News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by phaemon on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:56PM (#10283816)
The newspaper article is really exaggerating this report. Note how few actual quotes there are and how many "in other words". Read the report for yourself at:

http://www.broadbandcommission.org/Documents/reports/bb-wg-g...

It's mainly describing the current state of things, not advocating any specific solutions. The one mention of licensing is one bullet point in a chapter, not any kind of main focus. Half the actual suggestions are things that people are mentioning in these comments as alternatives.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by vilda on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:31PM (#10284150)
The report is exaggerating. That's expected and not surprising.

Groups within UN are fighting for funding. You won't get funded if the problem you aim for does not receive attention. It won't receive attention unless it's shoking in some way. That's why's there "pandemic proportion", "staggering number", "sheer volume"--not exactly scientific terminology.

The "report" should be called a "proposal".

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by ss93 on Saturday September 26, 2015 @04:20PM (#10284298)
> The newspaper article is really exaggerating this report.

You should also note the author of that washington post article is a chronic SJW. I was suspicious when I saw the articles under "Liked that? Try these" all fitted the same narrative. Then I discovered they were all written by Caitlin Dewey. That probably explains the over exaggeration.

Also this is relevant http://www.frontpagemag.com/point/259402/why-washington-post...

I think most SJW journalists are motivated simply by clicks. The more they complain about injustices the more trolls will say hurtful things on purpose, eg the wanting to rape women on twitter comments in the other article she wrote.

People need to remember the age old "don't feed the trolls". Grow a spine, without it you're going to live an awfully offended life.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jwess on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:06PM (#10283616)
According to the article, "the UN believes that online platforms should be (a) generally responsible for the actions of their users and (b) specifically responsible for making sure those people aren’t harassers."

Many websites already have problems with flippant takedown notices through the DMCA. This article leads me to believe that the UN wants to apply a similar process to eliminate "harassment", which is a fairly nebulous term. The benefits of this proposal seem minuscule, while the costs of making "online platforms generally responsible for the actions of their users" would be enormous. Why would anyone think this is a good idea?

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by Rusky on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:30PM (#10283707)
Points a and b in that quote actually sound eminently reasonable to me. Online forums already have moderators to make sure discussion stays civil, and it sounds like a good idea to include "prevent people from organizing stalking and SWATting campaigns" in that.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by radu_floricica on Saturday September 26, 2015 @04:10PM (#10284271)
The problem isn't if it's a good idea to moderate forums. Problem is when it becomes a liability not to. The possibility of fines, lawsuits or god forbid prison time can have the kind of chilling effects we can't even imagine.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by Rusky on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:29PM (#10284943)
No, the problem is whether to moderate forums- it's not happening and when people try to come up with codes of conduct so they can moderate better, there's a huge outcry.

It would be fine if we had better moderation in more places, even without any laws. But even that's not happening.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by oldmanjay on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:44PM (#10284980)
That huge outcry isn't going to go away no matter how patiently a censor explains that censorship is good for everyone
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by choward on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:29PM (#10283705)
Some people just don't understand software. They treat it as if it were something physical. For example, if I own a bar it is my responsibility to make sure my customers don't get too crazy and to make sure underage people don't drink. This law is relatively enforceable.

You can't apply this kind of thinking to the Internet. Software isn't a bar for many reasons. You can duplicate software trivially. You can't possibly monitor every copy of that software. For example, a site like reddit is open source (for the most part I think). So in theory anyone could just host their own reddit (or any other software). There are many open source web apps that you can easily deploy your own copy of today. Which brings me to my next point.

Where do you draw the line? Web sites are responsible for content their users post. Are web hosting companies responsible for the sites their customers post and therefore responsible for the comments too? What about ISPs? They let the data through. Shouldn't they also be monitoring it? What about hardware manufactures? They are letting the web hosting company run "bad" web sites.

If someone does something illegal on the Internet investigate it and blame the user. It's really as simple as that.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by Rusky on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:36PM (#10284962)
We have the exact same line-drawing question in the real world. All kind of infrastructure and different levels over ownership go into a place like a bar, but that doesn't mean the bar owner isn't responsible.

There is a similarly clear difference between an ISP (how the customer gets to the bar), a web host (the landlord, maybe), and the website itself (the bar).

