News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by samuel on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:18AM (#10573971)
Most of the models that we use everyday are "leaky abstractions". They are useful in most contexts, but they get fuzzy at their boundaries.

My favourite example is the "chicken and egg" problem. The difficulty of it is to define what a chicken is, everything is trivial afterwards. The answer, IMHO, is that "a chicken" was born from an egg put by a "non-chicken".

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by jernfrost on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:40AM (#10574053)
I really like Richard Dawkins explanation of this, where he has you imagine taking a photo of yourself from your are born to you reach adulthood with 1 minute intervals.

If you stack these pictures, there is no single picture you can pull out and say: "Here I transitioned from child to adult" e.g. Likewise with animals and evolution. Changes are so minute that you can speak of a transition from one species to another happening at the point of birth.

Only when you look at pictures of yourself far away from each other in the pile can you start differentiating them. Likewise with animals.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by sageikosa on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:57AM (#10574730)
Also Dawkins posits a relatively good empirical definition of species boundaries (although I'm not quoting him verbatim, and I may be extending/synthesizing some of the ideas somewhat), but...a species is basically the pool of organisms available at a period of time that can generate progeny that themselves can generate progeny. That is, they have replicator compatibility...

Under that definition, humans make a species. Horses make a species, donkeys make a species, but mules do not. Apparently in the world of Star Trek, Klingons and humans make a species: Worf (Klingon) had a child with a half-human/half-Klingon woman, and Tom Paris (human) had a child with a half-human/half-Klingon woman. Not sure about Vulcans and Romulans...obviously they can mate, but I'm not sure Spock himself can have children, perhaps we'll find out in a future movie. In Futurama, Kiff reproduced with Leela.

As to the concept of a human as a "super-organism", the problem with bacteria being part of the equation is that they do not transmit their replicator payload through the germ-line transmission vector. They are not integrated into the next generation in whole or in part. Via the concept of the extended phenotype they may alter and extend their environment to improve their chance of success (and often mothers and children have the same bacteria flora), but it's better to think of it as symbiosis (or in the worst case, parasitism) than true "super-organism" reproduction. (Me thinks!)

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by mortehu on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:25AM (#10574909)
> a species is basically the pool of organisms available at a period of time that can generate progeny that themselves can generate progeny

That's what we learned in high-school too, but as you mentioned, it doesn't make sense for donkeys, nor does it work for ring species[1], or organisms that reproduce asexually[2]. Mules can occasionally become mothers[3].

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asexual_reproduction

3. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1226025...

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by sageikosa on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:41AM (#10575016)
I wasn't familiar with the term "Ring Species" (I've only gotten interested in evolutionary biology in the past few years), although I had considered that a "pool" might have a relatively fluctuating degrees of mutuality and incompatibility among candidate members.

Also, I hadn't considered to qualify "sexual reproduction", as asexual reproduction might be better thought of as strains (perhaps), the classification systems for simpler organisms tends to be more structural than fecund. In my defense, I tend to refer to organisms as assemblages of organs of which simpler biota can loosely be said to possess, though I always thought of the "organs" of single-cellular creatures as organelles as they are not made up of "tissue" as they are in multi-cellular organisms.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by illivah on Monday November 16, 2015 @12:23PM (#10575675)
In Star Trek Enterprise a body from the future had DNA fragments from something like a dozen different "species". Vulcans, Klingon, and Human were all included.

The thing about life boundries though in biology is that the more you know the less it makes sense. All bacteria are technically a single species, as are Archaea. Virus's aren't considered alive at all, though they do evolve. Then there are asexual creatures entirely. I vaguely recall a lizard that has no real genetic diversity because they are all females that reproduce without any sex, and there are no males. So... they're not a species either, but are still reproducing. Biology is screwy.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by sageikosa on Monday November 16, 2015 @01:19PM (#10576026)
And all navel oranges are effectively clonal (with the requisite amount of replication drift). Dawkins chief subject of study was insects, so his books are filled with descriptions (and math!) of genetic similarity and divergence within different insect colonies. Some insect species have colonies whose members have a better than (human) sibling relationship with their "sisters", and in fact may even be (1/2) clonal instances of the queen, and full clonal instances of each other. The workers themselves are non-fecund, but their genes replicate on through the fertile queen. We certainly don't want to say the sterile workers are without species, and it may make more sense to think of the insect colony as a "super-organism"...if we could get past the fact that tissues and organs are distributed, but the long term success of the genetic line is concentrated in the germ-line.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by Retric on Monday November 16, 2015 @01:51PM (#10576263)
This is somewhat complicated by royal jelly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_jelly

Post menopausal woman and some adult workers have both lost the ability to reproduce. But, they did have it in the past.

Which suggests the question; should we consider tribes a 'super' organism? As it includes and benefits from sterile members. What about things like monastic orders or wolf packs whose members forgo reproduction?

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:26AM (#10574914)
> Horses make a species, donkeys make a species, but mules do not.

Rarely, sometimes mules are fertile.

And as far as humans, no one's entirely sure that chimps and humans aren't inter-fertile... at least at the level of horses/donkeys.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by sageikosa on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:46AM (#10575043)
Exception, not the rule, but I did warn it was a relatively good empirical formula, not a law of nature :-) I am of the mind that categories such as species are mental constructs to turn the phenomenal world into an approximate model-space so that understanding and action planning can be improved.

So for me rather than concepts like "species" being meaningless, they can have meaning (or at least value), but best not to think of them as iron laws. Mostly the point I was hoping to get to in my root response before I diverted myself reading my own text while typing it.

It's easier to create iron laws for categorical manipulation than it is to place observations into categories to begin with.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by moron4hire on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:29AM (#10574938)
Isn't that a bit like complaining about definitively stating in which square a chess piece currently sits because previously it had been on other squares?
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by ThomPete on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:57AM (#10574728)
Exactly, they are minute because they are constant. We are in constant flux so to speak.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by dTal on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:33AM (#10574024)
It seems to me that difficulty is not so much defining what a chicken is, but what a chicken egg is - is it an egg laid by a chicken, or an egg a chicken hatches from?
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by Dylan16807 on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:31AM (#10574597)
Just pick one. That's easier than picking the bird that is a chicken whose parent is not a chicken.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by bottled_poe on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:37AM (#10574043)
Sorry to be pedantic - but every model is, by definition, an approximation of reality. Everything we experience is a blurry rendition of the inconceivable volume of information dancing around us.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by Dylan16807 on Monday November 16, 2015 @09:49AM (#10574689)
To look at models as 'blurry' is misleading. Models are imperfect, but the imperfect model can be more crisp than the underlying reality.

Newtonian physics are very useful and less blurry than reality.

More relevant, categories are useful and less blurry than reality. There doesn't need to be a sudden major difference between a chicken and a not-chicken. They only need to have a clear distinction in the model.

For comparison, let's look at integers. 11 is very similar to 12, and 13 is at least as similar, but 11 and 12 are not-teen and 13 is teen. There's no ambiguity, there is only the definition of the category/model "teen".

The distinction is arbitrary, but there's still a distinction. You can easily "draw a line" as the sibling comment says.

Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by swamp40 on Monday November 16, 2015 @10:28AM (#10574931)
Re: Blurry, I think that and Dancing are Thru the glass darkly type references.
Re:Humans are not unitary individuals but superorganisms by eveningcoffee on Monday November 16, 2015 @07:43AM (#10574063)
The answer, IMHO, is that "a chicken" was born from an egg put by a "non-chicken".

And the thing is, you could not determine when exactly the non-chicken became the chicken i.e. when it is chicken enough. You could not draw a line.