News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by mratzloff on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:31PM (#10322479)
I think Randy Marsh from "South Park" had the most effective anti-marijuana speech I've ever heard:

Stan: I've been told a lot of things about pot, but I've come to find out a lot of those things aren't true! So I don't know what to believe!

Randy: Well, Stan, the truth is marijuana probably isn't gonna make you kill people, and it most likely isn't gonna fund terrorism, but… well, son, pot makes you feel fine with being bored. And it's when you're bored that you should be learning some new skill or discovering some new science or being creative. If you smoke pot you may grow up to find out that you aren't good at anything.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Vexs on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:57PM (#10322527)
Seriously, the only things that have ever made me think a second time about drugs are the honest descriptions of it, not the "I did drugs and now I have no teeth" kinda descriptions, but the ones that go, "When you're on meth, meth feels great! Everything is amazing, you feel like you can do so much, but when you're off it everything seems boring! So you go back for more, and eventually you're addicted." kinda descriptions.

If you talk about LSD, and say, "I've had some amazing times on it, and other times I've had spiders in my eyes", I think most people would be less likely to try it. Sure, not everyone, but still more than people saying just spiders in your eyes.

I mean, it's a classical argument tactic, give something up to make your point more valid. But damned if it doesn't work.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by astazangasta on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:23AM (#10322586)
Or, just do drugs. I mean, LSD is great, and people should try it. Smoking pot is also nice, I've done some great writing while stoned. Heck, Paul Erdos did amphetamines his whole life. Why are we trying to convince everyone not to do drugs again?
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by jeffdavis on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:45AM (#10322884)
"Why are we trying to convince everyone not to do drugs again?"

I guess you could say that occasional use is not a big problem for most drugs. But I wouldn't recommend it, because most people go through some vulnerable time when they could become addicted (or otherwise abuse drugs), and at that time you don't want to have the stuff in your house or a dealer friend ready to supply.

We dismiss people who join cults that sound crazy -- an alien ship coming to rescue them or something -- but I think a high percentage of people could be recruited if the cult appears at just the right time in their lives.

If you are a regular user of drugs, it's like always having the cult recruiter in your house, just waiting for the right time.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by visarga on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:48AM (#10323657)
> most people go through some vulnerable time when they could become addicted (or otherwise abuse drugs), and at that time you don't want to have the stuff in your house or a dealer friend ready to supply

Sometimes people do drugs to cope with their other problems in life. They need drugs as a reprieve. Life can be hard and people have used alcohol, pot and many other substances to create a refuge. Of course that doesn't solve the problem, but solving the problem is not always the top priority, and many times the problem has no solution. Why should we morally deny a refuge from anxiety and suffering to other people?

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by jeffdavis on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:29PM (#10324394)
Sure, they can help, too. But I wouldn't recommend it, because I have no idea which drugs would help and which would make things worse.

I'm not suggesting we deny anyone anything. I'm answering the question: "why do we try to convince people not to use drugs?".

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by qmalxp on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:02AM (#10322682)
I think it's a bit misleading to simply say "LSD is great and you should try it". It can be interesting, but also can be scary as fuck, and you should be in a good place mentally before trying it.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by astazangasta on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:02PM (#10324495)
"Snorkeling is great and you should try it," is a similar statement I might make with no qualifications or equivocation from you. Many pleasurable activities have attendant dangers that you should be aware of before engaging in them. Drugs are no different, except we surround them with the stink of moral judgment and refuse to educate people on how to use them safely.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by qmalxp on Saturday October 03, 2015 @10:38PM (#10326199)
The difference is most people snorkeling for the first time do it with an instructor who is very much interested in their well-being. I don't think the guy who sells you LSD is gonna lose sleep if you happen to develop a lifelong mental condition.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by s73v3r on Saturday October 03, 2015 @03:29PM (#10325055)
Snorkeling and psychotropic drugs are two completely different things.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by visarga on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:51AM (#10323669)
I read an article yesterday about micro-dosing LSD at a level where no hallucinations appear, but a boost in energy and creativity is felt. Like a different kind of coffee that doesn't wane after only two hours.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by ryanlol on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:58AM (#10323698)
Microdosing of psychedelics isn't very well (or at all?) researched and it's hard to tell whether what people are experiencing is a placebo or not.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Houshalter on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:00AM (#10322676)
C0nc0rdance is a scientist who makes well researched videos about various subjects, and did a few videos on the health effects of marijuana: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnNPm5cG85c

It may not be the most harmful drug, but it's certainly not harmless or non-addictive.

