News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by pm90 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:10PM (#10353671)
>John Criscitello placed posters in Seattle's Capitol Hill neighborhood proclaiming “Welcome! Rich Kids,” and “Wish you weren’t here.”

Its hard not to feel angry at people like this. "Rich Kids" really? These "Kids" spent years developing their engineering skills to get to the point where they are now. Are engineers paid a lot? Of course. But we're certainly not in the same category as those who inherit wealth. Most engineers that I know come from incredibly humble backgrounds.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by pazrul on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:30PM (#10353814)
This guy is a terrible hypocrite; he creates art bemoaning new people in his neighborhood, while being a recent transplant from New York himself. He's cashing in on the worst kind of 'us vs them' mentality.

Some people make excuses that he's only rallying against the stereotypical brogrammer, but I don't think that's true. He's really against anyone being in his neighborhood he didn't personally approve of. He's the same as the neighborhood watch keeping the 'undesirables' out of the cul-de-sac.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by civilian on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:57PM (#10357231)
Agreed. For more info, looks at the video here: http://www.thestranger.com/blogs/slog/2015/08/26/22761976/at...

an engineer confronts him in a Q&A session about his bias towards engineers. John just blows up. He accuses techies of being quiet &boring, while at the same time accusing them of being the people who are bashing trans people. He's very inconsistent and is just good at being loud.

Oh, and he's also a transplant from NYC, so if we're supposed to buy into his transplant-hate, we should hate him too.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by amyjess on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:10AM (#10360111)
As a trans techie (and a lesbian at that), I already can't stand John.

This guy is nuts. Tech is the single most friendly industry for trans people; there's a reason why working in tech is a transfeminine stereotype.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by JesperRavn on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:57PM (#10357459)
In my high school they didn't know the word "techie" so they had a different word for kids they considered quite and boring. Ironically it was the same word they used to describe people like John.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by mikestew on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:53PM (#10361461)
Turn the tables with the old guard being straight white guy blue collar workers, and the newcomers as gay artists, how do John's rants sound now? To me, sounds pretty much like the old white bigot bitching about how much better it was before "those people" moved in. Just as cranky, just as bigoted, just as cringe-worthy when a gay "artist" says it.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by arasmussen on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:28PM (#10356419)
And the worst part is that Capitol Hill is one of the most open-minded and welcoming neighborhoods in Seattle.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by walshemj on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:39PM (#10356492)
MM and in the old days it would have been "No Irish No Dogs No ..."
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by orik on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:10PM (#10357276)
this is the same guy that did the 'bellevue wives matter' huh? I didn't realize he was a recent transplant.

I love going dancing in Capitol Hill (Swing, Salsa, Ballroom) but I don't find the neighborhood as welcoming and I was told it would be. University District seems like the place to go if you're young.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:12PM (#10354755)
I think "terrible hypocrite" is a major overstatement. The guy is a gay artist who moved to an area built and populated largely by the gay and creative community, only to find it in the process of being colonized by moneyed interests and neighborhood tourists. He identified with the original neighborhood profile strongly and strongly rejects the new one, as I do — though unlike me, he's making his distaste known. I for one salute him, and I love his posters. And by the way, he's not getting rich off selling a couple handmade prints he makes in his own shop.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by wang_li on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:37PM (#10354987)
You mean a place once known as "Catholic Hill" was built and populated by gays and the creative community? Or do you mean that the current moment in time, which through the ongoing process of migration, renovation and economic activity just happens to have a particular demographic that this guy found appealing.

For every buyer, there is a seller and if he doesn't want the neighborhood to change, he should be speaking with the sellers rather than the buyers.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by vectorpush on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:12PM (#10355287)
Quintessential hipster bullshit. His community doesn't have any special rights to dictate the culture of the region and if he doesn't like the newcomers he can leave. It's also absurd to presume that just because someone has a high paying job they cannot qualify as a legitimate part of the community. Your petty and insular mindset is gross.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:08PM (#10355769)
We might have to fuck off because the rent is too high, but it doesn't mean we have to do it quietly. The people coming in should know how much they are resented by the people they are displacing.

The mechanics terraformed capitol hill, the current community colonized it, and now the next wave is buying it.

