News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by drnewman on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:03AM (#10238457)
Don't know anyone's ages here, but is anyone fascinated by the historical implications of this? I started using Linux in the 90's and the talk in the community at the time was "world domination". It seems to me that's happened--more or less behind the scenes, but it's happened.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by ChrisArgyle on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:04AM (#10239246)
I couldn't disargee more about Microsoft's current place in tech markets. They've lost quite a lot of weight since their 800lb gorilla days in the 90s.

They used to exploit their dominant market position to replace de-facto standards with their own: kerberos "extensions", creating ActiveX instead of just implementing NPAPI, removing JNI from the MS JVM. But they can't do that any more. They lost too much ground under Ballmer.

Now they're nearly tripping over themselves promoting their cross-platform tolerance. Run Linux in our cloud! Run our apps on all the platforms! Sync/connect our apps/devices to any service!

Source: Age 34, started with Linux in '97 (Slackware 3.2)

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by thwarted on Monday September 21, 2015 @09:35PM (#10256182)
I couldn't disargee more about Microsoft's current place in tech markets. They've lost quite a lot of weight since their 800lb gorilla days in the 90s.

You are aware that the "World Domination" being referred to was talk of Linux's World Domination, right? So you're not disagreeing, you're supporting the observation that Linux eventually dethroned the 800 lb gorilla and that the 800 lb gorilla is a shadow of what it once was.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by cbd1984 on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:42AM (#10239449)
For all the Old People, replace Microsoft with IBM above and transpose this back into the 1990s.

IBM went from EBCDIC and Micro Channel Architecture and SNA to "Well, they'll never actually beat Compaq and Dell in the primary growth market, but they still own the tippy-top of the Enterprise world. That's something."

Oh, and about this time, IBM shifted focus from AIX to getting behind Linux in a big way. Remember the TV commercials?

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by npsimons on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:57AM (#10239550)
37, started using Linux in '98 (what can I say, late bloomer), but ran OS/2 before that as "rebelling against the M$ hegemony" (plus OS/2 was technically superior). I still have some of the IBM Linux ads.

I still don't trust Microsoft and even if I did, I consider most of their offerings piss-poor and only "industry standard" because the "industry" is run by upper management idiots. (note that the "industry" I refer here to is most definitely not SV or startups; think old, entrenched organizations that have no impetus to change or improve. You know, like government orgs. Or Microsoft).

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by dx211 on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:41PM (#10240718)
40, started using Linux in '93 or '94. You're probably old enough to realize that even though you're kind of in the same casino, those "upper management idiots" are playing a vastly different game than you or your startup. What portion of your work, for example, is spent figuring out whether the EU is going to give you a seven-figure fine for not localizing something, or whether a vendor from a non-NATO country can troubleshoot a server with a given client's PII on it, or whether the update you're pushing this week has been tested to make sure none of the 27 major products that take dependency on it are going to break? If your only metric is how much chrome the end user sees...
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by WorldWideWayne on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:05PM (#10240374)
Yeah, it's so surprising that Microsoft didn't implement the "Netscape Plugin Application Programming Interface" (which was just for web browses) or other interfaces that weren't build for Windows.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by throwawaykf05 on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:11PM (#10241773)
Not only was NPAPI developed by a rival company, it was specific to browsers. ActiveX allowed features from any (Windows) application to be embedded into any other (Windows) application, not just browsers. It was a strictly more general framework and thus a better option for Microsoft. What really screwed things up was, security was not one of the foremost considerations when designing ActiveX because it was conceived for the desktop world. So it was horribly insecure when applied to arbitrary content downloaded over the web.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by noir_lord on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:14AM (#10238500)
I'm 35, started using Linux in '97 so I've been around for most of the history.

It's quite amazing how Microsoft has changed in that time tbh from "Embrace, Extinguish, Extend" and all the shenanigans they pulled with comparing Win2k vs Linux/Samba and the halloween memo through to submitting code to the kernel, using Linux as a guest in their VM stuff and now using it internally not to mention making .Net a first class citizen (which when it's done will be incredible, I love C# as a language but in Linux land it's not quite their yet compared to on Windows).

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by DanBC on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:33AM (#10238574)
MS used to really trash open source, with Ballmer calling GPL "cancer". (Although the company pulled back from that extreme).

When MS took over Hotmail they got rid of FreeBSD that was running it.