LSD can cause mental illness to emerge in some people. I also remember a study that gave LSD to 10 people during a religious sermon. 9 of them went on the be preachers or priests later in life. That doesn't necessarily mean it's bad. But anything with that powerful an effect on the mind is concerning.

Amphetamines certainly seem pretty cool. Especially if you have ADHD. But it definitely has side effects and potential for addiction. It's long term effects are not well studied, and a few studies I did see were concerning. E.g. brain damage in monkeys, and a group of kids taking it did worse than the control group after 3 years.

I think people should be educated on the risks and facts before they decide to take a drug. If they still want to do it, fine. But at least they know the risks. And it's not enough just to put a warning sticker on the back of it that no one reads. Even widespread education that a drug is dangerous isn't enough. Everyone knows cigarettes cause cancer, but why do new people take up smoking?

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by pantalaimon on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:02PM (#10324496)
> anything with that powerful an effect on the mind is concerning.

I find that statement absurd, anything with an effect that powerful should be cherished! Would life be desirable if it were stripped from all emotions, as they too have a powerful effect on the mind? Even if you agreed to that, it wouldn't be feasible as we are biological creatures and not pure rational beings. Denying that our biological self exists, with feelings and all, doesn't solve anything. The spiritual experience you describe is just another part of the human condition, I don't quite believe that 9 out of 10 people on LSD would become preachers, but I see how it can lead to a better understanding of religion. This doesn't require superstition, quite the opposite. When you know that those effects are caused by LSD or substances contained in Mushrooms, ferns or cacti, you don't need a higher power as an explanation for this peculiar state of mind. You might however find yourself coming to conclusions about life that other people on similar states of mind (whether induced by drugs or other means is irrelevant here) had before you, and who used the vehicle of religion to transport them.

So yes, psychedelics, as well as most drugs, should not be taken lightly, but banning them is like razing the Niagara Falls because someone might fall over the edge.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Houshalter on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:27PM (#10325456)
I believe those 9 people wasted their lives. Religion isn't remotely rational and is a plague on society. The fact that a single experience with a drug can cause people to completely devote themselves to it is terrifying.

What if it became widespread and our society became super religious? What other irrational things can it convince people of?

I don't know if they should be banned or not. I'm just saying they are not safe

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by pantalaimon on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:39PM (#10325853)
What goal is there in life other than living a happy, a good life?

Why do you condemn people that find something different to help them with that than you?

There is a difference in having a spiritual experience and merely following a ritual for the sake of the ritual.

It anything, more widespread LSD usage would make people less religious by your definition.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Houshalter on Sunday October 04, 2015 @02:00AM (#10326656)
Who says they lived a happy life? Who says they wouldn't have lived a happy life otherwise?

We don't know that. All we know is that the drug made them become obsessed with something irrational.

Would you take something like that? Would you want something like that to become widespread? Do you want a society that is far more religious and devoted to their religion?

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by c23gooey on Sunday October 04, 2015 @03:41PM (#10328542)
> We don't know that. All we know is that the drug made them become obsessed with something irrational.

Please provide a link to said study where the words you use above are quoted from.

Otherwise you making just as much assumptions as pantalaimon

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Rotten194 on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:29PM (#10325828)
That's an incredibly narrow-minded view, and I'm not a religious person either.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Houshalter on Sunday October 04, 2015 @02:03AM (#10326661)
Call me narrow minded if you like. The implications of such a drug are terrifying. Do you want a society that is far more religious? Where people are completely devoted to their religions and actually believe in them?

And on a personal level, would you want to take such a drug? Knowing it can convince you of something irrational and change your entire life path for the worse?

