News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by clarkmoody on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:44AM (#10360311)
For decades, government ______ only to find out later that it was really bad.

The social engineering has got to stop. A free people should not be subject to the latest schemes of self-appointed masterminds. The most evident and dangerous venue for such engineering is the public schools, in which the government subjects our children to every sort of social experiment, and what have we to show for it?

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by jegutman on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:02AM (#10360465)
For years the government has been encouraging _____ only for a news article never to be written because it dramatically helped the outcomes of real people.

Don't forget that the things that make the news have a huge selection bias.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ceejayoz on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:18AM (#10360577)
> The most evident and dangerous venue for such engineering is the public schools, in which the government subjects our children to every sort of social experiment, and what have we to show for it?

First two to spring to mind: A dramatic drop in violent crime since the 1970s because the "self-appointed masterminds" restricted lead. A dramatic drop in road deaths because the "self-appointed masterminds" required seatbelts, airbags, and crash standards.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ashark on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:24AM (#10360634)
I think the key argument in favor of the usefulness of these sorts of policies is that if I had to worry about all this stuff myself it would take a ton of time and I'd almost certainly still do a worse job than government regulators.

That regulators make mistakes, even fairly often, doesn't necessarily convince me my life would be better without them.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by dragonwriter on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:53AM (#10360872)
> A dramatic drop in violent crime since the 1970s because the "self-appointed masterminds" restricted lead.

I'm somewhat skeptical about that; while lead may be a contributor, there's fairly strong indication over a long period of time of age demographics being a key driver in crime rates, and the curve of the crime wave is fairly consistent with that, making an additional explanatory factor unnecessary.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by smt88 on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:41AM (#10360767)
> A dramatic drop in violent crime since the 1970s because the "self-appointed masterminds" restricted lead

There are many possible factors that went into this reduction in crime, but it's not entirely settled. For example, a substantial portion is attributable to a decrease in unwanted pregnancies [1].

1. http://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/LevittUndersta...

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by irixusr on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:22AM (#10360609)
Well the masterminds are still in the red, compared to the deaths from obesity (and drastic cut in quality of life).
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by clarkmoody on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:25AM (#10360636)
You'll need to be more specific as to the causes of the drop in violent crime in the '70s.

Your example about automobile safety devices makes the dubious assumption that manufacturers wouldn't include such technologies if not mandated by the state and that consumers wouldn't demand them. You also ignore the ridiculous amount of other required features on modern automobiles that make base models more and more expensive, hurting the lowest income levels.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by amalag on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:51AM (#10360372)
The US is somewhat unique in that there is a lot less tradition. Many "Old world" countries have millenia of established culture. How to live and eat healthy. Instead the US falls back to experimental science and corporations to define good health.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by enlightenedfool on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:59AM (#10360431)
I view the "established culture" you mention as science too..based on certain observations. It's not that all traditional methods are inferior or superior. We constantly re-evaluate as we evolve.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by irixusr on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:31AM (#10360678)
I've just become a father and my kid has very slight jaundice, not enough to have to do anything about it. But it did get me thinking, "how was jaundice dealt with before"? Considering 10% (??) of kids have bad jaundice that's a huge evolutionary pressure to either eliminate it (by favoring kids with larger livers) or somehow deal with it.

Well my wife's (who's from a third-world and (formerly) most isolated country in the world) grandma (eldest of 13) explained it to me: She's always taken newborn's and placed them by the window for an hour. That'll do it!

Then I read the history of neonatal jaundice care and I was shocked to learn that light therapy for jaundice wasn't discovered until the 50s (when a doctor noticed that newborns under the care of a nurse with particular habits fared better) and widely practiced until the 70s!

+1 for folksy medicine!

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by enlightenedfool on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:54AM (#10360397)
Well, I guess government follows the scientific conclusions and recommendations. Some might turn out to be wrong and we unlearn them. Science does make mistakes, but that's the best we've got. We can't leave it to intuitions of the masses.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by CapitalistCartr on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:00AM (#10360448)
In the US, the Federal Gov't mostly follows the money. And actually we can leave people's lives up to them to lead. Whether you think their decisions are right or wrong, based on intuition, religion, science, etc., the populace aren't children and the gov't aren't parents. Freedom is the right to be wrong.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:10AM (#10360526)
> Freedom is the right to be wrong.