On the other hand, investigating whether someone committed a crime is a little bit different online vs in the real world. Part of what websites could do is make it easier to run those investigations by making reporting easier- Twitter reporting, for example, is relatively hostile to people trying to report bad behavior.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @12:44PM (#10283551)
An interesting analysis:

https://medium.com/@KingFrostFive/citation-games-by-the-unit...

Using the metric of removing duplicate citations, not counting broken links, those with little to no effort shown for those missing links (as in, not even bothering to check the website), and removing anything that didn’t seem to exist, only 64% remained.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by danso on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:15PM (#10283902)
Not so long ago, we learned that the U.N. is a world-saving organization that can't even pay its own interns. Not because it thought was morally OK to not pay, but because they just didn't want to do the paperwork and rulemaking to offer their interns a pittance. Ignoring the likely possibility that this paper was partly compiled by the kind of work you get from unpaid laborers...I doubt that an institution that can't do the easy, moral thing for its most vulnerable employees is the type of institution that has the patience and attention to detail to double-check its own footnotes.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by leeleelee on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:28PM (#10283954)
The concept is a little ridiculous. First, there is this link which actually shows that men receive more online bullying than women do:

http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/01/the-darkest-...

Second of all, the concept of policing every piece of content that appears on social media is also ridiculous. With this line of thinking, why stop at just social media?

Our e-mails, and in fact anything that can be deemed as messaging/communication of some sort should also be monitored. Sending a private google hangout message, a private facebook message, etc.

The policing of content should also pertain to individual websites, news organizations like the washington post (before any article is published, a government official should have to approve it), and perhaps we should even be forced to allow random inspections by the government in our houses to prevent domestic violence.

Obviously this concept is completely ridiculous, and I think the general public will agree.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by stared on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:05PM (#10283856)
I think that in a few years we get a browser add-on which automatically all online harassments (at some cost of silencing false positives, as always). But then each person will be able to set their threshold, depending on one's sensitivity.

Global censorship actions (and especially be people not understanding Internet... or even worse - wanting to make the information flow top-down) are putting much greater burden... and risk.

While I don't want to downplay the online harassment, I (for a number of years) used Internet as the only tool to escape from it. (Online it is much easier to choose a place one is comfortable in.)

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by golemotron on Saturday September 26, 2015 @09:30PM (#10285081)
I think the neologism "cyber-violence" is incredibly loaded terminology. They need to be called out on it.

Violence according the dictionary is "behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something."

There is no physical force over the internet. Being subject to harassment is not violence.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by pluma on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @09:54AM (#10303939)
The problem is that "violence" isn't the subject matter in the first place. The subject is abusive behaviour. Abusive behaviour can involve physical violence but it can also involve things that aren't physical (e.g. threats of violence) or that are physical but not strictly violent (e.g. inappropriate touching).

But "cyber-abuse" makes it sound like we're talking about spam and virus attacks, so there's no useful term to slap "cyber" onto and call it a day. Not that that's a good way to name these problems in the first place.

"Cyber" bullying is just bullying. "Cyber" harassment is just harassment. Whether you do it face to face in person, remotely via phone or from the other side of the world using the Internet is not a useful distinction.

Of course "the other side" (not the actual victims, just those speaking on their behalf or portraying themselves as victims in order to suppress criticism) isn't really helping by crying wolf and spreading the idea that every single utterance in the world suddenly needs trigger warnings and gender neutral (or reverse gendered) language. Sometimes a cigar isn't a rape tool of the patriarchy.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by ZoeZoeBee on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:24PM (#10283941)
I'm quite surprised at the number of users calling for censorship on <u>Hacker News</u>....
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by geofft on Saturday September 26, 2015 @09:29PM (#10285076)
Hackers have been wanting to "censor" the internet since September 1993: not to enforce top-down rules, but to keep it a group of people (hopefully all people, eventually) who respect social convention and respect each other. The group that thinks it's a free-for-all without rules is a late-coming one trying to claim the mantle of hackerdom. And in many cases, as with ESR's de-facto takeover of the Jargon File, they've succeeded in presenting themselves as the original hackers.

Don't be fooled. The technical design of the Internet and its serious non-resilience to spam, malware, and other various opportunists (because we all trusted that Internet users were reasonable people) should show you that none of this was in the original vision. "Be conservative in what you send, and liberal in what you accept from others" worked because everyone respected that without enforcement, and there was no crowd demanding the right to be liberal in what they sent.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by wingless on Saturday September 26, 2015 @06:50PM (#10284709)
It's a cult called Social Justice Warriors. Pretty much most of San Fran is brainwashed by them.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by xacaxulu on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:29PM (#10283961)
Amongst other things, the UN has some extremely dangerous leftist (like farrrrr left) tendencies, bordering on dystopian nanny-statist ideas. It's almost considered a cabal in political circles that I've worked in.