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by forgetsusername on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:17AM (#10323587)
>It may not be the most harmful drug, but it's certainly not harmless

I'm no advocate of the claims that marijuana is "harmless" or, as some even claim, "good for you". But harm is relative. Sitting in your chair all day is harmful. Eating half the food we do is harmful, as are most medications.

Arguing that marijuana is "not harmless" isn't much of an argument at all.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Houshalter on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:41PM (#10325503)
According to that video, it increases cancer risk at a higher rate than cigarettes, and it is very addictive to some percent of the population.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by philwelch on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:34AM (#10322614)
We're not; it's just one drug cartel trying to push out the competition. Whenever you hear drug use described as "self-medicating", you're hearing the notion that drugs like Zoloft and Ritalin are ok but drugs like marijuana and MDMA aren't.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by andrepd on Saturday October 03, 2015 @10:07AM (#10323928)
"LSD is great, and people should try it" is as dishonest and misleading and agenda-pushing as "pot makes your teeth fall off".
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by hristov on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:57AM (#10322669)
Nobody has ever done any great writing while stoned. Even Hunter S. Thompson, one of the most pro-drug writers ever, said that pot is the only drug that prevents him from doing any good work.

And no, people should not try LSD. LSD leads to a high danger of psychosis or schizophrenia, and that is no fun at all. It is better not to risk it. Just because you may have gotten lucky so far, there is no reason to invite others to take spin on the russian roulette. If you have any mental illness in your family, it is strongly advisable you steer clear, but even if you don't, it is not worth the risk.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by throwawaymonoid on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:09AM (#10323201)
I'd encourage you to re-think your views.

"Drugs" is a legal delineation, not one of substance. Like every substance you consume, amount, frequency--and sometimes intent--matter far more than molecular composition.

In regard to LSD specifically, please note that the link to schizophrenia has since been proven null, and the individuals studied were already displaying signs of the disorder. Further research in more recent years, while limited, has been unable to find any correlation between incidents of mental illness and the use of hallucinogenics.

As per cannabis... without it I'd most certainly be addicted to Rx painkillers. I like knowing that if I travel or go somewhere it's prohibited, I won't suffer crippling withdrawals. In fact, aside from the return of a dull aching pain from chronic hyper-flexion, I wouldn't notice anything other than increasingly vivid dreams caused by REM rebound. For me it's a clear choice. It allows me to function, and unlike other pain management regimens, after 7 years its minimum effective dose (MED) despite daily administration remains unchanged; if I skip a day or 6 months, my pain is not magnitudes above baseline.

I'm not here to tout the benefits of marijuana, but to explain how drugs are an indifferent tool, and just because they are harmful in one context doesn't mean we should discount their usefulness in another. Their value is relative.

Because of a substance, I can function. Because I can function, I've been able to nurture my business from 3 people to >500, and into the Fortune 1000. For others with traumatic disorders like PTSD, hallucinogenic therapy may hold promises anti-depressants have been unable to actualize. Regardless, generalizations like yours (while in good faith) prevent the regulatory changes needed to once again allow for open research.

In respect to the diversity of the human condition, I'd implore you to take a more laissez-faire approach: decide what's right for yourself, not for others.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by thrwyycombinatr on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:33PM (#10324618)
Since you used some anecdotal evidence, I felt I could provide some anecdotal stuff back.

LSD: I've tried it a handful of times. The last time resulted in a strip so strongly horrifying I nearly stole a car with people in it to escape my extreme schizophrenic trip.

Note: I've never had any symptom of it before in my life, and it doesn't run in my family. Nor do I believe I ever will. It was so extremely out of character, I know for a fact it was induced by the drug. In fact I think the dealer who gave it to my gave me a hugely high dose, which is a big danger of taking LSD from dealers.

Cannabis: It may be good for pain relief, I had stomach issues that I used it to help with for years. Then a doctor told me it could be causing my stomach pain. Look up "cannabinoid hyperemesis". It was horrifying. The worst stomach flu you could imagine that lasted for weeks, and didn't leave me for years. I don't know if it was the weed, but I stay away from it now. I've had three different doctors talk about it (in different states), and all told me they have seen big spikes in stomach problems due to weed.