Exactly, that's why Freedom is to be left alone to individuals so that they can choose for themselves what best fits their lifestyle.

Governments have roles to play, but telling people what to do and not to do at a private level is certainly not one of them.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by Retra on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:12AM (#10360546)
The population is largely children, and nearly 100% of the population were children when they adapted to most of their culture, (specifically the kinds of ideas you are rejecting here.)

You don't think "freedom is the right to be wrong" wasn't something you were taught as a child by adults?

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by underdown on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:32AM (#10360695)
Yes, but they aren't the government's children.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by Retra on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:38AM (#10360740)
They're adopted.

Or are you trying to suggest that your genetics have a role in determining what rights you have or who has power over you?

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by 357467 on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:16AM (#10360568)
I find humans to be pretty funny. Modern day humans no longer trust the instincts they have developed over millions of years and instead put their faith in shitty science and corporate marketing. They no longer trust themselves to know how long to stay in the sun, how many steps to take, or what kind of foods to eat.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ceejayoz on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:20AM (#10360588)
Those instincts were evolved to get you to reproduce and live long enough for your offspring to be self-sufficient. The world has changed enormously since the industrial revolution and there's hardly been enough time for new instincts to evolve to account for modern society.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by maxerickson on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:24AM (#10360635)
New instincts aren't necessarily needed for there to be a population that has some sort of advantage in the modern world, some certain bundle of existing instincts/habits can possibly provide it.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by 357467 on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:28AM (#10360659)
I don't agree. The human body tells you when things are right or wrong. It is about the effects, not whether it is a new stimulus that caused those effects.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ceejayoz on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:32AM (#10360688)
> The human body tells you when things are right or wrong.

The human body won't tell you to avoid lifelong tanning to avoid cancer in your 60s, because living to your 60s isn't all that evolutionarily important (and hell, likely made you a drain on your hunter-gatherer tribe). There's no selection pressure.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by seren on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:52AM (#10360863)
> (and hell, likely made you a drain on your hunter-gatherer tribe)

Apparently there are some arguments that having elders around was a boon for prehistoric tribes. http://www.theguardian.com/science/2011/jul/24/prehistoric-m...

I don't know how much this is validated, but thought it was interesting nonetheless because it seems counter intuitive at first.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ceejayoz on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:56AM (#10360892)
Definitely interesting, but they're talking about "elder" being living past 30. I'm not sure that holds in the realm of cancer and knee replacements, though.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by 357467 on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:47AM (#10360820)
I used the sun example because a few years ago scientist had everyone avoiding the sun and now they have realised that sun exposure is important. Scientists literally have no idea what they are doing. Tans look good and the sun feels good. That is what guides me and it is a much more reliable source of knowledge than science.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by scoreponok on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:40PM (#10361895)
So your personal, cultural instilled, biased intuitions is what drives you? And you think this is more reliably than science? A methodology designed to control for such things, that has brought us antibiotics, vaccines, pretty much all of modern medicine. You know what else feels good? Cocaine, but that doesn't mean it's good for me. The dangers of tanning isn't something invented by colluding scientists and Hawaiian tropic made up to push more sun tan lotion. It's testable and repeatable scientific fact that the sun emits harmful UV radiation that can cause premature aging, cancer etc etc.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by Kristine1975 on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:08PM (#10360999)
>a few years ago scientist had everyone avoiding the sun

I'm somewhat doubtful of this claim. If anything scientists would have everyone avoid sunburn since skin cancer and cataracts.

Tans looking good are a recent phenomenon: A couple hundred years ago light skin was a sign of high status since you could afford to stay indoors instead of having to work in the fields, so light skin was deemed to be more beautiful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_skin_color#Social_status...

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by 357463 on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:16PM (#10361076)
Err no. There were specific campaigns that said tans were unhealthy. You still seem to believe this and think that tanned skin only seems attractive due to cultural factors. Are you also going to say that big boobs are only attractive because of cultural factors?
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by scoreponok on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:49AM (#10360840)
>Modern day humans no longer trust the instincts they have developed over millions of years ... or what kind of foods to eat.

