News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by verelo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @12:55PM (#10192563)
I want to love CloudFlare, I really do. We currently use them, but sadly the number of times that CloudFlare has been the cause of a service interruption is somewhere around 50% mark. They are no longer in use on any critical/important end points, I just don't need PagerDuty waking us up over an issue I have no control over.

This is not a problem I expect to improve. As they start to cover all of the web, i imagine that it'll actually only get worse. Curious about how they see this progressing.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by saurik on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:02PM (#10192597)
I wrote an article a while back digging into the details of an outage in a website I work with caused by CloudFlare, and while at some level the issue here was "CloudFlare didn't care enough to test their stack against popular browsers and then didn't have the in-house expertise to debug and correct issues that were later found", I frankly feel like this problem is pretty engrained into their business :/. If nothing else, the article might be interesting to some as it looks at how to even go about debugging complex interactions between web browser internals and overly clever JavaScript. http://www.saurik.com/id/14 "When 'Dumb Pipes' Get Too Smart"
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by kevingadd on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @02:13PM (#10193079)
I used CloudFlare for a while and it consistently caused more problems than it solved. Really hard to debug, too. Injecting broken JS into pages, serving up corrupted cached assets, etc.

Better to just pay for Amazon CloudFront or something and set it all up myself...

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by billyhoffman on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:32PM (#10193777)
Those errors are usually caused by CloudFlare automatic Front-end Optimization (FEO) stuff, like trying to losslessly optimize images, add cache control, gzip, SPDY/HTTP2, etc. It used to be a primary marketing point, and while its still there (and still causing problems) they have moved away from promoting it so much.

Its best to use of them as a CDN, DDoS sink, and SSL. Their other stuff like FEO or their web app firewall stuff really isn't that impressive enough to be considered a reason for switching.

Disclaimer: I work in the web performance space, and used to work in the web security space. As a whole I'm not a fan of the "stick a magic appliance in front of a website to automatically stop [web security issues | web performance problems]" approach, whether from CloudFlare or otherwise.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by manigandham on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:37PM (#10193834)
Just disable all the optimization features and get the benefits of the SSL + DNS + CDN + DDOS protection.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chrissnell on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @02:40PM (#10193306)
I tried their enterprise tier out about 9 months ago and was entirely unimpressed. Moving a site from Akamai -> CF increased page load times dramatically. We ended up quickly switching back.

CloudFlare's complicity with ISIS, however, was what turned me off permanently. For those unaware, CloudFlare was providing proxy shielding of ISIS's propaganda websites. The CF CEO publicly refused to discontinue their service, taking an anti-censorship, pro-free-speech stance. His absolutist views didn't sit well with me and I consider their servicing of these domains to be aiding and abetting this criminal organization.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by lost_my_pwd on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:36PM (#10193822)
Interesting. This is the first I have heard of this and CloudFlare's reputation has just gone up my eyes because of it.

Is ISIS dangerous and deplorable? Sure. Are there ideas so dangerous that they do not deserve to be exposed to public discourse and judged on their merits? I don't think so.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by voidlogic on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:42PM (#10193908)
I don't follow; CloudFlare is not the government, therefore freedom of expression isn't really the issue here. Who they choose to give a voice to says a lot about them.

I would oppose the government censoring ISIS; however, I would be proud of any company that refused to to business with them.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:02PM (#10194120)
> Who they choose to give a voice to says a lot about them.

I don't think they're choosing to give anyone specific a voice. I think they're choosing not to make judgement calls.

Once you start blocking anyone, you've weakened your ability to refuse to block others. You'd see greater demands for blocking Wikileaks, censoring articles like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_prime, enforcing Europe's right-to-be-forgotten, etc. on the basis of "well you were willing to block ISIS".

