News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by danpalmer on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:20AM (#10730824)
I find it interesting that this is described as a Spotify clone. To me, Spotify is a large music library that I can pay a subscription to access, with advanced (arguably) discovery features. This on the other hand is a web based player and streaming server. I wouldn't describe them as the same at all.

Is this really how people view Spotify?

Edit: interestingly, the product itself doesn't mention Spotify anywhere.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by jmilloy on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:00AM (#10730972)
Spotify is: a library, a streaming service, and a web/desktop player. This is: a streaming service and a web player. You have to provide your own library, which I think goes hand in hand with self-hosted.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by krisdol on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:46AM (#10731233)
Spotify is all about Music Discovery. It is:

1. a music recommendation engine

2. social sharing of playlists

3. a music subscription service

To me, those are more important than the player itself -- in fact, I'd say #2 and #3 on that list are the defining aspects of Spotify for the general user, where #1 is more of a personal killer-feature for me.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by untog on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:19AM (#10731447)
Spotify is "all about" whatever you use it for. As someone who does not share playlists nor use the sub-par radio feature, it certainly isn't about music discovery for me.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by krisdol on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:43AM (#10731610)
Do you use it for its player, or its cloud library?

Music subscription was on my list. But, if you already have all the songs you'd listen to, and don't care for finding new music, what do you use it for?

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by untog on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:17AM (#10731860)
I do care for finding new music, I just don't do it through Spotify. I do play that new music through Spotify, however.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by vdaniuk on Monday December 14, 2015 @01:48PM (#10732946)
Spotify radio is the worst recommendation system I've ever used in any software product ever.It's just that bad and my music tastes are not really esoteric. Do you have any suggestions for music discovery?
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by jmilloy on Monday December 14, 2015 @02:33PM (#10733207)
I mostly follow labels of albums I already like.

The main way I do music discovery on Spotify is looking at the "Appears on" section under artists I like. A lot of these are compilations and mixtapes. They've been curated by a person and actually released, so you can get quality, real variety, and real similarity (of taste).

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by vdaniuk on Monday December 14, 2015 @02:36PM (#10733225)
thanks!
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by EC1 on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:50PM (#10732519)
Nothing will ever beat the accessibility of What.CD for me.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by kenbellows on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:06AM (#10731782)
If you already have all the songs you'd listen to, you won't be using Spotify. My use of Spotify has historically been about listening to music I love without having to purchase/download it myself. That's plenty incentive without any of the social/discovery aspects.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by mbrock on Monday December 14, 2015 @07:03PM (#10734957)
The way I use Spotify is I just use the "saved albums" feature, plus offline caching. This is how I like music: as objects called albums, which I "have" so I can browse and play them easily.

I feel like most music systems, Spotify too, does a kind of violence to the album structure, with all their playlists and shuffling and whatnot. The very idea of "streaming" is vaguely antithetical to the album structure and to the idea of possessing discrete artifacts... If I designed the perfect music player for me, it would almost be a kind of simulator of a record collection with a record player.

Anyway, I am also completely uninterested in Spotify's "social" features. I think their metadata interface is pretty poor and their "Related Artists" is totally haphazard compared to the actual musical knowledge embedded in databases like AllMusicGuide (which I adore).

I also get irrationally upset about Spotify's prominent display of what I call lifestyle propaganda, like their playlists of the day like "Saturday Beach Party Bonanza" or "Yoga Morning Zen Relaxathon" or whatever. (For some reason I never see "Technical Death Metal Tuesday" or "Zappaesque Hell Jazz Extravaganza" or "Lonely Bong Haze Headphone Friday".)

So I dream of a music player with another type of appeal, more album orientation, more facts and knowledge based relational metadata, and better catalogue curation (Spotify's artist pages are overloaded and unorganized and the metadata for classical and jazz especially are messy).

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by jmilloy on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:09PM (#10735494)
I've started to write this media player a few times, but get distracted.

A digital music manager should be at least as good as a physical shelf of albums that you sort, browse, and select; otherwise what's the point? No digital music player has accomplished even that.

Some enhancements a digital album-centric manager would provide over physical items on shelves are: searching and sorting via metadata, putting albums in multiple "Shelves", and tracking listening statistics (not as an aggregate of track statistics, but at the album-level).

