News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by debacle on Friday September 18, 2015 @09:19AM (#10238989)
The GPL is a cancerous license, and Ballmer had to trash open source. That was their business model and they were using the OSS association against Novell.

Edit: For those of you downmodding me for saying that the GPL is a cancerous license, please understand that this isn't a negative connotation - it's simply an aspect of the requirements of the license. It's very likely a good thing, and part of the reason that Linux is doing well while BSDs have languished.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by scardine on Friday September 18, 2015 @03:11PM (#10241412)
It is not cancerous, it is just infectious. And not by accident, it is by design.

I used to like GPL, so nobody would "steal" my code adding it to a closed source product. I don't care anymore, just use BSD or other credit-where-credit-is-due license: my code was included in a high profile closed source product? Lots of bragging points and free publicity!

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by yarrel on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:31PM (#10240134)
The GPL isn't "cancerous. If you must use a negative biological term to do the work of smearing it, try "congenital".
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Touche on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:52PM (#10241296)
> It's very likely a good thing, and part of the reason that Linux is doing well while BSDs have languished.

You're mistaken if you believe that.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Spivak on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:51PM (#10241988)
Hey, you're not wrong. Linus used the GPLv2 only because it allowed him to get patches back into the kernel. He's neither a fan of the FSF nor the GPLv3 because of their philosophy on software freedom.

Linux is by far more popular for developers, tinkerers, and cool software projects but BSD is still massive in the server and embedded devices space.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by belorn on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:50PM (#10242477)
Massive for servers?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_syste...

BSD is a minority in servers, which also reflect my own experience talking with other sysadmins in conferences. Debian and Redhat are huge in the server market, outside of windows shops. Some older system might have novel or a BSD system running together with massive amount of legacy perl scripts, but those companies also complain that they have a hard time finding new employees that can support the old systems.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by Aldo_MX on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:11AM (#10239621)
The GPL is not a cancerous license, if I would use a negative adjective to describe it, it would be: misused.

I understand when people wants to keep making FOSS better by releasing entire projects with a GPL license, but I don't understand when people release simple stuff such as a code example with a GPL license...

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by debacle on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:36AM (#10239784)
The GPL is a cancerous license. If you use GPLed code, your code must (almost always) become GPLed, thus the GPLed codebase grows. If a GPLed project use other OSS code, it tends to be able to keep those changes, but the opposite can't generally be reciprocated (You can't take GPLed aspects of Linux and port them to a project under the BSD license without changing the license of that software).

This is not a bad thing. It sometimes sucks, but overall it's helped preserve the ecosystem and it has been integral, IMHO, in making sure companies stay honest with their upstream OSS meal tickets.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by robotresearcher on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:11PM (#10240988)
> This is not a bad thing.

Which is why cancer is not a good metaphor.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by throwawaykf05 on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:26PM (#10241852)
Way to quote selectively there. "It sometimes sucks" occurs more frequently for many people than many would like to admit. I work for a company that uses a ton of open source and open sources a ton of its own technology. Even for us, the GPL is poison. We're not allowed to touch GPL code. And we're not alone in this sentiment. A large number of open source enthusiasts decry the viral nature of the GPL, precisely because it has unpleasant properties common with cancer.
Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by belorn on Friday September 18, 2015 @06:25PM (#10242400)
If GPL is cancer for a company, then what then is proprietary licenses? nuclear bombs? Toxic waste? Ticking time bombs?

I don't think such language is nice. It is damaging to civil conversation and can only alienate people more. No one likes hearing that what they create is like toxic waste.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by throwawaykf05 on Friday September 25, 2015 @06:52PM (#10281197)
How are proprietary licenses any better or worse than the GPL? It totally depends on what the terms of the license demand.

Note that it is not the code that these people produce that is toxic, it is what they demand in return (via the terms of the license) that is. The language may not be nice, but it is descriptive of the situation the GPL puts many people into. The GPL essentially seeks to impose the ideology adopted by a subset of folks onto the rest of the world. "We believe code should be free, so if you want to use our stuff, your code must be free too, regardless of what you believe or what your business needs are or what is practical." That is not a very nice stance to have, and so many people do not say nice things about it.

Think of it like someone saying, "Here, I'll do you a favor, but you must change your religion". Having different ideologies is perfectly fine, but enforcing them on others is not.

Re:Microsoft has developed its own Linux: in-house software-... by hvs on Friday September 18, 2015 @02:16PM (#10241033)
I think the reason for the downvotes is that there are positive/neutral things that grow without the negative connotations of "cancer."