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by hackinthebochs on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @11:00PM (#10195945)
CloudFlare isn't the government, and so they are under no legal obligation to allow certain content. But their hands-off approach is precisely what gives them the rational standing not to censor any website any group finds distasteful. Furthermore, the threat of censorship does not only come from governments. I don't want to live in a world where a handful of corporations can decide what speech is allowed to be disseminated. Opinions like yours lead us head first to such a world.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by gozo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:00PM (#10194100)
Shouldn't you also be upset over all the other service providers including your own ISP that also doesn't block those sites? Unless it's specifically against protecting people against criminal activity, in which case we are really going down a slippery slope.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by voidlogic on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:23PM (#10194288)
>Shouldn't you also be upset over all the other service providers including your own ISP that also doesn't block those sites?

I would argue that the moral dilemma is different if you choose to allow ISIS traffic to pass through you, vs have them as a client.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by erkkie on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:58PM (#10194539)
It might, but the business model Cloudflare is on makes the distinction less clear. For example with their free plans would they need to identify all clients, scan their content and judge accordingly?

For paid clients, I might be more sympathetic to the argument, but even then the (moral?) rules (for nonbusiness) are incredibly tricky to figure out and keep consistent. Selective enforcement is bad for everyone in the uncertainty it spawns.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by ryanlol on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @10:43PM (#10195908)
>For example with their free plans would they need to identify all clients, scan their content and judge accordingly?

Ever heard of this little thing called abuse reports?

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by duaneb on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:45PM (#10194451)
I would argue it's better for them to have their own site rather than fostering a samizdat culture.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by JesperRavn on Thursday September 10, 2015 @12:45AM (#10196182)
If no ISP will host your content, then your message cannot reach anyone, and you effectively have no freedom of expression.

I wonder why you oppose government censorship, if you applaud private businesses achieving the same effect? Certainly your reasons cant be the same as the post you're replying to[0], and so you're missing their point.

[0] in particular Are there ideas so dangerous that they do not deserve to be exposed to public discourse and judged on their merits? I don't think so.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by devicenull on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @08:00PM (#10195430)
How about sites that let you remove someone else's free speech? Cloudflare provides services for those too (DDoS-as-a-service).
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by rwhitman on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:28PM (#10194332)
Cloudflare may be under court order by the DoD to keep ISIS on their network and protecting classified information with the free speech rationalization. Anti terrorist operations are much easier to conduct when the terrorists are using American communications infrastructure.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by mhuffman on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:51PM (#10194493)
I actually get this. If they don't take a hardline on censorship, they would be inundated with "offended" people wanted every site on the Internet removed from their edge caches because someone in the world found them offensive. Much better to just say, "We don't censor, take it up with the website owner!"
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by Zirro on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:24PM (#10193678)
What would you prefer their policy on censorship be? Though I was unaware of CloudFlare and this situation, I believe that one compromise can easily lead to a slippery slope.

How do you see protocols (bittorrent or ipfs, for example) where content can not be removed as long as someone has a copy - are we better off without their existence in your opinion?

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by threatofrain on Thursday September 10, 2015 @12:01AM (#10196083)
ISIS, for all we know, could become a legitimate government in a context where legitimacy is clearly unclear. Why do we want CloudFlare to be involved in international politics and middle eastern wars?

Should an American business have an opinion on what Muslims, and other interested parties, ought to be viewing over the web with respect to ISIS? I would hope not. CloudFlare should not be in the business of judging whether Muslims and others are vulnerable to brainwashing from ISIS and need the protection of CloudFlare censorship, lest their fragile worldviews become corrupted.

Let the people of that region judge for themselves the future of their land.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by codexon on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:24PM (#10194724)
CloudFlare is also complicit with DDoS for sale websites. People have asked them to remove them or reveal their ips to report but they have refused. Here are a few of them.

http://cyberstresser.com/

https://spboot.net/

https://alphastress.com

https://vdos-s.com/

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by bduerst on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @02:49PM (#10193379)
I'm curious if you think ISPs should block ISIS websites, domains, and IP addresses.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chrissnell on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:04PM (#10193495)
It should be entirely up to the ISP. Consequently, the ISP's customers can judge (with their spending) whether they approve of such blocking.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by erkkie on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:42PM (#10193906)
Common carrier[0] as a concept exists for good reasons, while cloudflare is not technically required to act as one, it just makes perfect sense to not have to make a ambigious content based judgement call for each of your clients.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_carrier

