News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by te_platt on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:35PM (#10460518)
One movie I've always had a hard time categorizing is Groundhog Day. I went through the 37 plots listed and still don't see a good match. Does achieving enlightenment count as a plot?
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:05PM (#10460711)
A second reply, because this is about the movie Groundhog Day and not the topic at hand.

Something that really bugs me about most people's references to the movie is that they grossly miss the point. When most people reference it they refer to something about their dull repetitive life, or being stuck in a rut. But that's not what happens in the movie.

He literally experiences the same thing for hundreds of days to hundreds of years (depending on interpretation). But something happens, he realizes the numerous opportunities present in this same, repeated, "uneventful" day. Sure, the daily grind of wake, commute, work, commute, dinner, TV, sleep, repeat is dull and repetitive. But unlike Phil, we don't have an infinite number of times to do this before we learn our lesson and change our approach. We get 100 years on the outside, 60 productive years for most of us. Even if you're doing the same thing each day, how do you spend the rest of your time? If it's living for the weekend, that's 5 evenings a week you've wasted. Fill it with time with family, friends, learning, hobbies, something. Become the best person you can be, because one day the repetition will end.

What will you have to show for it? Will you have just worked yourself to death and memorized every line of Star Wars, or will you be making ice sculptures with a chainsaw?

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by david-given on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:14PM (#10460775)
Why do I need to show anything for it?

That's a serious question; if I like working and enjoy memorising Star Wars, why shouldn't I do that? Why can't I focus my life around the things I enjoy doing, rather than concentrating on all the things which I could be doing (but can't do, because of any number of reasons) and end up miserable and feeling like I'm wasting my life?

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:40PM (#10460957)
If that's what you enjoy, that's fine. But many people don't really enjoy their work, it's just work. What they enjoy is done on the weekends or holidays. How many people waste 2 or 3 hours commuting each day, time away from the family they ostensibly want to be with, for work, and then lament, when their children are grown, missing out on those years?

If Star Wars and your job are the things you want to be doing, do them. That's fantastic. If dancing or drawing or rebuilding a jeep are what you want to do, but can't because of work, find some other job or some better way to do your current job.

And don't feel beholden to others to do things or enjoy things because that's what they expect of you. I fucking hate the Star * franchises (or, more accurately, what they've become and their fanbases). But I work with people who love them (in their current incarnations). But in this field (computer programming), everyone thinks I'm weird. Same with video games, I enjoy them to an extent, but I've played them enough to know that I want to do other things. OTOH, don't listen to me if that's what you enjoy and I tell you to stop. If it's what you want to do, do it. But if it's what you want to do, and something in your life is holding you back that you want to change (as opposed to certain obligations, like an SO, that you shouldn't or don't want to change), then find a way to get that time back.

EDIT: Hell. If your work and Star Wars memorization are what you really want. Make that commute work for you. Ride a train and get more work done. Or listen to the movies on your drive. I'm doing that with my current attempt at learning Italian. That's one of the ways people miss the point. The time is there for you to do many (though not all) of the things you want to do now, you just have to realize it and take it back.

EDIT Further: And I guess, with regard to having something to "show" for it. At the end of your life, do you think that you will be happy with how you led it? Did you achieve all, most or even some of your goals? It's not just a result to show to others, but also an internal understanding of where you are and what you have achieved (or not) and why. If I get married and have kids, I probably won't achieve most of the travel I want to in this lifetime. But I'll probably be happy to have made that trade. But if I can't achieve that goal because I decided to work until I was 70, then, for me, that will have been a failure. So I've set myself on a course to avoid that.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by kefka on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @06:16PM (#10461563)
> But many people don't really enjoy their work, it's just work.

That's because the threat in our economy is "If you don't work, you don't eat and you will go homeless." And that's a strong motivator to put up with shit at the workplace. Most people aren't wealthy.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by ghaff on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:20PM (#10462153)
Well, that's been more or less the situation for everyone since the beginning of history excepting a very small slice of the population born into or married into a privileged elite class--and not even all of them.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @10:23PM (#10468827)
Just because this has been the norm since beginning of civilization, doesn't mean it has to be like that forever. We really do have the technology now to relieve everyone of that burden; we only need more social will (and less referring to Idiocracy, Wall-E and "oh all those people who will be drinking their UBI in front of the TV") and a path through the phase-space of economy.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by PhantomGremlin on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @01:11AM (#10462949)
At the end of your life, do you think that you will be happy with how you led it?