But MS have used Unix for years. They released MS IE for Unix. (The only person I know who ever used it was on HN.) Perhaps more bizarre was the Windows Media Player for Unix. Their TCP/IP stack was from BSD for ages (and possibly other stuff. The EULA used to refer to the regents of Berkley.)

http://betanews.com/2001/06/18/microsoft-we-use-freebsd/

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5182249

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by dalke on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:47AM (#10238608)
The first Unix I ever touched was Microsoft's Xenix. Wikipedia says MS first released Xenix in 1980.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by cbd1984 on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:44AM (#10239460)
For a while, Xenix was the best-selling Unix under the sun.

(But not the Sun. It ran on commodity 16-bit IBM PCs.)

((I refuse to resist puns. They just flow through me.))

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by dalke on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:01PM (#10239957)
(((Flowing like Sun light through Windows.)))
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by amyjess on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:30PM (#10241131)
> I refuse to resist puns. They just flow through me.

Then you'll like this one.

When I was in college, we had a computer lab full of Sun workstations running Solaris. It was officially called the Solarium.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by astrodust on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:29PM (#10241123)
What's also crazy is it ran on the 80286, something most PC-based UNIX systems never even tried to pull off.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by ams6110 on Friday September 18, 2015 @09:35PM (#10242966)
Minix ran on 8086s
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by dunham on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:24PM (#10242396)
I downloaded and played with IE for Solaris, but I didn't use it for day to day browsing. One interesting thing that I recall from it was that it had .so files that corresponded to each of the windows DLLs. So it looked like they had some sort of framework for porting windows code to Unix.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by thwarted on Monday September 21, 2015 @10:00PM (#10256260)
There used to be a page from the IE for UNIX porting team[0] that talked about the challenges of a direct port. Last I checked, only a copy of the content could be found on a mailing list post[1].

There's some interesting stuff in there. This one always seemed like a weird problem:

    Global variables in Win32 dynamic-link libraries (DLLs) are visible across
    processes, so it is important that developers are careful that these globals
    do not conflict with any variables within the Unix shared libraries.
At least in the way it is presented. What does variables in DLLs being visible across processes on Windows have to do with variables in other libraries? Of course they need to be uniquely referenced.

[0] http://tech.slashdot.org/story/98/11/17/1624254/microsoft-pr...

[1] http://www.linux.cz/pipermail/linux/1999-September/051669.ht...

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by ams6110 on Friday September 18, 2015 @09:38PM (#10242974)
IE originated as Spyglass Mosaic, formerly NCSA Mosaic, a unix browser. So it was more like they ported unix code to Windows.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by teddyh on Saturday September 19, 2015 @09:45AM (#10244267)
Spyglass did not use any of the code from NCSA Mosaic¹.

① http://ericsink.com/Browser_Wars.html

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by caskance on Friday September 18, 2015 @09:42AM (#10239115)
GPL is cancer, but in a good way.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by donatj on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:23PM (#10241836)
I have misgivings about GPL. It's given me a lot, and I appreciate that, but while developing I won't use GPL libraries because I simply don't like being told what to do, and per the golden rule, I don't like telling people what to do, so I cannot with good moral standing release GPL code.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by gillianseed on Friday September 18, 2015 @05:30PM (#10242171)
Well in the case of GPL, what you are not allowed to do is to use GPL licensed code with yours and decide not to give recipients of the resulting code the same rights that you were given.

I personally think that makes for a decent 'moral standing'.

Basically GPL only a problem if you want to create proprietary software, which in turn is typically very much a 'being told what you can do with said software' type of situation, with no code and often incorporating DRM mechanisms to prevent copying.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Spivak on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:46PM (#10241962)
Libraries? Most of those are licensed under the LGPL precisely that reason.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by donatj on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:27PM (#10242410)
The vast majority of my code is either in scripted uncompiled form, or statically linked. Wordpress implied a while back that using uncompiled GPL libraries made your code GPL. I'm no license expert, I'd rather just not risk it.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by teddyh on Saturday September 19, 2015 @09:47AM (#10244274)
If you “don’t like telling people what to do”, you must be licensing all your code as CC0 or public domain, right?
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by donatj on Saturday September 19, 2015 @06:39PM (#10245777)
Some public domain, mostly MIT. All MIT really asks is to give me credit if they use my code.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by TallGuyShort on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:30AM (#10239382)
The more commonly used term is viral, which these days, I think captures the can-be-the-right-choice/can-be-the-wrong-choice nature, while still saying it spreads to most things it touches.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by debacle on Friday September 18, 2015 @09:19AM (#10238989)
The GPL is a cancerous license, and Ballmer had to trash open source. That was their business model and they were using the OSS association against Novell.

