News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by mahyarm on Friday October 16, 2015 @05:41PM (#10402181)
This is why I didn't use 23andMe's service. Because it's in their database, forever.

I want a genetic sequencing service where they sequence everything, put it on multiple encrypted USB sticks and send it to you. Once you confirm you received your copy, they destroy the backup USB sticks.

They never will store it on some centralized server. It will never end up on some tape backup. They will never have a copy after you get yours.

Then you need DNA analysis software that runs offline.

Most of them won't want to do that although, because it makes them a commodity service.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by aianus on Saturday October 17, 2015 @05:19AM (#10403849)
You're missing the whole point of 23andme.

It's not a consumer product to analyze your own DNA, that's just a disguise. With machine learning and a large enough population size they will eventually be able to determine the genetic markers that promote every disease. Personalized medicine will be the next breakthrough in medicine and human longevity.

This requires them to have everyone's DNA, trait, and medical history on file.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by amelius on Saturday October 17, 2015 @07:07AM (#10404040)
Imho, this crowdsourced data belongs to the public domain. Imagine that the most important research papers were not accessible to the public, while the public contributed to them. Well, that is about to happen.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by _ak on Saturday October 17, 2015 @10:16AM (#10404416)
Have you heard about openSNP? It may be relevant to your interests: https://opensnp.org/
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by jamesrcole on Saturday October 17, 2015 @09:28AM (#10404304)
It seems pretty clear that they're objecting to the means, and I don't see any evidence that they're naive about the ends.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by Camillo on Friday October 16, 2015 @09:15PM (#10402994)
Indeed! I have always been curious about trying 23andMe, but I was concerned about my DNA being forever stored in a database somewhere. Now my decision is final, I'm never going to use that kind of service.

I think this is going to impact their growth as more people realize the implications. I doubt their recent new investors[0] are happy.

[0]: http://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2015/10/14/23andme...

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by contrahax on Saturday October 17, 2015 @02:17AM (#10403563)
I'm working on an open source DNA analysis framework to solve exactly this problem - everyone should be able to check out their own DNA without paying for it http://genomejs.com/
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by username223 on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:07PM (#10402782)
Sequencing is getting pretty cheap, so I imagine it won't be too long before someone offers an honest, simple business model based on charging a straightforward cost + profit. 23andme, etc, who sequence at a loss and plan to profit by selling the data however they can, are creepy. Add in that they're creating huge new honeypots of extremely personal information begging to be stolen, and I can't imagine using them.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by danielsamuels on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:21PM (#10402390)
Even if they did provide that service, how would you prove they weren't storing the data anyway?
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by alecco on Friday October 16, 2015 @07:39PM (#10402683)
Yep, Ashley Madison taught us we can't trust any company with our data.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by mahyarm on Tuesday October 20, 2015 @11:16PM (#10423470)
You couldn't. But if they advertised their process of how they do it technically, especially the no server part, then the likelihood is far less.

It would be better than 23andme saying that they store it forever in their T&C, and advertise how great it is that it's in their servers basically forever.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by ams6110 on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:05PM (#10402317)
Yep -- this was so predictable.

I would never have my DNA sequenced for any reason.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by monatron on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:26PM (#10402418)
That seems a bit extreme. There are plenty of clinically relevant reasons to have your DNA sequenced.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by brianbarker on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:24PM (#10402403)
If someone wanted your dna badly enough, they could pick up your used coffee cup or fallen strand of hair just by tailing you for a minute.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by gph on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:38PM (#10402460)
True, but that's actually a very significant barrier to getting my DNA compared to having it sitting in a massive database that a cop somewhere can query.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by mattmanser on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:40PM (#10402466)
Which is an incredibly specific operation, and only affects one person, just like it should be.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by yoodenvranx on Friday October 16, 2015 @07:04PM (#10402553)
Currently it is a very specific operation, but just imagine that in 10-20 years it might be possible to install some kind of very fast DNA scanner at central locations (airports, ...) which scans the air or dust on the floor for traces of DNA.

Currently it sounds a bit scify-ish but I think we might get there in a decade or two.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by johansch on Saturday October 17, 2015 @12:10AM (#10403358)
How long until foreigners are required to leave a DNA sample at US immigration checkpoints at airports when entering the US? Fingerprints have already been collected there for a long time.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by facetube on Saturday October 17, 2015 @01:03AM (#10403449)
Or just bring back the TSA air puffer machines (rev. 2), and say you're doing it to keep people safe from known terrorists with fake ID whose DNA you have on file. You'd have a full-population genetic database in no time, matched to identifying information, passport/license numbers, and travel history.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by Tinyyy on Friday October 16, 2015 @09:43PM (#10403068)
That incurs a lot of R&D costs and costs of installation, and people might not be okay with such a thing happening because it affects everyone. On the other hand, querying a DNA database doesn’t face much resistance because it only affects a small number of people.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by scrollaway on Friday October 16, 2015 @09:42PM (#10403059)
That's a fun (and scary) thought. Thankfully we're not there yet. When we do get there I hope we'll have the same privacy concerns as we do today for these online databases.

