News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Keyboard by jacobolus on Sunday September 06, 2015 @04:39AM (#10177126)
The Datahand is a great tool for folks with severe injuries that make it painful or impossible to type on standard keyboards, but I wouldn‘t recommend them to someone healthy. Even the fastest Datahand typists I’ve seen only achieve moderately high speeds (though to be fair they can’t type on anything else, so that’s still a great boon). Sourcing used Datahands is difficult and expensive, and they have an extremely steep learning curve.

I’ve only ever tried typing on one for half a day, so don’t take what I say as gospel, but I’ve spent months thinking about keyboard shapes and hand anatomy, and my opinion is that many of the motions used by the Datahand are inherently awkward and slower to repeat or coordinate than the motions required for typing on more standard-ish keyboards. The idea is to use semi-awkward motions, but actuate with a very light touch, so that not much force is required, reducing impact shock. This is great for folks with injuries, but not the best way to optimize for healthy typists.

The standard keyboard does have significant flaws, but these can be solved in better ways, more closely aligned with human hand anatomy. Even on a standard keyboard, it’s possible to type without injury.

Here are some recommendations to help stave off RSI:

(1) Most importantly, keep your wrists as straight as you reasonably can. This is more important than any other aspect of typing technique IMO. Make sure to tilt the keyboard such that the plane of the keys is parallel to the plane of the forearms. Try using a low desk and/or a high chair and bringing the keyboard in close to the body to allow typing with the upper arms hanging down loosely instead of extending outward or forward, and the elbows at a >90° angle, with the wrists and palms floating in the air rather than resting on any surface. (2) Try to type with a springy light touch, and use only a little more force than absolutely necessary to actuate the keyswitches on whatever keyboard you use. If the keyboard is a cheap rubber dome board, and the keys must be mashed down hard to function, get a different keyboard. Mechanical keyswitches are much more comfortable for long-term typing. (3) Take brief breaks from typing every 15–30 minutes and longer breaks from sitting every hour or so. Stand up, stretch, go to the bathroom or get a fresh coffee. Walk around the block and think for a while if you want. Don’t type for 8+ hours/day if you can help it (you probably can unless you’re a data entry clerk or transcriptionist, and those jobs are getting rarer these days). (4) Try to get enough sleep, exercise, eat well, and avoid too much chronic stress.

For someone who wants something better (more efficient and more comfortable) than the standard layout:

(4) Try a split keyboard. An otherwise-standard split keyboard is a good gentle-learning-curve alternative, look up the Matias ErgoPro for the best one currently on the market. If you’re braver, try a Maltron or keyboardio. (5) Change the logical layout, try switching away from QWERTY to a layout that requires less awkward/uncomfortable motions. Most usefully, remap common functions like backspace, return, shift, escape, and arrows to more convenient locations. Add multiple layers and place common symbols and functions near the home row on a layer instead of at the far corner of the keyboard.

I could add a bunch more suggestions, but this comment is long enough for now.

Everyone come ask questions and chat on the Geekhack keyboard ergonomics forum! https://geekhack.org/index.php?board=125.0

Re:My Keyboard by patcheudor on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:27AM (#10177736)
>Try to get enough sleep, exercise, eat well, and avoid too much chronic stress.

Specifically, do exercises which strengthen your hands, wrists, and arm muscles. In my early twenties my hands and lower arms would get so sore after a day of typing that I could barely move them, with searing pain shooting up my lower arms into my wrists. I knew I had to do something quick so I focused on strength, taking up climbing and water skiing. In less than a year I was pain free & twenty years on I'm still fine.

I know guys who took other approaches like using voice to text dictation, pretty much joining "the keyboard of the month club", using funky mouses, using wrist braces, etc., but never focused on exercise. From my limited sample set, I'm the only one not wearing a wrist brace and who can still type at 100+ WPM with no pain.

Don't underestimate the benefits of strength training when it comes to solving RSI. Of course your millage may vary. I suspect that once you have the first signs of RSI you need to be on top of it before permanent damage occurs, but there's some pretty good science out there which backs up strength training when it comes to mitigating RSI.

Re:My Keyboard by melling on Sunday September 06, 2015 @11:10AM (#10177846)
Where's the science? I've collected lots of links to articles on RSI. There are anecdotes but I have never read any science.

http://thespanishsite.com/public_html/org/ergo/rsi.html

Re:My Keyboard by patcheudor on Sunday September 06, 2015 @02:22PM (#10178474)
There are numerous studies, I believe this one being foundational:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17394178

Re:My Keyboard by melling on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:11PM (#10179271)
It doesn't seem to be specific about the exact type of exercise. Any idea on what's a good upper body exercise? Push-ups, bench press, shoulder press, etc? Some people say wrist curls are good because they build up the forearms.
Re:My Keyboard by patcheudor on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:31PM (#10179502)
I stick to mostly body weight exercises plus a weight vest. I avoid the bench press like the plague. It's a good way to get hurt. Wrist curls seem to be effective. Rock climbing has worked the best for me.
Re:My Keyboard by melling on Sunday September 06, 2015 @05:17AM (#10177174)
I did a small write up on ergonomic keyboards: https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/the-model-01-an-heir...