So, yea. Nothings black and white. Drugs are an "arbitrary" definition (as all definitions are) for "something that affects you strongly". And anything that effects you strongly deserves a massive warning: if at all possible, don't rely on it.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by throwawaymonoid on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:32PM (#10325478)
I have no doubt your episode was induced by the drug. I also see clear indications that the lack of a safe setting and "sitter" means you set yourself up for a much higher risk of a bad experience. Sorry it was so uncomfortable for you.

As for cannabis, the condition you're referencing is exceedingly rare. In most cases the ER attendants I've known treating individuals with these symptoms have traced them back to synthetic "legal high" cannabinoid analogues, most of which are untested with an unknown toxicological profile. Their proliferation is a symptom of criminalization, and it is a burgeoning epidemic.

I can assure you your 'stomach flu' was not caused by cannabis, however there is some data to back up the link between dysphoria at high dosages and ghrelin (the precursor hormone that makes you hungry) deregulation with consistent usage. My extensive research has turned up no link between cannabis use and an altered micro-biome, but I think it's fair to say both acute and chronic usage can lead to altered/dysfunctional eating patterns. It is also well-known for causing dry mouth, which makes oral hygiene especially important if one wishes to avoid candida-related side effects (occasionally linked with GI upset).

Also worth noting, cannabis use in adolescence is correlated with a higher prevalence of anxiety disorders, and can trigger or accelerate latent conditions in those already predisposed to mental illness. It's not all fun and games, but it has a comparatively favorable side-effect profile to most similarly-indicated pharmaceuticals.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by pstuart on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:52AM (#10322776)
> LSD leads to a high danger of psychosis or schizophrenia

Citations please.

It's a powerful drug but has incredible value when used properly. If you're going to start wringing your hands over dangerous drugs, start with the killers of today: alcohol, tobacco, and prescription drugs.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by user_0001 on Saturday October 03, 2015 @09:15AM (#10323760)
Don't forget the bigger killers

* crossing the road

* driving a car

* choking on <insert any food here>

etc etc

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by hristov on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:29AM (#10322839)
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Cryptokeeper on Saturday October 03, 2015 @03:11AM (#10322941)
That article is 50 years old. Perhaps this one from 2013: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....

"21,967 respondents (13.4% weighted) reported lifetime psychedelic use. There were no significant associations between lifetime use of any psychedelics, lifetime use of specific psychedelics (LSD, psilocybin, mescaline, peyote), or past year use of LSD and increased rate of any of the mental health outcomes. Rather, in several cases psychedelic use was associated with lower rate of mental health problems."

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by thrwyycombinatr on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:35PM (#10324626)
But temporary schizophrenia is very common. Cmon guys, this is ridiculous. I've seen it so many times. It literally re-wires your brain.

And yes, temporary schizophrenia can be extremely dangerous. This is something no one can argue. I hate pedants.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by throwawaymonoid on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:16PM (#10325411)
Your brain literally re-wires itself constantly.

There's no such thing as "temporary schizophrenia." If you're referring to acute psychosis, as you seemingly experienced, then yes it's certainly a possible side effect--though never a permanent one.

Bad experiences are usually triggered by an uncomfortable setting, or a dose for which you were not prepared. I'm sorry that was your experience, but concerned your reaction doesn't add to the scientific discussion.

LSD increases glutamate and modulates the 5HTA (seratonin) subtypes, as well as having modulatory effects on D2 (dopamine) receptors--it alters conscious processes and lowers the inhibitory threshold of the action potential, allowing "new" neuronal pathways to develop. While we don't know the specific pharmacokinetic MOA, we do know it has a favorable toxicological and therapeutic profile, and that the content of one's hallucinations depend far more on the individual and the setting than the substance.

Yes, it can be dangerous. Yes, you can take steps to effectively minimize the danger like you do in every other area of your life (seatbelts? helmets?). Like anything there's a cost-benefit ratio for each individual to consider--are you willing to risk a potentially terrifying experience for a chance at novel insight?

