If I accept a lower pay job, I'm doing my part on lowering the pay for that job in the collective bargaining between employer/employee. You might think it's not detrimental for you, but it's detrimental for everyone who competes for that job. And, as your argument is truthful, it will become a spiral: no disincentive in accepting the $2/hr job, then no disincentive in the $1.95/hr job, then ... for n iterations until there's no disincentive in doing it for free, for the experience or the kicks.
And, of course, in the end the benefit will go the usual beneficiaries.
You say this like it's a bad thing. Study after study show that people perform their best creative work when it's decoupled from extrinsic reward.
If basic income covers all of your needs and allows you to do what you enjoy for the sheer pleasure of it, what's wrong with that?
as an example - what I do to earn money, while enjoying it mildly as abstractly creative process (software development) is vastly different from what I do in my free time (mountaineering, travelling, general wilderness adventures). You cannot buy my vote on this with some basic 1000 USD income, if you tax high earners like hell on the other side.
One thing I saw consistently all around the globe - people need motivation to give their best and try hard, only few deliver without it for sheer pleasure. It doesn't have to be monetary one, but this one is universal and quite well oiled principle. BI doesn't offer me anything - I want to work, I don't have an issue finding next job, and if there is anything between, we have working social system that helps me. What does BI offer to somebody like me?
...currently. Things change, and you may one day find you do have an issue finding your next job. As someone who has been in that situation in the past, relying on a "working social system", I would much rather have guaranteed basic income to fall back on (in addition to universal health care, which is even more urgently needed where I live).
What's wrong is a potential increase in income inequality and worst wealth distribution.
A corporation or somebody from a upper class will be getting richer from the work being done while the guy(s) doing the work with the basic income will stay at the same level. I don't think we should increase our inequality metrics even further.
But I agree with you on the whole. The serfs should just be grateful I'm not beating them.
http://inequalitywatch.eu/spip.php?article95&lang=fr#nb2
http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/social-mobility-memos/posts/2...
By the way, thanks for the interesting links.
you deal with it with progressive taxation
And, empirically, you can see it. In my country (Portugal), with a supposedly agressive progressive taxation, inequality measures (Gini and Palma) are increasing. And the amount of luxury cars too. :)
This means that in the overall collective environment jobs that are undesirable (garbage collecting is the normal example) will actually pay more than something like being an political intern. But people could do both of these jobs and still have money for housing/food/etc.
Only if you assume one's time is worthless.
Opponents to basic income argue, among other things, that this is too much power and some workers would become exceedingly picky, without the fear of not being able to pay for rent and food. There definitely is a moral aspect to the question, with "anti-cheater" emotions/reactions.
I think that's important, and not just for those people: that they don't have to accept a minimal (and likely dead-end) job to survive also means that those who would be inclined to are not prevented from taking steps that prepare them for a better and not-dead end job, that is more useful both to them and society.
There's a chapter on minimum wage in "Economics in One Lesson" that picks up the argument of the parent post.
The competitors of Deutsche Post are now using special structures not to pay the minimum wage to people (they are contractors) and this pushes Deutsche Post to do the same.
So, for this case, it was not good. In fact, the people in Germany pushed to get a minimum wage for all employees and the right wing government accepted. It shows you how bad the lack of minimum wage was for the people.
Basic income better aligns everyone's economic incentives, so it solves (in theory) a whole host of the problems we've got.
It's great to hear that some form of it is going to be tried.
Basic income realigns people's incentives. It might be better than a really badly designed welfare system at removing "welfare traps", but it also can be expected to have a whole host of negative aspects in comparison to other possible configurations of the payment of government subsidies.
I will accept that there are almost certainly edge cases which I can't predict that will need ironing out. probably due to the administration of updating the list appropriately. but basic income seems very much like the proverbial silver bullet that never exists, so I am curious over its negative aspects.
in discussing with friends and family, the worst thing about basic income is it means paying people for doing nothing and that _really_ _really_ angers some people. even worse, it means even millionaires get basic income!
- massive distortion of low-end wages, particularly for unpleasant, useful but not particularly revenue-generating jobs such as cleaning. Further outsourcing of manufacturing work for the same reason might be considered a negative aspect by some (especially people with moderate-to high skills related to that manufacturing)
- massive skewing of wage payments away from younger people in many competitive areas of employment, because now that the taxpayer will cover living costs and assuming removal of minimum wages there's absolutely no reason to pay trainees, apprentices (or the likes of runners desperate to make it in television) any non-trivial sum until they've spend a long time "proving their worth".
- regional cost-of-living differences and a guaranteed permanent income encourage former job-seekers to relocate to areas where their prospect of getting a job is minimal. This is further exacerbated if better-targeted housing benefit payments and social housing are removed from the equation.
