News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @03:43PM (#10460571)
Perhaps a combination of "Possessed of an ambition" (his egotistical behavior and treatment of others, producing generally negative situations that he doesn't realize are negative because he can't see beyond himself) combined with "Miracle of God" (the opportunity to redeem himself and finally become the best man he can be).
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:38PM (#10460945)
"Possessed of an ambition" is a weak attempt at listing a basic plot -- you can phrase this equivalently as "having a goal", and it will obviously be present multiple times over in any story at all.

Phil has several ambitions in Groundhog Day, some more closely related to each other than others:

1. get out of Punxsatawney (changes over the course of the film)

2. stop the repetition

3. sleep with Rita (when he finally gets this, the repetition stops!)

4. optimize the day

(3) and (4) are both given quite a lot of screen time and plot focus; (2) is the source of many jokes.

Some other thoughts on the list:

I was surprised to see "Struggle against God" categorized under DISASTROUS SITUATIONS PRECIPITATED WITH CRIMINAL INTENT. I would have put it under TRAGIC SITUATIONS OVER WHICH THE VICTIM HAS NO CONTROL.

"Possessed of an ambition", interpreted as a goal, includes a lot of the other elements (consider "love's obstacles").

The list makes a three-way distinction between "enmity between kinsmen", "vengeance", and "kindred avenged against kindred". A better-thought-out list couldn't do this.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Jtsummers on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @04:52PM (#10461030)
"Struggle against God" (more generalized to any higher power, I suppose) is a choice if it's precipitated with criminal intent. It's not that I'm running from my fate for killing my wife because God has it out for me. I chose to kill my wife, and now God has it out for me. The cause is my own decision and follow through. It's also probably assumed, in this list, that the story's main character would be the loser in this struggle.
Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @05:15PM (#10461196)
Hill's list is plagiarized nearly in whole from Georges Polti's list visible at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Thirty-Six_Dramatic_Situat... . The original comes with definitions, so we can see that "struggle against God" involves two characters, a Mortal and an Immortal, who "enter a conflict". Obvious exemplars in Greek mythology would be Hercules being born (and thereby coming into conflict with Hera), or Odysseus killing Polyphemus, who was going to eat him (and thereby coming into conflict with Poseidon, who, unknown to Odysseus, was Polyphemus' father).

Where's the criminal intent?

To the earlier discussion, it's probably worth noting that Polti's plot 30, "Ambition" involves a person, an object, and an adversary; the person seeks the object and is opposed by the adversary. Not applicable to Groundhog Day.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Retric on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @07:52PM (#10462029)
Note, these are dramatic situations not plots. Self improvement in not dramatic. So, stealing the money bag was dramatic, pretending to be an old classmate was comedic not dramatic.

Self sacrifice for an ideal was dramatic in the case of catching the kid who fell from a tree, but also played for laughs.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:00PM (#10462067)
> Note, these are dramatic situations not plots. Self improvement in not dramatic.

Rocky was received pretty well.

Re:The Thirty-Seven Basic Plots, According to a Screenwriter... by Retric on Tuesday October 27, 2015 @08:18PM (#10462139)
Rocky fits:

Daring enterprise a bold leader; an object; an adversary