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by pki on Thursday September 10, 2015 @12:01AM (#10196081)
In many many places, especially in the states there is no such thing as being able to judge with their spending because of monopolies.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chipperyman573 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:15PM (#10193594)
No they can't, at least not in America.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by erkkie on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:56PM (#10194909)
Actually they could, but they would lose their common carrier (see a sibling comment) protections.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:01PM (#10194941)
To the extent that they are not prohibited from doing so, they would also not lose common carrier status if they did. The rules applied to ISPs under Title II -- the FCC's recent Open Internet Order -- do not prohibit blocking unlawful content, only lawful content.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chrismsnz on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @07:10PM (#10195271)
On the flip side, if they were offering TLS services to these sites, they're literally man-in-the-middling encrypted comms to those sites. And in scope of US law-enforcement/intel collection.

Might be that they were asked to continue to provide services.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by duaneb on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:43PM (#10194437)
I think it's perfectly valid ISIS have a platform. Gagging angry people is not going to calm them down or prevent them from communicating.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chrissnell on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @04:51PM (#10194491)
That's not entirely true. ISIS fuels its ground combat force with angry young people recruited via predominately through social media. The social media often consists of video sharing and much of the video is served up from sites like isdarat.tv (now apparently gone) that are/were fronted by CloudFlare. YouTube and Facebook are efficient with their censoring; ISIS needs stable hosting for these videos for maximum efficacy and CF provided them with that.

Gagging these people certainly won't calm them down or stop their communication but it has a real effect on their recruitment, which is directly driving their combat operations in the Middle East and as a second-order effect, the flood of refugees to Europe.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by duaneb on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:05PM (#10194600)
Citation, please. I hugely doubt censorship has clear, measurable effect on recruitment. Among other things it's got to increase resentment of the western world.

Finally, there may be extenuating circumstances of which we aren't aware. Perhaps CloudFlare is granting them use of data in exchange for not cutting cables. When you're that big your presence is indistinguishable from the internet itself.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chrissnell on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:55PM (#10194901)
EDIT: Have a look at this: http://docs.house.gov/meetings/FA/FA18/20150127/102855/HHRG-...

I cannot readily cite any scholarly papers on this subject; this is from my observations as a frequent reader of /r/syriancivilwar, jihadology.net, and Iraq/Syria-related social media content. The typical pattern is for ISIS to release a video to their propaganda sites and for jihadist social media users to tweet the link.

al-Ḥayāt Media Center (ISIS's media outlet) relies on the ease of distribution via protected (proxied) channels to reach their large audiences. The reach of this content would be more limited if companies like CF wouldn't shield it.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by mtgx on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:28PM (#10193733)
That's doesn't sound much different than UK asking Facebook and Google to censor "extremist speech" on their platforms.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by jgrahamc on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:00PM (#10192590)
I would love to talk to you about this. jgc @ guess the domain.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by hueving on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:26PM (#10192736)
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by TheHippo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:39PM (#10192826)
He works at Cloudflare.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by nulltype on Thursday September 10, 2015 @03:23AM (#10196547)
So you're saying he's some sort of double agent.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by verelo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:14PM (#10193582)
Happy to chat, feel free to drop me a note. andrew at checkout51.com
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by MichaelApproved on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:09PM (#10192641)
Would you mind posting the types of problems you've had? I use CF for many critical websites I manage and haven't noticed any problems.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by verelo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:13PM (#10193573)
Timeouts are the majority of the issues, when our service is running perfectly fine otherwise.

