News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by flurpitude on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:34AM (#10265203)
>"When the news about Volkswagen broke last Friday, Carder heard from some of the heavy diesel engine manufacturers that were part of the consent decree.

>"They saw what had happened and called to say: 'Good job, you guys,'" Carder said. "Some folks said: 'How did they not learn from our mistakes 15 years ago?'"

Neither VW nor these companies made a "mistake", though they all use that term. This was deliberate deceit, fraud, trickery. If there was a mistake it was thinking they could get away with it and come out with more money. Each time they talk about their "mistake" they reveal how deeply attached they are to a culture of denying responsibility.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by brudgers on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:20AM (#10265537)
The minimum code necessary to pass the test is considered good engineering practice in the software industry. The application of that practice in the case of automobile emissions is an artifact of the lack of professional licensure for software engineers: e.g. in the US a professional structural engineer who took professional responsibility for a similar expediency in the design of a building would be personally liable because professional liability cannot be assigned to fictitious persons. The idea that "Engineer" connotes a person who applies some sort of professional standards to trump the most base of business interests is why Canada is pushing title protection and professional qualification as prerequiste for calling one's self a "software engineer".

The meaninglessness of the term "software engineer" and celebrated industry practices are why I am not optimistic about the safety of self-driving cars. Volkswagen presumably can attract as good and ethical a software engineering cadre as anyone in the business.

However, my suspicion is that VW allowed this to come out now in order to again pull diesels out of the US market for business reasons. I think it's a bet on low gasoline prices in the short term and fuel efficiency via electric motors in the long term with a little P.T. Barnum the-newspapers-can-write-whatever-they-want-so-long-as-they-spell-my-name-correctly thrown in. This will blow over faster than you can say "I don't care if I pay a nickle more per gallon, I won't fill up there because of Deepwater Horizon". It's not like Martin Winterkom shot an elephant or anything.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by mc32 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:33AM (#10265645)
There is no way, except for downright mad, that winterkorn would put the fate of his company in jeopardy just to pull out diesels from a market. If they had wanted to pull diesels out, they could have said, they don't sell well, people are asking for electrics instead. That's very unlikely speculation without sound basis.

With regard to engineering titling, this was done in Germany, I don't think any more rigidity would have had an effect on countering fraud. We have fraudulent physicians -having the distinction doesn't prevent that.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by brudgers on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:47PM (#10266619)
1. US engineering licensing is more than title protection, it is backed by education, testing, and work experience requirements.

2. Suzuki closed the deal to buy out Volkswagen's stake amid claims that Volkswagen was withholding information that effected their partnership in regard to fuel efficient technology, immediately [for some definition of "immediately"] before the revelations in regard to the TDD practices for TDI software: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-34275917

There's a matryoshka of foundations and policy groups behind the research funding for the project that uncovered the software design. VW has been in and out of the US diesel car market with every change in the price of gasoline since the first diesel Rabbits in the 1970's when famously, they had to remove the assertion that diesel fuel was less expensive than gasoline from their television commercials.

This way, Volkswagen Passenger Cars [a wholly owned subsidiary of Volkswagen Group] does not have to negotiate with its US car dealers regarding a lineup change that removes high profit options and models that bring customers onto the lot who often drive off with some other VW instead of a TDI. If history is a guide, with gasoline down around $2.00/gallon it won't be long until Americans lose most of their rather limited interest in diesels.

The worst case fine of $16 billion is highly unlikely and even were such a fine politically feasible in the US it almost certainly wouldn't send Volkswagen AG under.

The timing is no more likely to be accidental than the way in which the software is configured. The study was completed in 2013.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by mc32 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:16PM (#10267847)
I think you're reading too much into the timing. W/re the fine. It's not the fine which would break them, but the loss of confidence and prestige. They will suffer a sales slump due to these unbecoming tactics.

It was their aim to become the world auto sales leader, I don't think tarnishing their reputation in any way aids that aim.

Yes, GM has recently suffered a fiasco due to using an inferior part for cost savings, and I believe they dodged ( no pun) dire consequences in no small part due to its handling by their savvy CEO.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by brudgers on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:19PM (#10268308)
The code is a symptom. The underlying issue was and is that VW dies not have a marketable small diesel that complies with current emissions regulations. Never mind more stringent future regulations.

Today VW is in a position to expose the loss they were going to take anyway, dump the problematic technology, blame everything on Winterkorn, and go through a jumbo box of come-to-Jesus motions. And just as diesel-gate broke VW happened to announce their bet on electric: http://www.techtimes.com/articles/84995/20150915/volkswagen-...

