Ask HN: What are your opinions and experiences coding on a 13“ or 15” laptop?
I do like the 15inch screen size but this Dell is big and clunky. It's pretty heavy too. It's been a while since I programmed on this one because it is a bit slow now.
I have also programmed on a 10" netbook. I did a lot of programming on it but I do think it is too small.
I am trying to decide between a 13" MacBook Pro and a 15" MacBook Pro. Obvious advantages of the 15" are i7, 16GB RAM and larger screen space! The 13 inch has an i5, 8 GB RAM.
I don't have to travel with it much but I will be attending an evening course once a week until Xmas so I do have to bring it out of the house for that. Do people still carry about 15 inch laptops?
When I get my new laptop (whichever one I choose) I will be starting a new project. The project will involve lots of text analysis, neural network stuff, web crawler, database stuff (PostgreSQL), front end web stuff (python/javascript), mobile app dev (iPhone & android). So with this very brief overview, do you have any recommendations?
Depending on what I'm building, I often want to have a full-screen browser, or at least a pretty wide one.
I work on an 18" laptop and typically I just alt-tab between vim in the terminal and my browser, but sometimes I align them side-by-side.
My MBP is the best computer I've ever worked on (and am typing this on). I've used my girlfriend's 15" MBP and I vastly prefer my 13".
I use BetterSnapTool[1] for window management: browser on the left half, SublimeText in the upper right 2/3 of the screen, and Terminal in the lower right 1/3 of the screen. It works great for me, and I can't imagine that another 2 inches would make much of a difference.
At work, I dock to a 24" Dell monitor of some sorts, and that's more than enough extra real estate for me.
[1]https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/bettersnaptool/id417375580?m...
The end result is that I have a tiny and lightweight laptop for travel and at the same time reasonably big screen for everyday work.
The reason for choosing 13" is that I travel a lot for work and I want to get some work done when I'm on the road. I also find it the ideal size to still accommodate a decent-sized keyboard and trackpad. When I need some extra screen estate, I just hook it on an external monitor.
Because I do allot of programming on it, I've chosen one with a high resolution screen (1920x1080) so I don't trade in screen estate but that might be a bit too high for most people (e.g. everything tends to get a bit tiny).
With the MBP's the extra size really isnt a big deal because they are so light and thin. And with the 15" you can get a MUCH better dual graphics setup which helps with all the other non-coding things you might want to do (gaming).
TBH you probably done need the power you will get, but it is nice to have.
Another anecdote: a friend of mine just picked up a 15" MBP after having a 15" dell for ever. He loves it and was amazed that he could actually run Photoshop without closing other things. And if you have to do any graphics like that the extra space of the retina 15" is really good.
- Display Space: Even when set to the highest possible virtual resolution, there is still noticeable more space on the 15" version. It's still way worse than a 27" display, but the difference makes me more productive.
- RAM: Retina eats RAM. I could run several browsers, VMs, editors etc. just fine on a 4GB MacBook Air. When I upgraded to a 13" MBPr, I was constantly running out of RAM, the machine began swapping and became barely usable. With the 16GB 15" MBPr, it's a very noticeable difference. I easily run into >8GB RAM usage. In addition, when there's available physical RAM, OS X caches some stuff from the SSD which speeds it up further.
For me, the size or weight of the laptop isn't relevant. It's the "clumsyness of it". With unibody Apple made the larger ones easier to move around.
I'd buy a 17" MBP if they would still make them. I prefer laptops to an external monitor because I use the touchpad with gestures a lot, and I like the focus.
I am on a macbook air now, but I would not suggest it for development. Its very thin (which is nice), but its noticeably slower, and I am worried I will run into the memory cap quickly.
The funny thing is that I have been looking at Dell's 13" XPS Developer Edition. Has anyone tried it?
Anyone else got the latest one? Or can anyone suggest alternatives to the latest one?
15" is too big to fit in train and airplane seats comfortably, but 13" is too small to get lots of work done.
However, I guess that rules out a MacBook Pro - oh well.
Recently bought the new dell xps 13 with infinity display and that thing is just a pleasure to work on.
Your only limitation might be battery life if you're going to do a lot of neural network stuff while on battery.
So far, it seems great. Screen is amazing (although dim in bright sunlight), and I haven't had any issues with memory (right now, with 3 web browsers and a text editor open, I am using 5gb out of the 8gb total). The processor is very fast, although the integrated graphics card is slow (whether this matters or not depends on what you are doing... I wouldn't buy this if you want to play complex video games or do a lot of graphics work). The screen is big enough to run two windows side-by-side, a long as they don't have too many toolbars.
The one downside is the OS. Yosemite is extremely buggy. Drops wifi connections, hangs when logging out, etc. El Capitan is being released next week though - hopefully that will be better.
Whether or not you need more RAM and a faster processor really depends on what exactly you want to do with it. For me (text editor, multiple web browsers, terminal, MAMP, all running at the same time) it is fast and large enough.
