The fact is, as long as the financial system controls the political system, regulation will favor the banks. The only way for this system to be fixed starts at the ballot box.
The Finance minister basically rubber stamped it.
http://www.dutchnews.nl/news/archives/2015/11/dijsselbloem-u...
A credit union doesn't have "profits" because it is tax-exempt. Like banks they can, and do, run surpluses, which they return to members in the form of above-market interest rates on deposits or as dividends. If they lost tax-exempt status, they would have to pay taxes on the surplus before returning it to members, like banks do on profits before returning it to shareholders.
Interest paid is tax deductible for banks, and dividends paid to demand deposit accounts (the way most credit unions distribute them) are deductible for mutual savings banks (the banks most similar credit unions without tax exempt status), so this tax treatment isn't as special as it seems.
If you can make the argument that specific regulations offer no benefit other than to protect larger businesses that's one thing. But "It's hard" isn't convincing enough to me.
Where are you going to find politicians to vote for who cannot be influenced by money? Not on your ballot, because the one-party-with-two-wings has effectively made it illegal to run a campaign as an alternative. Greens and Libertarians are kept from the debates, kept from the ballot with restrictive measures, and certainly aren't owning the machines that "count" the ballots and determine the elections. (The election fraud from 2000 has never gone away, it just stopped being headline news. It happens in a recent past political election one of the presidential candidates called my house on election night to report their observance of the fraud- in some cases the absolute number of votes they got went down as more votes were counted. A mathematical impossibility.)
I refuse to give up on democracy, just as I refuse to give up on America.
That's the fundamental difference which means that you can't simply go to the ballot box to fix something. You can go to the ballot box to support people who you believe share your values. Sometimes it works, oftentimes it doesn't.
Unfortunately, it's unlikely that the USA will ever become a real democracy, so we have to make the best of the system we currently have.
The US (by Constitutional form) is both a (representative) democracy and a (federal, and democratic) republic.
> Unfortunately, it's unlikely that the USA will ever become a real democracy
You seem to be using "real democracy" to mean "direct democracy", buy direct democracy is no more real than representative democracy. (And there's a good case to be made that the problems the US has with being an effective democracy are curable while remaining a representative democracy, and that the problems lie largely in the particular electoral system.)
Would? No such calculation is necessary because banks are a state-maintained cartel everywhere - the opportunity for fleecing the masses with those sneaky & outrageous charges is just too delightful to pass up.
If people actually had a cheaper and better alternative, no one would keep paying those outrageous charges, and that's why the credit union 'had to be' "regulated"[1] to death.
Ever wonder why all banks charge roughly the same fees?
[1] "Regulation" is quite a double-speakey word. If you regulate an electric current, you make sure it isn't too strong, and that's where the word gets its positive connotation.
But when a government "regulates" anything, it's basically just coercion. "No, you can't offer people this beneficial service. You can't charge less for transfers. You can't give your customers debit cards" and so on.
> The only way for this system to be fixed starts at the ballot box.
Do you think politicians all over the world don't know that every single person on earth would rather not get fleeced with outrageous fees?
They all do, of course, and as evidenced by banks still raping us six ways from Sunday, they don't care.
Take any societal problem you see. Is there real evidence to show that they care? Whatever they tell you to get elected doesn't count, by the way. How often do politicians keep their promises?
Why would you think the solution to any problem would start at the ballot box?
You see things getting worse each year..
So do you not understand that voting doesn't actually solve anything?
Obviously, winning people over into participating in a pointless ritual doesn't help either, nor do the bribes a politician takes to fund the publicity necessary to win people over by lying to them.
Think about it.
2. Banks charge roughly the same fees for the same reason grocery stores charge roughly the same prices - competition.
3. Coercion is a straw man when considering government activity. Anything you don't like becomes coercive. I don't like that my roommate wakes up before me and disturbs my sleep - coercion! I like having subsidized education but not paying taxes - coercion! I like feeling safe with protected borders and the greatest fighting force ever assembled but not paying taxes or protecting people who don't look like me - coercion!