They have often been short, but sometimes long enough to cause me to sit there and flip DNS for various end points away from them until the issue is resolved.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by phonon on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @06:53PM (#10195189)
I'm in financial services...as part of our checkout process, the customer downloads a 1 MB pdf with sensitive and unique data to them. In testing ( a test site with cloudflare set up), everything was fine. In production, apparently cloudflare cached these pdfs after some sort of traffic threshold was reached (I guess they are all very similar in size...though they are probably not exactly the same size.) Now customers are calling that they are getting other people's data! Apparently cloudflare caches files without even comparing hashes of the download first. Needless to say, we entirely shut off any and all caching after that.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by pipeep on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @08:55PM (#10195595)
I feel like any CDN or caching proxy (which might even happen at the ISP level if you aren't using HTTPS!) would have that same issue. You should serve confidential files from unique URLs or at least set the right HTTP headers to disable caching.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by MichaelApproved on Thursday September 10, 2015 @07:51PM (#10201257)
If CF download the file to check the hash, it wouldn't really be helpful as a caching service. That would mean CF would hit your server for each request before it served up the asset to the customer. Your server wouldn't benefit from caching. Maybe you'd get a small speed increase from their worldwide endpoints but that would reduce the advantage of having CF manage your site. One of the biggest advantages is that CF serves hits that your server wouldn't have to. That allows you to need less infrastructure.

Further, it might be better to never serve sensitive financial data via a 3rd party server. That kind of data would be best served directly to the customer's browser from your server.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by pmtarantino on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @08:55PM (#10195597)
I am almost sure you did set up this, but worth asking anyway. Was it "Cache-Control: private no-store", right?
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by codexon on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @05:32PM (#10194776)
Most of the times cloudflare is fine, they've gotten a lot better over the years.

However we have found random areas to temporarily go down for random periods of times. You will not be able to see these downtimes if you are only checking from 1 location.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by A010 on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @09:54PM (#10195786)
I don't use CF-CDN but some websites that use CF gives me 50x error because it lost connection to origin servers, but when I switch to my VPN service those websites were up. Most of the time I get errors from CF's HKG point.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by api on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @02:16PM (#10193097)
What problem does CloudFlare really solve except for DDOS?
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by foxylad on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @09:54PM (#10195790)
SSL. SSL is easy on a single server, but gets complex/expensive very fast on cloud platforms. Cloudflare have an incredibly easy solution (branded "flexible SSL") where they handle the SSL between the client and their CDN, and the CDN does un-encrypted requests to your platform.

Yes, this is a security shambles - Cloudflare is officially MITM-ing your traffic. But given the HTTPS-only movement this is a perfectly valid solution for public websites. And this announcement actually makes a big difference because if your platform is Google Cloud, then the un-encrypted portion is now over a private Cloudflare-Google interconnect.

FWIW, I've been using Cloudflare for 6 months and haven't seen any drop-outs. It's improved latency, and the only issue I've had was it mangling email addresses in transit, to prevent scrapers. It took 3 minutes to find the setting and switch it off, so I'm OK with that. Although I would prefer things that modify your HTML should be off by default.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by api on Thursday September 10, 2015 @04:54PM (#10200503)
I'm curious about the difficulties you're referring to. If you're referring to secure key distribution, check out Hashicorp's Vault project. Other than that, I can't think of any show-stoppers to deploying SSL across many commodity cloud servers.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by nly on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:03PM (#10193485)
Latency, although you can solve that through any number of CDN solutions.
Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by api on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:11PM (#10193544)
That can be solved by using a cloud service with global POPs, spinning up nodes everywhere, and using a common core config built with Chef, Puppet, or Docker. Amazon, Digital Ocean, Vultr, Linode, Joyent/Triton, and probably a half dozen others will provide global presence with instant provisioning.

Slightly more work but you control it. Cost is probably similar.

DDOS mitigation is harder and is definitely something CloudFlare does well enough to earn some market share, but wouldn't it be nice if we had a more global solution to this problem that didn't involve third party firewalls?

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by manigandham on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:51PM (#10194013)
Cost is definitely not similar. Building your own CDN network is not cheap and CloudFlare provides DNS + SSL + lots of locations + better routing + free bandwidth.

The servers, ssl and bandwidth costs alone would be more than their fees for any big site.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by chdir on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @01:07PM (#10192616)
> no longer in use on any critical/important end points

What's your recommendation as an alternative. Cloudflare is tempting if you are tight on resources due to free SSl, CDN, etc. and it is super easy to setup. I'd love to try out alternatives though, just as a backup.

Re:CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform by verelo on Wednesday September 09, 2015 @03:09PM (#10193534)
We're in the process of moving to Akamai