Really? This is a naturalistic fallacy. It's out precisely our instincts that cause us to overeat. As has been pointed out our instincts haven't adapted to the abundance and availability of food seen today. In an environment where food is scarce it is evolutionary advantageous to ensure your body had enough calories to make it until the next available meal. And this didn't mean picking the most nutritious food sources, we didn't have that luxury, it meant picking the most available. Only as directed by science do we now know what foods provide the most benefit or determent to our health.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by 357463 on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:09PM (#10361007)
Yet humans have eyes and can see they are fat. They have the instinct to know what type of body looks healthy or unhealthy. Also every human knows that eating less food will reduce their weight. Whether we have the ability to change our habits is another question but is unrelated to my proposition.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by plonh on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:23PM (#10364357)
The notion that fat people are unhealthy is a modern notion. Look at the paintings in the Louvre.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by JoeAltmaier on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:20AM (#10360591)
Humans have been proved to be pretty bad at deciding things. We've used voodoo, superstition, trust in authority for thousands of years. I welcome some order in the process, in the form of science.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:08AM (#10360512)
> We can't leave it to intuitions of the masses.

Usually governments make worse decisions than common folks - in about every area (economics, science, medicine, education). I can hardly think of any area where Governments actually did not divert funds resulting in a bad consequence.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by bobcostas55 on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:57AM (#10360413)
>I guess government follows the scientific conclusions and recommendations.

Come on now.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by clarkmoody on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:57AM (#10360420)
A naive view, at best. You're forgetting all about politics and special interests.

> We can't leave it to intuitions of the masses.

Precisely the mindset of the power elite that gets us into so much trouble.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by toolz on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:03AM (#10360478)
What do you mean 'so much trouble'? We're constantly getting healthier, living longer lives, hurting each other lessand doing better by just about all metrics. The only thing that seems to be going downhill is our mental health, and I would argue that's simply because we have more diagnosis recorded, rather than those things simply not existing in the past.

Could we be getting better at a faster rate, as a species? Most likely, but it's not like we've halted progress or something.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by ekianjo on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:12AM (#10360539)
> We're constantly getting healthier, living longer lives

LOL, really ? There are more and more obese people in the US, does that count as getting healthier ? What are your metrics exactly ?

As for living longer lives, that's already clearly proven most of the life expectancy gains happened since we reduced infant mortality to minimum levels, raising therefore lifetime for all individuals on average.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by clarkmoody on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:10AM (#10360528)
> We're constantly getting healthier, living longer lives, hurting each other lessand doing better by just about all metrics.

Totally agree. But are those improvements due to the decisions of central planners?

> What do you mean 'so much trouble'?

Things that come to mind: abysmal outcomes for many in the public school system; skyrocketing prices in healthcare; urban families almost completely destroyed by paternalistic welfare programs; massive suffering and death caused by the warfare state; shredding of the Bill of Rights by the TSA; economic calamity caused by Fed-fueled booms and busts; etc.

Look at the places with the worst outcomes and you will find the most government involvement.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by kbenson on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:20AM (#10360586)
> Look at the places with the worst outcomes and you will find the most government involvement.

Of course. That doesn't mean they are the problem. It's entirely plausible they are involved because there's a problem. In a system with honey, bees and bears, just because you often see bears involved with honey doesn't mean they are responsible for its creation.

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by enlightenedfool on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:00AM (#10360441)
Well, take vaccinations for example. Would you better leave it to the people to decide? I'm sure half won't take them. EDIT: I do understand the corporate influence, but we could find a way to build unbiased scientific institutions if with collective global will.
Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by lackbeard on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:27AM (#10360647)
Letting people choose to not vaccinate their children will self correct. We'll lose herd immunity, a lot of people will die, and then everyone will know how awesome vaccines are, just like they did in the 60s. Then the cycle will begin anew.

I lean toward valuing individual rights over all else, but this scenario does present a serious challenge to that worldview.

Another contributor to the problem is that people trust science a lot less today than 2 generations ago. They've seen the negative results of a lot of fraud that has been perpetuated under the banner of "science". (E.g. "scientific socialism", the food pyramid, most of psychology, etc...)

Re:For decades, government steered millions away from whole ... by chrisan on Friday October 09, 2015 @11:29AM (#10360664)
Or insurance. "I don't need that, I will never ____!"