Edit: For those of you downmodding me for saying that the GPL is a cancerous license, please understand that this isn't a negative connotation - it's simply an aspect of the requirements of the license. It's very likely a good thing, and part of the reason that Linux is doing well while BSDs have languished.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scardine on Friday September 18, 2015 @03:11PM (#10241412)
It is not cancerous, it is just infectious. And not by accident, it is by design.

I used to like GPL, so nobody would "steal" my code adding it to a closed source product. I don't care anymore, just use BSD or other credit-where-credit-is-due license: my code was included in a high profile closed source product? Lots of bragging points and free publicity!

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yarrel on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:31PM (#10240134)
The GPL isn't "cancerous. If you must use a negative biological term to do the work of smearing it, try "congenital".
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Touche on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:52PM (#10241296)
> It's very likely a good thing, and part of the reason that Linux is doing well while BSDs have languished.

You're mistaken if you believe that.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Spivak on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:51PM (#10241988)
Hey, you're not wrong. Linus used the GPLv2 only because it allowed him to get patches back into the kernel. He's neither a fan of the FSF nor the GPLv3 because of their philosophy on software freedom.

Linux is by far more popular for developers, tinkerers, and cool software projects but BSD is still massive in the server and embedded devices space.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by belorn on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:50PM (#10242477)
Massive for servers?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...

BSD is a minority in servers, which also reflect my own experience talking with other sysadmins in conferences. Debian and Redhat are huge in the server market, outside of windows shops. Some older system might have novel or a BSD system running together with massive amount of legacy perl scripts, but those companies also complain that they have a hard time finding new employees that can support the old systems.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Aldo_MX on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:11AM (#10239621)
The GPL is not a cancerous license, if I would use a negative adjective to describe it, it would be: misused.

I understand when people wants to keep making FOSS better by releasing entire projects with a GPL license, but I don't understand when people release simple stuff such as a code example with a GPL license...

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by debacle on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:36AM (#10239784)
The GPL is a cancerous license. If you use GPLed code, your code must (almost always) become GPLed, thus the GPLed codebase grows. If a GPLed project use other OSS code, it tends to be able to keep those changes, but the opposite can't generally be reciprocated (You can't take GPLed aspects of Linux and port them to a project under the BSD license without changing the license of that software).

This is not a bad thing. It sometimes sucks, but overall it's helped preserve the ecosystem and it has been integral, IMHO, in making sure companies stay honest with their upstream OSS meal tickets.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by robotresearcher on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:11PM (#10240988)
> This is not a bad thing.

Which is why cancer is not a good metaphor.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by throwawaykf05 on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:26PM (#10241852)
Way to quote selectively there. "It sometimes sucks" occurs more frequently for many people than many would like to admit. I work for a company that uses a ton of open source and open sources a ton of its own technology. Even for us, the GPL is poison. We're not allowed to touch GPL code. And we're not alone in this sentiment. A large number of open source enthusiasts decry the viral nature of the GPL, precisely because it has unpleasant properties common with cancer.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by belorn on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:25PM (#10242400)
If GPL is cancer for a company, then what then is proprietary licenses? nuclear bombs? Toxic waste? Ticking time bombs?

I don't think such language is nice. It is damaging to civil conversation and can only alienate people more. No one likes hearing that what they create is like toxic waste.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by throwawaykf05 on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:52PM (#10281197)
How are proprietary licenses any better or worse than the GPL? It totally depends on what the terms of the license demand.

Note that it is not the code that these people produce that is toxic, it is what they demand in return (via the terms of the license) that is. The language may not be nice, but it is descriptive of the situation the GPL puts many people into. The GPL essentially seeks to impose the ideology adopted by a subset of folks onto the rest of the world. "We believe code should be free, so if you want to use our stuff, your code must be free too, regardless of what you believe or what your business needs are or what is practical." That is not a very nice stance to have, and so many people do not say nice things about it.

