News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by manachar on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:50PM (#10335822)
It's really weird to me how commonplace the attitude of "It is what it is" and "Government can't do anything".

The air and water quality in the US is vastly better since the passage of laws that created and empowered the EPA (Created by the Republican President Nixon). The endangered species act has had many similar successes.

I live on Maui. The waters are now filled with Green Sea Turtles and Humpback whales that were nearly non-existent just 30 years ago. Yet when development and global climate change are threatening our reefs, people look at you like you're crazy for thinking that laws can be effective in safeguarding the environment for the future.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by p_monk on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:43PM (#10336648)
The creation of the EPA, (and OSHA, Clean Water Act and Safe Drinking Water Act, Highway Safety Act, FOIA) was created because people demanded it, not because a Republican President was benevolent.

Ralph Nader, and the organizations who were influenced by his work, took advantage of the social upheaval in the late 60s/early 70s to make these laws pass.

Even though activist voices are as loud as they've ever been, we have a government that no longer fears movements. I've heard the Nader generation of activists make this point regularly. Power has been sharply shifting from people (activists organizations, labor unions) to business since the late 70s.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by stefanix on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @04:34AM (#10337463)
See Lessig's campaign for why this is https://lessig2016.us/one-mission/
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by lurkinggrue on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:00PM (#10335876)
"Government can't do anything" meme tends to be pushed by organizations that actively want less government.

The sort of groups that listen to people like Grover Norquest who said: "I don't want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub."

While there is a lot to be said about the idea of efficiency in government it isn't the same as wanting to burn our infrastructure down.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by manachar on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:03PM (#10335896)
American progressives can be just as guilty, if less organized. They tend to view big business with suspicion and incorrectly think that the American government is hopelessly corrupt and in the pocket of "Big Business and/or Wall Street".
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by beatpanda on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:34PM (#10336038)
In what sense is that view incorrect? The cost of access to the political process in America is astronomically high and keeps increasing, and acquiring the amount of money it now takes to be competitive in an election requires adopting a set of positions that are friendly to whatever industries have the most money to give.

What part of that analysis is wrong? What counterexample can you offer?

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by letitgo12345 on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:07PM (#10336164)
While money buys political access, a large part of the responsibility does rest with the voters (who are mostly ordinary people, not big money) who keep voting for reps (or don't vote) who support regressive policies. Also big money doesn't control the govt -- there are lots of times where they don't get their way -- immigration reform being a prime example where nativist sentiment has stalled it for more than a decade even though the business community is largely for it.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by crdoconnor on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:04AM (#10336702)
>Also big money doesn't control the govt -- there are lots of times where they don't get their way -- immigration reform being a prime example where nativist sentiment has stalled it for more than a decade even though the business community is largely for it.

Immigration reform is more of a fight between the corporations that want more legal immigrants to depress high wages (e.g. Facebook/FWD.us) and the corporations that want to keep employing illegals at sub-minimum wages (e.g. fruit & vegetable pickers).

This actually puts them in direct opposition to one another on a range of legislative issues.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by beatpanda on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:28PM (#10336243)
I think you are insufficiently cynical to understand immigration reform.

The current state of immigration reform, where politicians demand (and are getting) increased enforcement without any expansion of a legal right to work in the U.S., works great for companies in labor-intensive industries. On the one hand, you get a workforce willing to get paid less than the legal minimum, and you don't have to pay things like worker's comp, social security, etc. On the other, enforcement has increased so much that those underpaid workers live in constant fear of being deported or having their families split apart, so they don't report their employers breaking the law.

For companies that have access to that pool of precarious labor, the situation is great, and they've invested a lot in not changing anything.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by sgc on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:17PM (#10336563)
I think you are too cynical to be able to understand it.

What you propose they are doing is the equivalent of inviting the fox into the hen house to give the other roosters a run for their money--it is Russian roulette. I doubt anyone using undocumented labor wants more enforcement, although certainly a low-wage state would welcome enforcement for a "competitive"/"fair" advantage over higher-wage states (like California, with its massive undocumented labor pool).

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Retric on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:55AM (#10336818)
You only get to vote for a tiny number of people, the groups with early access to pick who runs have far more power than the 'popular' vote. "I voted for Kodos." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kang_and_Kodos

PS: Obama might have been a better option, but I disagree with over half of what he has done.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Chathamization on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:29AM (#10339524)
You get to vote for a lot of people, but most people simply ignore this. Take Obama - started as a state senator, ran for Congress, then ran for the Senate, then for the presidency. In each of these elections he had to get through both a primary and general election. In each of these elections he also had to rely on a network of supporters and surrogates, the most important of which are other elected officials (many at the local level). He also had to work with the state party (also elected).