Christopher Hitchens gave a brilliant speech on why censorship should not be allowed called the Tyranny of Censorship.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcJxN1VlcuA

Context: I've done UNDP security work in Afghanistan and worked at various US Embassies abroad.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by grej on Saturday September 26, 2015 @04:49PM (#10284386)
“The respect for and security of girls and women must at all times be front and center,” the report reads...

(Except when we're selecting Saudi Arabia to chair our Human Rights Council: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/anger-after-saudi-ar...)

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by devit on Saturday September 26, 2015 @12:56PM (#10283590)
Why "Future"? It's the present.

None of the most popular websites supports free speech, in the sense that they will not censor anything legal for them to distribute.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by moron4hire on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:44PM (#10283766)
Child pornography is not free speech. Free speech is not "say whatever you want."
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:59PM (#10283829)
I'm not sure parent was referring to pornography, but to countless examples of sites like Facebook, Twitter, Reddit censoring information that they find inconvenient (e.g. the fappening, r/fatpeoplehate, etc.).

> Free speech is not "say whatever you want."

Parent clearly defines "free speech" as "they will not censor anything legal", which the websites above unfortunately don't follow.

> Child pornography is not free speech.

Ironically, in many jurisdictions "child pornography" includes virtual child pornography and cartoons, which any sensible person would say should be free (we can see movies depicting children getting murdered, people getting decapitated and women getting raped, but not of 17 year olds having sex?!?)

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by RaleyField on Saturday September 26, 2015 @09:07PM (#10285029)
> Reddit censoring information that they find inconvenient (e.g. the fappening, r/fatpeoplehate, etc.)

Calling it information is being generous. As a private entity they simply don't have to suffer that speech. Fappening is probably illegal, and even if it were not it would be an acceptable courtesy call to remove it. Fatpeoplehate was about moderators harassing employees of imgur.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tiglathphilizar on Sunday September 27, 2015 @10:45AM (#10286661)
Free speech is just that FREE even if others consider what a individual says distasteful.If it wasn't for FREE Speech there would have been no civil rights movement.

David Finkelhor, a sociologist who directs the Crimes Against Children Research Center at the University of New Hampshire, sees the moral weight of the law , but not the empirical proof. “The evidence doesn’t yet tell us to what extent the experience of being a pornography victim aggravates the experience of the sexual abuse itself. How do you separate it out?”. What the law says is equivalent to aying voodoo is real. No one has to actually commit a crime they just have a look at an image or have a thought and they are guilty of the crime. A person that observes a digital image that has no form or life then through osmosis gives those images or objects a legal force, a power, is practicing voo-doo. To make things easy judges have allowed government prosecutors use of those unseen images in a computer file that have nor hold no power to communicate in the courtroom. Before long, the people are ensnared by the compulsion to give power to a thing of their own definition. www.truthmovement.us

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by bruceb on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:55PM (#10283809)
Child pornography is not quite the same as saying something. You could say you support child pornography and create stories about it. Just not create it with actual children.

Yes free speech is "say whatever you want"

What do you think it should be?

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by mtgx on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:20PM (#10283667)
I hope large tech companies like Google, Facebook and Twitter are happy now. They started this. They were warned that if they "build the infrastructure" for censorship - even for the most heinous of crimes - more requests will come for much more trivial stuff. Because it's easy to ask it of them once they've proven it can be done.

The same will be true of backdoors. As soon as they start enabling backdoors in China or India or Russia, you can bet not just the U.S. will want them enabled, but many other countries, and they'll all have various reasons for asking for them.

This is why, at least with the backdoor issue, they need to be pro-active, and start building end-to-end encryption into their services and products now, so they can actually say later on that they "can't" give access to the private communications of their users.

