No reason US law has to open taxpayers to blatant exploitation by multinational corporations, who probably benefit more than anyone, from the US' unique combination of highly educated workforce, stable and for-sale political system, protective military, and millions upon millions of the most prolific, indiscriminate consumers in the world.
- The rest of the world.
Stopping (or at least reducing the amount of) inversions is easy. Just lower the corporate tax rate to an acceptable level. Large companies who are not doing inversion deals are often leaving billions on the table.
R&D in country X, Y production in Y, Z sales in X, Y, Z, and A. Now, which country added profits.
Except instead of X, Y, Z, it's ~150+ countries.
Anyway, there are arguments to be made on both sides, and it's clearly not working very well.
Since the acceptable level is 0, this is a stupid suggestion.
That may be closer to zero than you'd like, but it's certainly more than zero.
[1] This is just the obvious example, include here any where that the US gov out spends the Irish.
So give in to terrorist demands? No.
We institute duty on your products or services, we nullify your patents, we prohibit you access to the market. GTFO.
What's that? You don't like that? Buck up princess, government exists to protect its citizens, not your corporate profits.
Situation one: I'm a US company, expanding abroad. I acquire foreign competitors, and build a global company. I'm taxed on every dollar (profit), since I'm a US (holding) company.
Situation two: I'm a European company, expanding abroad. I acquire a US competitor, and build a global company. Since I'm a foreign company with foreign shareholders, the US can't tax my global income (obviously)
This means a US company will be at a significant disadvantage to a UK/Swedish/Belgian company competing in the same market, because, even if their results are exactly the same, their after tax income will be significantly less.
This also means that a US company bidding for a US competitor will be able to pay less than a foreign company buying up US companies, because they can achieve less/lower (tax) synergies.
That's how it should be. But from observation this seems not to be happening, at all.
I wonder if someone could mention any example from the last years where the US government has clearly chosen against corporate interests, and for protecting its citizens.
This is the thing Elizabeth Warren spearheaded, and the Republicans have fought tooth-and-nail since before it existed.
I prefer being subject to laws and having recourse to a legal system where i am allowed to challenge even the behavior of the government.
Subjecting corporations to capricious bullying when they do something unpopular is not "protecting citizens" - governments that act like that invariably also abuse individuals the same way.
Not at all. I'm suggesting the legislative process be used. You're inferring that trade protectionism is totalitarian rule. Seriously? Citizens and their quality of life is more important than you business and its profits. Full stop.
> I prefer being subject to laws and having recourse to a legal system where i am allowed to challenge even the behavior of the government.
But you are. If you operate in a country, you're subject to its laws. You have recourse under the legal system, and recourse for its legislation if you are a citizen and have a vote.
> Subjecting corporations to capricious bullying when they do something unpopular is not "protecting citizens" - governments that act like that invariably also abuse individuals the same way.
Today I learned that forcing companies to follow the spirit rather than the letter of the law is "bullying". Makes me found of how China and Russia do business sometimes.
This mechanism is sometimes used by totalitarian or very authoritarian regiemes as a form of window dressing to justify punishing corporations and individuals who displease the government. And of course these punishements are always justified by some appeal to "protecting citizens" - both Hitler and Stalin constantly used this as justification.
I like the fact that I live in a country where I can be punished for breaking actual laws not one where laws are vague or can be applied whimsically based on a notion of "spirit" or the intension of the drafter of the law instead of what the words of the law state.
Leave or do something to change the status quo. Those are your options.
What do you think the mechanism for improving quality of life is? Trade.
Not to mention, the elephant in the room here is that no evasion is being performed, but avoidance. To equivocate the two would create a moral hazard that would also affect the same citizens you're supposed to be protecting.
...because of legislation and existing tax code allowing it.
> What intervention will your legislative pen impose?
I would have to speak with a legal associate with experience drafting legislation for specific language. The purposes would be to ensure any tax intended to specifically be avoided by a merger would be re-captured (this isn't out of the ordinary; the AMT in the US is specifically designed to disallow certain income tax deductions when a taxpayers income reaches a certain level, to prevent tax avoidance).