I think that's a choice everyone should be able to make for themselves.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by MichaelGG on Saturday October 03, 2015 @03:12AM (#10322945)
Do you have the text of it? Wikipedia has a small quote which doesn't back it up:

"The 3 patients in whom an extended psychosis followed a single ingestion of LSD clearly had long standing schizophrenia..."

The page on it is here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LSD_and_schizophrenia - there doesn't seem to be any strong studies. A small increased risk is possible/likely.

On the flip side, many folks seem to feel LSD is one of the most meaningful experiences they've had in life. It seems reasonable that healthy people should seek out such an experience in a controlled, safe, environment.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @06:02AM (#10323300)
To be fair: Using hallucinogens has been one of the most positive life experiences I've done. While you say things about mental health, the previous poster is correct: It merely can make symptoms more clear, but the cause isn't linked and is often reversed. Hallucinogens also tend to have the opposite effect on depression. One strand of pot isn't nice to anxiety, but if we are honest and open about stuff, affected people can avoid it (or use minimal amounts to test, or try it in the company of a trusted friend)... you know, using information and self-knowledge to try to make wise choices.

And that was Thompson's experience with pot - in which case, he should have learned thereafter not to do pot and expect good work from himself: Others find that pot makes them more productive, and yet others find that it is good for some portions of the work, but not others. Simply because his words seem to uphold the stereotype doesn't make it any more true.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by throwawaymonoid on Saturday October 03, 2015 @06:18AM (#10323332)
While I'm a proponent, research has made a fairly solid case for THC's ability to trigger latent psychological illness. As you stated, making informed choices relative to your medical history is both critical and necessary to avoid unintended permanent consequences.

It's interesting how vastly different everyone's qualitative experiences are when the physiological states are fairly uniform... I think observing those altered processes with next-gen EEG tech may offer some illumination in our current, limited model of neuroplasticity.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Cthulhu_ on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:06AM (#10323197)
To everyone, you should read The Episode (http://www.stilldrinking.org/the-episode-part-1), a series of blog posts by Peter Welch, most famous for his 'Programming Sucks' post, in which he describes his experiences with going completely batshit insane after a week without sleep plus LSD. It's a great piece of one person's experiences with LSD use gone wrong.

edit: actually he's published it as as an ebook too, titled "And Then I Thought I Was A Fish": http://www.amazon.co.uk/And-Then-Thought-Was-Fish-ebook/dp/B...

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:48AM (#10323524)
I've not time to read a book and reply to this comment in a timely manner, however: I'd note that lack of sleep in itself can cause some pretty freaky stuff to happen to people's minds in itself. If that is the experience I'm reading about - with an overtone of LSD - I cannot hold that representative of a bad trip.

Occsionally,people do have bad trips, however, there is truth in that. For me, that goes back to making informed decisions. Legal sales from trained folks, with stableized ingredients and dosages helps with such things. Yes, a few people are gonna be stupid, but that basically happens with everything.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by digi_owl on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:43AM (#10322879)
> said that pot is the only drug that prevents him from doing any good work.

And this is where i suspect the big anti-pot push is coming from.

With alcohol you can go out for some beers after work, get buzzed, get up the next day with a nagging ache, and still come back to work.

With pot it is more likely that you go "fuck work!".

End result, pot is not good for business.

Looking across history, there is a whole mess or barely concealed agenda aimed at maintaining a workforce. Even the modern school system is perhaps put into place to produce and maintain a more useful workforce.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:51AM (#10323527)
This isn't true for me. I'm more likely to get a good night sleep and wake up well-rested, without a headache ready to go to work after a night of smoking. I'm more likely to call off work if I am feeling sick from drinking the night before: In fact, I'm more likely to simply not go out after work to drink. I can smoke some and do my household stuff in the evening, walk to a coffee shop afterwards and talk with folks, draw, read, etc, most of which is impossible when drinking. I'm gonna guess absenteeism is higher among chronic alcohol users than it is among chronic pot users, but I don't have the citation to back it up.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Bouncingsoul1 on Saturday October 03, 2015 @03:17AM (#10322954)
For me it is quite the opposite, I prefer to stay at home if I have nagging headache after having to much, on the other hand I never had such an issue with pot.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by TelmoMenezes on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:02AM (#10323428)
Bullshit. There are numerous counter-examples to this, from artists and musicians to game developers, engineers and scientists.

