News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:01PM (#10248820)
Why are poachers shitty but ranchers are not? It seems much more ethical to me to kill an existing wild animal for money vs. breeding new animals in inhumane conditions for the sole purpose of killing them for money later on.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by hyperbovine on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:12PM (#10248875)
The legal version of poaching is called hunting. Provided the laws are sound (you haven't e.g. bribed someone to "legally" kill a tiger), hunting is fine. Killing a legally-protected animal almost always means you shot something whose species is in some sort of jeopardy. That's bad.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:36PM (#10248989)
> That's bad.

Why? Why is it bad? Why does it matter if, say, elephants go extinct? If they're extinct they're not suffering.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by erikpukinskis on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:56PM (#10249083)
I hope people stop downvoting you because this is an excellent question.

There is a number of species in that ecology today, let's call it N. It's a known good number of species: they work together, more or less, to stay alive as a group.

There are smaller collections of species which are nonviable. For example, if all species disappeared except elephants and tigers (2 species) the entire ecosystem would then disappear (the elephants would starve and then the tigers would) and eventually only inorganic material would remain.

There is a number of species, let's call it K, below which the probability of entire ecosystem collapse is nontrivial. We don't know what K is, but if we care about the existence of any ecosystem we must approach it carefully. And we won't know we've crossed it unless we go over.

We know K is somewhere between 2 and N. I think a good strategy is just to put the brakes on all extinction to try to buy us extra time to do science while we are approaching N=K.

As long as we keep N above K, we have a relatively easy problem: influencing a system at equilibrium. Once N drops below K we have a much harder problem: bootstrapping an ecology from nothing. Keeping N above K gives us more agency for less effort.

For that reason, I think the extinction of elephants would be bad.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by hsitz on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:05PM (#10249125)
It's also not just that the loss of a species is bad. It's that some species are especially important, and it's not necessarily known which these species are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keystone_species
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by stouset on Sunday September 20, 2015 @10:41PM (#10250089)
Important also is the rate of species extinction. An ecosystem with some number of species in it can likely cope with a low rate of extinction (as species get outcompeted quicker than the my evolve), but can't cope with several species dying out in rapid succession.

The issue with humans is that we are rapidly increasing the rate of extinction, by pollution, poaching, exclusively occupying large tracts of land, clear-cutting forests, etc.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @10:55PM (#10250116)
Surely an endangered animal would be the least likely to cause problems for us if it went extinct. Otherwise we would have noticed the ecosystem starting to go wonky as it neared extinction.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by Jemmeh on Monday September 21, 2015 @01:15PM (#10253673)
According to the National Parks Service website, only 41 wolves were released into Yellowstone and it had -major- impacts on fixing the ecosystem there.(Source: http://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/nature/wolves.htm )

It doesn't have to be " a lot" to keep an ecosystem in balance. A species that is there, even in low numbers(near extinction) could be the thread that ecosystem balance is hanging on by.

The issue with extinction is while it's natural for a few species to go extinct, due to human influence we are losing between 1,000 and 10,000 times higher than the natural extinction rate. (Source: http://wwf.panda.org/about_our_earth/biodiversity/biodiversi...)

We are part of the ecosystem we are damaging. You may take it for granted that animals continue to pollinate the plants you eat at dinner time. You make take it for granted that vultures cleaning up the dead prevent the spread of disease. There are many other cases of how the ecosystem is all tied together in a way that is integral to the human race's survival.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by chrismcb on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:26AM (#10251028)
Maybe we don't figure out why an ecosystem went wonky until the species is extinct. Reintroduction of wolves in Yellowstone us a great example.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by dredmorbius on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:49PM (#10249047)
Loss of species diversity, 50 million years of evolution, and potentially profound impacts on ecosystems.

Look for the story in the past year or so about dramatic impacts of reintroducing wolves to Yellowstone.

How Wolves Change Rivers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q

http://www.livescience.com/17263-yellowstone-wolf-environmen...

Destroy a species and it's gone forever.

Moreover, if you're looking to eliminate suffering, it's humans and their rampant overconsumption which are driving that. Not the elephant.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by codyb on Monday September 21, 2015 @12:11AM (#10250324)
Thanks for sharing that video, I'd heard of keystone species before but never have I had it so concretely shown to me just how vital and vast the effects can be. Really enjoyed the watch.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by thesteamboat on Sunday September 20, 2015 @06:15PM (#10249385)
> Why does it matter if, say, elephants go extinct? If they're extinct they're not suffering.

That's the same logic a cartoon supervillain uses to justify a plan for destroying the world.

To answer your question directly. I believe that elephants probably have inner lives at least as rich as humans with severe developmental problems, and thus should probably be afforded the same level of legal protection.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @06:27PM (#10249416)
That statement was made in the context of the relative morality of exterminating a species or enslaving it and forcing it to reproduce in order to feed on it.

So yes, the same logic applies to humans; I would prefer the human race including myself to be wiped out if the alternative was Matrix-style enslavement.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by thesteamboat on Sunday September 20, 2015 @07:03PM (#10249548)
If our only choices were exterminating elephants or raising them for food, I might agree with you. But that's not even close to the situation in the world today.

Elephants are not in the same position as cattle. When lab-grown meat is a viable alternative there may well be a decision to abandon ranching (and by extension cows as a species) en masse. But we don't depend on eating elephants for food; people kill elephants for status reasons (ivory, 'medicines').