My would-be media manager also supports "Mixtapes" (like playlists, except in set order and ideally with a length limit) which can be placed on Shelves alongside released Albums. Similarly, long "Live Recordings" have first-class status like Albums and Mixtapes and can be put on Shelves (even though they may be a single "track"/file). Finally, dynamic playlists of tracks are replaced by "Dynamic Shelves" of Albums/Mixtapes/Recordings, so you can quickly get to your recent-most-played or highly-played-you-haven't-played-recently, but always as sets of songs that should be listened to together, in order.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by jmilloy on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:24AM (#10731908)
You're mostly right, but the streaming service is useful, too, even if you have all the songs you listen to somewhere. That's particularly relevant considering the OP.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by jmilloy on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:59AM (#10731302)
Yeah, that's fair. When you self-host, you obviously also miss out on the social aspects, which includes music recommendation, unless you use a third-party service.

p.s. Do you really find that Spotify's music discovery is better than last.fm + curated reviews? New Releases could be a differentiator if they would at least offer a filter for full albums (not to mention filters by genre or "recommended for you").

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by krisdol on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:42AM (#10731597)
I don't know if it's better, but it's easy. I rarely look at my last.fm scrobbles. For me it's about hearing a variety of good music while I'm banging out code, driving, or gaming. I sometimes use last.fm and hypemachine to dig deeper but there are many more steps involved to get to hearing music that way. With Spotify, I get to be lazy.

Discover Weekly has been great. Shared playlists are great too. As for radios, they were OK when I first threw my music at them, but now I just hear the same old stuff.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by samstave on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:24PM (#10732373)
Re: 1. -- I find the recommendation engine ABHORRENT.

Disclaimer -- I have only recently started to use Spotify on a daily basis. And typically I am playing an already known-good-to-me Artist channel, and I am admittedly a newbie to using spotify in general.

With that said though, there was some feature, I believe it was called "discover music while you listen" or some such thing that would play some other artists amongst that which I chose to shuffle/play.

The genres werent even in the same galaxy!

I listen to EDM and industrial almost exclusively. It was interjecting Taylor swift, some country-sounding stuff and some other stuff that I couldnt identify but was the complete opposite of the spectrum from what I was into...

Further, finding a particular song that has the same word in the title as some song that is being heavily pushed seems impossible.

There is some band called TOVE LO -- and any time I search for a song actually titled "habits" not by them - the only thing it shows me is this TOVE LO page...

so, yeah - my experience with their recommendations has been worse than sub par.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by rjp0008 on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:35PM (#10732455)
I found 3 different "Habits" songs relatively easily. Are you sure it was Taylor Swift? Or just Taylor Swift-esque? Because she has relatively-famously not allowed her music on the platform.

I would recommend giving Spotify another shot, maybe spend some time favoriting and saving songs you do like, as it's recommendations have been on point for me.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by samstave on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:45PM (#10732494)
I was looking for "Maria Mena, Habits" and various remixes...

Maybe she isnt on Spotify... But ill give it a try...

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by danpalmer on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:31PM (#10732422)
> I'd say #2 and #3 on that list are the defining aspects of Spotify for the general user

I agree. I think most users find it very difficult to differentiate between features, so Spotify is 1, 2 and 3 all together. This is a sad state of affairs, because it means users are far less able to choose a product or service that solves the problems they actually have.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by wmeredith on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:59AM (#10731303)
I agree. In fact Spotify is kind of a shitty music player, but is so good at the other stuff that I love it.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by unethical_ban on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:48AM (#10731636)
I use it to play songs I already know and like. Its radio service is worse than Pandora, and I don't care to socialize music via the app - my friends and I use our voices.

I /do/, however, have a large music library for which a web player/library would be awesome.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by danvayn on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:52AM (#10731676)
last.fm has a much better recommendation system.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by laumars on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:35AM (#10731168)
Indeed. This is how I describe Subsonic to people as well. In fact there's quite a few of these solutions out there: Subsonic (and clones, eg Madsonic), Plex, Ampache, PlayOn, mpd (which has a plethora of supported web frontends). A lot of standalone players also support web frontends too, eg VLC. So it's quite an established market this is joining - which is great for us given the variety of choices we have available to us.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by BillinghamJ on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:24AM (#10730843)
I think it's more about the UI - which looks near-identical to Spotify's.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by est on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:44AM (#10730901)
Earlier Spotify desktop client was a state of art. 2 megabytes, every function works seamlessly.

It's developed by the same author of original uTorrent, Ludvig Strigeu.

Nowadays, Spotify kinda bloats with cef and funny feeling HTML5 UI.

Trivia: Ludvig Strigeus also developed Spotiamp http://news.spotify.com/us/2013/12/20/spotiamp-long-live-the...