4. There is never a single solution, no silver bullet to resolve complex societal problems. I sympathize a bit with you here - what is the point of progressive reform when the system will adapt? Nothing structural will change, but will only shift. But at the same time, shouting down calls for representative change serve nobody either.
I also resent your use of 'rape' in that context.
That wasn't my claim. I said banks are a state-maintained cartel everywhere, and that implies preventing competition.
One way to prevent competition is to make sure the cartel banks can't fail. It's difficult to compete with a business that gets handed unlimited amounts of other people's money when it's about to go bankrupt.
> Banks charge roughly the same fees for the same reason grocery stores charge roughly the same prices - competition.
Do you sincerely think banks couldn't charge less for their services? :) Because that's what it would take for competition to have resulted in the current price level, as anyone on HN should be able to understand.
I'll stop here now because I suspect you're not being honest.
Americans have no one to blame but themselves. When I tell people they should divest their savings from BoA, a bank which was directly responsible for massive fraud that caused the housing bubble, they look at me blank eyed and move on. These people have power because we gave it to them.
This used to be quite easy to do, since you didn't have direct payroll deposit and never had to worry about covering more than your outstanding checks.
Now, with all kinds of automatic transactions most people have, you have to coordinate things a bit more carefully.
I really hope this isn't the reason large banks have power (inconvenience of switching). With a whimper...
Meanwhile, Chase has a nice Android app which gives me instant information about all my transactions. They detect fraudulent transactions immediately. Auto-Pay for bills. Convenience and security wins.
Since this is all anecdotal experience: there was a period of time between jobs when they sneakily charged me $5 per month when I did not make a deposit in my checking account. So I do see the evil aspect is there.
But point being, bigger credit unions are generally a bit more smooth at the edges.
Read up on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_McColl , the Genghis Khan of the US banking industry.
That's the problem for a lot of people.
Once a member, always a member.
EDIT: I think I misunderstood your point. If you're talking about being close to a branch or whatever, then that's also not necessarily a concern. The closest branch for my CU is 350 miles away. But the Co-op network and the website together cover 100% of my needs.
We don't have non-profits deliver most services because they wouldn't be efficient and/or couldn't raise capital from investors. And once investor come in, their profits are taxed. But there's nothing that in-principally stops a charitable organization from opening a non-profit car repair shop which runs with no net profit.
If, for whatever reason, it's feasible for non-profit banks to get started and operate successfully, why would we not allow them? (Please put "because the legislators are bought-off"-type arguments aside. What are the reasons people give?)
Are grocery co-ops limited in membership?
EDIT: So I'm reading through your link above. They mention the obvious way that nominally for-profit corporations could run at zero-profit by returning all excess funds in the form of interest to depositors:
> In contrast, mutual corporations are owned by their depositors, and the equity of a mutual corporation is derived solely from retained earnings. Because depositors are the owners, payments to depositors can include both interest and an equity return to depositors in their role as owners. While depository institutions are generally permitted to deduct interest paid on deposits, mutual thrifts are also allowed a deduction for amounts paid or credited to their depositors as dividends on their accounts, including amounts that represent an equity return, if such amounts may be withdrawn on demand subject only to customary notice of intention to withdraw.
Why don't credit unions just become non-profit and do this?
There can be. If you mean, why can't there be "tax-exempt non-profit banks", the reason is because the tax code doesn't allow it (though no-capital-stock member-owned banks seem to be effectively untaxed, except on transactions subsidized by federal assistance to such banks, if they actually distribute their operating surplus to demand deposit accounts of the members.)
> We don't have non-profits deliver most services because they wouldn't be efficient and/or couldn't raise capital from investors.
If you are referring to "tax exempt non-profits", we don't have them deliver most services because there are limited categories in tax law of tax-exempt non-profits.
Maybe here's another way to formulate my question: why can't a credit union operate as a for-profit bank, but just structure their company so that it's committed to never earning a profit and hence never paying much taxes? (It's perfectly legal for corporations to pursue ends besides maximizing shareholder value, so long as they are publicly disclosed, popular misconceptions notwithstanding.) In other words, why do credit unions bother to satisfy the legal requirements of being credit unions?
