News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by jcrei on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:01AM (#10620689)
There is already a big sense of alarm on social media (particularly along new EU/NATO countries) that this can lead up to new confrontation between Russia and NATO. I would like to think that Russia is not going to start attacking Turkey or any other NATO country just because one plane was brought down near Syria. Thoughts?
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by honestcoyote on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:21AM (#10620793)
Russia's initial reaction was to place the blame on insurgents and not Turkey. Even after Turkey claimed responsibility, Russia essentially said: "Are you sure? We really think it was the rebels. Hint. Hint." [1]

So that's pretty telling. Russia showed a willingness to sweep this under the table but Turkey wouldn't let them.

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2015/nov/24/russian-je...

"President Putin is reportedly readying a statement. On Russian state television, there was little discussion of the Turkish claim they had shot the plane down, with anchors and analysts speculating that the Su-24 could have been shot down by rebels with anti-aircraft weapons. This chimes with the Russian Defence Ministry’s claim that the plane was shot down from the ground, but completely contradicts the Turkish statement that an F-16 from its airforce shot the plane down."

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by ckozlowski on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:35AM (#10620892)
I thought that was rather interesting as well. It was only till Putin got on the air that they acknowledged it was a Turkish F-16.

There's differing opinions here on what the best course is to take on IS, though the one thing Russia and the west seem to agree on is that the Syrian state needs to be reestablished. Bombs from the air won't defeat IS; only a functional state will.

Russia is betting that Assad is Syria's best chance, and so they're bombing rebels. The west is betting the rebels are better in place to rule Syria, and so they're bombing IS to keep them off the rebels, but more importantly, giving the rebels a bit of air cover (no-fly zone or not, the Syrian Air Force is not about to test the presence of western aircraft over Syrian territory. The west simply needs to "be there".)

Russia is not keen on seeing their man in Syria (and by extension, their only base west of the Bosperous) vanish, though they seem to be conceding a bit in that they've acknowledged he could go in a managed transition. I dunno what impact this event will have on any of this.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:42AM (#10620948)
Putin came out and strongly condemned the strikes and implied it would have serious consequences for already-strained Turkish-Russian relations.

In reality I don't think it will change much, but Putin needs to keep up face with his population.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by norea-armozel on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:36AM (#10620904)
I wonder why Putin is trying to give Turkey an exit out of responsibility. Is he still trying to pull them out of the NATO fold? Or is Germany still stringing Turkey along for the possibility of an EU/EC membership?
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by honestcoyote on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:07AM (#10621095)
Because Putin doesn't want to see tensions rise and have the situation go out of his control. There's nothing for him to gain by blaming Turkey or be pushed into a direct confrontation with NATO. I mean, he seems to enjoy pushing NATO & the EU's buttons. But he tends to do so when he feels like he has control over the situation.

Blaming the rebels would bolster his plans in Syria and probably make it an easier sell. Might have been best for Turkey to also allow the rebels to be blamed. The Kremlin would still get Turkey's message loud and clear, but there wouldn't be any public conflict with unpredictable consequences.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by venomsnake on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:15AM (#10621140)
Because deescalation is the wise choice. Anyway the Turkey of today is not the country that was accepted in NATO. Which complicates stuff immensely.

Turkey is a rogue state now, with very fast islamisation going on that is protected by the NATO treaties. Bad combination.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:33PM (#10622163)
> I wonder why Putin is trying to give Turkey an exit out of responsibility.

Because doing so would allow Putin to look strong against those who did the shooting down by redoubling efforts in Syria against the rebels, while that doesn't work if Turkey is seen to be the one that did the shoot down. Putin doesn't want to give Turkey an out so much as Putin wants to give Putin an out.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by tomp on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:11AM (#10620740)
Russia has other, non-military means of "attacking" Turkey. For example, but cutting off the gas pipelines in the winter ("technical difficulties").
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by cryoshon on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:38AM (#10620924)
Sort of like how the Saudis created a glut of oil to drive the price down and crash the Russian economy, no?
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by tomp on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:54AM (#10621007)
That's one possible explanation... Although it seems unlikely that they could actually do that, their share of oil exports is high, but not that high. Even if they could, they have better reasons than hurting Russia - such as simply driving down the price of oil to hurt green technology and fracking investments. There's of course also the abundance of oil coming from the US, and the slowdown in China...
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by seren on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @11:07AM (#10621489)
There are also in the process of crashing their own economy, which even to reach strategic goal does not seem wise.