No one here is dictating culture - they are asserting their preference to a community that was built over decades over another that is superseding it, and which they find distasteful.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by pkinsky on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:50PM (#10356107)
Absolutely! It's disgusting how those people are flooding our neighborhoods and changing our culture. Donald Trump 2016!
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by vectorpush on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:05PM (#10356664)
II reject the idea that you can judge someone as a cultural reject based on the salary they take home.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:44PM (#10356900)
Us too. We also reject the wealth-forward culture helping itself to the neighborhood, not necessarily the people who take part in it. But very often we find the representatives of that culture to be intolerable as well. Ye shall know them by their fruits, and so forth.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:48AM (#10358237)
Guy from Tulalip tribe on line 2. He sounds miffed.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by forrestthewoods on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:23PM (#10354857)
The "original neighborhood profile" wasn't gay creatives. That didn't happen until the 70s/80s. It was blue collar mechanics and auto-shop workers before then.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:37PM (#10354988)
Oh yes definitely. I don't mean a bunch of gay artists came and built it in the 30's or postwar period. But the reinvention of the place, in the 70s and 80s as you say, was what helped make it distinct culturally. That's now coming to an end and a new era is starting - but lots of people would rather it didn't, myself included. Not much we can do though.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by Zach_the_Lizard on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:57PM (#10355173)
I'm thinking those blue collar folks didn't want it to change either, but it did.

The only thing constant is change.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by relaytheurgency on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:13PM (#10355298)
Only my subculture has value and deserves to be preserved.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by e40 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:20PM (#10354821)
Just because he's gay doesn't excuse his behavior. Just change the labels on your post and many would be horrified.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:32PM (#10354941)
That's really, really not what I said.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by eropple on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:07PM (#10355254)
It's not, and you're completely right and I agree with you, but the schtick of ignoring all context that doesn't help out privileged folks is alive and well and highly encouraged on HN. Please try to keep up.

=(

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by dang on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:40AM (#10358216)
That seems both unfair and uncharitable.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by eropple on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:29AM (#10358348)
I'll agree that that's certainly uncharitable; I could have phrased it better but I don't regret that I didn't. I don't think the tech community, or the people who would attempt to elide the vast power differential between it and the people they displace, deserves charity.

If the marginalized had other tools to fight for themselves, I might very well agree with you that it's unfair. As-is, I'm pretty okay with the notion that the rules of the road change when you have all of the money and all of the power and saying not-nice things about you because you are economically destroying them is simply one's tragic burden to bear.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by dang on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:04PM (#10361563)
I understand the political argument, but it doesn't help your cause when you prosecute it on HN in way that addresses others disrespectfully. Unfortunately you do that often, and as you know it breaks the rules here.

The HN guidelines don't have an exemption for being right. On the contrary, it's when you're right and the other person is wrong that they apply most.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by acchow on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:46PM (#10355572)
> And by the way, he's not getting rich off selling a couple handmade prints he makes in his own shop.

If he was, would that make him "one of them"? Making good money suddenly bars you from being a valued member of the community?

> only to find it in the process of being colonized by moneyed interests and neighborhood tourists

Can you explain what you mean by this?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by OrwellianChild on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:48PM (#10357187)
Not sure why the downvotes - you're being articulate about your position, and folks are allowed to prefer what came before to what is coming... I get the sense that folks are threatened by the labels Criscitello throws around because they resemble them and are challenging his right to them in reaction. Thanks for providing cultural context to the anti-tech backlash in Cap Hill.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by CamperBob2 on Friday October 09, 2015 @12:51AM (#10358248)
What he's expressing is the worst kind of conservatism. Ask any African-American family that dared to move into a white neighborhood in the 1960s.

No, it's not OK "when we do it."

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:20PM (#10354826)
Our problem on Capitol Hill is people coming from the rich suburbs to trash our neighborhood, yell "fag" at the locals, fail to tip, and then Uber out, never to be seen again until next Friday. The poster doesn't say "get out of here, self-made engineers!"

That and the construction of cheaply made housing that rents for well above what the neighborhood has ever paid. It's the same story in many other places, of course.

I think John's a treasure, and I love his posters. They express very succinctly what many of us here feel - though there are less every year of course. Not much we can do about it, but a parting "fuck you" seems pretty appropriate to me.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by aaronbrethorst on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:26PM (#10354881)
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:47PM (#10355098)
The "LEGENDARY" dick is still unsurpassed, though.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by aaronbrethorst on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:59PM (#10355190)
Oh yeah. Forgot about that one.

NSFW, assuming your workplace is opposed to drawings of male genitalia: http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archives/2014/04/10/legenda...