If they would've done this years ago, like pre-Snowden revelations, Russia and China (and soon EU) would've had fewer excuses to "worry about national security and privacy" and then ask them to build local data centers, costing them billions.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by moron4hire on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:43PM (#10283761)
This is so easy. Let the market decide. If such censorship is so fucking great, let a new startup create a censored social network and see if all the downtrodden people of the world flock to it, or see if they prefer to stick with the rest of the world in the places where they may speak freely about their own pet issues.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:52PM (#10283796)
Last I checked, Facebook wasn't exactly a bastion of free speech. It seems like the market has indeed spoken, though I'd personally be very wary of ascribing any moral judgments from macro-level market transactions -- especially given that in practice we live in highly complicated mixed market societies, and not anything resembling laissez-faire.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by rdlecler1 on Saturday September 26, 2015 @12:56PM (#10283589)
Policy makers consider the benefits, but not the costs. If we now need licensing and content monitoring this protects incumbents because only they have the resources to actually handle this, in the end we end up with a few big organizations and the. Surprise suprise we try to regulate them because they are too big.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by littletimmy on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:20PM (#10283672)
Now this, is bullshit. We cannot sacrifice every little freedom we have in the name of security.

I might get downvoted to hell for saying this, but women have to learn to be comfortable with some degree of harassment if the only alternative is to convert the internet into some limited speech zone.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:24PM (#10283688)
> women have to learn to be comfortable

I'm a bit reluctant to generalize like this... I think it's mainly a (relatively) small group of people (women and men) that are pushing this agenda to suit their other interests, using "women" simply as an excuse that people can easily emotionally identify with. None of the women I know are bothered by this kind of "violence".

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by pluma on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @10:01AM (#10303988)
The particularly nefarious aspect of this is that they try abuse the feminist label for credibility and then victimise themselves to avoid criticism. To paraphrase "you shouldn't treat women as if they are more vulnerable/inferior but you can't criticise me because I'm a woman and any criticism by you is sexist even if you are a woman yourself".
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by mnkypete on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:25PM (#10283692)
Because there is only two possibilities? I don't think it should be necessary (or desirable) to get comfortable with harassment... It should neither be necessary to cross-check EVERY single post or comment someone writes, I personally see A LOT of middle ground between these two options ... One could think of:

- Calling out harassment / reporting it

- A better education regarding stuff like that (yes, this is an offline-first problem, only amplified trough anonymity)

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by Spivak on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:56PM (#10283818)
I think the middle ground is letting each platform self-moderate, and let users decide where they want to post. If you want to be anonymous and filter absolutely nothing then you can, if you want to aggressively moderate hate speech then go for it.

If government gets involved then its likely going to be all or nothing.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DannoHung on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:08PM (#10283864)
I honestly wonder if people would be so dismissive of this if they were subjected to the same levels of harassment that some people are getting.

I think that'd actually be interesting in the way that Hitchens allowed himself to be waterboarded to see if it was really all that bad. Y'know? Put up or shut up.

But not the scaredy cat way that Hitchens did it with a safeword and all. You'd have to commit to it.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by zanny on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:11PM (#10284098)
Can you not just block harassers on facebook? I never use the thing (or Twitter) so I have no idea, but I cannot imagine such services becoming popular without an ignore list.

The other alternative is that famous people are being harassed. In which case... well... that happens to famous people in real life too. It doesn't matter if you are online, once you have fame, your life is going to be harassment anywhere. You just need to make a sudonym personal account and not present yourself publicly on forums like facebook or twitter, and only share your new handles with people you trust.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DannoHung on Saturday September 26, 2015 @07:13PM (#10284785)
What you're missing is that the sort of harassment in question isn't nasty names and unwanted messages on Facebook, it's using every piece of available information to stalk and threaten the physical safety of the people in question. To the point of finding out where people live and following everyone they know personally who has a social media presence and posting things like, "Jane is at the bar downtown tonight, I hope someone kills that slut."

Celebrities deal with this sort of thing by hiring bodyguards and other personal security teams. An average person cannot have that kind of protection.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by 13thLetter on Wednesday September 30, 2015 @03:35PM (#10306504)
> I honestly wonder if people would be so dismissive of this if they were subjected to the same levels of harassment that some people are getting.

As the Pew link posted earlier pointed out, men get harassed more than women on the internet. So, looks like the answer is yes.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by bruceb on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:38PM (#10283742)
This is the attitude that is frustrating. Should the net be free of censorship? Of course.

But the dismissive attitude of some of the absolute vile garbage that is online is annoying. It isn't "some degree of harassment" it is god awful. Easy to be dismissive when you are not subject of something. Women by far are the target. A tad more empathy instead of dismissing something with the attitude their complaints are some needlessly whining

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:53PM (#10283800)
> Women by far are the target.

That is actually not true, see for example:

http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/06/01/the-darkest-...