A long time ago on a semi-obscure Internet bulletin board, a regular participant used this tagline to end his postings:

   No apologies, no regrets.
I don't fully agree with that, but it's something to think about as one lives their life.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by numbsafari on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:22PM (#10460829)
Put another way...

Will you have just worked yourself to death making ice sculptures with a chainsaw, or will you memorize every line of Star Wars?

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by megablast on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @11:26PM (#10462707)
Sure. And someone could spend their entire life sitting in front of the tv all day everyday.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 28, 2015 @10:35PM (#10468873)
Even if - and I'm willing to bet that no mentally healthy individual would ever do that out of their own will - is there something wrong with it? Do we have to keep everyone working when there's no need for that, so that some individuals don't have time to do things we deem unproductive?
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by pjmorris on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:36PM (#10461336)
Interesting. I mostly agree with your take, but I want to add a wrinkle. What I think Phil had to show for his 'day' was an appreciation that he wasn't alone in the world, and that fulfillment came through helping everyone he could along the way. I think the 'become the best person you can be' part only serves the 'do what you can for others' part, evidenced by the cycle ending on a day where every virtuoso performance, from changing a tire to playing piano, to ice sculpture, was for the benefit of someone else.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by mentos on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:49PM (#10462241)
Yea I think the change in Phil's character is that he goes from being cold and selfish to warm and caring.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by rjurney on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:28PM (#10460868)
Holy shit broseph, you just converted me to a new film religion... I shall no longer worship The Dude. I shall worship Phil.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:43PM (#10460571)
Perhaps a combination of "Possessed of an ambition" (his egotistical behavior and treatment of others, producing generally negative situations that he doesn't realize are negative because he can't see beyond himself) combined with "Miracle of God" (the opportunity to redeem himself and finally become the best man he can be).
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:38PM (#10460945)
"Possessed of an ambition" is a weak attempt at listing a basic plot -- you can phrase this equivalently as "having a goal", and it will obviously be present multiple times over in any story at all.

Phil has several ambitions in Groundhog Day, some more closely related to each other than others:

1. get out of Punxsatawney (changes over the course of the film)

2. stop the repetition

3. sleep with Rita (when he finally gets this, the repetition stops!)

4. optimize the day

(3) and (4) are both given quite a lot of screen time and plot focus; (2) is the source of many jokes.

Some other thoughts on the list:

I was surprised to see "Struggle against God" categorized under DISASTROUS SITUATIONS PRECIPITATED WITH CRIMINAL INTENT. I would have put it under TRAGIC SITUATIONS OVER WHICH THE VICTIM HAS NO CONTROL.

"Possessed of an ambition", interpreted as a goal, includes a lot of the other elements (consider "love's obstacles").

The list makes a three-way distinction between "enmity between kinsmen", "vengeance", and "kindred avenged against kindred". A better-thought-out list couldn't do this.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:52PM (#10461030)
"Struggle against God" (more generalized to any higher power, I suppose) is a choice if it's precipitated with criminal intent. It's not that I'm running from my fate for killing my wife because God has it out for me. I chose to kill my wife, and now God has it out for me. The cause is my own decision and follow through. It's also probably assumed, in this list, that the story's main character would be the loser in this struggle.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:15PM (#10461196)
Hill's list is plagiarized nearly in whole from Georges Polti's list visible at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thirty-Six_Dramatic_Situat... . The original comes with definitions, so we can see that "struggle against God" involves two characters, a Mortal and an Immortal, who "enter a conflict". Obvious exemplars in Greek mythology would be Hercules being born (and thereby coming into conflict with Hera), or Odysseus killing Polyphemus, who was going to eat him (and thereby coming into conflict with Poseidon, who, unknown to Odysseus, was Polyphemus' father).