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by sushisource on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:23PM (#10353766)
These signs piss me off every time I see them. Always make me think "Oh, I know, it's so horrible that we're helping to bring fresh life into your local economy, with new amenities and attractions". Sure, high paying tech jobs certainly contribute to housing crunches, but they also help solve them by making high-density buildings with affordable housing in them possible. The street goes both ways.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by c22 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:33PM (#10354956)
So I've lived in Seattle my whole life. In the last 5 years the locally operated grocery store near my house was torn down and replaced with a Whole Foods while my favorite movie theater (the only theater I've ever known to provide a sound-proofed room for small children) has become a 21+ reserve-your-seats $80 movie night ordeal. I don't really have a problem with new people moving in and some of my best friends work at Amazon, but you can't really classify all these "new amenities and attractions" as a positive, most of them are just overpriced crap targeted to a demographic I don't belong to. It's not like Seattle was bereft of services and entertainment before you showed up.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by eli_gottlieb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:26PM (#10357782)
Hi, I work in tech.

Whole Foods is shit - it's literally just a CostCo with fancier packaging that charges more - and that movie theater sounds like pretentious pap. This all sounds like overpriced crap even though I'm the target demographic.

Are you sure there's a magical market force whereby tech workers volunteer to be surrounded by overpriced crap?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by deegles on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:07PM (#10354710)
Did he do this one[1] as well? They're getting more and more aggressive lately. (Also I can't help but notice the irony that it was made in Microsoft Word.)

It says "New to the city? Work in tech? You're a plague and locals FUCKING HATE YOU. LEAVE."

[1] http://i.imgur.com/pIkA91B.jpg

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by devindotcom on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:39PM (#10355002)
No, that's just someone printing stuff up and taping it to poles. John does big one-off hand-painted things.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by sbilstein on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:43PM (#10353901)
Ya, some of us even grew up poor! I know I don't speak for all engineers (and we still could do better about this) but when I was in high school the easiest route to money for college was STEM scholarships and gov't funding for STEM degrees. That's what got me a CS degree.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by ForHackernews on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:13PM (#10355823)
You may not have inherited great wealth directly, but it's a fair guess that you "inherited" some or all of the following:

* Parents who pushed you to focus on your schoolwork.

* Parents who owned a computer, or bought a computer specifically for their kids' education.

* Parents who lived in a house with consistent water, electricity and internet service.

* Parents who made sure you got glasses if you needed them, so you could see the board in class.

* Parents who understood the importance of a college education, and who helped you apply to colleges (real colleges, not for-profit scam schools), took you on college visits, filled out financial aid paperwork, contributed to your tuition.

* A relatively high IQ and/or an analytic mindset.

I'm sure you've worked hard, but don't discount the advantages you were born with, and don't fall victim to the Just World Fallacy. This planet is full of people who worked twice as hard as you and got nowhere.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by oldmanjay on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:46PM (#10356076)
Sure, ascribe everything to luck, and then so what? Where does that leave us? With less of an appetite for technology and progress? With more of a use for people who have no salable skills and hungry mouths and envy for the good life? Or does it just leave us with a bunch of people who contribute nothing more to society than constantly exclaiming that things aren't fair? We know they aren't fair. They've never been fair, they'll probably never be fair. Spinning tires over that basic fact of our universe is so pointless I'm almost offended people waste so many bits about it.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by rayiner on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:36PM (#10357820)
Where does that leave us? With humility hopefully. You don't deserve any credit for being born with a high IQ, aptitude for acquiring sellable skills, and into a life station where any of that mattered. You work hard, sure, but so does the farmer in Bangladesh. The only difference between him and you is the cosmic lottery. So get off your high horse about "contributing to society." All you should feel is grateful that $Diety gave you the gift of being able to do that.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by optimiz3 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @11:19PM (#10357963)

  bool is_other_person_is_humble()
  {
    return do_they_make_less_money_than_me();
  }
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by theworstshill on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:18PM (#10356334)
Couldn't have said it better myself. Those folks are straight out of an old (early) USSR caricature on how Lenin shared a watermelon with a passing peasant - took his watermelon, dropped it on the ground, picked up half of it and walked away.

Spent a decade educating yourself and endless nights practicing your craft? Its all "privillege" and "luck", now give me some of that money.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by SolaceQuantum on Thursday October 08, 2015 @08:16PM (#10357295)
> ascribe everything to luck,

Did you misread when the person said specifically "I'm sure you've worked hard"?

Person is probably not saying "hey nothing you did was on you" but is more likely wanting to say "hey consider the greater context of your existence".

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by ForHackernews on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:53PM (#10356127)
> Where does that leave us?

With a sense of compassion and a diminished sense of smug self-satisfaction, I might hope.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by bethling on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:49PM (#10356095)
Until I met my wife, I hadn't realized exactly the fortune I had with my family. My parents were teachers and really understood the value of education. We came from a modest background, but it was stable and they did push me to focus on school. I went to a really good school (yay need based financial aid), have a great job that pays me well.