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by drsounds on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:48AM (#10732110)
I loved the old client, I want it back as much I want my deceased mother come back to life, I really loved that program. It worked so smooth on my crappy laptop I had before.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by uniclaude on Monday December 14, 2015 @01:01PM (#10732596)
That's... a disturbingly strong statement! I'm sorry for your loss, and I really want to try this old client now.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by Domenic_S on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:46PM (#10732500)
> I loved the old client, I want it back as much I want my deceased mother come back to life, I really loved that program.

Holy crap, that is quite a claim!

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by dkns on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:32AM (#10731151)
Yes! I remember when they introduced new client. I was less than impressed. I think the new one is built on chromium or at least uses it partially as base.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by icebraining on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:05AM (#10731340)
uT was a good client, but it pales in comparison to his other project, OpenTTD.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by lucaspiller on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:30AM (#10731522)
Actually all he really* did for OpenTTD was disassemble the original TTD into C, which became the first version of OpenTTD. He left in the early 0.x stages of OpenTTD.

*Ok it's still an epic task :)

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by SmellyGeekBoy on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#10731703)
Wow, TIL that the same guy wrote uTorrent, Spotify and OpenTTD. His Wikipedia page informs me he was behind ScummVM as well! That's an impressive portfolio.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by 72deluxe on Monday December 14, 2015 @10:24AM (#10731481)
Very interesting! OpenTTD is truly great, and a program that I will always remember for giving me a crick in the neck whilst playing on it all weekend (on a tiny netbook).
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by circa on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:32AM (#10731154)
I always hated the Spotify UI. Now if someone could clone Rdio now that its on its way out. Then I'd be interested.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by pearle on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:17AM (#10731859)
Yeah, Spotify and Tidal have terrible Uis. I'm testing deezer now and I find it a lot better.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by circa on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:10PM (#10732276)
I've been waiting to try Deezer here in the US forever. Its still not available here. Which sort of blows my mind at this point with all of the competition here. Now that Rdio is ending. I may just do the trial via a VPN just to test it out.

At the moment I have been using Tidal on a trial and I just keep finding so many small features I miss from Rdio. The only thing I like about Tidal is the Lossless option.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by pearle on Monday December 14, 2015 @02:13PM (#10733097)
The lossless option is nice but to be honest I had a lot of streaming issues with Tidal. For example, if I paused a track and walked away for 10 minutes and resumed it would hang and wouldn't pick the stream back up. I had to restart the track from the beginning (this is using the desktop app).

I'm in Canada so I didn't realize Deezer wasn't available in the USA.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by circa on Wednesday December 16, 2015 @02:25PM (#10746572)
Yes, I have had those issues with Tidal as well. I was listening to an album the other day and it just sort of froze at the end of the track. Very odd.

As far as I know. Deezer is available almost everywhere except the US and Japan. I hope they figure it out soon. I"m glad to hear that you like it.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by richoakley on Monday December 14, 2015 @08:24AM (#10730841)
It's a visual clone.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by zuron7 on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:21AM (#10731885)
Without saying that it's a Spotify clone, marketing the product will take the devs a lot more effort.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by drsounds on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:48AM (#10732114)
I do think getting the rights to stream is slighly more difficult than getting this to run for a newbie coder
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by antsar on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:20PM (#10732353)
If one is streaming (legally owned) music for their own (and only their own) personal use, would that even matter?
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by kevinwang on Monday December 14, 2015 @01:34PM (#10732838)
>interestingly, the product itself doesn't mention Spotify anywhere.

The wiki page does mention the spotify inspiration, though.

>Using the client component of Koel is dead simple. If you’ve ever used Spotify, you should feel right at home. As a matter of fact, Koel’s client interface is a shameless rip-off of Spotify’s.

Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by AznHisoka on Monday December 14, 2015 @09:03AM (#10730989)
I agree. This is like producing a clone of the Google homepage with another logo, and sleeker textbox, and saying "This is a Google clone!"
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by antsar on Monday December 14, 2015 @12:23PM (#10732372)
Does your Google clone also include the search infrastructure behind it (in the same way as this project includes a streaming server)? Because then yeah, it is a Google clone. And just like this Spotify clone, the data stored in that infrastructure would be your own, not Google's.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by AznHisoka on Monday December 14, 2015 @01:05PM (#10732625)
Yes it does. But it has 0 pages indexed.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by dabernathy89 on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:06AM (#10731780)
I definitely agree - in fact, the Spotify player itself was the main reason I switched to Google Play Music. I hated the interface.
Re:Koel: A personal music streaming server by drsounds on Monday December 14, 2015 @11:49AM (#10732117)
BTW, I seeked for an open source clone of Spotify GUI. Maybe I can take this can translate the integration with Spotify?