The vast majority of people ignore 99% of the elections out there, and then wonder why they don't have an influence on things. I mean, seriously - we often have elections here with turnout in the teens. And I've worked the polls for those elections - even the minority of people who bother showing up have no clue to who's even on the ballot. Many times when I ask people who they voted for, they can't even remember (again, the few who bothered to vote).

It's like staying at home while other people work on a year long project, then showing up 3 days before release and complaining that you have no control over it. Well, yeah.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by beatpanda on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:46PM (#10340208)
You're still ignoring the role of money here. Yes, there are a lot of elections, and in every election, the amount of money a candidate is able to spend is a huge influencing factor on whether they can beat their opponents. This is also true in primaries, and in state legislature elections, and governor's races, and everywhere else. If you can't buy advertising to get in front of people, you can't get name recognition, which means you don't poll well, which means the media won't cover you, and nobody will think of you when it comes time for them to vote. It's all very straightforward.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Chathamization on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @02:37PM (#10341253)
But that's the thing - no matter the amount of money poured in, the vast majority of campaigns still feature candidates ignored by almost everyone. For most campaigns, the money doesn't affect someone's opinion of the candidates, because they aren't even aware of the candidates.

You see this more and more as you move away from the big races - I've seen numerous examples where the loser outspent the victor 20 or 50 to 1. Heck, there was even a situation recently where someone with just about no political or financial backing came in second (doing better than several candidates with much better funding and much more insider connection) simply because his name sounded like another politicians. When I look at things like this, it seems like apathy influences our politics much, much more than money.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Retric on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:18PM (#10339964)
There are ~320 million people in the US the first filter that drops 99.99% of them is by far the most important. EX: Pro life democrat or pro choice republican running for president = good luck.

Further, I don't think a great president looks much like a great senator.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by guelo on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:11PM (#10336183)
The environmental laws you mention happened more than 30 years ago. It sure seems like bigcos have gained the upperhand in the last generation.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by chris_va on Monday October 05, 2015 @10:27PM (#10336417)
Not really, it is mostly just more media coverage and observation bias.

As an example, it used to be that you could just dump whatever you wanted into the local water table. Now everything is picked over with a fine comb.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by MaysonL on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:20AM (#10337615)
Contrast the treatment of bank executives after the S&L crisis, and after the recent financial crisis. They got away with murder (not quite literally) this time.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Frondo on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:06PM (#10336162)
No, I don't think I ever hear American progressives assert that they want less government.

Less corrupt government? Absolutely, but the idea that government is "too big" seems entirely in province of the contemporary right (and you can partition that up into the industrialists who want to abolish the EPA, the code-worded-racists who want to end welfare, the bootstrappers who want to privatize everything, etc).

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by zero_intp on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @01:08AM (#10336852)
As a progressive, I would support a plan of re distributive basic income. The plan I would support would involve shrinking existing government.

As a progressive, I support removing the costs of worker healthcare from labor costs to industry.

As a progressive, I support reducing the over-all social cost to higher education by eliminating the federal grant and loan processes, and simply block allocating per-student rates for state schools.

As a progressive, I would love to see Corporations dehumanized; Speech equal speech; and commercial activity limited to the interaction of autonomous entities.

As a progressive, I would support returning the sovereign responsibilities of application of force to the government, and in doing so reduce the actual per-body cost of warfare and law-enforcement. (Ending cost-plus contracting) (Returning prisoners to the states from private enterprises)

If given free reign, every industry would cloud it's cost externalities, such as the environmental repercussions, or the needs of the dependents that work those convenient company towns. Quarterly balance reports rarely see the value in education, healthcare, or decent food in those locked-in labor units.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:18AM (#10337607)
Apologies for the political observation, but I'm a history buff and I found your comment interesting.

It used to be that progressives would resoundingly argue for smaller, more efficient government that achieves desired social goals. Somehow over the last 50 years they stopped doing this, and instead got into some kind of pissing match with conservatives over the size of government. It'd be great to get back to a discussion around "what are your goals, what are the trade-offs you are willing to make, and what is the most efficient way to achieve them?"