On the other hand, we have my wife. She is smarter than me, but went 7 different schools as her family moved from place to place before she finally dropped out, worked retail as she essentially raised one of her sisters as she scraped by. In a more stable environment, she'd have almost certainly ended up in law or business school.

She now really tries to provide some sort of stability, and encourage focusing on schoolwork with her nieces and nephews, who are in danger of repeating the history of poverty.

Seeing that makes me realize how very lucky I was to be born into the family I was, and everything I took for granted really isn't just what "normal" is.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by seansmccullough on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:20PM (#10356346)
I worked my ass off to get here. Plenty of my peers with the same advantages didn't work hard, and aren't here.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by rhino369 on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:26PM (#10356403)
Sure. People who are born into the middle class are certainly better off than people born into poverty. That still doesn't make them rich kids. Three of your factors are true for virtually everyone in America. One is pure luck unrelated from wealth. And the other two are just good parenting.

Tech is a very middle class profession. Much more middle class than most high paying professions like Medicine, Law, Executives, Consultants, Banking, etc.

And most people who would call someone a rich kid were born just as middle class (or even better).

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by dwaxe on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:06PM (#10356677)
Did any of us choose our parents? Parents are the purest luck anyone has.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by joesmo on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:28PM (#10353804)
It's also ridiculous that these same people benefit greatly from a growing economy that's directly influenced by (and these days also partially propped up by) the boom in tech while deriding it like it's some kind of negative force. It sounds to me a lot more like envy than any nostalgia for artistry and run-down neighborhoods, as they claim.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by ondrae on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:58PM (#10354019)
This article is about Seattle trying to slow the rising number of families being gentrified out of their homes and long standing communities. The nostalgia of not taking your kids out of their current school? The nostalgia of not having a new crazy commute? There is real pain happening to real people.

Who is getting this great benefit that is so ridiculous?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by s73v3r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:00PM (#10354643)
Money isn't everything to a lot of people. On top of that, how much do they benefit if they end up chased out of their neighborhood?
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by amyjess on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:43PM (#10355053)
I wish I was a rich kid.

I only got to go to college on a scholarship, and I spent the first five years of my career making under $50k.

I'm disappointed that some people think working in tech means that you're made of money.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by blakeyrat on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:39PM (#10357155)
My mom was a school teacher, and I think she approached $50k maybe her last one or two years before retirement.

I'm not saying that the assumption that all tech workers are rich is correct, but you might want to rethinking how much money $50k after 5 years really is.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by nugget on Thursday October 08, 2015 @09:43PM (#10357631)
Public school teachers don't seem terribly underpaid to me. In Seattle the 2015 starting salary is $44,372[1], which is about $60k when adjusted for a 12 month calendar. That's a solid middle class job that favorably compares with other similar career options. There is another 30% in benefits/hidden comp (health care and pension) on top of that[2]. And there is significant upside for ambitious teachers who want to focus on increasing their earnings.

[1] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/education/pay-varie...

[2] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240529702036875045766553...

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by ForHackernews on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:42PM (#10356044)
> I spent the first five years of my career making under $50k.

Many people spend their entire lives making less than $50k. Try and have a little bit of empathy.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by NotABox on Friday October 09, 2015 @10:09AM (#10360101)
Jesus! The first five years of your career making under $50K? Poor baby!
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by sgustard on Thursday October 08, 2015 @06:01PM (#10356633)
He's not targeting engineers. He's targeting yuppies, fraternity punks, late-night bar hoppers, Yelp-adoring foodies, crowds of drunk people in baseball caps with money to burn standing in line for hipster restaurants and nightclubs, shouting and pissing in the streets at 2am. That's the crowd that invades your city like a plague when it becomes a trendy destination.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by ForHackernews on Thursday October 08, 2015 @10:51PM (#10357878)
> yuppies

What makes you think that yuppies and engineers are disjoint sets?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by s73v3r on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:54PM (#10354571)
At the same time, they're people that are coming in and pushing people who have lived there out, simply because they have more money. That would piss most people off.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by srdev on Thursday October 08, 2015 @07:41PM (#10357165)
Its really understandable why that would piss them off and I sympathize. At the same time, it seems like the only solutions are for me to quit my job and "fuck off", or to live in the suburbs and suck up a > 1 hr commute. People deserve to live a good life and improve their station, and that includes techies who are well off, in addition to the poor and middle class.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by s73v3r on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:06PM (#10361570)
Unfortunately, it currently seems like the techies improving their station is coming at the expense of the poor and middle class who were there.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by steve-howard on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:51PM (#10355612)
I hear and empathize with this complaint, and I think it's a real problem. But what about the people on the other side of the fence? You work in software, some company pays you a lot to move out here, and you're in a position to choose where you want to live. Should you really not live in a particular area because it makes you part of a bigger problem?
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by serge2k on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:21PM (#10355883)
Well you are new, so you should be required to take your substantial income and use it to get a place an hour from work so you can bus everyday.

