This doesn't factor in Silicon Valley. SV is an entirely different animal. The cost of living there throws the math way off. I can imagine that those wages are typically very low. $200k in SV is comparable to $70k in most other cities. This is why it's beneficial to work remotely for a SV startup and live somewhere more desirable.
I think we're conflating all startups with SV, which shouldn't be the case. Certainly folks joining SV startups IN SV are being taken for a ride.
What's the basis for that estimation? Given California's income tax and higher rent, I'd say that the difference in cost of living is $20-30k, not $130k.
Most people don't want to rent for the entirety of their lives.
The raw numbers are nothing to sniff at, and you don't get that buying power in much of the country.
I think it does a disservice to the other problems and discussion points to toss everything under "risk".
There are a lot of different variables involved and a great many of them boil down to calculated gambles on the part of the employee and employers. Those are worthy of discussion and there are plenty of discussions to be had around those. But simply calling it "risk" and saying you need more of the upside is so simplified its nearly meaningless and impossible to have a conversation about with everyone involved having the same idea about what is being discussed.
Only true in good times. Ask the employees who were associated with failed startups during dot bomb, circa late 1990s and early 2000s. You were SOL if you worked for a failed startup or a high profile failed public tech company. You were at the bottom of the pile in consideration. I know several companies that excluded employees from consideration that were previously associated with such failed ventures, Guilty by Association. This didn't change until 2004+ or so.
History will repeat itself.
People who lost jobs due to their companies going out of business were pretty SOL during this stretch of time (early 2000s), but in my experience the problem wasn't bias against them due to prior employers but rather that hardly anybody was hiring at all. Almost everyone (that wasn't busy filing for bankruptcy) was in a hiring freeze holding pattern waiting for the sky to stop falling.
They're the folks typically being asked to take below market salaries, but unless they're founders they won't see tremendous upside without a larger equity stake.
I'm only getting better as a developer.
Funny story, one hiring "kid" the other day asked me if I like to wear ties... ha! I thought, I'm roughly ten years older than him, and wasn't working in the sixties, or whenever ties were popular.
There are plenty of reasons to argue for more equity but risk is not one of them. If you're good at what you do you can get a job tomorrow anywhere and there is near zero stigma about being associated with a failed startup unless you're on the founding side AND you've failed multiple times.