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by arebop on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:31PM (#10336251)
Really, you have never heard American progressives call for reduced military expenditure?
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Retra on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:47AM (#10336799)
Mostly they aim to divert military expenditure into other things like education, healthcare, or research.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by bluthru on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:08PM (#10335919)
When money buys political speech, I don't think you can call the other side "just as guilty".
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by baddox on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:22PM (#10335988)
Which side has the actual ability to forcefully implement their desired policies over a large population?
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by deciplex on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:44PM (#10336301)
Both.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by baddox on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:47PM (#10336311)
Do you really suppose so? I suppose it's technically possible for both to try, but imagine the resistance one side would be met with.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Asbostos on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:11AM (#10336720)
The side with the real power - the voters. You can blame businesses or activists or interest groups or governments or whatever but America still has a democracy and American people actually do choose the outcomes they get. You personally might not want them, but most of your fellow Americans either do want them or succumb to some personal greed to make them happen.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by baddox on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @01:03AM (#10336836)
I disagree very much. The fact that concentrated interests win out over dispersed interests is not some failure of the population to educate itself and vote hard enough. It's an extremely basic game theoretical inevitability.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by dredmorbius on Thursday October 08, 2015 @02:17AM (#10351194)
Exactly. See Mancur Olson, "The Logic of Collective Action".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by mfringel on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @09:32AM (#10338714)
No. The electorate chooses from a set of outcomes that are chosen long before they get a chance to vote on any of them. The political process starts a very long time before a typical citizen gets to vote.

Thinking that the political process begins and ends with voting is one of the key components of despair and cynicism in a democracy.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by BurningFrog on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:12PM (#10336189)
Government is quite different from infrastructure.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by baddox on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:53PM (#10335837)
What are you referencing in regards to poverty? I would have guessed that the recent reduction in poverty is largely attributable to wealthy nations reducing efforts to centrally plan the economies of poor nations.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by malchow on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:09PM (#10335927)
The conceit of the article -- borne out by economic history -- is exactly that: it's the reduction of efforts to centrally plan, and the rise of entrepreneurial, capitalistic efforts to advance, that has reduced poverty. [1] [2]

[1] https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/deirdre-mccloskey-... [2] https://ricochet.com/perhaps-the-most-powerful-defense-of-ma...

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Steko on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:36PM (#10336619)
The article is actually fairly silent on the reasons so read into it what you will. If anything the author is endorsing his friend's book without giving away the thesis and if the link is accurate it covers a wide range of factors.

As for Deirdre McCloskey, as Noah Smith says,"do not believe things that Deirdre McCloskey says just because she says them."

http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2015/06/deirdre-mccloskey...

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by manachar on Monday October 05, 2015 @07:59PM (#10335871)
While this article was more focused on poverty, the other major theme was that things and people are better now in many respects that people think it is.

For me, the environmental successes of the last 30 years are a pretty amazing example of some of the awesome things humans can do when they put their minds to it.

Additionally, the overly negative and pessimistic view of government and laws removes critical tools for that improvement.

That move away from centrally planning poor nations was often achieved by changes in laws, and by the actions of a wide variety of organizational bodies and peoples. I'm not sure I have enough information in this article or elsewhere to state what has been effective at reducing the poverty.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by ArkyBeagle on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:59PM (#10336690)
It's less than awesome, really - people got richer and demand rose for a cleaner environment.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by Zigurd on Monday October 05, 2015 @08:31PM (#10336021)
> reducing efforts to centrally plan the economies

"Reducing" is technically correct, even in China. But China still has a command economy in housing, infrastructure, telecommunication, transportation, etc., and is still run by a big 'C' Communist Party. That's where the uplift happened, and it needs to be explained in terms of local conditions.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by amelius on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @05:59AM (#10337780)
Yes. And I think the following sentence best explains why:

> When 95 percent of Americans are completely unaware of a transformation of this magnitude, that reflects a flaw in how we journalists cover the world — and I count myself among the guilty.

Sometimes it is really maddening how far astray the common perceptions are with respect to reality. It is good to have an example here that shows this clearly.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by WalterBright on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:45PM (#10336306)
It's the classic tragedy of the commons. Nobody owns the waterways and the air, and hence individuals have neither the power nor incentive to protect them.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by danharaj on Monday October 05, 2015 @10:04PM (#10336349)
It is reasonable to believe that the tragedy of the commons is caused by society being organized around private ownership, not the nature of the commons itself.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons#Critici...

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by webXL on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:07PM (#10336528)
Without private ownership, resources cannot be traded to their highest utility. Politicians ultimately are left to figure that out (when they get around to it, of course).
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by danharaj on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @12:22PM (#10339991)
> Without private ownership, resources cannot be traded to their highest utility.

The language of economics is designed so that this is tautologically true and all empirical evidence that this is false is euphemized away with the term 'externality' or 'market failure'.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by webXL on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @02:40PM (#10341293)
Externalities can only exist with public goods, such as the commons or air pollution. The more public goods, the more chances of externalities.