That's totally the way the world works right?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by s73v3r on Friday October 09, 2015 @01:07PM (#10361575)
At the same time, why are you more deserving of living there than them?
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by steve-howard on Friday October 09, 2015 @02:38PM (#10362375)
There are good arguments to be made against gentrification, and there are good arguments to be made that people don't deserve to have special privileges just because they got here first. It makes me sad that a lot of the public debate in places like Seattle comes down to "fuck you, go home."
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by refurb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @12:50PM (#10353961)
But we're certainly not in the same category as those who inherit wealth.

Ahhh... it's the old, I'm not rich! The rich are people that make more than me!

By that definition, almost nobody is rich.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by napoleond on Thursday October 08, 2015 @01:06PM (#10354088)
That's not the argument being made.
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by refurb on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:09PM (#10354744)
Sounds like it to me. What difference does it make if you inherit your money or earn your money. Either way you're "rich".
Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by gingerrr on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:32PM (#10354945)
I can't imagine you're this obtuse for real but I'll bite.

Pretty sure the backlash is against the "kids" part of rich kids - as the phrase "rich kids" insinuates second-gen wealth, a mass of money without having the responsibility or maturity to have earned it.

Very different story than for many of us self-made engineers, coming from the lower end of the economic bracket and taking advantage of scholarships and financial aid to get the skills that have now landed us well-paying jobs as adults, which we've worked 8-12-hour days to earn and keep.

We may be "rich" but we're not spoiled "rich kids", that make more sense?

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by eropple on Thursday October 08, 2015 @03:14PM (#10355312)
What makes you say that "rich kids" implies second-generation wealth? Everyone I know who uses it in a pejorative sense is pretty clearly referring to how most of the people in question are still being carded at bars. A 23-year-old making $120K is on the lower end of upper-class and can safely be assured of moving upward barring very unusual circumstances. And if you work in startup-ish/leading-edge tech, I'll lay even-odds on "spoiled" fitting. (Where do you think all the Mom-replacement startups, the feed-me-and-do-my-laundry startups, come from?) I am profoundly fortunate in my choice of career and the benefits I've realized from it--and I don't apologize for it, but I at least try to keep perspective on my extreme good fortune. There but for the grace of God, so on and so forth.

The backlash is not against "kids", but unreasonable defensiveness about the word "rich," because "oh, I'm not rich, I'm just getting by even though I have a stupid-good 401k and benefits and make enough money to never look at a bank statement." When you have to own up to just not really working all that hard and just not really having a struggle in your life that you didn't create, lots of people feel real bad. (And the ones that are hurting people with real problems should feel bad. "But economics" does not clean one's hands of one's contributions to even faceless evil.)

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by gingerrr on Thursday October 08, 2015 @04:31PM (#10355960)
Fair enough, "rich kids" can also mean fresh-out-of-mom-and-dads' with too much money and not enough impulse control.

I guess the reason I assume the backlash is against 'kids' and not 'rich' is, to use my own anecdote, most everyone I know in this industry who might be incorrectly classified as "rich kids" came from much humbler circumstance, and they also try to keep perspective on their extreme good fortune as you do.

Perhaps it's the circles we run in, but most of the people I know personally who would be caught in the crossfire of "rich kids" are aware and grateful daily of their massive advantage because of the stark contrast to their childhood economic experience - and it makes them work twice as hard to make sure they maintain it, as well as pay greater attention to those evils.

I feel like the truer crime called out by "rich kids" is reveling in privilege, oblivious at its cost to others - that total lack of societal awareness I tend to associate with children, which I guess is why 'kids' seemed more backlash appropriate.

Re:Seattle, in Midst of Tech Boom, Tries to Keep Its Soul by eropple on Thursday October 08, 2015 @05:21PM (#10356354)
I think you and I are probably pretty much on the same page! I dig how you put it in your last paragraph, but I tend to see that as more immaturity than the actual state of being a child. And many (I'd say "most" but it could just be that the many are loud) of the folks I deal with on a daily basis are deeply socially and societally immature; my hunch is much more that that's an artifact of being so insulated than anything. I do tend to work with leading-edge, startup-bait technologies and for the organizations that use them, which may further color my perspective.

I don't think the tech industry or the people of it want to coexist with other people, and I very strongly feel like the mean streak of turbocapitalist libertarianism shooting through tech encourages a culture of not feeling a need to coexist.

And now I'm bummed again. Grumble.