I also find a bit of a contradiction between you praising bluntness and honesty while at the same wishing for not being nasty to high school children. It is kind of impossible to have both. I would prefer if people were cautious, not blunt.
"Your contribution does not fit our current guidelines. Please read CONTRIBUTING.md and feel free to ask if you have any further questions."
comes across very differently than something aggressive.
You're telling the contributor that his/her work does not conform to the project's standards without being an asshole.
I don't see where the difficulty of treating other human beings with some respect resides.
"Your contribution is inadequate. Try again." That's blunt. For one, it's purely negative. It doesn't say what to do instead, only that something wrong was done. It makes people feel like there's no hope for them to do it right.
Let's try it:
"I, speaking not only for myself, would be most grateful if, at least for a period of some number of years during which your already considerable skills continue to attain even greater heights of excellence, you might, as kindly as you have done here, bestow the favor of your well-considered patches upon some other open source software project. Should you be so obliging as to accommodate our wishes in this matter, you shall be rewarded with no less than a half pound sack of jelly babies, delivered to your place of residence by overnight courier."
Now that I look at it, though, not bad! Would it kill those kernel developers to use this friendly template?
Hostility is not avoidable in human interactions; the British have off-the-shelf reusable solutions that satisfy everyone involved with reasonable compromise.
I was recently working with a particular hardware module from a certain company. Their lead technical support person was also helping develop the ARM side of the kernel and merge their drivers into the tree.
The awful technical interactions and pretty much the complete lack of patience and empathy for a customer, made the whole thing a nightmare. Eventually I lobbied, and got, our company to drop them as a vendor and move to a competitor. That one developer created -$1,000,000 in annual revenue for the vendor.
I still don't think they realize what happened.
Basically your goal was to punish not to correct?
Since this was the business model this company deemed acceptable, I figured it was completely acceptable to do it in return. When all you receive to your questions is "RTFM, idiot", that's a punishment in my opinion...not a correction. And I'm the one holding the million dollar purchase order in my hand.
I could not (and would not) waste development time trying to reeducate this person into being a better customer support person. That's not my job - it's theirs. Sometimes you need to whack someone on the head with a 2x4 before they get the message.
(Attempting to correct from the outside, the flaws of vendor bureaucracies seldom goes well.)
Yes, it is possible: objectively. However, there exist people with whom you cannot be honest whatsoever without coming across as hostile to them. (Maybe via heaps of sugar-coated language, interspersed with all sorts of reassuring hedges.)
Sometimes a contribution simply cannot be salvaged, calling the person an idiot has chance going to chase them away resulting in a net loss. "Sorry to make you try this again, here is a more appropriate approach" could result in a usable contribution and possibly future higher-quality contributions from that same person - a net gain.
That line of thought indicates that being nice is the most logical "contributor architecture" choice. Why do we have all these guidelines about how to deal with code, yet none about how to deal with people? It's insane.
Re: the Linux/distro split. It's true, an IRC room for a distro is not the Linux kernel group - however, it's not a vast stretch of the imagination to conclude that they learned that attitude from the kernel group.
I am also equally fond of a sentiment I read somewhere that "Those who love brutal honestly love brutality more than honesty."
Real honesty reveals the genuine feelings beneath the PC surface. Those feelings can include genuine respect, caring, esteem, etc. It in no way is required to be cruel. If honesty involves nastiness, it tells you something about the person being "honest" in that way.
Granted, it can be hard to tell the difference at first blush, as it certainly isn't PC to be so honest.
That's not to say that I don't like IRC, quite the opposite. But like with Redit, you'll often meet few bored and outspoken individuals that will taunt you. But once you look past those trolls, you can usually still find a real depth and friendliness to a community. Sadly that sometimes requires interacting with said community via other mediums or portals.
[1] excluding YouTube's comments section. But that's a whole other level of hell.
And your experience is certainly not reflective of anything in the article, which is about Kernel developers. The LKML is its whole own world with its own set of problems (mostly volume and competence related) and very few downstream communities model themselves on it.
For example, Ubuntu and Ask Ubuntu both require their community members to follow the Ubuntu Code of Conduct[1] if they want to remain part of the community. That codifies being respectful into everyday tasks.
Edit: That's not to say that LKML is fine as is. It needs to retain developers and many don't enjoy being abused by seniors... It just has very little to do with your comment.
Unrelated to your post: When you live and work intimately with people you know on a public mailing list it you will have friction. There are way to many people self inserting themselves as "victims" in online conversations without any knowledge about the relationship between the conversation partners.
Interesting. What have you contributed to Windows and Visual Studio? (If you don't mind.)
And to paraphrase a local "saying": tween is a mentality, not an age.
I approached the IRC room for the distro I was using (this time from within Linux!), asked for a wiki or some website where they would recommend I post the quick-fix and got a disproportionate aggressive response from a few of the participants.
A few weeks later my brother got me a friends-and-family license for Visual Studio and I've been developing on Windows ever since - I found people always appreciated contribution (ironic) no matter how insignificant, and would give far friendlier (as a relative term) advice on how to fix problems with the contributions.
I praise Linus and the Linux community in general for their bluntness and honesty, but I don't think being honest requires being nasty to high school children.
Edit: I strongly recommend having a look at the Contributor Covenant[1]. It has some great guidelines for ensuring that any misguided contributions are guided toward success in a friendly manner.
[1]: http://contributor-covenant.org/