News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:45AM (#10627408)
These "regulatory hurdles" that prevent credit unions from competing with banks were not created in a vacuum, they were created by the banks. No amount of Kickstarting will solve the problem of our political system's fetish for financial domination. The cause is obvious: as a for-profit institution, a bank has the money to lobby for preferable laws, let alone the laws they write themselves. If people began switching from banks to credit unions en masse, the banks would probably calculate that it would be cheaper and easier to manipulate the regulatory environment to inhibit credit unions than to compete on honest terms.

The fact is, as long as the financial system controls the political system, regulation will favor the banks. The only way for this system to be fixed starts at the ballot box.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by davedx on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @09:48AM (#10627421)
This is true. There was a scandal here in the Netherlands the other week where ING had literally written a law giving big banks huge tax breaks.

The Finance minister basically rubber stamped it.

http://www.dutchnews.nl/news/archives/2015/11/dijsselbloem-u...

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rayiner on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @10:26AM (#10627617)
The "banks writing the laws" narrative is misplaced in this context. Credit unions are tax-exempt. If you remove the mutuality restrictions applicable to them, they would not be "compet[ing] on honest terms" with commercial banks--they would have a major competitive advantage on the basis of their tax status.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by ensignavenger on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @12:18PM (#10628236)
What major advantage exactly does being tax-exempt offer a Credit Union? A bank pays taxes on profits, sure, but a credit union doesn't have profits, so they still wouldn't pay much income tax (no income to tax) even if they weren't tax exempt! They may have to pay more property tax (not sure if they are exempt from that or not) or other taxes, but surely a well ran credit union would not have a significant tax burden if it were not tax exempt. (Paper work might be an issue... but banks and credit unions alike have to do plenty of that anyway!)
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rayiner on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @12:46PM (#10628405)
> A bank pays taxes on profits, sure, but a credit union doesn't have profits

A credit union doesn't have "profits" because it is tax-exempt. Like banks they can, and do, run surpluses, which they return to members in the form of above-market interest rates on deposits or as dividends. If they lost tax-exempt status, they would have to pay taxes on the surplus before returning it to members, like banks do on profits before returning it to shareholders.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @12:56PM (#10628447)
> A credit union doesn't have "profits" because it is tax-exempt. They can, and do, run surpluses, which they return to members in the form of above-market interest rates on deposits or as dividends.

Interest paid is tax deductible for banks, and dividends paid to demand deposit accounts (the way most credit unions distribute them) are deductible for mutual savings banks (the banks most similar credit unions without tax exempt status), so this tax treatment isn't as special as it seems.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by toast0 on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:01AM (#10627789)
Credit unions are returning most of their profits to their members through dividends (interest), so they shouldn't have a very high net income; so tax exempt status has a low financial impact. (Some of the profit is reserved as a buffer against future losses, and would need yo be taxed for an equal playing field)
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:01AM (#10627790)
What costs more to a small institution? Tax or regulatory compliance?
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rayiner on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:06AM (#10627822)
Banks have to deal with more or less the same regulatory compliance requirements.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by smcl on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:36AM (#10627985)
Banks are rarely small institutions - even the smaller ones will have dozens of people employed whose sole job is to handle regulatory compliance (UK finance perspective here)
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rayiner on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @02:05PM (#10628905)
So what? Difficulty with regulatory compliance is intrinsic to being a small entity. That doesn't mean the regulations are stacked in favor of banks.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by smcl on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @03:34PM (#10629490)
So "tough luck if you're the little guy" basically? Seems a little unfair no?
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by Goronmon on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:08PM (#10629704)
Sure, it's unfair. But your argument for loosening regulations can't just be "It's too hard for small businesses." I'm sure things like health and safety violations are a burden for small businesses, but they don't get to opt out because solely because they are small.

If you can make the argument that specific regulations offer no benefit other than to protect larger businesses that's one thing. But "It's hard" isn't convincing enough to me.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rodgerd on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @04:11PM (#10629726)
So? Should Linux Torvalds have been required to charge money for his code because it might drive crappy Unix vendors out of business?
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by MCRed on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @10:41AM (#10627679)
> The only way for this system to be fixed starts at the ballot box.

Where are you going to find politicians to vote for who cannot be influenced by money? Not on your ballot, because the one-party-with-two-wings has effectively made it illegal to run a campaign as an alternative. Greens and Libertarians are kept from the debates, kept from the ballot with restrictive measures, and certainly aren't owning the machines that "count" the ballots and determine the elections. (The election fraud from 2000 has never gone away, it just stopped being headline news. It happens in a recent past political election one of the presidential candidates called my house on election night to report their observance of the fraud- in some cases the absolute number of votes they got went down as more votes were counted. A mathematical impossibility.)

