News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:35PM (#10267543)
Modifying a contract usually requires the consent of both parties. If IANA/ARIN tried to claw those IPs back from Apple, and Apple sued to stop them, who do you think would win?

They could enforce renting (vs owning) going forward with all new assignments, but that will probably just encourage even more hoarding of existing space.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by zokier on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:41PM (#10267595)
My understanding is that at least ARIN holds the position that IP allocations are not property that the recipients own.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:30PM (#10267945)
Since Apple's allocation predates the existence of ARIN, is ARIN's position relevant?

More to the point, the IPs were assigned to Apple by some agreement more or less akin to a perpetual lease. Under what conditions can that lease be terminated? (Actually some of the earliest allocation were apparently because "Postel says so". But probably still close enough to a handshake deal to be valid.)

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by stock_toaster on Thursday September 24, 2015 @04:57AM (#10270541)

  > Actually some of the earliest allocation were 
  > apparently because "Postel says so"
Postel's other, lesser known, law?
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:18PM (#10267859)
> If IANA/ARIN tried to claw those IPs back from Apple, and Apple sued to stop them, who do you think would win?

IANA and ARIN, historically. You don't ever own your IPs, no more than you own your phone number.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by icedchai on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:48PM (#10268488)
That's doesn't appear true for legacy blocks. They are, effectively, owned. ARIN can't "claw back" legacy IPs which were assigned before ARIN ever existed.

I own legacy IPs. And I pay nothing, because I did not sign the ARIN registration agreement. If they could force me to pay by threatening to revoke my IPs, they would have done it already.

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:54PM (#10268521)
Nothing stops someone else from announcing those IP blocks. You would be hard pressed to prove ownership in court.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by icedchai on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:01PM (#10269429)
You misunderstood, I think. My organization name is in the ARIN registration database from the early days of the internet. Most ISPs require some proof of ownership to do the BGP announcement (address, name match, etc.) My /24 block is announced and routed to my home network, by the way.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:08PM (#10268596)
Yes, that's the solution. Whoever announces a block the loudest gets to use it.

You may also want to look into concepts such as water rights. Nothing stops you from draining all the water out of the Colorado river upstream. Except the things that do...

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:37PM (#10268722)
I don't have a dog in this fight, as I don't manage network edges, AS, etc anymore. I'm simply stating that if you fight against ARIN, you'll lose. You're free to try, I've got better things to do.

http://www.finnegan.com/resources/articles/articlesdetail.as...

Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @06:54PM (#10268815)
Uhm, did you read your link? There's nothing in it about losing if you fight ARIN. It's pretty clear ARIN knows they'll lose, which is why they're badgering people into signing these legacy agreements. So they'll be brought under control. If ARIN had authority, they wouldn't be asking for companies to volunteer it to them.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by jwatte on Thursday September 24, 2015 @01:14PM (#10272958)
Or we could decide that the internet is important to society and pass some laws that gives IP allocation some claws, at least in the US. But, because the US works like it does, that doesn't happen. Win some, lose some.
Re:ARIN Finally Runs Out of IPv4 Addresses by tedunangst on Thursday September 24, 2015 @05:24PM (#10274856)
People already shit bricks when the government seizes .com domains. I can't wait to see what happens when they seize AS numbers too. "OMG, those imperialist bastards think they can regulate the internet!"