Falling oil prices and a a costly campaign in Yemen seems to be a bad combination.

http://www.economist.com/news/middle-east-and-africa/2167440...

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:05AM (#10620704)
Social media can do a horrible job of being alarmist when it comes to news of this sort.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by petercooper on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:29AM (#10620852)
But I thought we all got realistic when we all died of ebola after dying in the oil-filled Gulf of Mexico after that avian swine flu that was doing the rounds after the entire economic system fell of the rails a decade after comedy died on 9/11.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by cinquemb on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:13AM (#10620754)
Yes, I'd prefer cat photos and self referential reports on such by CNN, WAPO, NYT et al……
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by ch8230 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:36AM (#10620909)
According to the article NATO is holding an emergency meeting in brussels so I wouldn't say this is a story hyped up by social media. It's a sign that things are getting very messy and have major potential for escalation.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by redwood on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:05AM (#10620709)
You're probably right. But folks remember Franz Ferdinand. Caution is merited
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by omginternets on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:22AM (#10620813)
I get your point, but it's frankly a bit silly. We're nowhere near the political tension and arms-race that enabled WWI. This is decontextualization ad absurdum.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by redwood on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:47AM (#10620976)
A lot of people disagree and believe the middle east is very much like pre WWI Balkans with great powers sleepwalking with a sense of long peace. Don't very me wrong... this is a different time. But caution is merited because everything can burn up in the snap of a finger. Thats rhe lesson learned exactly 100 yrs ago. Cant take peace for granted
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by omginternets on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:56AM (#10621020)
>But caution is merited because everything can burn up in the snap of a finger. Thats rhe lesson learned exactly 100 yrs ago. Cant take peace for granted

Yes, but that's very different from implying that there's been an arms race that could set off a war between major superpowers. You're confusing the destabilization of a large region with a world war.

To be clear: the former is very worrying, it's just very different from the latter.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by redwood on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @08:13PM (#10624766)
The Serbian national aspirations were not initially global in scope
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by nkrisc on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:13AM (#10620755)
What does the hit Scottish rock band have to do with this? ;)
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by skylan_q on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:06AM (#10620713)
I would like to think that Russia is not going to start attacking Turkey or any other NATO country just because one plane was brought down near Syria.

You're likely right. My guess is that they'll find ways to put more pressure on Turkey aside from threatening direct confrontation.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by cryoshon on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:34AM (#10620887)
This is a bad incident, but I do not believe that a major war is about to break out; this isn't the cold war anymore, and the major powers are actively avoiding war with each other because neither can bear the consequences of such a war. If you read the article, you will see that even Putin is treating this as a one-off event that occurred as a result of poor coordination between the parties ostensibly united in attacking ISIS.

The Russian anger is focused largely at Turkey, who is the ally nobody wants to have in the fight against ISIS... it's no secret that the Turkish MIT (intelligence agency) has been caught transferring weapons directly to radical Sunni groups near the border while killing Kurds whenever possible. I think the overarching idea of this incident is that everyone knew that an accident would happen eventually, and so a mature response is to take steps to increase coordination rather than saber rattle about a downed aircraft. A complication is that the Russian pilot who survived the crash was captured by rebels; I assume Russia will deal with this swiftly.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:46AM (#10620971)
Russia probably isn't going to do anything other than tighten their adherence to the borders. They can't afford to start up with Turkey and NATO at large, but Putin is sure going to make it sound like he would.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:06AM (#10620714)
The next time a Russian plane observes a Turkish fighter plane approaching, it will be more motivated to react, it can be faster on the trigger, and then it's one NATO plane down, and then the NATO can escalate etc.

On another side, the area where "IS free to operate" is still huge:

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/83ED/production/_...

On the third side: Turkey doesn't like that Russia bombs also the Turkmens in Syria in the areas controlled by the rebels.

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/24/turkey-caught-b...

"Ömer Abdullah, commander of the Turkmen Sultan Abdülhamit Brigade called on Turkey’s government to intervene to halt the month-long offensive, the Cihan news agency reported.

