News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chrisann Brennan on Steve Jobs by DanBC on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:30PM (#10328509)
Just checking: You know that a bunch of people took Nazi propaganda, changed the word "Jew" to "migrant", and posted it to the Daily Mail comment section, and that those comments were upvoted by DM readers?

https://medium.com/@bestofthemail/i-was-upvoted-for-posting-...

And, scarily, the Nazi propaganda was mild in contrast to other comments openly calling for the murder of migrants?

Look at the upvotes on these comments: https://twitter.com/DMReporter/status/650656856529092608

DM engages in the worst kind of click-bait. They are the scum of the earth.

Posting links to the Daily Mail on HN is like flinging excrement at your readers.

Re:Chrisann Brennan on Steve Jobs by dang on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:39PM (#10328538)
As I'm sure you know, the relation between article quality and site quality is complicated.

HN's approach is to focus on the quality of the article, because that's what maximizes interestingness for the reader. We penalize sites that mostly produce bad articles, but we override that penalty for the occasional good one, which this is. I'm happy to change the URL if there's a better one but I don't think it makes sense for HN readers not to see Brennan's remarkable piece.

Re:Chrisann Brennan on Steve Jobs by ta83742389 on Sunday October 04, 2015 @04:44PM (#10328747)
Another point of view: Daily Mail is trashy, but at least it does not display the sanctimony of something like that Medium experiment linked above.

I am fine with it.

Re:Chrisann Brennan on Steve Jobs by NoCulturalFit on Sunday October 04, 2015 @06:11PM (#10329036)
I am probably missing something, but I take it you're okay with The Guardian as a source? How is this not clickbait? https://twitter.com/somuchguardian
Re:Chrisann Brennan on Steve Jobs by muddi900 on Monday October 05, 2015 @02:54AM (#10330284)
I do not know if the original commenter(commentator?) is okay with The Guardian as a source, but that twitter account is trash.

Sadly, one thing the original commentor(commentator?) seem to not understand that it's about what's being said, rather than who's saying it.