My understanding is that the Double Irish Arrangement "loophole" has been closed, but further work needs to be done.
Mergers the size of this will always have genuine economic incentives in place to do the deal. Add to that very well paid lawyers who will put together an amazing story to get the deal through. So it won't stop them.
Also, this won't stop companies from being sold outright to a foreign competitor. If a Chinese company swoops in and buys the US company, these laws can not apply.
It seems like an easy problem to fix, but it's extremely complex.
Please remember that the TPP hasn't passed yet, and I don't think it should pass, so let's not treat it as a done deal yet. (even though you and I both know it will be a hard battle to win). Also, I think the world should be more protectionist...
It's also a reason why I think a defiant blowhard like Donald Trump could make waves as president. I don't think he'd have any problem dropping his sac to break treaties and crack skulls.
How about the US simply change its tax laws to prevent this happening?
I like the logic of trying to close it with domestic legislation, but the US sucks at that. For one, congress and the president cannot ever seem to work together to get anything meaningful done. But secondly, every single time we think we make an exception or a rule in the tax code, we learn that crafty investment bankers figure out how to exploit the rule. As Plato said, "know thyself." And we suck at playing nicely.
Completely hypothetically, say we could kill tax inversions. The whole thing has felt like a game of cat and mouse game for a century now. Inversions are the tax-avoidance scheme du jouer. For example, for years, Pfizer has already been paying virtually no taxes in the US by storing all of its IP in an offshore subsidiary. The "double Irish" trick is being done by companies who have never done an inversion. There are all sorts of holes in the tax code that other nations use to fuck the US. And there's no way we can compete on the rate, since we'd be competing with countries that have a 0% rate. Many companies pay a zero percent corporate tax rate on all of their offshore profits (which, IIRC, is attributed to a subsidiary in Bermuda), and mostly claim to have nothing but losses to write off in the US.
We need to finally say, "fuck this nonsense." Companies don't need laws to inform them when they're acting morally. It is immoral to act the way they are, and instead of playing cat and mouse like we have been doing, we need to put our foot down and MAKE every company obey the spirit of the tax laws, and not the letter. And the only way I know of to make that happen is to use extreme threats like invalidating their IP if they pull these tricks, or threatening the countries that aid them.
Unfortunately it is about as uncertain as a deal can be due to concerns about the government not allow the merger.
For those of you who don't follow corporate mergers, there has been a trend recently of larger american based corporations doing mergers with smaller foreign companies to move their head quarters to another country where the corporate tax rate is lower, these are know as tax inversions.
Burger King famously recently merged with Canadian "icon?" Tim Hortons in an attempt to domicile the corporation in Canada to lower their tax rate.
This is only going to intensify and its corporations telling America that their corporate tax rates are too high.
The US has a tax rule specific to itself where by it taxes corps at 35% on profit no matter which country it was earned it. It does let companies deduct taxes paid to foreign governments but it leads to companies operating in a way to minimize their US taxes.
From the article linked at the bottom[0]:
> Pfizer takes in about 40 percent of its revenue from sales in the United States and 60 percent from foreign sales. Yet, according to its 2014 annual report, Pfizer had about $17 billion in pretax income from overseas, and almost a $5 billion pretax loss here in the United States. By shifting profits overseas, Pfizer pays relatively low cash taxes compared with the nominal United States tax rate of 35 percent. Instead, much of its American tax liability is illusory, taking the form of an obligation to pay taxes in the future if it repatriates cash to the United States.
This leads to companies jumping through hoops to shift earnings income around and to holding large chunks of cash off shore of the US.
This might be upsetting to some people who think corporations don't pay enough taxes but it's not going to go away. The world isn't going to get more protectionist, especially on the heals of TPP.
The US needs to deal with this.
[0]http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/25/business/dealbook/why-pfiz...