I think most people are aware there could be cheating, but not on the scale being claimed. I don't think it's unreasonable to have placed a bit of trust in the number.
Maybe you're an expert in ICEs and this was obvious to you. Would you notice if your cell phone charger was actually pulling 10 amps out of the wall instead of the 1 it was rated for? What about if your non-GMO strawberries were actually created in a lab? Your organic beef injected with hormones?
The whole point of having these standards is so that consumers can rely on them and don't have to independently analyze everything they buy themselves.
Did you test your water for drugs this morning?
Did you check them yesterday?
We all live at certain layers of abstraction.
probably not
http://rockyroadblog.com/caveat-emptor-vetting-mpg-claims-30...
The same transaction costs argument for regulatory disclosure apply to the quality of such disclosure as well. Ever try reading nutritional labels? It goes on and on...has very little to do with one particular instance.
That being said, a auto is a capital good and a substantial purchase and investing some time to understand the buying process is both economic and sensible. so in this case the faux shock/outrage seems particularly misplaced...as the arguments for ignorance are weak indeed.
Maybe /user/emp_zealoth had petrol cars in mind? I've not personally seen a petrol (non hybrid) car consuming less than 7l/100km and when I had one it was 10l/100km (8 if I was lucky) and it was small Peugeot 306.
To rant even more.. IMHO, those fuel consumption tests are a total fraud. Look at new diesel sedans, local dealer declares that huge VW Passat TDI uses 4l/100km, or Skoda Octavia TDI (GreenLine or something) uses 3.1l/100km. Maybe it's true when you're driving at 90km/h with wind blowing in your tail and slight downhill.
Apart from Up, the other two models you listed are for the above-average-middle-class-people, so to speak, at least in Europe. Most of the car-owners in Europe drive hatchbacks like Opel Corsa (average weight 1200 kg) or Skoda Fabia (average weight 1100 kg).
Usually there are 2 weights: unladen weight and maximum weight. I've heard about some third weight which is between the unladen and maximum weights, something like a car's weight with full tank and a driver, but don't quote me on this.
Probably you have the maximum weight listed. My Skoda Fabia (Audi Q3 equivalent) has maximum weight of 1680kg and unladen weight of 1200kg. I refuse to believe that VW Up is heavier than the Skoda Fabia.
AFAIK, minivans have quite big weight on their papers, but empty minivan can't weigh 3000kg, which is only possible if it's loaded.
My old '89 Chevy S-10 weighed just over 1700 pounds (770 kg) empty. At 55 MPH (90 kph) on the freeway (back when that was still the limit), it got about 30 MPG (13 km/l / 7.7l/100km). OK, not great mileage, but what do you want for 80s US car tech :-)
For safety reasons, or whatever, they don't make mini trucks in the US any more. I did a double take on a new Dodge "Dakota" in the store parking lot the other day. It looked just like a full size pickup as far as I could see.
VW Up!: curb weight 920 kg, max total weight 1290 kg.
Audi Q3: curb weight 1460 kg, max total weight 1980 kg.
Audi Q5: curb weight 1935 kg, max total weight 2460 kg.
So, modern passengers are very heavy...
Audi claims 22mpg city, 32mpg highway and 26mpg combined.
What I see is 24mpg city, 31mpg highway and 26mpg combined; I don't drive especially slow either. FWIW, I factory ordered a manual transmission so that may make a difference.
I'm skeptical of cars that claim crazy high MPG ratings and performance cars claiming good MPG numbers, but for a standard car I do expect the numbers to be achievable. I've gone through a lot of cars over the years and I've gotten very close to the published numbers on all but one (Cadillac CTS).
After the VW news I'm rather happy I went with petrol. Actually I never gave diesel a thought because Audi doesn't sell A3 or A4 diesels in the US (at least dealers don't have them and the website doesn't show them).
If you want to talk about "believable," start from basic physics and calculate the best possible fuel efficiency that a car could be expected to deliver. Even taking into account available materials, fuels, and engines, the answer is way better than what regulations currently require.
A lot of the expected gains will come from taking known "custom" solutions and scaling them up to mass market--like greater use of aluminum, and ultimately, composites.
So you are telling me that my actual, measured fuel consumption numbers of 4.25l/100km on flat highways in the US South are impossible? I have a diesel Passat (yes, one of the NOx Boxes :P) and can get from Dallas, TX to Pensacola, FL (650 mi) without refueling and with a decent reserve (~2 gallons) still in the tank.
What they do is wild speculation and possibly a smear campaign because people care more about the fuel economy (their own money) than CO2 emissions.
It is interesting that this (some) data is provided but how it is presented does not make it look very credible.
Therefore any claim about CO2 emissions equates to a claim about fuel consumption.
The problem is that these findings do not reflect my anecdotal experience.
I have two recent measurements. About 500 km round trip and small trips inside the city.
This is accordingly about 17% and 21% increase (and it was in the same region for the older model of the same car).
Sorry, I did not include the make and model of the car because I do not want to leak too much personal information but it is nowhere close to the claimed difference.
Even more the round trip was mostly on the highway and included small city part (let say about 20 km). This differs from the official test cycle.
Also the city traffic includes high elevation differences and very bad slow traffic with constant stopping.
Also the car was more occupied in both cases (official tests consider about 70 kg driver and 7 kg luggage).
This means that in more fair test the results should be even more close to the official numbers.
So what could explain this?
I do not know as we do not see the fuel economy numbers.
Perhaps during the official tests the car is actually stationary and can not take enough air and the burning is not that efficient but a good exhaust filter hides this problem?
What is also strange is the difference between BMW 3rd series and 5th series because both use the same engines (and also some Renault models do use BMW engines but it do not know about Megane).
I calculated the fuel consumption and CO2 ratio for several models and it is about the same (as expected).
I also calculated weight to CO2 ratio for similar engines over few series and this gave also very similar results. As the different series look quite similar these days then I would assume that they also have quite similar aerodynamics.
It looks to me that the following is entered (I have not used the app) by the users.
Objective data:
Date of fuelling,
Current odometer value,
Amount and price of fuel.
Type of tires (summer/winter) [should be mostly objective]
Subjective data: Driving style used (Moderate, Normal, Fast),
Roads driven (Motor-way, City, Country roads)
For roads driven all the options could be selected and are then doubly reported in the detailed statistics.This means that there is no objective acceleration and speed profile and also elevation difference data is missing (is not collected).
To illustrate this I will compare two different entries for BMW 3er 320d touring efficient dynamic
1) http://www.spritmonitor.de/en/detail/595885.html?cdetail=1 (2012, 120 kW, 4,14 l/100km) 2) http://www.spritmonitor.de/en/detail/672858.html?cdetail=1 (2011, 120 kW, 5,54 l/100km)
As both cars have the same power, I assume that they are the same model.
The consumption difference is 33%!
Driver one believes that driving style has been mostly moderate and driver two believes that driving style has mostly been normal.
Edit: I think that it illustrates that it is possible to drive this car close to its spec but it also easy to have more courageous driving style.
Cars keep getting bigger and heavier. The current Golf -- nominally a compact car -- is half a meter longer (at least 4.25m) than the first one and half a ton heavier (at least 1.2t).
Whoever actaully believed the fuel consumption figures is a fool. You cant have a 1,5t of a car and expect it to use only 5l/100km. That's a good rate for a goddamn motorbike (450ccm,one piston, dont exceed 90 km/h and you might reach 4,5l/100km) Its one fifth of the mass...