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @10:50AM (#10627725)
This is how our political system wants us to feel: ineffectual and powerless. Don't bother voting because none of the options are good. The system can't be fixed so you shouldn't even bother. You end up falling into the trap they set for you.

I refuse to give up on democracy, just as I refuse to give up on America.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by SeoxyS on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:25AM (#10627919)
The USA is not a democracy, it's a representative republic.

That's the fundamental difference which means that you can't simply go to the ballot box to fix something. You can go to the ballot box to support people who you believe share your values. Sometimes it works, oftentimes it doesn't.

Unfortunately, it's unlikely that the USA will ever become a real democracy, so we have to make the best of the system we currently have.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by dragonwriter on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @05:15PM (#10630111)
> The USA is not a democracy, it's a representative republic.

The US (by Constitutional form) is both a (representative) democracy and a (federal, and democratic) republic.

> Unfortunately, it's unlikely that the USA will ever become a real democracy

You seem to be using "real democracy" to mean "direct democracy", buy direct democracy is no more real than representative democracy. (And there's a good case to be made that the problems the US has with being an effective democracy are curable while remaining a representative democracy, and that the problems lie largely in the particular electoral system.)

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by Kinnard on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:59AM (#10628100)
We could create a new system. Why is that never thought to be an option . . . people do do that.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by sukulaku on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:14AM (#10627863)
> the banks would probably calculate that it would be cheaper and easier to manipulate the regulatory environment to inhibit credit unions than to compete on honest terms

Would? No such calculation is necessary because banks are a state-maintained cartel everywhere - the opportunity for fleecing the masses with those sneaky & outrageous charges is just too delightful to pass up.

If people actually had a cheaper and better alternative, no one would keep paying those outrageous charges, and that's why the credit union 'had to be' "regulated"[1] to death.

Ever wonder why all banks charge roughly the same fees?

[1] "Regulation" is quite a double-speakey word. If you regulate an electric current, you make sure it isn't too strong, and that's where the word gets its positive connotation.

But when a government "regulates" anything, it's basically just coercion. "No, you can't offer people this beneficial service. You can't charge less for transfers. You can't give your customers debit cards" and so on.

> The only way for this system to be fixed starts at the ballot box.

Do you think politicians all over the world don't know that every single person on earth would rather not get fleeced with outrageous fees?

They all do, of course, and as evidenced by banks still raping us six ways from Sunday, they don't care.

Take any societal problem you see. Is there real evidence to show that they care? Whatever they tell you to get elected doesn't count, by the way. How often do politicians keep their promises?

Why would you think the solution to any problem would start at the ballot box?

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by webjprgm on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:31AM (#10627960)
It starts before the ballot box, winning over voters. And that takes money.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by ethbro on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:50AM (#10628051)
It realistically starts and stops at the Supreme Court. Unless they change their "money is free speech" decision, the US stays with a free market political system.
Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by sukulaku on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:13PM (#10631228)
You know they pretty much always break their promises, and you understand that your vote doesn't bind them in any way.

You see things getting worse each year..

So do you not understand that voting doesn't actually solve anything?

Obviously, winning people over into participating in a pointless ritual doesn't help either, nor do the bribes a politician takes to fund the publicity necessary to win people over by lying to them.

Think about it.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by huac on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:52AM (#10628060)
1. Banks are not state-maintained. You can argue that 'too big to fail' means government support for them, but support is not control.

2. Banks charge roughly the same fees for the same reason grocery stores charge roughly the same prices - competition.

3. Coercion is a straw man when considering government activity. Anything you don't like becomes coercive. I don't like that my roommate wakes up before me and disturbs my sleep - coercion! I like having subsidized education but not paying taxes - coercion! I like feeling safe with protected borders and the greatest fighting force ever assembled but not paying taxes or protecting people who don't look like me - coercion!

4. There is never a single solution, no silver bullet to resolve complex societal problems. I sympathize a bit with you here - what is the point of progressive reform when the system will adapt? Nothing structural will change, but will only shift. But at the same time, shouting down calls for representative change serve nobody either.

I also resent your use of 'rape' in that context.

Re:Difficult Times at Our Credit Union by sukulaku on Wednesday November 25, 2015 @11:18PM (#10631242)
> Banks are not state-maintained. You can argue that 'too big to fail' means government support for them, but support is not control.

That wasn't my claim. I said banks are a state-maintained cartel everywhere, and that implies preventing competition.

One way to prevent competition is to make sure the cartel banks can't fail. It's difficult to compete with a business that gets handed unlimited amounts of other people's money when it's about to go bankrupt.

> Banks charge roughly the same fees for the same reason grocery stores charge roughly the same prices - competition.

Do you sincerely think banks couldn't charge less for their services? :) Because that's what it would take for competition to have resulted in the current price level, as anyone on HN should be able to understand.

I'll stop here now because I suspect you're not being honest.