lazyjones on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @05:23AM (#10736939)
> What is far more likely to be the case is that the support costs around problems caused by random third party components messing with the Zigbee network were exceeding the value of providing that support

I'm amazed at the level of belief in Philips' honest motives after such a move. They just saw a large market of 3rd party bulbs emerging and saw potential profits for themselves, that's the most likely explanation with the available information. If anyone has financial details to back up claims of "need" for such a move by Philips, please provide them.

Philips has been investigated and fined for antitrust violations repeatedly. They don't really deserve benefits of doubt regarding predatory/unfair business practices without need at this point.

Re:Philips Hue blocks 3rd party lights by cbsmith on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @06:29AM (#10737170)
Let's just say first hand experience with 3rd party bulbs has convinced me that there are non-trivial problems there.