News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by dschiptsov on Monday December 07, 2015 @10:21AM (#10689963)
There is no You in the brain. That You is an illusion produced by the conditioned mind. Animals doesn't have any You.

99.9% of activities which brain controls are "non-verbal", which means have nothing to do with the prefrontal cortex, Wernicke's areas, etc.

To put it simply, almost everything is non-verbal (doesn't require your self). We grossly overemphasize importance of that You we are obsessed with.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by marklgr on Monday December 07, 2015 @10:53AM (#10690148)
It depends on how you define "you". If it's the conscious self, then it does exist, even though it's anywhere near in control of as much as it believes. It's more like it's sometimes notified of what happens in the hood, and it got some veto on that.
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by esMazer on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:20PM (#10691910)
there's no separation, you and your brain are not 2 different things. The interface (what most people call "you") is that, just the interface. The real "you" is everything..
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by cmcnally on Monday December 07, 2015 @03:31PM (#10692457)
There has to be some degree of separation at some point though. For all I know, there could be more than one "me" experiencing life as processed by my brain at any given time, but the self cannot possible be the complete interface as a whole. If it were so, then the self could not continue to exist if a portion of the interface were removed, but it can, regardless of it being a less than optimal condition.
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by monort on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @12:40AM (#10695007)
There is seems to be indeed two of you as evidenced by split brain patients:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Split-brain

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by wnmurphy on Monday December 07, 2015 @05:36PM (#10693313)
It exists conceptually, as a representational model only. It uses symbolic systems of thought and language to perpetuate the illusion of a separate self.

"All boundaries are merely useful fictions." -Buckminster Fuller

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by _nedR on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:27PM (#10690918)
"Animals doesn't have any You."

How can you possibly know that.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by snowwrestler on Monday December 07, 2015 @12:55PM (#10691159)
Agreed. I think much of the western received wisdom on animal cognition actually comes from religious attitudes of the unique specialness of man and his God-given dominion over the birds and beasts.

In general I think we are still adjusting to what science tells us about who "we" are.

For example, we know we're animals. As animals, we experience a concept of "self." So why would we assume that no other animals experience a concept of self?

We know that the mind arises from the brain. So why would we make a distinction between our concept of self and the "other" parts of the brain? The title of the above article is essentially clickbait, in my opinion. There is no scientific basis for distinguishing between the brain and the self.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by dschiptsov on Monday December 07, 2015 @10:03PM (#10694504)
It seems like there is a fundamental difference between awareness of a fit back signals from various systems (fear, hunger, cold, pain, etc.) and awareness of the self as an separate entity. Animals obviously have fit back awareness but probably does not have the concept of the self, like toddlers and young children.

Self comes with language acquisition, which rewires the brain. That's why almost no one remember their baby days, it seems.

Before that language conditioning you are a perfect animal.)

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by _nedR on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @06:44AM (#10695835)
Oh ok. Looking up what you told me i learnt that what I thought was 1 concept called conciousness, could be defined as 2 separate but related concepts - Qualia and self-awareness.

Looking up the wiki article, it seems most animals don't pass the mirror test of self-awareness although few have (such as primates, dolphins, magpies).The mirror-test has been criticized by some as human-centric approach which could give false negatives meaning possibly more animals could be self-aware.

Your connecting of awareness and language is interesting. Do you have any sources to look at (articles, books ,etc)? Quite interesting field really.

Thanks.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by PavlovsCat on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @01:11AM (#10695080)
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by estefan on Tuesday December 08, 2015 @04:49AM (#10695561)
I've read about various research data that suggests animals may very well have a rich internal life which may well indicate they have their own "you" minds (although I can't cite any off the top of my head right now...)

I agree that an unqualified sweeping statement - possibly just regurgitated from various religious sources - shouldn't be blindly accepted. That sort of religiously-prescribed attitude also conveniently justifies maltreatment of animals at slaughter, even though research suggests that, e.g. the slitting of an animal's throat causes far greater suffering rather other more modern approaches.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by estefan on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:43AM (#10690545)
The User Illusion by Norretranders discusses this in depth. He relays an estimate that our conscious bandwidth is roughly one millionth of the total bandwidth of our subconscious mind. Incredible!

It's literally one of the most fascinating books I've ever read that completely changed my view on a lot of things. I wish there were an updated version based on more recent research.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by codeulike on Wednesday December 09, 2015 @10:18AM (#10704104)
Analysis of the claims about the bandwidth of consciousness here: http://memebake.blogspot.co.uk/2008/08/straw-dogs-and-bandwi...
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by estefan on Thursday December 10, 2015 @11:53AM (#10711628)
Interesting, thanks for posting!
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by dominotw on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:51PM (#10692153)
This Has been on human mind for thousands of years

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C4%80tman_(Hinduism)

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by estefan on Tuesday December 15, 2015 @07:37AM (#10737409)
Call me new fashioned, but I want something backed up by science and research rather than, well, not...
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by knughit on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:48AM (#10690583)
If You is an illusion, who is perceiving it?
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by gshubert17 on Monday December 07, 2015 @02:04PM (#10691775)
Perhaps part of our minds is a "module" or "function" that helps us infer what is in the minds of others based on their behaviors. No doubt this would be helpful in social animals. This "module" infers what is in our mind based on our feelings and behaviors. Then we ascribe agency to that "mind", give it a name, and call it "I".
Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by yesco on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:17AM (#10690331)
Daniel Dennett delves into an idea similar to this in his essays 'Where Am I?' and 'Self as a Center of Gravity'. I think he explains it a bit better than the parent comment which I found to be a bit too forceful. That can't be helped though, its not something you can sum up in a couple sentences.

Here the links to them for those who are interested: ('Where Am I?') http://www.newbanner.com/SecHumSCM/WhereAmI.html ('Self as a Center of Gravity') http://cogprints.org/266/1/selfctr.htm

The first one is a (fictional) story many people here might be interested in so I highly recommend it. If you are still interested read the second which delves deeper into personal identity but without the story.

Re:How Your Brain Decides Without You (2014) by umaguma on Monday December 07, 2015 @11:41AM (#10690537)
"99.9% of activities which brain controls..."

s/activities/known &/