News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:57PM (#10629248)
> Stopping (or at least reducing the amount of) inversions is easy. Just lower the corporate tax rate to an acceptable level.

So give in to terrorist demands? No.

We institute duty on your products or services, we nullify your patents, we prohibit you access to the market. GTFO.

What's that? You don't like that? Buck up princess, government exists to protect its citizens, not your corporate profits.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by charlesdm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:03PM (#10629288)
The problem lies in the fact that the US is all about free trade. They don't want to do that. You can't have it both ways.

Situation one: I'm a US company, expanding abroad. I acquire foreign competitors, and build a global company. I'm taxed on every dollar (profit), since I'm a US (holding) company.

Situation two: I'm a European company, expanding abroad. I acquire a US competitor, and build a global company. Since I'm a foreign company with foreign shareholders, the US can't tax my global income (obviously)

This means a US company will be at a significant disadvantage to a UK/Swedish/Belgian company competing in the same market, because, even if their results are exactly the same, their after tax income will be significantly less.

This also means that a US company bidding for a US competitor will be able to pay less than a foreign company buying up US companies, because they can achieve less/lower (tax) synergies.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by Maarten88 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:18PM (#10629400)
> government exists to protect its citizens, not your corporate profits.

That's how it should be. But from observation this seems not to be happening, at all.

I wonder if someone could mention any example from the last years where the US government has clearly chosen against corporate interests, and for protecting its citizens.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by Frondo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:23PM (#10629423)
You want the consumer financial protection bureau: http://www.consumerfinance.gov/

This is the thing Elizabeth Warren spearheaded, and the Republicans have fought tooth-and-nail since before it existed.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by derriz on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:16PM (#10629755)
That's how business is done in places like Russia and China and in many very poor countries. Displease the government and face the full force of state power regardless of actual laws.

I prefer being subject to laws and having recourse to a legal system where i am allowed to challenge even the behavior of the government.

Subjecting corporations to capricious bullying when they do something unpopular is not "protecting citizens" - governments that act like that invariably also abuse individuals the same way.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:20PM (#10629790)
> That's how business is done in places like Russia and China and in many very poor countries. Displease the government and face the full force of state power regardless of actual laws.

Not at all. I'm suggesting the legislative process be used. You're inferring that trade protectionism is totalitarian rule. Seriously? Citizens and their quality of life is more important than you business and its profits. Full stop.

> I prefer being subject to laws and having recourse to a legal system where i am allowed to challenge even the behavior of the government.

But you are. If you operate in a country, you're subject to its laws. You have recourse under the legal system, and recourse for its legislation if you are a citizen and have a vote.

> Subjecting corporations to capricious bullying when they do something unpopular is not "protecting citizens" - governments that act like that invariably also abuse individuals the same way.

Today I learned that forcing companies to follow the spirit rather than the letter of the law is "bullying". Makes me found of how China and Russia do business sometimes.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by derriz on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:13PM (#10630101)
It is not part of the legislative process in western liberal states to introduce laws that target specific named corporations or individuals separately to their peers.

This mechanism is sometimes used by totalitarian or very authoritarian regiemes as a form of window dressing to justify punishing corporations and individuals who displease the government. And of course these punishements are always justified by some appeal to "protecting citizens" - both Hitler and Stalin constantly used this as justification.

I like the fact that I live in a country where I can be punished for breaking actual laws not one where laws are vague or can be applied whimsically based on a notion of "spirit" or the intension of the drafter of the law instead of what the words of the law state.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:29PM (#10630177)
> I like the fact that I live in a country where I can be punished for breaking actual laws not one where laws are vague or can be applied whimsically based on a notion of "spirit" or the intension of the drafter of the law instead of what the words of the law state.