I suspect that the perceived correlation between smoking cannabis and being a loser is that successful cannabis smokers have a strong incentive against disclosing this habit -- they could lose their jobs, or be excluded from further opportunities. They also have more resources and possibly life experience and wisdom to protect themselves from law enforcement and the social status quo (i.e people like you who might judge them unfairly).

Of course I am not advocating cannabis use. I am advocating seeing what works for you and making up your own mind. Some people love coffee, some people don't. None of our business.

One problem I suspect that the status quo has with cannabis is that it is a type of drug that makes you more relaxed about status games. Some people describe the experience like this: it's not that you don't want to do things anymore, it's that you don't care so much about what other people think you should be doing.

But mostly, cannabis is illegal because of racism (it was associated with black people and the jazz scene when it became popular in the west) while alcohol -- a much more dangerous drug that is indeed heavily used to mask boredom -- is ok because white people were used to it, it was part of their culture.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by kalleboo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:10AM (#10323447)
> There are numerous counter-examples to this

I'm not saying the GP is correct (I'd rather see a study than "something a cartoon said"), but there are "numerous counter-examples" to everything. Pack-a-day smokers who lived to 110, high-functional alcoholics, people who lived long lives around lead, mercury and asbestos. That doesn't mean you don't want to encourage people to not try to beat the odds.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by TelmoMenezes on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:53AM (#10323679)
Tobacco smoking, alcohol abuse and exposure to lead, mercury and asbestos have been shown to have strong negative health effects by extensive studies with a lot of statistical power and grounded in theory.

This is not the case for cannabis use. The public perception of cannabis as having horrible negative health consequences comes from state propaganda, not science. Look it up yourself. But look for scientific articles, not newspaper articles.

So before you use that classical argument, you have to actually have some data that provides evidence for the substance under question being generally harmful.

Carl Sagan (one of the counter-examples) used to confront his scientist friends with this, and they were surprised to find that there is indeed very little scientific support for this view. For a while, the strongest result was that cannabis could help trigger early schizophrenia, but even this research is on shaky grounds (turns out that the population under study was highly biased).

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by TelmoMenezes on Saturday October 03, 2015 @10:20AM (#10323967)
> There is a high barrier to research about pot and other drugs such as LSD, for obvious reason. This means that while you have a gigantic corpus of data about alcohol usage, for instance, you have next to nothing to work with on pot.

Prohibition prevents scientific research, but it is not true that there isn't a lot of indirect data. One of them is cause of death at emergency rooms. While alcohol produces a large number of deaths daily, cannabis produced zero so far (in the history of modern medicine).

> Just because you don't have studies showing pot is harmful it doesn't mean pot isn't harmful. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Sure, but this applies to everything. Maybe having brown curtains in your living room increases your chances of suffering from depression. Let's make brown curtains illegal until we know more?

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Retric on Saturday October 03, 2015 @11:14AM (#10324164)
Pot has produced cancer deaths just like other forms of smoke inhalation. Incense is also harmful for similar reasons.

THC is fairly safe, inhaling smoke is stupid.

PS: As far as I know eating it is ok, but many things become harmful when you do them for 30+ years. Ex: Runniners often have knee problems over the long term.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by andrepd on Saturday October 03, 2015 @10:10AM (#10323936)
There is a high barrier to research about pot and other drugs such as LSD, for obvious reason. This means that while you have a gigantic corpus of data about alcohol usage, for instance, you have next to nothing to work with on pot.

Just because you don't have studies showing pot is harmful it doesn't mean pot isn't harmful. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by danschumann on Saturday October 03, 2015 @11:33AM (#10324222)
When I was going through the period of learning to program where every solution creates 3 more problems, the hard times, the learning, I was smoking.