“We are trying to survive under unbearable brutality and we need Turkey’s help,” Abdullah said. “Every day our Turkmen brothers are dying. We expect the government to support us … Why are we left alone?”

Abdullah said his forces were under attack from the Syrian army, Hezbollah and Iranian forces. “I don’t understand why our Muslim brothers remain silent. We need all kinds of support. It’s impossible to survive under such heavy bombardment,” he said.

Turkey’s National Intelligence Organisation (MIT) was accused of involvement in clandestine arms shipments to Turkmen forces earlier this year.

Cumhuriyet newspaper published a report on arms smuggling on 29 May that included images of weapons allegedly carried by trucks operated by MIT. Mehmet Şandır, a former Nationalist Movement party MP, told Today’s Zaman newspaper that Turkmens were facing ethnic cleansing in northern Syria."

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:13AM (#10620759)
"motivated to react"-like turning away from the Turkish border at full afterburner? Alarmism and freaking out doesn't do anyone any good.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:18AM (#10620779)
See the map of the bombings (the post above). There is a huge bombing activity near the Turkish border. "Turning away from the border" would mean stop such operations. It's obvious that Turkey intentionally overreacts. See also honestcoyote's comment here.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:33AM (#10620878)
With all due respect, nothing except our own opinions are "obvious" at this time.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:36AM (#10621293)
See other comments here, the plane was obviously only some seconds over Turkey and therefore already flying out of territory. It's an ambush-kind of attack. But Turkey can surely still claim it protected its territory.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:41PM (#10622204)
> See other comments here, the plane was obviously only some seconds over Turkey and therefore already flying out of territory.

This was not an isolated incident, many incursions have occurred since Russia started its operations in Syria, and Turkey has warned, repeatedly, that if aerial incursions continued, it would result in planes being shot down. It seems to me Russia has been deliberately sending a message by the continued incursions, and that Turkey has responded to that message in exactly the way it said it would (and the only way possible other than accept that it will become a vassal of Russia.)

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @12:58PM (#10622303)
"the only way possible other than accept that it will become a vassal of Russia."

So a few seconds of a flight by a plane from a country supposedly on the same side against the ISIS, over the few km of the territory, is equal to becoming a vassal of a said country. So the only way possible is shooting the plane. Thanks for explaining your view.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @01:51PM (#10622669)
> So a few seconds of a flight by a plane from a country supposedly on the same side against the ISIS, over the few km of the territory, is equal to becoming a vassal of a said country.

No, the "few seconds" and the relationship to Daesh are irrelevant.

The continued incursions into sovereign territory by a country which has engaged in such incursions without permission and been publicly threatened with force if it does not cease means that.

(Anyway, Russia is attacking opponents of the Assad regime, not just Daesh, including non-Daesh forces which are supported by Turkey. That the set of entities Turkey opposes in Syria and the set Russia opposes overlap because both include Daesh does not mean that they are on the same side.)

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by pjc50 on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:27AM (#10620838)
I very much doubt it's in the Russian rules of engagement to fire on NATO aircraft over third-party territory.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:28AM (#10620850)
But it is in NATO rules of engagement to fire on Russian aircraft over third-party territory? Obviously there is some kind of willfulness for the escalation and the tolerance levels are never infinite.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by merpnderp on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:47AM (#10620980)
That NATO fired on a Russian aircraft over third-party territory is not a fact. Turkey has offered evidence that the Russian aircraft was over a thin sliver of Turkish territory.
Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by acqq on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @09:54AM (#10621013)
The map here:

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/06EE/production/_...

And according to the Google Maps, it was cca 3 km crossed during the whole flight, which means the plane was effectively just some seconds over what's considered Turkey and obviously flying out of the territory.

Re:Turkey Shoots Down Russian Warplane Near Syrian Border by merpnderp on Tuesday November 24, 2015 @10:57AM (#10621422)
I agree with your parent statement that there is a Turkish willfulness to escalate. Flying over sovereign territory for 2 seconds, with a clear exist trajectory, isn't usually considered attack worthy. But it is not unlikely that this was Turkey taking what it considered a legitimate attack as revenge for Russian attacks on ethnic Turks in Syria.