Tax-exempt non-profits are a subset of organizations not organized for profit. To be tax-exempt, an organization must not only be not-organized-for-profit, it must also meet the qualifications of one of an enumerated list of categories of tax-exempt non-profits in the Internal Revenue Code.
> Maybe here's another way to formulate my question: why can't a credit union operate as a for-profit bank
Because then it would be a "bank" and not a "credit union".
> but just structure their company so that it's committed to never earning a profit and hence never paying much taxes?
An organization structured like that is a mutual savings bank; as the return of surpluses via demand accounts (the same way a credit union typically returns surpluses) is tax deductible for them, as discussed upthread, it is quite possible to have a bank (rather than a credit union) that returns surpluses to members like a credit union and is effectively untaxed (it looks like a mutual savings bank that didn't retain surplus profits would be untaxed except on things for which it received federal subsidies as a mutual savings bank.)
> Why do credit unions bother to satisfy the legal requirements of being credit unions?
Because the legal requirements for starting a bank are pretty hard, too (whether legitimately to protect people from bad banks, or as protectionism through regulatory capture by incumbents, whatever, the barriers are there), so while the rules are slightly different for credit unions, you don't actually make your job easier by trying to start a bank-to-operate-like-a-credit-union.
> Because the legal requirements for starting a bank are pretty hard, too
So then the point of being a credit union, ultimately, is just to avoid the legal requirements of starting a bank? And it really has little to do with tax-exempt status? Elsewhere in this thread people have said the opposite. rayiner, above:
> You're ignoring a very important part of the story: credit unions, unlike banks, are tax-exempt: http://www.treasury.gov/press-center/press-releases/Document.... (see page 2). Those "mutuality" restrictions you note are the trade-off for tax-exempt status. Otherwise, the regulations applicable to credit unions and banks are more or less the same (see pages 1-2).")
It's a fantastic company that does great things because they want to help people, not grow huge profits. They were among the first to do ATM fee refunds (use any ATM), they never charged fees for using another ATM, were among the first with scanned check deposits, then smartphone camera deposits.
If you're eligible, you really should be using USAA. I prefer them even to the local SF credit unions.
Edit: I guess they are both a bank and insurance company.
It would be great if someone were to include some information about their executive compensation plan to see how their incentives are aligned in comparison with the large retail banks.
Their insurance rates are very competitive and their customer service is stellar.
There is a branch in Annapolis, Maryland across the street from the Naval Academy. Just as the Washington, DC branch, they don't handle cash but have a full-service ATM outside.
However, upon creation of new accounts in the past 2-3 years, they offer the predatory BoA-style overdraft protection. It's opt-in, so I imagine very few customers choose it. Still, I was dismayed to see it even being offered. It is completely out of place with the rest of the USAA offerings.
That said, it's hard for a cooperatively structured to be nimble and the bureaucracy and internal politics are legendary.
I don't recall what drove the transformation, but It wouldn't be surprising if those who made the decisions had some upside from either their current or future compensation packages.
Are companies still using Utah-based "industrial loan corporations"? That used to be an interesting vehicle for providing banking services.
The archive.org is an important project. This dude seems like a genuinely nice guy who's trying to go out of his way to help the little guy. In fact, I try to bank exclusively with the little guy (check my posting history re: that schpeal). "Mr. Modell and Mr. Kahle said the red flags raised by the N.C.U.A. examiners had been over small discrepancies and record-keeping issues — and often turned out to be factually wrong." I'm going to guess their risk analysis procedure just flagged his institution with 'red flags' as such: "new financial institution, potential violations here, here, and there." Those small discrepancies are important. You're a monetary institition in charge of what's often the only safety net someone has. Even if the 'small discrepancies' were minor, the risk analysis software seemed to do a good job because they caught the oversight. Small or not, I'd be upset if my interest bearing account wasn't paid to the cent, because it would shatter my trust. Their job is to move money around on time and with a very high degree of regulated precision. (In this hypothetical case, of course) the institution failed to comply with are admittedly sometimes onorous minutia.