As for RSI, there are lots of anecdotes about how to prevent and treat it. I don't think there's anything definitive. I have a large collection of notes: http://thespanishsite.com/public_html/org/ergo/rsi.html

Re:My Keyboard by muxxa on Sunday September 06, 2015 @09:08AM (#10177524)
Good to see the link to the Mind Body approach — I tried all the variations on swapping out gadgets but eventually traced it back to excess caffeine causing me to work at a much higher level of stress. As an RSI sufferer I needed to relax and realize that I'm not going to get all my goals done today, but that that's ok. It's more of a mind problem than a body problem (I know lots of computer users who spend countless hours in ergonomically catastrophic positions).
Re:My Keyboard by MichaelGG on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:34AM (#10177288)
A Sculpt with real switches. Oh what I'd pay for that! I currently use the Matias Ergo Pro, but even after months, I find myself still accidentally hitting the rearranged modifier keys. The arrow keys are annoyingly tiny, too. It's like they had a great design, then just untweaked it.

The Fn key is out of the way, making using things like the play/pause controls difficult (I never use them). The escape key is also difficult to hit. And, as expected, I've never used the Paste/Cut/Copy/Undo keys.

It's doubly annoying because the keyboard is almost all that I want, so these obvious, pointless defects are all the more hurtful. I'm not sure it actually wins against a Sculpt.

Re:My Keyboard by smoe on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:49AM (#10177313)
My personal anecdote to potentially avoid wrist problems: I never took classes in proper touch typing so I naturally evolved my “own” system over the years. My hands are placed on the standard keyboard in an angle similar to a split keyboard. My left hand rests on Capslock (bound to ctrl), w, e, f and my right on j, i, o, [.

So far I never had any problems this way but every time I try to work with my fingers on the home row, my wrist and arms immediately tell me to stop. I'm not as fast as a professional typist, but couldn't care less about mere speed as long as I'm comfortable.

Re:My Keyboard by pjmlp on Sunday September 06, 2015 @05:44AM (#10177213)
Thanks for the links.
Re:My Keyboard by amelius on Sunday September 06, 2015 @09:04AM (#10177514)
My best advice against RSI is to get rid of the mouse and get a pen-tablet instead. This change has helped me two times (I switched back to a mouse after my first switch, and got RSI back after a while; switching back to pen-tablet resolved the RSI issues again).
Re:My Keyboard by rambambam on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:18AM (#10177700)
Just something to add to your comment, I don't disagree with your suggestion: I frequently switched between a normal mouse, a Logitech Trackball (with the thumb on the ball, but I would definitely want to try one where I have to use the middle finger on the ball) and a Wacom pen-tablet. When I used one of the devices for a couple of days or weeks and when the pain (at least an annoying feeling, not necessarily pain) came back, I switched to another one.

This is not the only option to avoid or decrease pain. Like some other commenters said: your body position is important, frequent pauses away from keyboard (good for your eyes too), a smaller keyboard so your mouse is closer to the imaginary center of your body, regular walks or runs are very good (when you walk, don't wear a heavy backpack or coat, so you can move your shoulders properly and relax your core, arms, shoulders and neck even more).

At the end, it's about listening more to your body, I guess. I ignored the symptoms for too long, not knowing what was happening to me. And finally the RSI kicked in. I'm glad I didn't have CTS, but I had to recover for a couple of months and slowly had to build up the time I spent behind mouse and keyboard again.

The Body and Mind approach some other commenter talked about is also important and, I think, at the core of the problem. Relax, don't stress behind your computer and mouse/keyboard. Peace of mind translates directly to a healthier body, in all sorts of ways.

Re:My Keyboard by kps on Sunday September 06, 2015 @12:50PM (#10178153)
Most current mice seem designed to violate the straight-wrist dictum as much as humanly possible. After a few years trying several low-profile mice I've settled on a trackball, in a recessed mount placing it near keycap height.
Re:My Keyboard by collyw on Sunday September 06, 2015 @10:23AM (#10177719)
I get tight muscles down might right arm (I am assuming its from keyboard use). I can swa between left and right with the mouse. I use the mouse with my left hand, but my right hand side is tight still.