News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by crystaln on Monday November 23, 2015 @07:56AM (#10614290)
The idea that induced demand entirely compensates for new road capacity is ridiculous on its face. This would only be nearly the case if the road infrastructure is vastly behind what's needed. Even then, much of the newly accommodated traffic will be of economic benefit.

Consider that the theory states that traffic is unchanged because people will be incentivized to drive more because of less traffic. This is self contradictory - there can't be both less traffic and the same traffic.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by dsfyu404ed on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:45AM (#10614501)
For high demand times of day the infrastructure is vastly behind what's needed...
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by maxerickson on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:49AM (#10614520)
Especially if you take "needed" to mean the amount of infrastructure that would be utilized in a particular place if it existed.

Much of the point of public planning is that in practice that definition of need isn't one that really creates fantastic outcomes.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by revelation on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:45AM (#10614500)
Nobody is saying that. The problem with induced demand for roads is induced demand for personal cars. Transport is a zero-sum game, someone who takes the personal car to work is someone not taking the train. As countless studies attest, this is not of economic (or personal) benefit. It locks people into a life-long dependency on cars with the terrible health outcomes for them personally and the humongous cost of human life in traffic deaths every year.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by mikeash on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:05AM (#10614937)
Transport is not a zero-sum game. People optionally telecommute. People work odd hours (or don't work at all) and take optional trips at peak times. People move closer to or farther away from the places they routinely go (e.g. work).
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by dsfyu404ed on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:46AM (#10614509)
"the terrible health outcomes for them personally"

Cite this, I dare you.

edit: the part I'm not buying is the combination of "terrible" and "personal"

It matters little whether you're sitting on your but for 45min in a car or on a bus, you're still not getting exercise. That's not really "terrible" as it's something that can easily be counteracted unlike (for example) working in a loud environment for 45min twice per day without hearing protection.

The "terrible" stuff (accidents) isn't really personal because it only comes into play on a statistical level (seeing as most people will never be seriously injured in a vehicle accident)

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by andys627 on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:52AM (#10614547)
http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/content/33/2/160.full this cites about 50 more that could be listed
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by audunw on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:12AM (#10614636)
What about actually spending 10 seconds to Google it yourself, rather than implying that there couldn't be such a study?

(a note: you'd have a point if you're pointing out that "terrible" is exaggerated, but that would silly since it's obvious, so I'm assuming you think that there's no health benefit)

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by revelation on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:11AM (#10614628)
What's to cite? Sitting in your car is not physical activity, no physical activity is strongly associated with any number of bad health outcomes (cardiovascular disease, obesity, diabetes 2). All of the alternatives provide lots (cycling) to moderate (walking) physical activity.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by mikerichards on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:56AM (#10614569)
I can't reply to Andys627 directly, so from his citation

Background Public health must continually respond to new threats reflecting wider societal changes. Ecological public health recognizes the links between human health and global sustainability. We argue that these links are typified by the harms caused by dependence on private cars.

Right there off the bat tells us that they have a political ideology that they're trying to justify with their "study".

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by mikerichards on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:54AM (#10614555)
It's funny how people will make things up to satisfy the HN anti-car hive mind.

Sorry people, you're living in a bubble. The vast, vast, VAST majority of people don't hate cars like the HN collective does.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by audunw on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:16AM (#10614664)
*The vast, vast, VAST majority of people _in the US_ don't hate cars

People generally don't hate their own culture. But it's obvious from a european perspective that the US has an unhealthy obsession about cars. Not that we hate cars, but we don't worship them either.

And I don't think HN hates cars. All I've seen is people pointing out real issues. Maybe some exaggeration here and there, but everyone is guilty of that.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by ant6n on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:23AM (#10615425)
Actually many people on HN live in the pro-car-obsession bubble. Which seems strange for a group of people that is collectively educated, aware of issues, good at analysis of problems, and generally dreams of a better future.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by distances on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:16AM (#10614663)
Many countries in Europe have a clear generational change ongoing: young people are much less likely to get a car or a driver's license. I would expect HN just to reflect this general trend.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by trgn on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:31AM (#10615460)
There is no hive-mind about this issue on HN. About half the comments here are from people who dispute the article.

