It's absolutely not direct connection. You're looking at the phone which is looking at the thing, not looking at the thing. It's more direct than a professional photograph, but it's less direct than looking at the thing.
> A professional photograph depersonalizes it.
Looking at it through a phone depersonalizes it.
And to elevate oneself socially based on select signalling of goods and services consumed, places visited and activities performed.
The photos will happily sit on a device, external storage or the printed page for occasional review but let's be honest here: it has less worth unless others see it. It's not the memory-trigger aspect that's so important but the feeling people get from knowing others are admiring what they're doing. The act is mostly for signalling.
Some people forget the era where you typically didn't have a camera everywhere you went, and when you did have a camera you were limited by the amount of film you had. I remember that time and have plenty of vivid memories from it thanks to carrying the best camera I've ever owned: my eyes.
the cost to the experience is minimal
For the people capturing the moment perhaps. In Versailles I was whacked in the head with a selfie stick by a pirouetting halfwit. People fumbling with their phones and selfie sticks aren't considerate of the people around them.
I do think most people place a higher value on photos they took themselves - that much is obvious.
That's true, but it seems absurd to me to place a higher value on a photo than the experience itself.
They would like to have the photo in addition to the experience, typically so that they can remember it. Sure, you can look at a professional photograph of Times Square, but it's probably not going to help you remember the time when you were there. And you can't point to it and later and say, "hey grandkids, try to imagine me standing here but really young!"
It's bizarre to me that you don't understand this.
It's also strange that you think spending time taking a photo would cause you to somehow "miss" the experience - which, I guess would be true if the experience were a one-time only event that lasted a few seconds - but spending five minutes snapping a few photos at a two hour concert is not going to "ruin" anything.
You don't get to have both. You have to take time out of the experience to take a picture of it.
> typically so that they can remember it.
This reason makes sense if the person has some form of alzheimer's, sure.
If you want something to remind you of it: have T-shirts I bought at every concert I've ever been to, which have the benefit of supporting the band and not taking time from the show and the experiences of the people behind me. They're also something I'll actually look at on a regular basis, because there are few enough of them that I can realistically look through them all, and most of them are still in good enough condition that I wear them occasionally. I've recently switched to buying records at the concerts instead, which has an even more direct connection to the experience.
> spending five minutes snapping a few photos at a two hour concert is not going to "ruin" anything.
Except those five minutes.
It's not. You're just arguing to argue.
Unless you mean that it more directly supports the band, to which I say, why don't you just throw dollar bills onstage.
> This reason makes sense if the person has some form of alzheimer's, sure.
"Hey, I would've taken photos of my wedding, but I don't expect to get the Alzheimer's, so screw it."
Whatever.
Honestly, when I hear this, I think, "Why?" You want block the views of the people behind you and watch Prince on a 3x5in screen when he's physically right in front of you just so you have some grainy, poorly-lit photos of your own instead of looking at the professional photos of Prince that are available online? It harms the experience of other fans. It harms your own experience. It harms the performer's bottom line. There's literally no upside to this.
Practice some immediacy.