News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:53PM (#10267183)
Require payment of $1 per year per public IP, and suddenly wastrels like the Apple class A will be available again...
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by msbarnett on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:38PM (#10267575)
IANA was allocating at a rate of 2 /8s per month right before they ran out.

Recovering an /8 would take staggeringly more effort than it is worth in terms of how little it fills existing demand.

There is no scheme that will make IPv4 work in the long-term. The mathematics are very simple. You cannot fill demand for exponentially more than 4 billion numbers with a pool of only 4 billion numbers.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:07PM (#10272898)
I think you mean /24?
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by km3k on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:57PM (#10273306)
Nope. They've been allocating at least several /24's per day even since getting down to their last /8.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by msbarnett on Thursday September 24, 2015 @03:35PM (#10274075)
Only two /24s a month? Demand hasn't been that low in ages.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by rtpg on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:18AM (#10270134)
but do we need 4 billion numbers? I thought things like NAT make the global static IP utility less than needing every other person to have an IP address
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by msbarnett on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:13PM (#10273435)
Carrier grade NAT is a disaster for end users, unless you want to do little more than browse the web unreliably.

Multiplayer gaming, peer-to-peer anything really, is an unmitigated shitshow under heavy NAT.

You definitely do not want carrier grade NAT to become entrenched in North America, like it already is in Asia.

And at some point, even if we did want it, we'd run out of numbers for people who want to serve content, and at that point NAT isn't going to do anything for you, and the barrier for entry for new web businesses becomes sky high.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by WorldMaker on Thursday September 24, 2015 @11:21AM (#10272103)
I think a point here is that NAT isn't long term sustainable. We seem to be teetering on the point where NAT Traversal becomes almost impossible to reliably do and the concept of a single internet breaks down, one NAT black box network at a time. Already there are systems that really can only communicate via HTTP to the global internet and then only if they initiate the request. To some people that is a "feature" and the future of firewalls, but I don't want to live on an internet where you have maybe one reliable protocol and a pull-only view of that one protocol at that...
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:02PM (#10272863)
There's a difference between "pull" and "initiate." NAT traversal is getting better over time, not worse. (Says data from gaming platforms) You only /really/ need more than one IP if you want to expose more than 65000 different services from a single physical place. But, instead of solving this through economics and ingenuity (which we knew could, and had to be done 10 or even 20 years ago) we let device vendors and academics run the show into IPv6. Which doesn't solve the /real/ problem we're /actually/ having: devices change connectivity every 5 minutes and move continents in a few hours. IPv6 just doesn't have an answer.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by msbarnett on Thursday September 24, 2015 @02:17PM (#10273480)
> NAT traversal is getting better over time, not worse. (Says data from gaming platforms) You only /really/ need more than one IP if you want to expose more than 65000 different services from a single physical place

There's a big, huge, insurmountable difference between home NAT traversal, with port-forwarding, and Carrier-grade NAT traversal, where fuck you and your ports.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by WorldMaker on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:06PM (#10274742)
Yes, there's a difference between "pull" and "initiate", but it is academic to my point/hyperbole. Also, yes, UPnP Port Forwarding has made less of a mess in the case of most modern "home" NATs, and this does show up nicely in gaming platforms. UPnP Port Forwarding is a nice kludge. Have you seen how much code and effort is involved in kludges like UPnP Port Forwarding? The game platforms are getting better at it over time mostly because the good platforms can spend a lot of money building the necessary complex software.

But we're already leaving behind the case where a single NAT near the edge of the network graph (the "home") is sufficient and are starting to see larger deployments of "carrier-grade NAT". So far as I know there is no equivalent kludge to UPnP Port Forwarding that works reliably on that scale, and building such a kludge seems like a major question of what sort of internet topology we really want. For hyperbole's sake, "carrier-grade NAT" and other similar cases of NATs speaking to NATs that what we're talking about is ultimately a balkanization of the internet, breaking the internet back into sub-networks of various addressability.

Even with economic incentives, we'd still be running out of IPv4 addresses for all of the "physical places" in the world that have 65000 devices. More critically, with IPv4 we've already hit scaling problems with the size of routing tables for the physical places that connect to the internet, we can't easily do "per-IP routing" and there aren't economic incentives that will quickly change that.

Ultimately, I'm wondering if this is the confusion you are having: IP (v4 or v6) is about the physical routing to the places of the internet. IPv6 doesn't have answers to device connectivity or movement because that's not its job. Logical Device to Physical IP Address mapping is the job of internet layers like DNS and mDNS/Bonjour. NAT is a series of hacks designed to deal with the fact that IPv4 doesn't do as great of a job at physical routing as we would like, now that we have millions of devices connecting to it every day. IPv6 is an actual attempt to fix how the internet does physical routing. It does solve the real problem we are actually having: physical routing on the internet. It solves it much better than NATs wish they could solve it, regardless of the "device vendors and academics" that "ran the show".