From my own personal experience(real life, not on-line), techies are by FAR more pro-car, and dismissive off traditional urbanism. Real Engineers outside software even more so. I think it is because suburban homes have a lot of space for all the crap tinkerers collect. Hobbies in this crowd tend to skew to things with stuff; drones, cars, ... A more introverted disposition may drive engineers to the quiet and seclusion of the suburbs too. Plus, engineers like to optimize things. Keep the process intact, but strive for less travel time, less fuel consumption, less pollution, less casualties. Hence electrical cars. Hence self-driving cars. But always "cars".

Not necessarily related to what you were saying, but I'll sneak it in anyway:

Traffic is not a technological challenge, it is a human one, with all the messiness that entails. An anthropologist can just as well study traffic (and propose solutions) as a traffic engineer. The big mistake in the US was to hand over the governance and implementation of our urban environment to technocrats. The planning profession has long since come around, precisely because often they were educated in sociology departments (Oh, the affront an engineer must feel when he has to justify building codes to this numbnut planner who probably only passed intro to stats by schmoozing with the TA!). Anyway, eventually the bureaucrats, legislators, and building professionals will come around too. But it requires for a lot of people to reject what they have - literally - bought into. The suburbs are NOT doomed though, there's a lot of good about it. But they are expensive. So the suburbs at all cost are most definitely coming at an end. Municipalities are strained financially, precisely because the financial obligations of maintaining car sprawl are high. On an individual level, the suburbs just cost a lot too. Everybody needs a car, maintenance & utilities costs of the home are born by just a single household, etc... The suburbs are massive social engineering, a federal project to promote home ownership and promote financial independence. Plus, a sprawling city would be more resilient should a nuclear war breakout, that paranoia was also something in the 50s. The home ownership part has succeeded, but the financial independence part has been a total failure.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by andys627 on Thursday November 26, 2015 @08:10AM (#10632788)
I don't hate cars. I want people to understand how much we subsidize them. I want to bust the myth that they are the only way in the US and I want that to lead to subsidizing alternatives.

In the USA the car is the solution to every city building problem. This is the problem as I see it.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by pfortuny on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:12AM (#10614348)
Inertia makes things react late to forces. Same here. The article clearly states that the new capacity is essentially filled in the long (10 year range) term, not the short one.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by skellington on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:58AM (#10614579)
Wow, what an illuminating study. If you build roads and the population continues to grow and/or pent up demand is release, those roads will eventually/immediately clog up.

Obviously people use roads until the equilibrium of pain is met (like any economic decision). But, there is a point where you can supply so much capacity that there won't be traffic. It's a lie to say that no amount of capacity can overwhelm all forms of demand.

The only real question is how much road would it take to fully satisfy demand and what would that cost vs the alternatives. (Ignoring pollution issues)

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by lhopki01 on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:35AM (#10614771)
And what is that point? More roads mean less living area which means more roads to get out to where there is living area. A poorly designed response to a problem makes the problem even worse. There are better ways of dealing with pent up demand for movement than to build more roads. Ones that are more efficient of resources, that are better for the environment and that provide a better quality of life for everyone.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by Majestic121 on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:05AM (#10614608)
I don't see any good reason to ignore pollution when looking for the best solution.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by rplst8 on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:51AM (#10614538)
I think in some major metro areas, the road capacity is vastly behind what is needed. My commute is is 26 miles of limited access highway that occurs at nearly 1/3 to 1/2 of the posted speed limit.

The only reason there is induced demand is that the infrastructure is too small to support the way our cities and metro areas have evolved. Maybe the way they have evolved is a product of the Eisenhower Interstate highway system, but we're already invested in that infrastructure. It would take an inordinate amount of money, resources, and effort to relocate and redesign our cities than to just build the correct size (and number) of highways to support the population.