Think of it like someone saying, "Here, I'll do you a favor, but you must change your religion". Having different ideologies is perfectly fine, but enforcing them on others is not.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hvs on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:16PM (#10241033)
I think the reason for the downvotes is that there are positive/neutral things that grow without the negative connotations of "cancer."
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Friday September 18, 2015 @10:32AM (#10239391)
Don't forget Halloween Memo X, along with as I remember stuff from GrokLaw, which revealed that Microsoft funneled 86 million to SCO when it was litigating SCO v. The Open Source World.

(Especially bogus because SCO knew in advance they didn't have the rights to UNIX(TM), but I doubt Microsoft knew that.)

I'll bet that by itself had consequences.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by valarauca1 on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:22PM (#10240080)
When Microsoft sold the Xenix license to SCO it took its payment in stock. Mircosoft owned ~25% of SCO during these legal battles.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:59PM (#10240332)
Huh, I don't remember that, especially if those were the two different SCOs. The first, the Santa Cruz Operation, was OK ignoring some quality issues, and they are the organization that Microsoft got 25% of through that transaction in 1987. Much later, in 2001, this happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Cruz_Operation#Asset_sal...

And Caldera, which renamed itself in the next year to The SCO Group, got all of the original SCO's assets but Tarantella. Not sure what happened with Microsoft's ownership of the original SCO, but I don't remember through the years of SCO v. The World that Microsoft had a large ownership stake ... which would have been major.

Instead, per http://www.catb.org/esr/halloween/halloween10.html and my memory of Groklaw ..., well, here's ESR's first summation paragraph:

There you have it. At least a third of SCO's entire market capitalization, and their entire current cash reserves, is payoffs funnelled from Microsoft. Their 10Qs reveal that every other line of cash inflow is statistical noise by comparison. The brave new SCOsource business model is now clear: sue your customers, shill for Microsoft, kite your stock, and pray you stay out of jail.

I also seem to remember some Microsoft related deal involving the purchase of Novell SUSE? licenses, although now I can't remember if The SCO Group directly benefited from it.

Microsoft earned this part of its bad reputation, and I'm sure I'm not the only one who's purchases from the company in part ended with Windows XP prior to that (of course, it helped that Vista was long delayed and awful). Supporting Microsoft back then was unconscionable.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by valarauca1 on Monday September 21, 2015 @10:59AM (#10252728)
To fill in your missing memory

In 1987 Microsoft sold Xenix to Santa Cruise Operations Group for a 25% ownership shared of Santa Cruise Operations Group.

In 1993 Caldera purchases Santa Cruise Operations Group, and renamed their collective company to SCO Group. Caldrea was part of Canopy Group which has a lot of subsidiaries.

Round about 2003 the SCO vs. Linux fight started. Microsoft still owned Caldrea stock, and provided them financial assistance as they attempted to sue the entire world.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Monday September 21, 2015 @11:57AM (#10253102)
In 1993 Caldera purchases Santa Cruise Operations Group, and renamed their collective company to SCO Group.

As noted in my posting replying to you, that doesn't match my memory or Wikipedia, can you provide any citations to support it?

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by valarauca1 on Monday September 21, 2015 @12:45PM (#10253471)
Sorry in 2001 Caldrea didn't purchase Santa Cruise Operations Group outright. It just purchased everything relating to Unix.

After this sale Santa Cruise Operations Group changed its named to TARANTELLA inc. While concurrently Caldrea founded SCO Group, which was built on the purchased Santa Cruise Operations Group software.

Agreement and Plan of Reorganization:

http://sec.edgar-online.com/tarantella-inc/8-k-current-repor...

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by x5n1 on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:27AM (#10238548)
They don't have a choice. Linux has already won. Heard of Android? Yeah that's the Linux kernel right there, over a billion mobile devices. Heard of Mac OS? That's a Unix kernel right there. Microsoft makes a proprietary operating system with cumbersome licensing restrictions. Microsoft is 10 years from death if it does not embrace Linux.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday September 18, 2015 @08:29AM (#10238742)
> Microsoft is 10 years from death if it does not embrace Linux.

FWIW, I remember people saying this in 1999 as well...

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by npsimons on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:04AM (#10239588)
The IBM comparison is really apt. IBM hasn't died, they used to dominate like Microsoft, with all the same underhanded tactics, and they eventually came around.