By perpetuating this false stereotype, you're doing more harm to gender equality than harassment does. Online harassment can be bad - I've suffered it myself - but at least it's fairly equal in harming everyone.

The stereotype that men are harassers and women are victims arises because there are a few famous women that have been harassed very publicly. Why have there been more famous cases of women than men, when surveys do not find a large gender difference in actual harassment? I suspect it's that very stereotype of women as victims. It's an easy narrative to fall into, as you are doing right here.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by bruceb on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:59PM (#10283827)
How does this link prove your point?

Doesn't measure the intensity nor does it go in to general atmosphere of hate. Having post after post about "fat chicks" that is not specifically aimed at you can still be incredible painful.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:04PM (#10283854)
The very first chart shows women are not the "by far" targets of online harassment. Look at the numbers.

Anecdotes like "posts about fat chicks" are not convincing. There are plenty of anecdotes going both ways.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:12PM (#10283886)
Can I just check: Are you saying "this happens to everyone, so it's okay"? Or "this happens to everyone, and it's not okay"?

If it's the latter I agree. A bunch of people working in open source receive death threats and considerable levels of harassment. That kind of stuff needs to stop, no matter who it's aimed at.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:14PM (#10283897)
Of course it's not ok - I said it was bad, and that I suffered from it myself.

All I am saying is that gendering this issue, when the data shows it is actually something not limited or even focused on one gender, is incorrect, unhelpful, and sexist.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:31PM (#10283969)
> Of course it's not ok

You think "of course", I think "of course", but there are people in this thread saying it's not a problem.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by pkinsky on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:56PM (#10284055)
I know, think about the kind of fedora wearing, basement dwelling neckbeard loser that makes posts attacking entire genders! /sarcasm
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:26PM (#10284137)
Adding a "/sarcasm" after hurtful words doesn't make it ok.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by pkinsky on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:48PM (#10284203)
Sorry, I'm trying to point out that gendered harassment targeting men is very common online. I've edited my post for clarity.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @04:31PM (#10284330)
I understand, but the risk is that the sarcasm you used is in fact used online in a hurtful way. It can mean either what you did, or be used to intentionally ridicule people.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by vezzy-fnord on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:08PM (#10283870)
To back up littletimmy's point, I very much as a male have been the subject of it. I was persistently and relentlessly trolled for well over a year in some of the online communities I frequented when I was younger, and it has had an effect on me. I would dare say a somewhat positive one, in that it fueled a certain level of misanthropy and cynicism that influenced me to educate myself on the human condition and thus read on subjects that would nominally be considered outside my age group. I have thankfully mellowed out quite a bit since then, and none of this excuses the original actions, but it's not all grim.

And, conversely, the Internet is not all rosy. The fact of the matter is we've opened up a real Pandora's box. This is the first time in human history we've enabled people to really be bombarded by public opinion in instant, rapid numbers at every moment they express a viewpoint. It's the first time the marketplace of ideas is out there in its true colors. Humans simply aren't used to this. It's perfectly normal that a lot will break down at the immense cognitive overload.

However, one thing annoys me. The idea that this is purely a women's issue, and how it's presented as a culture war over gender and feminism. In fact, this is a very recent development, and it seems to me that the zeitgeist on the subject changes cyclically. It used to be trolling, and it was acknowledged it happened to everyone. Don't feed the trolls, don't share public info on the Internet. But then, as social media totally subverted that, it became "cyberbullying". And though it was still acknowledged it occurred to all, it became a matter of imminent policy decision. Now, it has gone further off the edge. It's no longer trolling or cyberbullying, it's harassment and it has suddenly been morphed into an identity politics issue. What tripe.

I expect that soon this will change, of course. Some other neologism or term with a corresponding narrative will usurp the current gender feminist understanding. That's how it appears to work, observing prior historical precedent.

The way I see it, there's two real options: a) Humans must adapt to this new circumstance and learn to be more resilient in the face of a new reality, one where they are under constant global supervision for their words, or b) We must lower our dependence on the Internet and have decent analog/low-tech fallbacks to how our societal institutions operate instead of marching in full digital for everything. The latter, quite clearly will not happen. This leaves us with a).