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by meric on Sunday September 20, 2015 @09:24PM (#10249929)
You don't depend on elephants for food, it doesn't mean no one else does.

    Once an elephant is shot, the villagers just start to appear. Word gets out fast.
    
    It is like a celebration when an elephant is killed, the entire village will join in.
    
    The natives cut all of the meat off the bone and take it to their village to eat.
    They don’t let anything go to waste.
http://gothunts.com/see-what-happens-to-an-elephant-after-el...

You're right, there is a distinction. We don't imprison elephants and raise them for the sole purpose of imprisonment, impregnation and death.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by hvis on Sunday September 20, 2015 @09:20PM (#10249916)
Speak for yourself. I'd choose enslavement over extermination in a heartbeat.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by dacohenii on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:09PM (#10249144)
Radiolab has a new episode about this called "Rhino Hunter" about this type of thing: (show and description here: http://www.radiolab.org/story/rhino-hunter/)

It talks about how hunting is used as a funding mechanism for conservation, and in general the ethics of whether (and how) killing an individual could benefit the species as a whole.

If you have 50 or so minutes to spare, I highly recommend it.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by drdeca on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:10PM (#10248868)
Of those two, poaching seems to me more likely to reduce the number that remain in the wild.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by rbritton on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:09PM (#10248865)
Without picking a side, one notable difference is the sustainability of ranching. To my knowledge it hasn't driven many species to the brink of extinction (though maybe it has contributed indirectly by changing the habitat?)
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by quickquicker on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:57PM (#10249329)
One case that comes to mind is that of wolves in Montana: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/05/science/earth/conflict-ove...
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:42PM (#10249018)
The sustainability of an evil act is a con, not a pro.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by elektromekatron on Sunday September 20, 2015 @06:15PM (#10249382)
On that logic, murderers would be better if they killed everyone, as then murder would not be sustainable.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @06:30PM (#10249431)
Certainly there are situations where killing is more ethical than prolonged suffering. We kill injured or sick animals to 'put them out of their misery' all the time.

Isn't killing someone preferable to enslaving and torturing them and forcing them to reproduce so that you may do the same to their descendants?

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by eimai134 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @12:37PM (#10259711)
I agree - factory farming and even most "humane" farms are horrid. It would be better if we didn't eat meat (for our health, the environment, and ending world hunger). Then a smaller number of these animals could be pets or live on nature preserves.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by fosk on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:09PM (#10248863)
We don't necessarily have to choose: they are both unethical and evil activities.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:35PM (#10248973)
I agree, I just can't see why people vilify poachers and not ranchers.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by DanBC on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:38PM (#10248997)
Because thes submitted article is about poachers, not ranchers.

When someone submits an article about ranchers you don't get comments saying "but don't forget the elephant poachers".

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by simonh on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:39PM (#10249255)
It's because biodiversity is beneficial to all species on Earth because it makes for a more resilient and stable ecosystem. Poaching endangered species tends to drive those doecies to extinction, reducing biodiversity which as I've explained is a common good for all living species. Ranching maintains biodiversity by establishing an equilibrium artificial ecosystem. Combined with conservation, it contributes to economic prosperity and sustainable management of a rich and resilient ecology.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by eimai134 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @12:42PM (#10259748)
People do vilify ranchers. There are tons of organizations that are fighting against animal farming, and it's a movement that is gaining a lot of traction. Like others have said, people just aren't talking about here since this article is about poaching.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by eruditely on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:04PM (#10249121)
Because the article is about poachers you moralizer.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:24PM (#10249193)
I'm not moralizing, parent was moralizing about poachers.

I couldn't care less about elephants or cattle. I just can't stand cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy.

Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by chrismcb on Monday September 21, 2015 @04:35AM (#10251062)
What cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy? If some says "I don't like x" do you think they need to enumerate everything they like or dislike as well? Perhaps the op thinks ranchers are shitty too, except the article mentioned poachers. Why would the op then make a non sequitur about ranchers?
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by perfTerm on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:59PM (#10249095)
Who said anything about ranchers? Where do you come up with this presumption about ranchers based on gps simple "poachers are shitty"? This is an article about poachers, thus the comment talking about poachers.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:02PM (#10249110)
Because elephants and lions and whatnot being poached makes international news and ranching is business as usual. Clearly there is a substantial population that believes the former is wrong while the latter is not.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by eimai134 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @12:34PM (#10259695)
Ranchers are shitty too.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by beams_of_light on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:37PM (#10248991)
Ranchers are breeding animals for food. Humans are omnivorous, and it relieves us of the burden of hours of hunting. Elephants are not poached for food, they are poached mainly for their tusks. One could reason that this is an egregiously unnecessary waste of one of the most intelligent species on Earth.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by aianus on Sunday September 20, 2015 @04:41PM (#10249010)
Would you rather have a normal life and be shot for your teeth as an adult or grow up your whole life in a cage being force-fed and end up shot for your meat anyways?
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by disordinary on Sunday September 20, 2015 @05:59PM (#10249338)
Neither. Society is changing, at least in the West, eventually all animals will be treated humanely and reared in conditions that are not only better for the animal physically but allow them to interact and socialise as they would do in the wild, and therefore its better for them mentally.
Re:Elephants Shot with Poison Arrows Travel to Humans for Help by eimai134 on Tuesday September 22, 2015 @12:43PM (#10259760)
Yes! It's exciting to see how animal rights is becoming the next big social justice movement.