There's also the "culture wars" to consider, where many (myself included) revered IBM for superior alternatives (OS/2), while old timers would just shake their head at anyone trusting them. Now, I shake my head at anyone trusting Microsoft, although they've tamped down their rabid attacks on open source and Linux, and they do offer some things that aren't complete garbage.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:03PM (#10239963)
IBM at its peak was much more dominant than Microsoft ever was. Microsoft -- thanks to IBM (via PC DOS and Basic) -- eventually became the IBM of software. But Intel became the IBM of processors, Cisco the IBM of routers, Google the IBM of the web, and so on. IBM was the IBM of everything.

Incidentally, Microsoft co-developed OS/2 and there were only three problems with it: (1) you couldn't sell PCs running OS/2 -- IBM tried; (2) you couldn't get software houses to write programs for OS/2 -- except maybe Lotus; and (3) you couldn't get end users to install it. You had to install a whole OS to run OS/2, but Windows installed just like any other DOS program, and you could delete it if you decided you didn't like it.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yuhong on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:34PM (#10242426)
Yea, this OS/2 2.0 fiasco used to my favorite topic, and I have plenty of bad things to say about MS's behavior there.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:41PM (#10242682)
Windows was selling well while OS/2 sales were, to quote Gates, "dismal", and Microsoft couldn't afford to support a failing project. (IBM may have had more programmers on OS/2 than Microsoft had programmers.)

Thanks to hiring Dave Cutler and staff from DEC, Microsoft could see a way out. However, IBM rejected the plan to move to NT as OS/2 3.0, and the two companies formally divorced. After that, IBM did its best to kill Microsoft. (One IBM senior manager told me: "We're going to burn Bill's butt.")

Bear in mind that in 1990, when Windows 3 came out, IBM had an annual turnover of $69 billion and Microsoft's turnover was $0.8 billion. It was a giant monopolist against a tiny start-up.

So, given the context, what was underhand about Microsoft's behavior, and what should it have done?

How did IBM's 1991 development of Workplace OS for PowerPC -- intended to cut both Microsoft and Intel out of the PC market -- fit into the strategy?

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yuhong on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:58PM (#10242732)
I am also talking about a few years later, up to the "Chicago"/Win95 period when the attacks really got nasty.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Saturday September 19, 2015 @08:01AM (#10244049)
A period when IBM was spending more than $1 billion a year on OS/2 and WorkPlace OS to try to kill Microsoft? A period when IBM formed an alliance with Apple and Motorola to create a PC Reference Platform to try to kill both Microsoft and Intel? Up to the point in 1995 where IBM spent $3.5 billion on Lotus and used SmartSuite bundling to try to kill Microsoft Office?

Microsoft's turnover had grown to $5.3 billion in 1995, but IBM's turnover was $72 billion, and it was still a brutal monopolist targeting a much smaller company.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Saturday September 19, 2015 @09:14AM (#10244193)
Indeed, people like me were cheering Microsoft back in that period.

I started programming in 1978, on IBM systems, and they were indeed "a brutal monopolist", probably feared more than Microsoft has ever been.

Sure, during the early-mid '90s Microsoft had sharp elbows and was looking out for its own interests, but those also just happened to coincide with ours. IBM was big, stupid and much more dangerous, UNIX(TM) was horribly fragmented (one of the core competencies I developed in the early '80s was porting software between different versions of it, and see The Unix Haters Handbook publishing in 1994: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Unix-Haters_Handbook (disclaimer, Simson is a friend)).

GNU/the FSF was doing worthwhile stuff, but was and still is hanging fire on a kernel, the BSD porting efforts had been crippled by the '92-3 AT&T lawsuit, Linux was started from scratch in 1991 and immature, while NT was developed by well funded top notch experienced people (at least back then it was very rare if not unheard of for someone to develop more than one operating system, the process was so onerous) and was a great hope for a lot of us. In the mid '90s I developed or took part in developing several very solid systems using it, and I believe it's TCO and maintainability exceeded UNIX(TM) during that period.

Unfortunately, Microsoft started fumbling the ball about 3-4 years after NT's release (on or after the first Service Pack of NT 3.5 or more likely 3.51 as I recall), NT 4 was conceptually hopeless by moving graphics into the kernel, "and the rest is history".

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:45PM (#10245969)
Good points.

Microsoft, of course, had a major problem, which was how to get the market to move from DOS-based Windows to NT. Not even offering OEMs 75% off the price of NT managed to shift them. Ultimately, Microsoft had to do whatever it took, and not all of it was nice. It didn't manage to do it until XP in 2001.