I made a rule. "IF I SMOKE, I CAN ONLY PROGRAM AFTERWARDS"

IT WORKED!!!! :P

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by afarrell on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:59PM (#10322533)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_tx_fTjhBI Basically takes that same tack.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by FireBeyond on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:47AM (#10322647)
If you want to convince teenagers not to try (certain) drugs - have them watch Trainspotting and Requiem For A Dream. Emotionally punishing, both of them.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by pstuart on Saturday October 03, 2015 @01:54AM (#10322779)
Sigh. Then have them read Bukowski and have them never touch a drink again.

Edit: my brother died of a heroin overdose, so I have zero fucking tolerance for this bullshit simplistic reasoning.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by MichaelGG on Saturday October 03, 2015 @03:12AM (#10322944)
Eh Trainspotting has a decent chance of encouraging heroin use. At least that was my (apparently not too uncommon) reaction to the film. Requiem seemed too nonsensical.

And all they really do is show that you should have money and the real problems aren't the drugs but finances and society.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by mtanski on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:59PM (#10324962)
> And all they really do is show that you should have money and the real problems aren't the drugs but finances and society.

I think many socio-economists would agree with that statement.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by stuaxo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @04:31AM (#10323112)
I'm curious about how, it seemed pretty horrible what thy were going through.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by user_0001 on Saturday October 03, 2015 @09:22AM (#10323779)
"wow the fun bits look fun, as long as I don't get addicted....."

If you are a drug user, reading / watching something that others may thing would turn people away from drugs, a certain kind of drug user (perhaps more adventurous) will be thinking, "yeah I'd like to try that".

Used to be like that for me and others I knew. Case in point, all the PCP scare stories, "man gets super human strength, fights off 10 police, gets naked". I would just focus on the "gets super human strength" - yeah should get some of that.

But at the end of the day, drugs are pretty stupid. Fun. But stupid. Doesn't mean we should stop people taking them. Lots of things are stupid - really, if you think about it. Riding your bike down mountains, any of the more "extreme" sports, rock climbing. Anything with a risk that isn't necessary. But it is up to the individual to weigh the risk, the "fun" reward and decide what they want to do

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Cthulhu_ on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:11AM (#10323203)
Doubtful, the more influentiable people would be like "Oh wow I can totally get rich selling drugs as long as I don't startg using it myself!"
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by ossreality on Friday October 02, 2015 @11:58PM (#10322530)
I almost want to login to my non-throwaway/hellbanned account just to laugh at this notion.

The times I've been most curious. Most engrossed in a piece of new tech has been when I'm high. Some night, I will go home from a 9-10 hour work day and get high to relax and make dinner and then go to bed... but will wind up reading about the latest and greatest in container tech, or whatever.

The notion that pot makes you distinctly less interested is just laughable in my opinion.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by cbgb on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:14AM (#10322571)
I think that what you may be experiencing is a heightened sense of concentration toward a passion of yours that you were passionate about before you smoked pot.

However, think about children who smoke pot from an early age and don't develop the kind of curiosity that I'm sure proceeded the pot smoking you're talking about. Did you first discover your passions while you were young, impressionable, and smoking pot? Or did that come afterward, after all the initial experimentation and learning about yourself had already occurred?

I think the following quote from a NYC high school teacher better explains what I'm trying to get at:

“I hate pot. I hate it even more than hard drugs. I’ve taught high school for 25 years and I hate what marijuana does to my students. It goes beyond missing homework assignments. My students become less curious when they start smoking pot. I’ve seen it time and time again. People say pot makes you more creative, but from what I’ve seen, it narrows my students’ minds until they only reference the world in relation to the drug. They’ll say things like: “I went to the beach and got so high,” or “I went to a concert and got so high.” They start choosing their friends based on the drug. I hate when people say that it’s just experimenting. Because from what I’ve seen, it’s when my students stop experimenting.”[0]

[0] http://www.humansofnewyork.com/post/129574836736/i-hate-pot-...