Where's the criminal intent?

To the earlier discussion, it's probably worth noting that Polti's plot 30, "Ambition" involves a person, an object, and an adversary; the person seeks the object and is opposed by the adversary. Not applicable to Groundhog Day.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Retric on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:52PM (#10462029)
Note, these are dramatic situations not plots. Self improvement in not dramatic. So, stealing the money bag was dramatic, pretending to be an old classmate was comedic not dramatic.

Self sacrifice for an ideal was dramatic in the case of catching the kid who fell from a tree, but also played for laughs.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:00PM (#10462067)
> Note, these are dramatic situations not plots. Self improvement in not dramatic.

Rocky was received pretty well.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Retric on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:18PM (#10462139)
Rocky fits:

Daring enterprise a bold leader; an object; an adversary

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by scardine on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:56PM (#10462050)
For me it is the Rebirth: during the course of the story, an important event forces the main character to change their ways, often making them a better person. It is also a Comedy: light and humorous character with a happy or cheerful ending; a dramatic work in which the central motif is the triumph over adverse circumstance, resulting in a successful or happy conclusion. But these are from "The Seven Basic Plots" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Seven_Basic_Plots)
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by justathrow2k on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:44PM (#10460580)
I think you could describe Groundhog Day as the sum of a few of those plots listed.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:48PM (#10460596)
Yeah. Keeping in mind that this is the list of basic plots. Most stories will involve some combination of these, perhaps without a strong overarching basic plot to use as its primary category.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Someone1234 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:23PM (#10460839)
I'd go with for Groundhog Day:

- (3) A miracle of god

- (5) Love's obstacles

- (14) Pursuit

- (23) Struggle against god

"God" being the situation he find himself in (both the miracle of it, and the struggle), pursuit being his overall progress, and of course the "main" love plot.

Depends how literally you take "god" for if those fit or not.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:26PM (#10461267)
Definition of "conflict with a god" from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thirty-Six_Dramatic_Situat... , the source of the list in OP:

    - a Mortal; an Immortal
    - The Mortal and the Immortal enter a conflict.
There's no way to make Groundhog Day fit this. Love's obstacles doesn't fit either:

    28. Obstacles to love
       - two Lovers; an Obstacle
       - Two Lovers face an Obstacle together.
Here's "pursuit":

    5. Pursuit
      - punishment; a fugitive
      - the fugitive flees punishment for a misunderstood conflict. Example: Les Misérables
"A miracle of God" is the only plot Hill didn't lift from Polti, so I guess it could be anything.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by meric on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:41PM (#10462402)
a Mortal; an Immortal

That looks like it. The world around him is "immortal", and he was a "mortal" trapped in the "immortal" world. In the movie that is metaphorically represented by the day repeating, seemingly forever. The more the "mortal" tries to fight things, the further he is away from freedom. It was only by cooperating with the world he was finally free.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:41PM (#10460555)
Sure, the basic plots begin to elude anything remotely surrealistic or avant-garde. Try similarly categorizing the likes of Luis Buñuel, Krzysztof Kieślowski, Stan Brakhage, Catherine Breillat, or hell, even Michael Haneke.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by wj on Friday October 30, 2015 @11:08AM (#10478257)
Two Hollywood screenwriters really dove down into Groundhog Day and is a discussion you might find insightful:

http://johnaugust.com/2014/scriptnotes-ep-133-groundhog-day-...

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by stonogo on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:48PM (#10460597)
The classical Christian interpretation of enlightenment is (3) A miracle of God.

This tells me the counterpoint to Groundhog Day is any Michael Bay movie, which are all (23) Struggle against God.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Steko on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:37PM (#10461347)
Situation Number Five - Love's Obstacles

Subplot (f) - a union of lovers prevented by a lack of congeniality between them

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by hyperion2010 on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:56PM (#10461067)
Becoming a truly good person.

Struggle against ones lesser self.

edit:

Existential doubt. Struggle against nihilism.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by GPGPU on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @09:57PM (#10462444)
Groundhog day is a "boy gets girl" plot (Boy meets girl, boy redeems himself to win her approval, boy gets girl).