Portability: I travel a lot and the 15" is too heavy but the 13" Macbook Pro was heavy as well and in combination with everything else I'm carrying around, the difference doesn't really matter. I got a nice bag that I can convert to a backpack instead. The 15" doesn't feel very "clunky" to me. I was worried that I wouldn't want to sit on the couch with it like I used to with my 13" but here I am and I like it.
Screen size: the 15" screen is a little bit more convenient but the 13" was no problem for me either, you get used to it.
I would never do 11 or 17 " again, the 13 and 15" are both ok to work on.
For a more ergonomic backpack when I have to walk more and carry a lot, I use a booq backpack (booq boa because I wanted it to have hip belts).
I, personally, use a 13" with 16GB RAM and have external screens both at home and at work. It provides a good balance between portability and utility.
I like it: a space saver and aesthetically pleasing, good build quality, and never had any issue plugging and unplugging (need to follow the setup instructions properly).
However, a bit inconvenient as you need to take out your MBP to power it on. The alternative is to leave your MBP on sleep (and it will wake on mouse / button click). Also, factor in a purchase of the display adaptor extension. I found that my existing Mini DP to HDMI does not fit on the dock.
Clevo chose to do an "on paper" GPU upgrade of on the WS230 which is their 13.3" laptop (860M and 960M are the same) with a 3200x1800 screen.
The Clevo 650SG is a nice 15.4" with a 4k matte and 980M option.
The Razer Blade 2015 is 14" with a 3200x1800 screen and 970M.
Give me a 12-14" laptop with a 980M and 4k screen and I'll be happy. Razer Blade is closest so far, maybe Razer Blade 2016?
No, 4k in 12-14" is not too small. We have had 1080P 5" phones for a while now and Sony has released 4k phones. So we should be able to have 4k laptops. I'd like an 8k laptop though ;)
There isn't a hard and fast rule to what you need and what works for one person won't work for another. The only way you'll know is to try it for yourself. And even then you could argue either way depending totally on the context so it's a tough call for you to make.
Portability with the 15" is acceptable, but you need a dedicated carrier bag, I wouldn't carry it around in my backpack. That would be the one reason why I might go for a 13" next time I buy a laptop - as long as I have the external monitor at home, the small screen doesn't matter too much.
I use a de-Chromed Chrome book (acer c720) with xubuntu for personal projects these days. I do java/j2ee on a macbook pro for work, I never use it as a laptop, it's always docked. For personal projects on the chrome book, I code apache/python/django/vim, which run wonderfully on it. The smaller screen does take some getting used to, and the nonstandard keyboard takes some remapping. Otherwise, after 9 months, no complaints.
I just switched from a 17" Macbook Pro to a 13" Macbook Pro. I miss the humongous screen when diffing files, but I just love how portable my 13" is! I don't travel much, but lugging that 17" machine around was such a pain...
I guess the 15" isn't as bad as the 17", but since you do plan on carrying it around I'd recommend to go with the more portable option.
The main reason I use 13" is because I'd probably spend $1000 more for 15", and I try to limit the price of hardware in total that I have on me. My laptop and phone together cost about as much as a loaded 15" rMBP.
However, 15" seems to pay off when using IDEs with all their panes.
Specially when doing code navigation across multiple modules or UI design.
Also quite painful when using the debugger and being forced to context switch all the time between top level windows.
However, if your Mac needs more power than the adapter can provide, it'll take it from the battery.
Only downside: When your battery goes empty, the Macbook won't start immediately when a weak power adapter is connected. It will first charge the battery a bit, and only boot again after a few minutes. If you use the power adapter with the correct rating, the Macbook boots immediately after connecting it to power.
- You might like getting a 4K external screen: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10168766
- A 2ndhand desktop or previous-gen server in the corner can provide extra computational power; AWS et. al. throw in staggering network bandwidth and uptime guarantees.
I would go with a 13" and then connect to a monitor at your main work area when you need side by side displays. I use a 23" Acer monitor from amazon and a rain mStand, wireless trackpad and keyboard, It's a great setup for my main work station. Having a 13" air is great for working in other locations, outside and at a coffee shop.
I bougth it during last black friday, and I've been happy with the purchase until now. Only caveat: had to disable the touchpad because i tend to touch it when typing
I have always wanted to try out the Dell XPS 13, but its way too costly. For me, the choice is between a 13" laptop or something lower (12", perhaps).
[0]: https://captnemo.in/blog/2014/07/04/galago-ultra-pro-review/
I would get the more powerful laptop if possible due to the text analysis and neural network stuff you will be doing. Hook it up to an external monitor if you can. It really helps to have the display at eye level.
The computer is fast enough, the two extra cores are probably helpful, but the 13" is fast enough.
I code on it daily. I did get some upgrades like the 16GB RAM.