Regulatory decisions will not work. The regulatory bodies do not understand the problem. I don't think any of us do. We have to learn to deal with the revolution we have started, as there's no reversing it.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by oldmanjay on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:49PM (#10284992)
Everything you said mirrors my thoughts. I may get a little downvoted but whatever, well said.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by rayiner on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:46PM (#10283779)
As a society we have the prerogative to balance values like freedom from harassment and free speech. I fall strongly in favor of free speech myself, but nobody has to learn to get comfortable with something they find objectionable. Democracy means that people get to live in the society they want to live in.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by bediger4000 on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:55PM (#10283811)
nobody has to learn to get comfortable with something they find objectionable

Can you elaborate on this a bit? For instance, what about Kim Davis? Or extending Kim Davis' claims only a very little, those Mennonites and Quakers who pay only 48% of their Federal Income Tax because their religion makes them very uncomforable with the 52% of federal spending that goes to Department of Defense. And yes, I may have the exact percentage wrong, don't pick nits.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:17PM (#10283907)
Not to nitpick, but

> Democracy means that people get to live in the society they want to live in.

is not true. It means they have a say, but we don't always get what we want. We might all not want to die of old age, for example. We might also all want to live in a society free of crime, but that will never happen either.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by avn2109 on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:56PM (#10283819)
Where I come from, in the American West, it is your job to fence your neighbor's cattle _out_ if you don't want them on your land. It is not his job to fence them _in_ so they stay on his land. This principle is enshrined in centuries of statues and legal precedent. It works really well.

Similarly, I claim that in a free and open society, with lively and vibrant debate constantly transpiring in the metaphorical agora, it is your job to _not be offended_ by things that other people say, not their job _to avoid offending you_.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by geofft on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:07PM (#10284089)
What is the relevance of people being offended to this discussion? This is about threats and harassment, not being "offended".

Neither the original article nor any other comment in this thread talks about people being "offended". The UN report itself only mentions "offensive behaviour" or similar a few times: a small number of times in quoting other people's opinions or existing policies, once in regards to "sending offensive emails from victim's email account" (that is, it is not the "offensive" content per se that is a problem, but the impersonation), and once favorably quoting Facebook's policy: "We prohibit content deemed to be directly harmful, but allow content that is offensive or controversial. We define harmful content as anything organising real world violence, theft, or property destruction, or that directly inflicts emotional distress on a specific private individual (e.g., bullying)."

The threat to "lively and vibrant debate" here is entirely invented, and it is disingenuous for you to pretend that this discussion is about being "offended" by things that people say. The discussion here is about threats and harassment, which have no part in encouraging lively and vibrant debate, not about potentially "offensive" ideas.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by oldmanjay on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:55PM (#10285011)
A passionate defense of an unworkable mindset is a truly a sign of the munificence of our age.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by geofft on Saturday September 26, 2015 @09:19PM (#10285059)
I'm sorry, I don't understand this comment. Which mindset do you believe is unworkable, which defense do you believe is passionate, in what way would you say our age is munificent, and is that a good or bad thing?
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:59PM (#10283828)
Everywhere else in the world you are responsible for the harm that you cause.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:02PM (#10283841)
Except the governments (and the UN), of course.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by waterlesscloud on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:55PM (#10283813)
"nobody has to learn to get comfortable with something they find objectionable."

Do you really believe that? Think about where that goes.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:58PM (#10283824)
It's a bit easier if by objectionable we limit ourselves to threats of sexual violence or death threats.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:01PM (#10283839)
Anyone who considers online insults as "threats" is being insincere and only propagating their own agenda.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:29PM (#10283957)
Have a look at the threats being sent to Caroline Criado Perez.

https://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/JCO/Document...

The judge said it was "hard to imagine more extreme threats".

> In summary these tweets said: “Fuck off and die...you should have jumped in front of horses, go die; I will find you and you don’t want to know what I will do when I do... kill yourself before I do; rape is the last of your worries; I’ve just got out of prison and would happily do more time to see you berried; seriously go kill yourself! I will get less time for that; rape?! I’d do a lot worse things than rape you.”

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/twitter-trolls-is...

> He said that, despite the defendants' claims, the harm threatened against Criado-Perez "must have been intended to be very high".

> The judge said the effect of the abuse on Criado-Perez had been "life-changing".