In addition - one thing that it seems highway planners rarely plan correctly for is growth. The population of the Washington DC metro area has grown from about 3 million in 1980 to over 6 million currently. Many of the highways are nearly the same size over that span.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by angdis on Monday November 23, 2015 @09:52AM (#10614859)
DC actually did plan for growth when they build the metro. Everyday it transports a staggering number of people which would be intractable for ANY highway system if these same people drove.

What they failed to account for, however, is the growth of exburbs like Ashburn VA and other places even further out like Frederick MD.

These remote places are built by developers who literally put ZERO thought into infrastructure and what will happen to traffic and many other things when thousands of well-paid people move into their McMansions in the middle of nowhere.

They just buy up farmland from farmers who want to retire, sell a fake dream of idyllic rural living, plop down a bunch of cookie-cutter houses, then take the money and do all over again somewhere else. People have been finally getting wise to this anti-pattern (it was known in Maryland since the 90's) and the citylab article is an example.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by rplst8 on Monday November 23, 2015 @10:29AM (#10615086)
The DC Metro has a daily ridership of about 700,000 trips. This is nothing to sneeze at, and it is impressive. However, I'm not positive how they calculate a trip, but my guess is that it's a card swipe entry and exit. Most people are traveling to and from work, so that is likely half that number in unique people. So say 350,000 - 400,000 a day. On the other hand, I-270 through Maryland sees about 200,000 cars daily. That's one highway - with at least some cars carrying more than 1 person. Interstates 66 and 95, US route 50, MD route 295, and VA route 267 all carry similar amounts of traffic. And lets not forget the other minor routes and streets that carry additional traffic. Your assertion that it "would be intractable for ANY highway system" to handle this is absurd - it already does.

While I too find some scorn for the McMansion culture, it is not really a local developers job or role to plan for medium to long distance infrastructure. I don't think it would even be legally possible for a private entity to take on a highway project that crossed multiple counties and/or states without a massive amount of support from local and state governments.

Also, I wouldn't call suburban and rural development an anti-pattern. Unless you want the cities to be double the density they already are, some people are going to have to live in the suburbs and rural parts of the country.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by angdis on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:11AM (#10615345)
There's a more to a car trip than just going through a highway. Trips have endpoints. If you increase the size of your pipe into the city, you also have to increase the volume of the parking within the city. That means parking garages, lots of them. In addition to more costs for everybody, you're then deteriorating the urban fabric and making drivers within the city miserable in process (whether they recognize it or not).

As far as # of daily metro rides. My point is that if the metro were shutdown, the highways in and around DC would be a nightmare and people would not enjoy travelling in or through it. Getting around in DC, without the metro, would BE INTRACTABLE.

As for developers, while it is not "their job" to plan for infrastructure, it is very disturbing that they can simply buy land for cheap, put down and sell thousands of homes and walk away while forcing the nearby cities to deal with the mess they made. In response, many localities are now pushing "smart growth", we simply can't allow developers to make short-term selfish choices and pass the long-term costs onto everyone else.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by bryanlarsen on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:29AM (#10615451)
Note that developers pay very large development fees to cities. In many cities, those fees are their primary source of revenue. These fees are supposed to pay for infrastructure: water, sewer, roads, schools, parks, et cetera.

The biggest problem with these fees is that they are "local". Bedroom communities use these fees for local infrastructure, whereas a portion should be paid towards metro infrastructure.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by rplst8 on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:18PM (#10618546)
We all pay gas taxes too. Those are supposed to go toward highway infrastructure.
Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by sampo on Monday November 23, 2015 @11:45AM (#10615524)
> On the other hand, I-270 through Maryland sees about 200,000 cars daily.

Daily... so one commuter to work and back home counts as two? So the road enables 100,000 commuters, or somewhat less than that, if we subtract people who drive through during other times than commute hours.

Re:California's DOT Admits That More Roads Mean More Traffic by rplst8 on Monday November 23, 2015 @08:22PM (#10618558)
The 200,000 is a "summary" at best. The traffic counts are measured between intersections. Some are higher, some are lower, and some people could be getting off before the next intersection, etc. I'm not exactly sure how the traffic counts work - if they are just the on and off ramps, then the highway itself carries a hell of a lot more cars than 200,000.