- depending on the level of BI entitlement children get they're either likely to become a lucrative income source or unaffordable in many areas, especially for single parents.
- a surprising amount of BI revenue will be captured by low-end rents, and other costs that people with more cash to spend at the bottom of the pyramid can't avoid. A surprising amount of BI costs will be funded by the productive
- non-citizens are inevitably going to be heavily penalised (otherwise the country becomes an migrant magnet)
- many advocates use BI as an excuse to push for middle-class squeezing flattening of the tax system, withdrawal of education and health subsidies etc.
- the cost of paying people who would really rather not work almost certainly vastly exceeds the cost of paying wages to people whose job it is to kick people who would really rather not work off benefit programmes. Throw in the fact that people who never had any intention of claiming benefits are now entitled to them.
Like every other reform to the tax or benefit system there are a whole host of winners and losers (including people you probably don't want to be winners like "slum landlords" and the indolent, and people you probably don't want to be losers like the owners of the neighbourhood cleaning firm and hardworking immigrants). It's about as far from the proverbial silver bullet as imaginable: it's reforming existing incentives that have (for better or worse) been tested and debated for decades with a blunt instrument.
I imagine any sensible, practical proposal for basic income would start it relatively low, keeping many current benefits and gradually expand it if it is successful. That seems to be the option Finland proposal will probably take. This will give time to assess the impact and allow corrections/adaptions/cancelling it . No doubt basic income is a blunt instrument, honestly I think that's part of its appeal to me. It seems fair compared to a plethora of well-meaning but convoluted network of social welfare initiatives, that we call a social welfare system.
I will consider you points more carefully.
- obviously a lot depends on the level of basic income. and what is sacrificed for it. I had not considered the politics of people using basic income as an excuse to withdraw education or health subsidies.
- effect on wages can be mitigated in the short term by retaining a (perhaps lower?) minimum wage.
- I agree a lot of basic income will be swallowed in rent. but that will be because that is what is important to people with the money to spend.
- cost-of-living differences will encourage job-seekers to relocate to cheaper areas. this seems like a good thing. if inner city companies can not find the workers it needs, it will either relocate or provide company buses or something. that seems a much better solution than keeping job-seekers where they are.
- non-citizens is a very good point I hadn't considered. But then, non-citizens are penalized by requiring visas etc. plus EU nations will be restricted on what they can do to stop EU citizens claiming.
thanks again.
That really only applies in industries where people would do the work regardless of pay ("passion" based industries like film). And even then it only makes sense for capital intensive roles (e.g. it wouldn't apply to music, software, painting, comedy, etc).
For most industries, in the face of steady demand (for workers) and a drop in supply (of workers), compensation for trainees, apprentices, etc will increase.
> regional cost-of-living differences and a guaranteed permanent income encourage former job-seekers to relocate to areas where their prospect of getting a job is minimal.
Good. It stops companies from externalising their costs onto the most vulnerable in society.
For example at the moment most companies in my city are located in the middle of town. Companies are happy with this situation only because they can externalise most of the costs.
For example most of the offices in my city are ~1.5 hours travel away from the poorer areas of town. But its where the jobs are. This means a lot of low income wage workers have no choice but to spend ~3hours/day in unpaid travel time. That is hardly fair.
Introduce BI and what happens? Low income earners refuse to donate ~3hours/day unpaid labor to companies. Companies will either compensate the low income earners (great outcome!), move offices closer to the low income earners (great outcome!), decentralise (great outcome!), or be forced into more automation (great outcome!).
> massive distortion of low-end wages, particularly for unpleasant, useful but not particularly revenue-generating jobs such as cleaning.
Actually, what we have now is a distortion of the market. BI would simply cause a market correction.
> a surprising amount of BI revenue will be captured by low-end rents, and other costs that people with more cash to spend at the bottom of the pyramid can't avoid.
Probably not, because like you mentioned above, you actually significantly increase the supply of land and housing available because its no longer tied to jobs.
And if you only doubled the amount of vacant housing you would send the property market into "free-fall" - aka back to affordability.
Such as?
Our world and species is not so noble as to roll over and quietly take it like the author's many many assumptions suggest. Nor would we be above being so petty as to start global wars to take what's AustraliaCorp's.
To expand on this, removing the minimum wage is meant to make it easier for people to "get their foot in the door". The economic notion is that e.g. if X's labour is not worth more than $5 per hour, and the minimum wage is $10 per hour, then X will have great difficulty finding work (because the ultimate minimum wage isn't $10, it's $0). This means they'll have more trouble obtaining the work experience that would make them more productive. Removing the minimum wage means anyone can work who wants to, and the basic income protects them from the hardships that normally accompany low-wage jobs.