Market failure is a subjective term that assumes a problem can be always be solved fairly (no one is made worse off). That euphemism tends to be used by those who believe "free market" (no such thing) solutions are inferior to state-imposed solutions, which often involve force and/or benefit the ruling class. There's plenty of empirical evidence to support that.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by danharaj on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @03:04PM (#10341476)
> Market failure is a subjective term that assumes a problem can be always be solved fairly (no one is made worse off). That euphemism tends to be used by those who believe "free market" (no such thing) solutions are inferior to state-imposed solutions, which often involve force and/or benefit the ruling class. There's plenty of empirical evidence to support that.

Market failure is defined as a situation in which markets fail to achieve pareto efficiency; pareto inefficiency is definitionally the condition where someone's situation can be improved fairly, as you call it. A few heterodox schools simply choose a different definition of efficiency to wave away the problem of market failure, but this is circular logic: They define markets as the best system of allocating resources and therefore it is impossible for markets to fail.

If that's the position you want to take, please be forthright about your assumptions. I no longer think we're using the same basic definitions and I am fairly certain I am talking about well established mainstream concepts in economics.

P.S.

> state-imposed solutions, which often involve force

Private property as it exists is definitionally a state-imposed by force concept. I don't think your moral claim about people who use the term market failure is as biting an indictment as you think.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by webXL on Wednesday October 07, 2015 @08:11AM (#10345484)
How am I not forthright about my assumptions? I started this all off by simply stating that privately owned resources can be traded to their highest utility, and you seem to have a roundabout way of challenging that claim. Empirical evidence would be the most direct way.

And while state-enforced property rights have enabled many other technological advancements and objectively moral outcomes, this does not give the state the moral high ground to use force for its own arbitrary purposes. On the micro scale, just because my authority allows my children to claim their own space, clothes, etc. doesn't necessarily mean that authority can always lead to good outcomes in every interaction they have with each other. It's just a means to an end, like the state.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by cbd1984 on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:42PM (#10342937)
This post alone shows enough misunderstanding of economics to discredit you on the subject.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by danharaj on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @10:38PM (#10343904)
Good thing I don't depend on being a credible expert in economics; neither do many purported experts in economics.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @03:53AM (#10337311)
The original statement of the Tragedy of the Commons implies that ownership of grazing land leads to better outcomes. Whether that applies in similar cases when it is invoked depends. Pigou taxes are proposed as a bridge technology to gain the benefits of private ownership for common goods.
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by ZenoArrow on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @06:56AM (#10338010)
>"It's the classic tragedy of the commons. Nobody owns the waterways and the air, and hence individuals have neither the power nor incentive to protect them."

Why does lack of direct ownership imply lack of protection?

It's possible to have a common resource that is owned by nobody/everybody, and have an organisation set up to protect misuse of this resource. Just because it's free to use, doesn't mean it's free for all potential uses.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:16AM (#10339425)
> It's possible to have a common resource that is owned by nobody/everybody, and have an organisation set up to protect misuse of this resource.

And this organization would be different from a government how?

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by ZenoArrow on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @11:56AM (#10339774)
A government is one valid way to organise this. Is that bad in your opinion?
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by andyfleming on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:52PM (#10336673)
What about the sea turtles with tumors in Hawaii? There is some concern that humans are to blame, right?
Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by manachar on Tuesday October 06, 2015 @04:10PM (#10341968)
Yes, and I actually just had dinner with some humans working on figuring it out. One possibility is that an invasive species of seaweed is throwing their diet out of whack.

Humans can keep helping by gaining greater understandings of the impact our actions have on everything around us (negative externalities if you want economic-speak).

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by andyfleming on Monday October 12, 2015 @02:23PM (#10376177)
Fair enough. I'm not sure why I was downvoted. I'm not suggesting regulation or the EPA is bad.

I saw a turtle with tumors, in person, and a local suggested that it was suspected that some sort of runoff was the cause of the issue. My thought was that there may not be enough regulation and accountability.

Re:The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy ... by jqm on Monday October 05, 2015 @09:19PM (#10336211)
While I don't disagree government has been at time effective (in making life better and improving the world), one doesn't have to look very hard to find to find instances where they have not been effective or even counterproductive. The government of today isn't necessarily the government of 30 years ago. It's bigger. Maybe slower. Maybe filled with worse people. I don't know that all these things are true but as they say in the stock trading commercials... "past performance is no guarantee of future success".

But I do believe people shouldn't give up and should be informed and try to participate in elections and citizen activisms. I mean... if we don't try how can we keep the corrupt from running the show?