Re Unix, you have missed out the COSE/Hamilton group development of OSF/1, first released in 1991. This was supposed to unify most of the major players -- DEC, HP, IBM etc -- except Sun* behind a single Unix to prevent Microsoft from getting into corporate computing with NT.

Presumably you would have come across it....

* OSF = "Oppose Sun Forever" according to Scott McNealy

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Saturday September 19, 2015 @09:43PM (#10246264)
"Oppose Sun Forever", heh.

Yes, indeed, I used it in 1996-7 on the Alpha, just after it was renamed Digital Unix from DEC OSF/1 AXP. It was very nice, ran everything we wanted well, plus had a great High Availability capability. But I didn't view it as a major contender, back then at least, Sun provided the systems of choice. Assuming you could manage to buy them.

As for Win 16 -> Win 98 -> XP ... I don't know, I went from Windows 3.1 to NT, and as far as I could tell NT was better and more stable than the legacy non-memory protected stuff; hmmm, but I'll bet not for games (and NT4 putting graphics in the kernel was ugly). XP was great, and due to things mentioned elsewhere, I and then my parents used it for more than a decade.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Sunday September 20, 2015 @07:29AM (#10247170)
Yes, NT was much more stable than Windows 95/98/98SE, and technically superior. Unfortunately it wouldn't run quite a lot of Windows programs, and one of them was whatever we used for AOL access, which was quite important at the time.

I dual-booted the two types of Windows way back then, and it was just too hard to stay on the NT side....

To some extent (possibly a large extent), OSF/1 was a push against the AT&T/Sun effort to unify Unix with SVR4. It just ended up more fractured than ever, which was a shame.

There was a brief window when Unix could perhaps have been more successful. That was between DOS and the Windows vs OS/2 war, when Microsoft Xenix was relatively successful. However, IBM was dead against Unix at the time, and OS/2 EE was meant to be the IBM-owned cornerstone of its Systems Application Architecture.

Unix could run on everything from PCs to Amdahl mainframes and supercomputers, whereas IBM had two major mainframe operating systems, at least five on minicomputers, plus workstations and desktops. No wonder IBM saw Unix as a massive threat to its account control.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yuhong on Saturday September 19, 2015 @02:06PM (#10245035)
If MS went with "NT OS/2" I doubt "OS/2 for PowerPC" would exist, which was a stripped down version of the "Workplace OS" you mentioned BTW. Interestingly, Windows NT themselves was ported to PowerPC too, and it was one of the main focus for NT 3.51 back in 1995.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:29PM (#10245924)
Well, Microsoft did go with "NT OS/2" -- it just quickly replaced intended OS/2 compatablility with Windows compatibility.

Otherwise, IBM claimed Workplace OS was new code.

NT, of course, wasn't written for x86 in the first place. It was intended to be cross-platform. It was also sold on PCs with DEC Alpha chips.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yuhong on Saturday September 19, 2015 @07:46PM (#10245972)
Of course, the problems with this plan wasn't the WinNT part, it was the Win95/Chicago part. My favorite technical problem is how it's dependence on DOS led Caldera to continue their DR-DOS lawsuit. But it wasn't just the technical problems, there was also the tactics MS used to attack OS/2 2.x and later.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Sunday September 20, 2015 @11:12AM (#10247797)
Win95 was cheap, easy to install (no reformat needed), had masses of software support, and sold well. Microsoft would have preferred to sell NT but the market voted with its wallet. (By the way, Win95 mainly used DOS as a loader.)

Otherwise, which tactics were unacceptable in the context of a small company being attacked by a giant monopolist that wanted to drive it out of business?

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yuhong on Sunday September 20, 2015 @01:31PM (#10248287)
I am comparing it with OS/2 2.x not NT.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scholia on Monday September 21, 2015 @08:23AM (#10251692)
As I pointed out above: "there were only three problems with it: (1) you couldn't sell PCs running OS/2 -- IBM tried; (2) you couldn't get software houses to write programs for OS/2 -- except maybe Lotus; and (3) you couldn't get end users to install it. You had to install a whole OS to run OS/2, but Windows installed just like any other DOS program, and you could delete it if you decided you didn't like it."

