News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by tptacek on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:23PM (#10622469)
What's the alternative to mixed-income housing? The US tried segregated low-income housing for decades, and the result was a disaster. The new system, called Section 8, is a privatized voucher system; it doesn't give tenants lower rents, but by subsidizing rents directly, it has the same fairness impact.
Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by laurencerowe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @04:22PM (#10623677)
The UK experience of social housing was less bad than in the US, probably because it was a much larger proportion of the housing stock. There were still some terrible housing estates and I do think mixed-income housing is desirable.

Going from building half of new homes as social housing to subsidizing rents through housing benefit turned out to be horribly expensive. With many fewer new homes being built rents have increased and ever increasing subsidies are needed.

Interesting radio programme on this the other day: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06bnbpx

More background: http://www.lrb.co.uk/v36/n01/james-meek/where-will-we-live

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by spangry on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:30PM (#10625182)
Notwithstanding my above comment, this is a valid concern that governments need to address if they move to a 'untied rent subsidy' approach. In my opinion, the best way to address this problem is to take measures that increase the elasticity of housing supply, and reduce distortions in housing and land markets.

So things like: replacing transfer duties with land value taxation, relaxation of zoning regulations, removal of any unnecessary regulations on dwelling density/height etc.

Hell, they could probably achieve a pareto improvement (though probably a lower one) by completely separating government supply of additional housing stock and provision of rent subsidies. In other words, it would be better, relative to current social housing schemes, if the government just built and sold houses at market value while separately providing rent subsidies to the financially disadvantaged.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by zeveb on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:22PM (#10622914)
Just FWIW, Section 8 (in combination with depressed rents) is why for a good portion of the past decade I was constantly awoken by sirens: police, fire and ambulance services coming to take care of the folks renting a condo near me.

Y'know, I really do feel for poor folks, but I'd be just as glad if thieves, prostitutes and dysfunctional alcoholics would live somewhere else (financiers, escorts and functional alcoholics may be just as immoral, but at least they are discrete). It's nightmarish to have one's home turned into a disaster area.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by tptacek on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:46PM (#10623102)
I live on a block with several Section 8 renters, and they all seem like perfectly nice people with families.

We all want the thieves to live somewhere else, but the previous strategy we had for isolating them also involved segregating millions of low-income people and trapping them in neighborhoods without opportunity, child care, safe schools, or, in some cases, even grocery stores.

This way is better for everyone.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by yarou on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:44PM (#10623543)
For the most part, the US is still income-segregated. Detroit is the classic example, where the city houses poor, often dark-skinned inhabitants while their lighter-skinned counterparts live in the surrounding suburbs.

The greatest irony now is that traditionally undesirable areas like Oakland are being reclaimed, further marginalizing those low-income people who are unable to adjust to the increased cost of living.

It's true we all want thieves to live elsewhere, but at some point elsewhere runs out, and you're left with a class of people that are permanently enserfed as the underclass.

I'm not sure which way is better.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by tptacek on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @03:55PM (#10623619)
If you take SFBA out of the picture, the story behind gentrification and its impact on minorities gets very blurry. There are studies showing that gentrified neighborhoods have lower minority turnover than non-gentrified neighborhoods: people leave poor non-gentrified areas more often than they do gentrified ones.

This sort of makes sense when you realize that people who don't make much money aren't a different species, and like many of the same benefits and services as rich people: parks, grocery stores, schools accountable to active and engaged (busybody) parents, &c.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by lfam on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:43PM (#10622606)
I think the issue in most US cities is capture of zoning boards by property owners and developers. They have made it impossible for supply to meet demand.

For example, new apartment buildings in New York are required to include parking if they are taller than a certain height (I think 6 stories). That drives up the cost unnecessarily, in my opinion.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by andor on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:05PM (#10622783)
Mixed-income housing is not the problem, the implementation is: earn a bit more, pay a lot more. There's a similar argument against unemployment benefits: in some cases, unemployed people can earn less by accepting a job.

I don't have a solution, but I think a basic income would set better incentives.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by nosuchthing on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:19PM (#10623979)
Why not set a gradient percentage of income against the cost of social/public housing?

The hard cut off for social housing benefits incentivizes keeping income below that threshold to maintain the benefit.

Basic income does nothing to increase housing supply, so urban rents would increase as a result.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @06:03PM (#10624223)
Presumably the people who set these hard-cuttoffs aren't totally oblivious to the results, Australia has a similar problem with social welfare payments.

My suspicion is this is by design because a certain level of unemployment is required to keep labour costs down - or so the theory goes.

I've met a lot of people who don't want to work, some because they're slackers and some because they'd have to get full time employment because anything casual they're likely to get wouldn't be worthwhile as it eats in to their welfare payments. So the system 'works' for some definition of the term 'works'. It probably also catches a lot of people unnecessarily too.

Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by johnrob on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @07:26PM (#10624584)
The government should actively maintain an over supply of housing. This works for food; prices have been consistently low for a long time now. If you can reduce the amount people pay on housing, they'll spend it on items that actually grow the economy (instead of simply enriching land owners).
Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by dionidium on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @02:29PM (#10622975)
The alternative is a system in which you aren't penalized for earning slightly more. The current system disincentives work in all sorts of silly ways. Just give everybody money directly (i.e. a basic income).
Re:Berlin social housing winning the residential race by sedachv on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @05:13PM (#10623947)
Basic income without rent controls will just be a transfer from taxpayers to landlords.