Your continued denial of the harassment that women face, in every thread, is really fucking weird.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:49PM (#10284990)
Trolls gonna troll. I really don't know what else to say to you except "don't feed the trolls". I don't oppose you calling these "harassment" and I don't deny it happens. But I cannot take it seriously, it is far from "violence" and I wouldn't take it seriously even if it happened to me and even if I was annoyed by it, and I don't think these require or deserve any kind of police intervention.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Sunday September 27, 2015 @10:09AM (#10286542)
Let's play a game. You send me your social media account names, and I get five days to change your mind.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:16AM (#10286779)
Gladly. You can deduce my name from the HN info. I just googled it - most of my accounts are there, although I only use LinkedIn with any frequency... Missing is Facebook, which you can also find pretty easily, I'm sure.

Edit: I'm not really hiding anything, so you don't actually need my consent to start harassing (or "play-harassing" me). But if you seek my consent, I only give it for troll harassment (i.e. emotional abuse), not SJW/thought police harassment (perverting people's words to get them fired from their jobs, like Tim Hunt or Justine Sacco).

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by pen2l on Monday September 28, 2015 @12:17AM (#10288888)
I just googled you too.

Sorry, I have nothing else to say, except: damn, you look so cool.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:11PM (#10283882)
On the contrary, anyone who plays down the specifically threatening nature of some of the online "insults" women like Kathy Sierra have had to endure (doxxing, detailed descriptions of violent acts, photoshops of violent acts, etc.) is being insincere and only propagating their own agenda.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:14PM (#10283899)
> only propagating their own agenda

I am, no doubt about it. My agenda is freedom of speech and dealing with real-world, not virtual, problems.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:22PM (#10283937)
Being the target of sustained harassment is a real world problem. You can't ask the women (And, sure, some men) who have been subjected to the troll-rage of the internet to just shake this off. What online harassers do needs to be treated as what it is: a deliberate attempt to harm another person. It needs to be subject to criminal sanctions.

That doesn't mean I think websites need to become an arm of the state, it means I think the state needs to get a whole lot more tech savvy and figure out how to find and prosecute these idiots.

I don't think that threatens freedom of speech.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:33PM (#10283975)
> It needs to be subject to criminal sanctions.

So if someone is insulting you in public, you call the police? Or simply walk away?

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:54PM (#10284045)
Not 'insulting', vividly describing violent fantasies about me? Yes, yes I would.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @08:49PM (#10284993)
Well I sincerely hope that people like you don't start writing laws.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Saturday September 26, 2015 @10:17PM (#10285179)
Why are you so adamant about protecting the freedom of strangers to make someone's online life a living hell? To send them specific, personal, detailed threats? I don't understand why you believe that is 'speech' worth protecting.

Sure, there's a line, and some behavior that people complain about as harassment doesn't cross that line, but some behavior is way out of order and should be stopped, with the force of law. Drawing those lines, between what is acceptable and what is not, is the job of laws. That isn't the top of a slippery slope, it's not the thin end of a wedge that leads to censorship, it's the way society functions.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Sunday September 27, 2015 @06:42AM (#10286111)
I can think of 3 main reasons:

- in the vast, vast majority of cases, it's not as bad as they (you, feminists, the UN, the "victims") claim it is

- the solutions they suggest are difficult to implement - for example, you would need to eradicate online anonymity - whereas my solution is very simple - use personal blocking software or, better yet, just ignore the trolls

- both of the points above lead me to conclude that their goals are insincere - that they're using "harassment" just as an excuse to legalize and implement more censorship and restrictions that will be used for nefarious political causes, the same as happened before with e.g. the "threats" of piracy and pedophilia

Edit: another reason is that I don't really recall many laws that made the internet better (DMCA, EU cookie laws, the "right to forget", Australia's blacklist), so it's seems unlikely that this time they will do it right

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by rayiner on Sunday September 27, 2015 @08:46AM (#10286329)
I think the idea that you can say things online that you couldn't say in person is going in the dustbin of history. I don't think that's a good thing, but it's not just "feminists" and the UN in that camp. As the Internet becomes just an extension of the real world, with broad participation from everyone, totally anonymous and consequence free speech likely won't be tolerated by the public.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:01AM (#10286727)
"As the Internet becomes just an extension of the real world"

Newsflash: the internet is part of the real world, and always has been. Those people on the other side of the screen? They're real people.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:13AM (#10286772)
I don't understand... what can't you say in public? I mean, insulting someone won't get you thrown in jail...
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by jameshart on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:31AM (#10286829)
You admitted at the top of this thread that you are minimizing online threats by calling them 'insults', and that you're doing so to push your 'free speech' agenda.

You're doing it again, and it is growing tiresome. We aren't talking about 'insults', we're talking about sustained campaigns of intimidation using specific, personal threats.