Microsoft realized that you couldn't force people to buy something they (rightly or wrongly) didn't want, and decided to sell them something they did want. Small companies are like that. Being a global giant with a long history of monopoly power (going back to the 1930s), IBM didn't think like that.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by MaysonL on Friday September 18, 2015 @05:20PM (#10242123)
I used to work with a guy who used to be the DP VP [what's called CIO these days] at the only Fortune 100 firm that didn't have a corporate IBM mainframe (although a subsidiary or two did, IIRC). IBM tried a number of times to get him fired (such tactics as golfing partners of the CEO saying that he was really incompetent, etc.). They played hardball, and probably still do, when they can.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by astrodust on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:31PM (#10241141)
Don't confuse "death" with "irrelevance".

There are companies out there still shambling along that used to be dominant but are now ghostly memories of their former selves.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by tracker1 on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:24PM (#10240553)
Microsoft is not going to die if it doesn't embrace Linux... that said, they are much more open today than a decade and a half ago. .Net Core is making a lot of progress and has respawned interest in C# cross platform. I think a lot of this is in the light of what happened with Oracle v Google.

There's also, XBox itself and Azure, which are key points to the future of MS along with Office, which will now grow to other platforms, as it should have some time ago.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by pakled_engineer on Friday September 18, 2015 @03:21PM (#10241477)
This assumes tomorrow MS doesn't drop a BSD licensed Android clone of their own and clean up in that market.

I thought Facebook was going to die out too then they became defacto telecoms in the developing world through WhatsApp/Internet.Org, and now have a billion users.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by osullivj on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:17AM (#10238509)
Yes, Linux has dominated the commodity server space. Look what happened to Sun & Solaris. But what about the desktop? Back in the late 90s there was much talk of how the Linux desktop would take over, KDE vs Gnome etc. IBM and Sun backed Open Office, Andy Herzfeld launched Nautilus. And then it didn't happen. MS still owns the business desktop with Windows & Office. And MS still has a big chunk of the consumer desktop, though Apple has taken a lot of it with MacOS.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by anon4 on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:56AM (#10238641)
People focused on innovating too quickly without building enough stability. Plus, programmers started imagining they could innovate as designers and we have Gnome 3, Unity, etc. All built for a mythical herd of grandmas who run linux, but need it to be user-friendly, in some imagined user-friendly way.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by reitanqild on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:38PM (#10241191)

  Plus, programmers started imagining they 
  could innovate as designers and we have 
  Gnome 3, Unity, etc.
I always thought those happened because someone allowed designers to make decisions on the projects? "Usability" I think has been the main driver behind a lot of the problems I have experienced over the last few years.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by realusername on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:44AM (#10238597)
Yes for sure but the desktop itself is not the end of the game anymore, yes Microsoft still owns the desktop but on mobile and tablets, it's another story.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by organsnyder on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:10PM (#10240011)
The desktop market is still mostly Windows & MacOS, but if we instead look at client devices in general, Microsoft is losing quite badly: Android (running a Linux kernel) and iOS (BSD-derived, like MacOS) have almost all of the market share, with Windows struggling to make much of a dent.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by frik on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:16PM (#10240492)
With a proper open source Web based Office alternative, MS Office would loose a lot of customers.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by r3bl on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:37PM (#10240670)
From my own perspective, both LibreOffice and Google Docs are both more then capable enough. I know that LibreOffice is primarily a desktop application, but it has a not-so-perfect remote web interface since version 3.5.

But, for filling out forms and keeping the design as it is, I'm currently using a web interface of Office 365. It's a bit annoying to use it at the moment (you can't get rid of the constant "Install Word on Your Device" messages and you first have to upload your document on OneDrive before you can edit it), but it gets the job done.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by tluyben2 on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:35PM (#10241901)
The problem is that other solutions are just not good enough to deliver the exact end product to send to clients or partners or management. We do everything in Google docs because it is just really nice and convenient but when it needs to be finalised for sending off we send it to the one person with a MS Office license who fixes it. I would never condone paying more licenses though because when we all had MS Office licenses exactly the same thing happened... People writing content are usually not the people doing layout and design.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hga on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:35PM (#10240654)
Unless Microsoft ruins Office, I can't see it happening. I believe it would take a seriously funded company to implement all the needed features (sure, no one uses all the features of Word, but each uses a different vital set of them), prove that, oh, Excel was safe to run your company/trading on, and provide support.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by snnn on Friday September 18, 2015 @07:33AM (#10238573)
I'm 29, started using Linux in 2003 when I just bought my first PC.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by gaigepr on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:42PM (#10241930)
22. My first distro was Ubuntu 8.04. I remember struggling to get various windows games to work through the use of wine.