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by xj9 on Saturday October 03, 2015 @05:01AM (#10323186)
Teenagers should not smoke cannabis or consume alcohol, not because it is harmful to adults, but because it is harmful to them. Teenagers should not consume any kind of mind-altering substance because it fucks their their brain development. There are very few proven negative side-effects of cannabis on healthy adults.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by girvo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:25AM (#10322592)
And for me, every time I smoke pot I become absolutely useless. Anything more difficult than watching whatever the hell happens to be on TV is nigh on impossible for me. And I don't normally watch TV! Anecdotes are fun.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by danielbln on Saturday October 03, 2015 @08:20AM (#10323594)
Nobody talks about dosage when they talk about cannabis, why is that?

For example, downing a bottle of Jack vs. having a couple of beers. Unless a severe alcoholic, no person will be good for anything after the former (health risks not even included), whereas you are not really impaired after the latter.

Dosage matters, and that's true for cannabis as well. Most people won't be very productive/active after hitting the bong or whatever, lightly vaporizing some sativa strain, different story.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by rashkov on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:23AM (#10322587)
Everyone reacts differently to different substances, etc etc, but perhaps what you're describing is a little different from chronic, every-day smoking? Smoking pot occasionally can make anything more fun, but over time it seems like it would desensitize you to novelty.

Your mileage may vary of course. I've met some brilliant and highly successful people who smoke every day to no ill effect.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by Broken_Hippo on Saturday October 03, 2015 @07:54AM (#10323536)
That's the thing - most people that regularly smoke blend seamlessly into society. It isn't that we are talking smoking joints as cigarettes. What most people refer to as smoking is more equivelent to binge drinking rather than a glass of wine with lunch and/or dinner.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by draw_down on Saturday October 03, 2015 @11:42AM (#10324261)
My favorite part about this quote is that it comes from a television show.
Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by mistercow on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:02AM (#10322544)
> pot makes you feel fine with being bored

The problem with that is that it's also super not backed up by data.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by tonyarkles on Saturday October 03, 2015 @12:34AM (#10322611)
Anecdote, data, yadda yadda. This is precisely why pot has a very infrequent place in my life. In my misspent youth, I came to the same realization: when I was smoking weed frequently, I had no problem just doing nothing with my life.

Edit: on the flip side, I have come up with some really cool solutions to problems after having a bit. But it'll never be a frequent thing for me again, precisely because of the probability of just getting back to the "OK with not doing anything" state.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by mistercow on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:43AM (#10332539)
>Anecdote, data, yadda yadda.

Sorry, are you waving away the comparative value of hard data and personal experience?

> when I was smoking weed frequently, I had no problem just doing nothing with my life

Sounds like pot isn't for really you then. I'd even be OK with a statement like "A danger of pot is that some people find it makes them OK with being bored".

But making sweeping generalizations that don't apply to everybody (and haven't even been shown to apply to most or many people) is exactly what is wrong with anti-drug propaganda. First off it's bad because, you know, lying is wrong. Secondly, it destroys your credibility with anyone who decides to see for themselves, and doesn't have anything close to the experience you described.

And with drugs like cocaine, meth and heroin out there, it's probably a good idea for kids to have someone with a little credibility to turn to when they want to know what's up.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by tonyarkles on Monday October 05, 2015 @12:08PM (#10332728)
>> Anecdote, data, yadda yadda.

> Sorry, are you waving away the comparative value of hard data and personal experience?

Absolutely! Not because I don't see value in data, but because my personal experience is all I have to go from. A cursory lit review didn't come up with any hard data for or against that specific proposition (that marijuana makes you ok with being bored). The closest I found was:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2723942/

Which suggests that among their N=634 marijuana users, ~25% reported boredom as a motivation for smoking.

I absolutely agree that we should have credible data to use both for education and policy making! The unfortunate part of our current legal situation is that it's incredibly difficult to study those things directly.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by static_noise on Saturday October 03, 2015 @02:32AM (#10322847)
> it'll never be a frequent thing for me again

This is how drugs are taken best: Not frequent.

Re:DARE: The Anti-Drug Program That Never Actually Worked by mistercow on Monday October 05, 2015 @11:37AM (#10332499)
Sorry, that's just still a huge overgeneralization. If you are deriving significant therapeutic benefit from a drug, this statement is completely false.