Leave or do something to change the status quo. Those are your options.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:25PM (#10629818)
Citizens and their quality of life is more important than you business and its profits

What do you think the mechanism for improving quality of life is? Trade.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:31PM (#10629845)
Not all trade improves quality of life, as I'm sure you're aware.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:35PM (#10629869)
Right, trade is neutral. Quality of life is a normative statement, however. The implication being that the state, as a centrally planning agent, is capable of calculating what will objectively increase or decrease QoL. Taken to its conclusion, we reach the spectacular failures of the Five-Year Plans and similar initiatives.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:39PM (#10629894)
I'd say the US economy isn't centrally planned. I would also say existing tax policy is used to encourage certain behaviors. I'm suggested further tax policy to encourage other behaviors as well. I don't see the problem. Shareholder's don't get as high of a dividend? Because its not like Pfizer is going to be using those savings for R&D. Its either going into people's pockets or used to acquire competitors (which arguably does not help consumers or increase their quality of life).
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by eggy on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @07:13PM (#10630628)
Following your suggestion, go ahead and tax US corporations at a very high rate, they GTFO as you suggest, and now US citizens have to pay either for an inferior, generic low-priced drug, or a high-priced one imported by the very same, once-US-based corporation that also supplied jobs to US citizens that are now also exported overseas. What Pfizer does with its savings whether for R&D or not, is not yours or the government's business as long as they are not doing anything illegal with the profits. If they didn't invest in R&D or maintain competitiveness and their profit margins will go down. Eliminate any government subsidies and corruption that may enable them and other companies to escape market forces and it will take care of itself. Central planning - no thank you.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Friday November 27, 2015 @01:00AM (#10636068)
You're free to your opinion in the same way a government is free to not enforce any "intellectual property" rights a corporation may attempt to exert.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:07PM (#10629701)
Of course, the cost of duty is ultimately offloaded to the same citizens you're supposed to be protecting.

Not to mention, the elephant in the room here is that no evasion is being performed, but avoidance. To equivocate the two would create a moral hazard that would also affect the same citizens you're supposed to be protecting.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:11PM (#10629728)
Funny enough, a stroke of the legislative pen changes these activities from avoidance to evasion, no moral hazard required.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:19PM (#10629777)
How? Corporate mergers appear to be an intrinsically available strategy for avoiding an extraterritorial corporate tax system. What intervention will your legislative pen impose?
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:30PM (#10629837)
> Corporate mergers appear to be an intrinsically available strategy for avoiding an extraterritorial corporate tax system.

...because of legislation and existing tax code allowing it.

> What intervention will your legislative pen impose?

I would have to speak with a legal associate with experience drafting legislation for specific language. The purposes would be to ensure any tax intended to specifically be avoided by a merger would be re-captured (this isn't out of the ordinary; the AMT in the US is specifically designed to disallow certain income tax deductions when a taxpayers income reaches a certain level, to prevent tax avoidance).

My understanding is that the Double Irish Arrangement "loophole" has been closed, but further work needs to be done.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:45PM (#10629935)
So, the business purpose and economic substance doctrines. Again, flimsy normative statements. A legislative pen obsessed with maximizing such a function will eventually write things unsavory to civil liberties, as well.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by charlesdm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:29PM (#10629833)
So your solution is to make every merger with a foreign entity illegal?
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:31PM (#10629849)
Only if done primarily to avoid/evade taxes.
Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by charlesdm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:43PM (#10629916)
I'm not up to date on the details of US tax law, but I'd be surprised if such a general anti avoidance rule does not exist.

Mergers the size of this will always have genuine economic incentives in place to do the deal. Add to that very well paid lawyers who will put together an amazing story to get the deal through. So it won't stop them.

Also, this won't stop companies from being sold outright to a foreign competitor. If a Chinese company swoops in and buys the US company, these laws can not apply.

It seems like an easy problem to fix, but it's extremely complex.

Re:Pfizer’s Big Breakthrough: Global Tax Avoidance by arca_vorago on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:05PM (#10629296)
If only the people in positions of power took this stance, we would be in a much better place today. What bothers me is that the merger between corporations and state through k-street and the revolving door/regulatory capture has become exceedingly rampant.