It doesn't invalidate the current concerns, though.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by icebraining on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:25PM (#10402851)
How would it link to you? The DNA is useless by itself.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by chongli on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:32PM (#10402870)
It could link you to a surveillance photo and from there it'd match any photo ID you have via facial recognition.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by shorttime on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:14PM (#10402806)
Why not just sign up with a fake name, like I did?
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by jevinskie on Friday October 16, 2015 @08:51PM (#10402926)
Because a fake name doesn't do you much good when your DNA is similar to a related person's DNA who did use their real name.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by djhn on Saturday October 17, 2015 @03:21AM (#10403685)
For once it's very useful to have very few family members, or have a family that is totally oblivious to technology, internet and SV startups.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by striking on Friday October 16, 2015 @06:02PM (#10402292)
But then you lose the genealogy search feature, and many people use that feature.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by tacotuesday on Saturday October 17, 2015 @12:04AM (#10403346)
Yeah. Big loss. I don't find out my dad isn't my dad.

Sometimes, it's better NOT to know these things. );

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by striking on Saturday October 17, 2015 @12:16AM (#10403369)
This article talks about that. I think it was posted on HN before. http://www.vox.com/2014/9/9/5975653/with-genetic-testing-i-g...

"check this box if you want to see close family members in this search program." It's your choice whether or not you do. If you can't handle the truth, if you're going to use that truth and act on it and ruin your life with it; that's your prerogative.

Can't blame them for telling you what you asked for.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by technofiend on Saturday October 17, 2015 @08:22AM (#10404201)
As a counterpoint I found out who my dad really was after using Family Tree in an effort to find relatives of who I thought my dad was. Anecdotal but for me it was quite useful.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by return0 on Saturday October 17, 2015 @03:57AM (#10403738)
I would assume millions are traceable through 23and me simply because they can be "triangulated" via their relatives. Even if you don't use 23andme your genetic data may well be out there.
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by rmc on Saturday October 17, 2015 @10:30AM (#10404465)
What about 23andme's European offerings? The EU's data protection laws should protect you?
Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by developer1 on Saturday October 17, 2015 @04:34AM (#10403793)
I try not to use offensive language on HN, but are you fucking kidding me? You actually expect a single company out there to not keep your personal information? The type of system you are looking for will never exist. Ever. The only reason a company wants your DNA to begin with is either to profit from its data, or to perform crowd-sourced research that requires keeping your information indefinitely. Your comment goes far and beyond a fantasy. There will never be anything positive to gain from having your DNA analyzed. Corporate, hospital, "non-profit"... there is no such thing as a secure outlet from whom to obtain your DNA profile. There will always be a record, even if it's "erased" but still recoverable from the raw disk. Either you don't understand how corporations and modern government work, or you are insanely naive about the possible benefits from DNA analysis compared to the politicians and corporate psychopaths who will find a way to benefit from it.

If you're willing to hand over your biological fingerprints to anybody, you may as well walk into your local police station and admit to a murder you haven't committed. Even if 99.99% of people submitting their DNA for analysis never see any negative consequences, the other 0.01% are going to have their lives ruined because of some supposed family association to a criminal. These days, suspicion is equal to guilt beyond a doubt. If one out a million people are falsely chased down based on something like DNA, that is one person too many.

The possibility that you have some horrible abnormality that can be detected via DNA testing is so astronomically low. Stop thinking about the interesting science behind what you can learn about your body. Instead, be very concerned about the fact that there are people out there interested in nothing other than having power over others. Nobody should be submitting themselves to this horrendous risk.

I cannot imagine how someone would even consider submitting themselves to such a process. I took a season pass to my local amusement park; they strongly suggest you provide your thumbprint instead of taking a photo for your ID. It's insane. Obviously the police or state government can force this park with hundreds of thousands of fingerprints to submit to database searches. Who the hell offers to provide their fingerprints to an amusement park, in order to save the 5 minutes of inconvenience required to go have your photo taken? "Stupid sheep" is the only phrase that comes to mind.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by zer0defex on Saturday October 17, 2015 @05:08AM (#10403833)
"I try not to use offensive language on HN, but are you fucking kidding me? You actually expect a single company out there to not keep your personal information?"

Yes, I do, actually. This kind of response is exactly the kind of attitude that perpetuates the fly-by-night shady handling of our private information that's all too pervasive these days. This bullshit stops only when laws are on the books that bring down the rain of hell if a mere squeak occurs outside regs - HIPPA is a great example of this.

I've had a 23andme test kit sitting in the closet for years now at this point. I never was able to push past the hesitation they would have my data, forever, and would more than likely be persuaded at some point down the road by the almighty dollar to distribute it, as it didn't come with HIPPA protection.

I don't have all the answers, but I absolutely am game for being a part of the solution.

Re:Cops are asking Ancestry.com and 23andMe for their custom... by pdkl95 on Saturday October 17, 2015 @05:44AM (#10403906)
> This bullshit stops only when laws are on the books

Absolutely. Handling personal data[1] absolutely must carry liability. If you move customer data as a black box, common carrier style, then your liability can be limited to a refund. If, on the other hand, you inspect the data in any way, then you're liable for that happens to and everything derived from that

This idea that companies can gather all the data they want without any consequences for mishandling that data is patently unethical.

[1] all personal data, not just "personally identifying information". 2nd and 3rd parties do not get to make the decision about what data is important.