This is attractive to the NIMBY crowd, fewer cars, less non-resident parking, less noise ( electric motors ) less local pollution. Who wouldn't want local rapid transit? They're not putting in Walmarts.
And in this hypothetical world, absolutely everyone who uses public transit has a smartphone?
Now picture the line at Space Mountain in the afternoon, except in a subway station.
Why can't you load 15 people into 15 pods at once?
> very importantly, each car must have odor detectors / biohazard detectors in case someone has an 'accident' in the car.
The subway doesn't have this, and it works okay. People just use their built in odor detector, and if there's a problem, they avoid sitting in it and notify a conductor.
There could still be a phoneless kiosk/swipe system for people who don't have/don't want to use the app version, but with cheap Android phones available for $20-$50 (and that's today -- imagine where we'll be in 5 years) I figure 95% of throughput could use the streamlined flow.
---------
All that said, I think I agree with the article's sentiment that this system's time may have come and gone. It's hard to imagine what transport will look like 15 years from now, but I suspect that electric robot taxis as part of a multi-modal transport infrastructure with existing trains/subways could deliver most of the benefit of a personal pod system without the huge infrastructure investments of building a completely new set of tracks all over the city.
Now, everyone doesn't wait 3-4 minutes. They just get on the next available pod. Remember, people coming into a typical station don't come 40 at a time. They come in clumps of 1-4.
All of which transforms a batch system (subway/light rail), to a continuous system.
There is an assumption that stations are off the main rail. Which, given the size of a typical pod, is feasible. It is certainly much smaller than your typical light rail system
=== btw. wrt to speed.
There's nothing stopping you pre-ordering a destination at a machine (or smartphone) before you get to a pod. Swipe your credit card, see your name on the pod you should go to. Walk in. Sit. And go.
And in the case of your daily commute, even easier. Have it pre-set. Jump in to a pod, face-recognition (or nfc/ble) and if it's your 'typical' time, you're off. No pressing/no swipes. Just go.
=== NIMBy's are always going to be an issue and off-grade (eg. above/below ground) is typically going to be required.
Self-driving cars.. are definitely -the- alternative. But only if there's actually enough road. Eg. it's not going to go any faster during rush hour. It just means you're not going to be driving.
Corollary: Is it really that bad to have to ride a bus or train with other people on-board?
Obviously not every case, but I've taken a fair amount of Bay Area busses in my time and there was always at least one of the above complaints.
The problem is cultural. Another poster here mentioned Japan, where busses are pleasant. After all, that is a place where "the nail that sticks up gets hammered down." If we really want public life on par with Japan or Europe, change has to start with each and every one of us. No government program or well-funded startup could ever do it alone.
If you have to take multiple forms of public transit to get where you are going, good luck. A 40 minute drive can easily be 2.5 hours on public transit if everything goes perfectly.
Also the average speed of SF MUNI buses is 8 mph, probably among the lowest in the nation. If I'm going any distance less than a 30 minute walk, it's probably going to be a better idea to walk than take the bus.
A PRT system would possibly have a station much closer to my house, so there wouldn't need to be a single commuter rail station for a town of 20K people, and therefore no dealing with crowded parking lots. It would likely have a stop at or near my office, as it's a very busy business district (Kendall Sq, Cambridge.)
Don't they have at least the occasional Chikan issue?
"Interesting people" exist around the world, good and bad.
So, a system like this would be infeasible in a dense city like SF. Above ground is another story altogether: the NIMBYs would block all construction.
What could work is a system of autonomous vehicles (taxis) the size of a Google self-driving car, running above ground, summoned via a smartphone app or a kiosk at every corner. So, instead of dedicated pathways and elevated tracks, use autonomous cars.
Also: very importantly, each car must have odor detectors / biohazard detectors in case someone has an 'accident' in the car.