On a more positive note, you Silicon Valley buds should all group together and open a credit union. I wasn't joking when I said the initial expense is around 100k followed by a few ten k each year. Here[1] you can do it for 50k if you're effectively online only. Credit is so cheap right now, assuming you can issue out mortgages in the fractional method banks can do (e.g., hold a dollar for every ~10 (or around abouts) you lend out in traditionally safe paper like mortgages), it wouldn't take much for you guys to save a _ton_ of money by charging 0% overhead minus the opex of the CU itself.
Also, re: the 'commonality' it can be anything really. Most famously you have any former member of the US armed forces, their spouses, and their ROOMMATES (if they're active duty IIRC) can join. Its been a long time since I looked at the specifics but the 'common ground' you share can be very vague like "yeah we all hold HAM radio licenses" would be a genuine justification.
[1] http://www.ncua.gov/Resources/Documents/CUDev/AcrobatDocumen..., page 7.
Their parent groups also runs a bank, electrical retailer, funeral directors, travel agents and solicitors.
Banks don't charge outrageous surcharges and fees to be evil. They do it because providing banking services, especially to small accounts is expensive. In 2011 an average checking account cost $349 for a bank to maintain [0]. Anytime there is an attempt at more transparent pricing or discouraging small customers there is a huge backlash for the public and regulatory bodies like financial protection bureau. Bank of America tried charging a $5 monthly debit fee for accounts less than $5k, 2011 only to drop it shortly after hundreds of thousands of petitions came in opposing the idea. Thr consumer protection agencies would have probably shut that down anyway by fiat.
I understand why a credit union is appealing to some but I personally don't care whether my services are provided by a for profit company. I give my business to the organization that can provide me the best value. Walmart shareholders can keep their 5% pretax margin.
[0] http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/176_238/checking-accoun...
Edit: I get it, it appears as though I'm defending the big banks. I just think an explanation as to the high fees is better than blind populist response of claiming the banks are somehow evil. Or the response that any organization that earns a profit is evil.
From the article:
"The single biggest cost, Israel says, is the cost of bank branches and ATMs. Another 20% is spent on back-office functions, including maintaining call centers and payment operations."
It seems like this is all about bad workflows and customer service... which are technical issues, not inherent business needs. There are probably technical solutions to these problems that would drive the cost per customer down dramatically. Perhaps going forward, there will be more incentive to innovate on this front.
...or maybe there's enough regulation out there that it doesn't really matter.
Yes they do. It's very common for commercial banks to intentionally order transactions which cause an overage such that they result in the highest amount of fees possible, and then charge an extra fee because you couldn't cover the overage fee.
If this were simply banks trying to be profitable, why wouldn't they simply raise overage fees and charge them predictably? Is there a regulation which disallows this?
Sorry, I'll stick with keeping my money with an institution that's not legally bound to engage in an adversarial relationship with me.
Banks charge fees because they seek to maximise profits. Those fees don't have to relate closely to costs. I'm not saying this is good or bad, just that it is so.
I guess you can call those fixed costs. No mention of executive salaries, maybe product development? If they were just fixed costs, and banks were making money off small accounts, why are they discouraging them so much with minimum balances and fees? I cancelled a small account recently and the bank seemed happy to let me go. Not even a question of why I was leaving.
From the article you linked: "Overhead costs, including executive salaries along with security and compliance expenses, also account for about 20% of the costs."
I'm not saying that the marginal cost of maintaining an additional account is zero. I'm just saying it's closer to zero than it is to $349/year.
What's stopping credit unions from being competitive against traditional banks are the regulatory hurdles. For instance, all credit unions' members must have some common affiliation, such as a small geographic area, or a common employer or alma mater. So you can't just create a credit union that competes with the likes of Capital One 360 or other online banks, even though it would be beneficial for that to happen, because the law says it can't be open to just anyone.
Although credit unions are perhaps the most successful and widespread example of cooperative businesses in the U.S., we Americans have not really embraced cooperatives, and that's a shame. Look at the U.K., where one of the most popular grocery chains is a co-op, or at Mondragon in Spain. Wouldn't it be awesome to have something like Walmart, but entirely member-owned? Instead of all those profits going to a relatively few wealthy shareholders, they'd go back to the members in the form of lower prices.
Technology has made it easier to gather like-minded people to start cooperatives. I would love to see a Kickstarter-like service take it to the next level.