It's not like the people at VW are stupid or naive in regards to PR. Diesel was not going to propel VW past GM in a sustainable way. This story makes that obvious.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by CamperBob2 on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:17PM (#10268304)
Yes, clearly erecting more artificial barriers to entry in the software development business is the answer. How can VW's management have been so blind as not to see that?
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by a3n on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:13AM (#10265500)
If you steal a car when you're young, then become a fine citizen later, then it's common usage to call that a mistake. People understand what's meant.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by dlhavema on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:00PM (#10266243)
i don't think we can compare a naive, young and/or peer-pressured juvenile to a multi-million ( billion ? ) dollar company that knows what they are doing.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by brainfire on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:59PM (#10268542)
"knows what they are doing"

I'm not sure that necessarily applies to most large companies.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by dalke on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:47AM (#10265307)
I interpreted their mistake as mistakenly 'thinking they could get away with it and come out with more money', as you said.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by magicalist on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:53PM (#10268115)
> If there was a mistake it was thinking they could get away with it and come out with more money

Not to get in the way of someone getting to make an angry comment, but considering that the article is referring to companies similarly trying to fraudulently pass EPA tests and being punished for it, it's pretty obvious that's exactly what they're referring to.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by niels_olson on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:41AM (#10265262)
So, what deceits do software makers call "mistakes"?
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by Gravityloss on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @10:58AM (#10265389)
Graphics drivers can detect when a speed test is being run, and degrade the output quality to get a higher frame rate.

I don't think anybody called that a mistake, it's just straight cheating.

If anything, they've probably seen that and thought it was a great idea!

http://techreport.com/review/3089/how-ati-drivers-optimize-q...

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by gambiting on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:24PM (#10265997)
As someone who works in games industry - we have a line to AMD and NVIDIA open all the time. They change their drivers to work with our game just as much as we change our games to work with their drivers. Each driver has thousands of profiles for different games, and that has nothing to do with cheating - it's because no one writes perfect, 100% standard-compliant shaders or other gpu related code. The article you linked is ancient, but this still happens - drivers know that in your specific game there's a problem with the textures so they will automatically reduce the fidelity of texture shaders, or do some other changes. If you changed the name of our game internally, the drivers would no longer pick it up and you would lose 10-20 fps depending on the situation. That's not "cheating".
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by MengerSponge on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @12:51PM (#10266201)
Optimizing the device's profile for a known input is generally celebrated. Deliberately misrepresenting the device's capabilities to deceive a test is what folks are generally upset about. It's a subtle distinction, but I'm happy to use Justice Stewart's "I know it when I see it" criterion.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/live-memory-test,1241-10...

http://www.anandtech.com/show/7384/state-of-cheating-in-andr...

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by ryandrake on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:43PM (#10266586)
To me, the line between cheating and ensuring good compatibility is drawn when you deceptively "optimize" for particular benchmark measurements at the expense of other qualitative un-measured or difficult-to-measure qualities. This undermines the purpose of the benchmark.

There's a huge difference between "Game XYZ uses these inputs and shaders, let's make sure our driver works as well as possible when we see this pattern" and "When we detect the user is running Benchmark ABC, make everything look like shit so we come out with a high benchmark score that we can use in our marketing materials!"

I'll admit, however, the line gets fuzzy when the game itself is used as a benchmark.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by Gravityloss on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @05:57PM (#10268533)
Come to think of it, with computer proliferation this will permeate everything, and already has.

Trying to buy airline or cruise tickets? Some kind of shenanigans are bound to happen. The system is trying to infer if you might be willing to pay a lot.

Though, in the old times this haggling was done by real people.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by ForHackernews on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:06AM (#10265463)
How about Google hopping on personal wifi networks, slurping up and storing any data they could grab? http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/05/wifi-data-collection-...
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by baldfat on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @11:16AM (#10265513)
> In 2010, Google acknowledged that its Street View Wi-Fi collection was a mistake. “We screwed up, and I’m not making excuses about it,” Google co-founder Sergey Brin said at the time. “We do have a lot of internal controls in place, but obviously they didn’t prevent this error from occurring.”

That seems pretty upfront.

Well you really got that opposite from what I saw. It wasn't slurping any data that was protected behind a wall of privacy that Google climbed over but was public broadcast. I have always tried to let friends know that if they have WiFi they need to have an understanding what they are broadcasting. One time my friend had no passwords on his wifi and his Documents were being shared. I got the last three years of tax records sitting next to me. I did ask want me to look at downloads, videos or pictures. He blushed said no and we put up a password on his wifi and stopped sharing his data.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by ForHackernews on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:27PM (#10266466)
> That seems pretty upfront.

Only in the exact way described by the parent: deceit couched as mistakes.

Do you really honestly believe that they "accidentally" implemented a feature to associate with open wifi networks, grab any and all data they could, and store that data in their archive?

Google is a big place. One or more people designed that feature, multiple people implemented it, probably dozens of others tested it, and managers signed off on it before it was deployed on their StreetView cars.

It's not like "Whoops, someone left out a null check and it accidentally grabbed all your data!"

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by baldfat on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @02:34PM (#10267036)
It was one programmer that put in the code. Interesting read here but I still buy the one engineer theory.

http://allthingsd.com/20120501/google-releases-fuller-fcc-wi...

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by dalke on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @03:05PM (#10267310)
It says 'the project had sailed through an approval process.' That requires more than one engineer.
Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by ChrisClark on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @04:37PM (#10267997)
I also remember when it happened. Google put out a blog post about it when it was discovered, apologizing for having the logs turned on and promising to delete the data. It was only months later that suddenly websites were reporting on it, and then even more months before any governments decided to do anything about it.

If Google hadn't made that blog post, I don't think anyone would have known about it in the first place.

Re:West Virginia Engineer Proves to Be a David to VW's Goliath by rdancer on Wednesday September 23, 2015 @01:17PM (#10266399)
> mistake [...] thinking they could get away with it and come out with more money

Oh, you're funny!