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by msbarnett on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:32PM (#10274910)
> So far as I know there is no equivalent kludge to UPnP Port Forwarding that works reliably on that scale

There's only Port Control Protocol, but almost no sane ISP will ever enable it, because it can't really solve much and the security implications make people really uncomfortable.

The big problem with carrier grade NAT is when you stick N people behind 1 IP, they can only have at most 65,536/N ports each. If you're a big city in India, say, and N=1000, that's 65 ports per person.

Your ports-per-person is your ceiling on maximum simultaneous TCP sessions per person. 65 ports is barely enough for a few browser tabs to be open simultaneously, and god help you if you've got another layer of NAT at the household level (which you probably do) and you're splitting those 65 ports between 2 or 3 other people (which you probably are).

Consequently, browsing the internet is a fraught process in a lot of places with carrier grade NAT. You can absolutely forget about P2P or anything else complex and port-hungry.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by zokier on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:34PM (#10267530)
To what end? Reclaiming allocations would only prolong the painful transition to IPv6 which has already been going on for too long. For the internet at large IPv4 exhaustion is a good thing because it moves IPv6 forwards. The quicker we can get rid of IPv4 the better.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by simon_vetter on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:41PM (#10267591)
This. Running dual stack networks is harder and more expensive to manage, secure and troubleshoot.

The faster we get to single stack ipv6 only, the better.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by teacup50 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:49PM (#10268493)
Single stack IPv6 is just not happening; there's just WAY TOO MUCH STUFF out there that only speaks IPv4.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by icebraining on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:22PM (#10268664)
Yeah, but you can have that only at the edges, using ipv4-to-ipv6 proxies to connect to the Internet.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by teraflop on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:54PM (#10268812)
Yep; this is what T-Mobile already does if you set your phone's APN to "IPv6 only".
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by simoncion on Thursday September 24, 2015 @12:47AM (#10269869)
Similarly, my cable modem (which is distinct from my router) only gets an IPv6 address from Comcast.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by simon_vetter on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:00AM (#10270404)
That's only a management interface tho, the modem will still happily forward ipv4.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by simon_vetter on Thursday September 24, 2015 @03:58AM (#10270396)
what icebraining said: use a nat64+dns64 at the edge of your network and make all your endpoints ipv6 only.

If you're an ISP, you could probably put multiple nat64 boxes in the core so that all your customers benefit from it and can gradually switch ipv4 off (since they can transparently reach ipv4 endpoints through the nat64 gateway).

Then there are a few applications that don't handle ipv6 properly (i.e. skype), and Apple's decision of mandating ipv6 support is meant to fix just that.

Then there is 4XLAT, ds-lite and others which allow for a single stack ipv6 network and carry ipv4 on top of it to the endpoints which need it.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by Retr0spectrum on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:06PM (#10268581)
We just need to wait for all that stuff to become obsolete.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by RKearney on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @08:10PM (#10269123)
Why single out Apple?

The US Government owns:

  6.0.0.0/8
  7.0.0.0/8
  11.0.0.0/8
  21.0.0.0/8
  22.0.0.0/8
  26.0.0.0/8
  28.0.0.0/8
  29.0.0.0/8
  30.0.0.0/8
  33.0.0.0/8
  55.0.0.0/8
  56.0.0.0/8
  214.0.0.0/8
  215.0.0.0/8
HP also owns 2 /8's, 15.0.0.0/8 and 16.0.0.0/8
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:04PM (#10272871)
Because they are easy pickings? MIT, USGOV and HP deserve equal pressure, of course!
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by astrodust on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:05PM (#10268233)
Apple would just pay the tab. So would Google. It wouldn't change anything.

If you're large enough to get allocations that huge, you're large enough to afford it.

Why is Apple a "wastrel" when it's building gigantic datacenters all over the place, yet MIT, who has an equal sized allocation for a university, is somehow fine?

It's not in Apple's interest to yield the block unless there's industry consensus and other companies and organizations with similar allocations are doing the same.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by Natsu on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:59PM (#10268837)
At $1 per IP, given that Apple has a /8, that'd be almost $17M. They could probably cut quite a bit of usage if they wanted to.

The real problem is that this doesn't make sense: we don't WANT IPv4 to persist. The sooner we all go to IPv6, the better.

Ideally, usage will gradually wane until only obsolete items even use IPv4, then a cutoff date will come from major ISPs and such cutting off IPv4 service and we'll finally pass the last hurdle.

At least, one might hope so.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by vacri on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:53PM (#10269410)
$17M/year to avoid having to re-architect all the internal networking at a trillion-dollar company? Easier to just pay it, really.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by astrodust on Thursday September 24, 2015 @12:33PM (#10272584)
They probably pay more than $17M a year on domain registrations. Just the cost of doing business.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:11PM (#10272932)
"Like" Apple. All single company /8 are wasteful.

And the holders didn't get the /8 in modern times "because they are huge" they got them in ancient times because historical reasons.

