Also, they likely violate EULAs (the A is for agreement) for non-pre-release hardware all the time. Not that big a difference.
I would not condone redistributing copies of software or significant portions thereof in a way which violates the license, whether it be a copyleft license or a commercial license. If apple distributed gerber files for the PCB of the new hardware device, or original CAD schematics it uses to manufacture parts, under some license, I'd also want the terms of the distribution of that to be respected.
But this is something of a different nature. It's taking hardware apart and seeing what's inside and sharing that researched information rather freely on the internet. This is not a copy of source code or hardware schematic. This is learned information. It's not vandalism - there is no expectation that any dev kits be returned, each recipient can use theirs exclusively. This is something everyone everywhere should always have the right to do. And iFixit does, more or less.
What sucks is that Apple can retaliate by exerting their complete and arbitrary control over what software millions of people are permitted to run on their own devices. That's really messed up. This is just one more great example, in case you don't understand yet.
Apple didn't have problem with them tearing down other Apple devices.
And iFixit got the device because the sign the agreement not to publish the information before it hit the market.
It's not about reverse engineering knowledge. It's about breaking the agreement, which is what iFixit is asking others not to do when using their API.
> This is something everyone everywhere should always have the right to do. And iFixit does, more or less.
Most people get their devices by purchasing them when they are released. iFixit have been given the enormous privilege of being sent a developer unit.
> What sucks is that Apple can retaliate by exerting their complete and arbitrary control over what software millions of people are permitted to run on their own devices.
Apple aren't "retaliating". iFixit broke the developer terms. Their developer account was thus suspended. That developer account happened to contain their app.
I don't know about the downvotes. I upvoted you to try to compensate.
I think people are misunderstanding what happened here, maybe thinking that Apple is punishing them for disassembling retail hardware or something.
I assume that most people were taught things like "Two wrongs don't make a right", or some other Aesopian adage at some point in their lives to similar effect.
Just because they violated Apple's NDA/EULA terms does not entitle anyone else to violate theirs.
Also, your last statement makes absolutely no sense. "Just because they violated Apple's NDA/EULA terms does not entitle anyone else to violate theirs". Wut?
What else can Apple do? Send the device teardown Police?
They never acted like they did not violate the terms of the agreement, or that Apple did some injustice. I don't see the hypocrisy. Even if they were hypocritical, it is an overrated vice. Asking people to honour their agreement does not become wrong just because they are hypocrites.
I think the idea here is that being able to fix your own devices rather than put them in a landfill is a moral stance and such rules deserve to be broken.
Then Ifixit should have waited until it's available on the market then did the tear down. They consumed a valuable and limited resource that is known as the dev kit. A dev kit, which I may remind you, could have ended up in the hands of an actual developer and put to real use. Instead, they broke the rules and tore down a product that's not on the market yet.
They got off easy, and anyone who attempts to argue that they are in the right simply have not done their homework regarding the matter.
Sure iFixit provides a great service. I happily support them by buying tools and parts from them. "Public service" simply isn't a valid reason for this teardown. It was regrettably thoughtless of them to do this just because they can.
That's not valid justification for what occurred at all. They broke the rules, and Apple gave them what many consider a light punishment.
Ifixit has learned a valuable lesson for a cheap price. This was not ok.
If you start going down the rabbit hole of "You violated their license terms so I'm going to violate your license terms" then things would fall apart very quickly. Is it morally OK to pirate Justin Bieber's music because he faced drugs charges? Is it reasonable to shoplift from Walmart because they broke a contract with a supplier?
iFixit broke their contact with Apple, and for that they should (and apparently have) faced repurcussions. That doesn't give anyone the moral right not to respect the license they publish their app source code under (by putting ads on it or selling it).
"In the meantime, we will continue to support our Android app" they say. Not subtle at all.
:)
The vindictive attitude.
They blatantly violated the agreement for obtaining the pre-release hardware, and then expect people to honor their own license terms?
IMHO, they are extremely lucky the worst thing that happened was their developer account getting pulled.
[Edited for clarity after feedback]