As an exercise, please, today, go out to a public space, pick someone at random, and follow them around for a half hour or so, hurling abusive, threatening language at them. Draw pictures of them being subjected to violent abuse and hand them to passers by. Follow them to their home, ring the doorbell, and when they answer tell them that they and their family aren't safe.

I think you'll discover that your freedom of speech gets curtailed pretty quickly.

Then explain why doing the same while following someone from Twitter, across internet message boards, and then calling their cellphone, is qualitatively different.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:56AM (#10286915)
> You're doing it again, and it is growing tiresome. We aren't talking about 'insults', we're talking about sustained campaigns of intimidation using specific, personal threats.

It's equally tiresome for me when you call them threats. A real threat is e.g. "Give me your money, otherwise I'll shoot you.". I'm calling them insults because I'm not taking these "threats" seriously. I believe that in the very vast majority of cases, these threats are meant only to have an emotional impact (just like insults), not to express actual intention to commit a crime (warning your target would be stupid). However, if you disagree, you can always inform the police, there are no new laws required. IIRC, some anti-GamerGate activists did that, and the police dropped their investigation, not considering the threats serious, just like me (and so far, they've never been wrong).

> I think you'll discover that your freedom of speech gets curtailed pretty quickly.

I think either one of two things will happen: either (1) someone will attack me, which is a crime, or (2) someone will accuse me of being politically incorrect and will try to publicly shame me in hopes of getting fired.

Internet removes option (1), which I think is good, while option (2) is equally abusive as the one you're against.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Sunday September 27, 2015 @11:34AM (#10286834)
Telling someone that you're going to rape and murder them isn't going to go well for you, even if you claim a freedom of speech defence.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:53PM (#10283802)
> nobody has to learn to get comfortable with something they find objectionable

Why don't they just turn off the computer?

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by DanBC on Saturday September 26, 2015 @01:55PM (#10283815)
Apply that to yourself. Turn off your computer now, and leave it turned off for the next week. Include your phone. Include any online connectivity you have at work.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tomp on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:00PM (#10283837)
How about being reasonable and doing it only as much as necessary? Block people on twitter, avoid going to "hateful" websites and report abusive emails as "spam"?
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by geofft on Saturday September 26, 2015 @03:11PM (#10284099)
Sarah Jeong's recent book The Internet of Garbage has a good discussion of the benefits and drawbacks of handling abuse as if it were spam, and argues in favor of a solution that is technically similar to current spam filtering, though not the same. Well worth reading for anyone interested in building productive solutions to the problem of abuse.
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by tveita on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:02PM (#10283840)
Those are obviously not the only two choices.

There's a lot individual communities can do to recognize and mitigate the problem, even on Hacker News. Not starting off the discussion with "women have to learn to be comfortable with some degree of harassment" would have been a great start.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by geofft on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:19PM (#10283920)
The internet already is a limited speech zone. Women who are not comfortable with the current degree of harassment are not speaking.

If you think that it's important to preserve the internet as a free speech zone for those who are already freely speaking, and not for those who aren't, that's certainly a position you can take. But please say it in those terms.

[dead]
Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by wingless on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:05PM (#10283857)
>Trump

White? Check Male? Check Cis? Check Straight? Check

So no one would care, and perhaps people would go even harder on him.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by a3n on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:11PM (#10283883)
I'm trying to imagine this article written by the NYT, or pre-Bezos WP.

The WP is feeling very vaguely and subtly an outlet for Bezos/Amazon's interests.

Re:The United Nations has a radical, dangerous vision for th... by brighteyes on Saturday September 26, 2015 @02:02PM (#10283842)
I agree with the article that the changes propose are radical and dangerous. Instead, improvement could be achieved bottom up. For example, many women complain about online dating being an unpleasant experience for women. Some women decided to do something about it and started Bumble,

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/12/bumble-dat...

A dating app that only lets women message men. It's an interesting idea and totally changes the dynamic.

If online harassment is a problem on dating sites, women can and have created a better solution for themselves in Bumble. Women can do the same with a safer Twitter and Facebook - if they want. It's never been easier to do so, with Kickstarter and other funding options.

Women are not a minority - they are over 50% of the population, and more than capable of solving problems like this, again, if they want. Apparently things were bad enough in dating for Bumble, but since there isn't a female-oriented Twitter or Facebook, I suspect the problems are overstated on those sites.