The fact that we've treated those allocations as sacrosanct means that we're stupid political people, not engineers. (What else is new? :-)

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by benjojo12 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:59PM (#10267239)
How would you go about enforcing that. and enforcing that is still covering up the issue that we really do need to move to IPv6
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tptacek on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:17PM (#10267419)
Why would that be hard to enforce?
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:35PM (#10267543)
Modifying a contract usually requires the consent of both parties. If IANA/ARIN tried to claw those IPs back from Apple, and Apple sued to stop them, who do you think would win?

They could enforce renting (vs owning) going forward with all new assignments, but that will probably just encourage even more hoarding of existing space.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by zokier on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:41PM (#10267595)
My understanding is that at least ARIN holds the position that IP allocations are not property that the recipients own.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:30PM (#10267945)
Since Apple's allocation predates the existence of ARIN, is ARIN's position relevant?

More to the point, the IPs were assigned to Apple by some agreement more or less akin to a perpetual lease. Under what conditions can that lease be terminated? (Actually some of the earliest allocation were apparently because "Postel says so". But probably still close enough to a handshake deal to be valid.)

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by stock_toaster on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:57AM (#10270541)

  > Actually some of the earliest allocation were 
  > apparently because "Postel says so"
Postel's other, lesser known, law?
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:18PM (#10267859)
> If IANA/ARIN tried to claw those IPs back from Apple, and Apple sued to stop them, who do you think would win?

IANA and ARIN, historically. You don't ever own your IPs, no more than you own your phone number.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by icedchai on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:48PM (#10268488)
That's doesn't appear true for legacy blocks. They are, effectively, owned. ARIN can't "claw back" legacy IPs which were assigned before ARIN ever existed.

I own legacy IPs. And I pay nothing, because I did not sign the ARIN registration agreement. If they could force me to pay by threatening to revoke my IPs, they would have done it already.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:54PM (#10268521)
Nothing stops someone else from announcing those IP blocks. You would be hard pressed to prove ownership in court.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by icedchai on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:01PM (#10269429)
You misunderstood, I think. My organization name is in the ARIN registration database from the early days of the internet. Most ISPs require some proof of ownership to do the BGP announcement (address, name match, etc.) My /24 block is announced and routed to my home network, by the way.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:08PM (#10268596)
Yes, that's the solution. Whoever announces a block the loudest gets to use it.

You may also want to look into concepts such as water rights. Nothing stops you from draining all the water out of the Colorado river upstream. Except the things that do...

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:37PM (#10268722)
I don't have a dog in this fight, as I don't manage network edges, AS, etc anymore. I'm simply stating that if you fight against ARIN, you'll lose. You're free to try, I've got better things to do.

http://www.finnegan.com/resources/articles/articlesdetail.as...

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:54PM (#10268815)
Uhm, did you read your link? There's nothing in it about losing if you fight ARIN. It's pretty clear ARIN knows they'll lose, which is why they're badgering people into signing these legacy agreements. So they'll be brought under control. If ARIN had authority, they wouldn't be asking for companies to volunteer it to them.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:14PM (#10272958)
Or we could decide that the internet is important to society and pass some laws that gives IP allocation some claws, at least in the US. But, because the US works like it does, that doesn't happen. Win some, lose some.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:24PM (#10274856)
People already shit bricks when the government seizes .com domains. I can't wait to see what happens when they seize AS numbers too. "OMG, those imperialist bastards think they can regulate the internet!"
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by vinceguidry on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:45PM (#10267627)
What's probably going to happen is a marketplace will open up and unused IP blocks will go to those willing to pay for them. Eventually the cost of deploying IPv6 will be less than the cost of IPv4 addresses.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by spydum on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:04PM (#10268577)
i am fairly certain RIRs do not allow this, though i know it was common practice for major hosting providers to buy up dinky/unprofitable companies which had larger legacy allocations purely for their address space.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by joepie91_ on Thursday September 24, 2015 @12:13PM (#10272463)
Still is. Along with various other IP hoarding schemes. ColoCrossing is a notorious offender in this area, and has also been draining IPs from ARIN.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by detaro on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:58PM (#10267719)
That market already exists, although not centrally organized by the RIRs.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by iridium127 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @09:06PM (#10269276)
Aren't they allocating ipv6 IPs in a similar way though? the only difference is exponentially more addresses to a single company...
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by ChuckMcM on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:27PM (#10268362)
So a class A would cost $16M /year to hold? I think folks should just move to V6 in all its silliness and be done with it.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by api on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:39PM (#10267578)
Unfortunately that would prolong the life of IPv4.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by astrodust on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:06PM (#10268242)
Like it or not, we're going to be stuck with it for at least twenty years.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:12PM (#10268274)
Naww, make it $50, which is close to what we pay for domain registration renewal. Now watch everyone give up all those IPs they've been hording. Apple has 16m IPv4 addresses, that's $800m right there. They're not dropping nearly $1b annually to hoard IPv4.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by drcube on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:37PM (#10268418)
At a rate of $1B per year, they'll be out of cash in... 300 years.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by drzaiusapelord on Thursday September 24, 2015 @10:04AM (#10271617)
I don't think shareholders would be happy spending that kind of money on things they don't use and probably will never use now that v6 is on the table.