Going from building half of new homes as social housing to subsidizing rents through housing benefit turned out to be horribly expensive. With many fewer new homes being built rents have increased and ever increasing subsidies are needed.
Interesting radio programme on this the other day: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06bnbpx
More background: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n01/james-meek/where-will-we-live
So things like: replacing transfer duties with land value taxation, relaxation of zoning regulations, removal of any unnecessary regulations on dwelling density/height etc.
Hell, they could probably achieve a pareto improvement (though probably a lower one) by completely separating government supply of additional housing stock and provision of rent subsidies. In other words, it would be better, relative to current social housing schemes, if the government just built and sold houses at market value while separately providing rent subsidies to the financially disadvantaged.
Y'know, I really do feel for poor folks, but I'd be just as glad if thieves, prostitutes and dysfunctional alcoholics would live somewhere else (financiers, escorts and functional alcoholics may be just as immoral, but at least they are discrete). It's nightmarish to have one's home turned into a disaster area.
We all want the thieves to live somewhere else, but the previous strategy we had for isolating them also involved segregating millions of low-income people and trapping them in neighborhoods without opportunity, child care, safe schools, or, in some cases, even grocery stores.
This way is better for everyone.
The greatest irony now is that traditionally undesirable areas like Oakland are being reclaimed, further marginalizing those low-income people who are unable to adjust to the increased cost of living.
It's true we all want thieves to live elsewhere, but at some point elsewhere runs out, and you're left with a class of people that are permanently enserfed as the underclass.
I'm not sure which way is better.
This sort of makes sense when you realize that people who don't make much money aren't a different species, and like many of the same benefits and services as rich people: parks, grocery stores, schools accountable to active and engaged (busybody) parents, &c.
For example, new apartment buildings in New York are required to include parking if they are taller than a certain height (I think 6 stories). That drives up the cost unnecessarily, in my opinion.
I don't have a solution, but I think a basic income would set better incentives.
The hard cut off for social housing benefits incentivizes keeping income below that threshold to maintain the benefit.
Basic income does nothing to increase housing supply, so urban rents would increase as a result.
My suspicion is this is by design because a certain level of unemployment is required to keep labour costs down - or so the theory goes.
I've met a lot of people who don't want to work, some because they're slackers and some because they'd have to get full time employment because anything casual they're likely to get wouldn't be worthwhile as it eats in to their welfare payments. So the system 'works' for some definition of the term 'works'. It probably also catches a lot of people unnecessarily too.
And once you're in your rent-subsidised government owned dwelling, you're tied to that location. If you're offered a higher paying job that would require you to move, chances are you wouldn't because you'd either:
(a) have to go to the back of the rationing queue, or (b) lose access to social housing entirely
In other words, the effective marginal tax rate on additional earnings are well over 100% if relocation is required. Therefore, the rational financial decision is to stick with your lower paying job (or unemployment) to hold on to your rent-subsidy. Hence the social housing 'poverty trap'.
From a 'whole of economy' perspective it's even worse. In the aggregate, social housing impedes labour mobility, in turn lowering economic output and increasing the rate of structural unemployment/under-employment. Furthermore, it saps land market efficiency, as older social housing locations (that were previously on the outskirts of the CBD) are now in 'inner-city' areas (due to metropolitan expansion). As a result, land that could be put to much more productive use is tied up by social housing tenements.
Although the above is a bit of a simplification, in the final analysis social housing is a complete policy disaster that creates bad economic outcomes for both the financially disadvantaged and society overall.
It would be far better if social housing (and the land it is situated on) was sold on the private market (at market value) and the money put towards direct rent subsidies (that taper as income rises). Although this still causes higher effective marginal tax rates (due to payment tapering), the system can be designed so that EMTRs do not come close to 100% and there are actually positive incentives for those receiving rent subsidies to relocate if offered a higher paying job.
You cannot get a social housing -- you earn too much. But than again you (mostly) cannot afford going over 70-80sqm, especially if you are only earner in the family.
This means you're in the most competitive area and for every flat viewing it's you against 30, 40 or even 100 other suckers.
Edit: did some searching: http://www.thelocal.de/20150819/germany-building-homes-in-wr...
Quite interesting stuff.
http://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article146994158/So-schnell-en...
Five Bundesländer there had the population reduced from 14.5 Million down to 12.5 million...
If you earn average IT salary you need to prepare for weeks, maybe even months searching for a flat.
The only thing is during those times the city was criticized for being an overcrowded concrete (well, cobblestoned) dump with many slums.
The city needs to build out instead of up. Current infrastructure can barely hold population density as it is today.
The problem is that the fallback position tends to be building no new housing at all. This results in the same new people with more money moving in, driving up housing costs and gentrifying the area. No amount of not building housing makes rents low.
What is that mistake? Permitting new, nice housing?
If this is your opinion, I cannot agree with it.
Firstly, something like 10->20% of all new residential construction must either be set aside for "affordable housing", or enough money must be given to The City to construct those units on behalf of the developer. Secondly, San Francisco's mistake is to -through a variety of screwups- make it nearly impossible to build new, dense residential buildings in the city.
If a district is able to build enough housing to meet current and expected near-future demand, rents will usually remain stable. See footnotes 0 and 1 at [0] for some info on long-term trends in the area.
edit: There is an alternative and that is to find a second hand contracts where you will have to move out in a year because most co-op boards won't allow the owner to rent out for more than a year.
Also, if you've been in your current apartment for 5+ years, changing apartments effectively means double rent for you. Everybody I know who has an OK apartment in Berlin stays there, because an extra room etc. would mean 500-1000 Euros rent increase.
Have you been following the events surrounding the problems with rising rents in San Francisco? What you're describing is what has already happened here. I cannot overstate the importance of avoiding the mistakes of SF. Refusing to build in a place people want to live in will not lower rents. It only drives gentrification, evictions, and higher rents.
"Though about 20 per cent of the development was to be reserved for affordable housing, the locals decided to keep their expansive city oasis free of any new buildings. The rationale was that increased supply often only means more luxury dwellings and does not address affordability."
"Luxury" here doesn't mean huge, it just means "well built, nice kitchen, 14 EUR/m^2". It's like saying: "I don't want anybody else to buy a car, because they might get a Mercedes, which I cannot afford."
The social housing system is also quite unfair, if you ask me. Social housing apartments are in regular buildings, not separated from the rest. The idea is to counter gentrification, and keep the population mixed. You are only eligible below some margin of income. So far so good, but if you work and earn one Euro too much, you need to pay twice the rent, for the exact same apartment.