News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by transfire on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:11AM (#10109181)
Anyone notice that the media is eating this up? But let me tell you the media also lent its support to this website. I was watching CNBC a few years ago and they had the CEO of Ashley Madison on and had a great time talking about their "brilliant business model", and how great the site was. No one seemed morally repulsed then.

Well I was curious just from a business perspective (and curious how many people would actually go for it). Turns out you could not even peek at the site without giving them your email address. So I did, thinking little of it, and discovered to my surprise that is all it took to create an account. After being thoroughly unimpressed (honestly I don't even recall the site it was so lack luster) I went to delete my account only to discover they wanted $80 to do so. Well, I discovered their brilliant business model.

Far more disgusting than any individual that wound up in this data dump are the heads of this business. How have we come to accept this kind of immoral behavior on the large scale, while blanket condemning all the individuals who fell prey to their game?

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by smtddr on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:57AM (#10109695)
>>I went to delete my account only to discover they wanted $80 to do so. Well, I discovered their brilliant business model.

Hmm, so... did you pay? And if you did, have you verified your data is _not_ in the torrent dumps? It's been said that AM wasn't deleting as promised, even after paying, and that's a key part of a pending class-action-lawsuit.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by akshatpradhan on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:39PM (#10111603)
For me, its really the company Ashley Madison that's the most horrible out of all of this. Relationships are definitely high risk because they can seriously damage personal reputation.

To have a company simply not do their due diligence in providing reasonable protection is beyond incompetence and negligence. Its gross that they didn't even honor peoples' request to have their profiles deleted.

Hackers are gonna hack.

Cheaters are gonna cheat.

Haters are gonna hate.

But damn Ashley Madison, in such a high risk game, WHAT WERE YOU THINKING?

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by burnburnburn on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:22AM (#10109229)
The immoral business behavior seems to be the hackers' motivation, based on what they've written. They sought out to destroy the business. I'm guessing they'll succeed in that.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by bradleyankrom on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:43AM (#10109327)
I know the sample Troy showed may not be representative of the whole, but I think there are a lot of users, outside of tech, that aren't aware of the breach.

There is a comment somewhere -- maybe it's from the article, I can't remember -- expressing surprise that the AM home page doesn't acknowledge the breach at all. I would imagine that they are still receiving signups from folks who aren't following this story.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by lemevi on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:19AM (#10109490)
Those Ashley Madison users that aren't aware of the breach, or with families that are not aware are still possibly going to be targets of people will use the data to blackmail them. That is there may be a large number of AM users who will be made aware of it one way or another. If there is enough personally identifiable information in the dumps, strangers on the internet are going to use it as their personal piggy bank and send mass emails out to threaten whomever they find with black mail. They'll say "Send me $1,000 or I'll tell your spouse" and they'll keep doing it. Apparently home address and phone numbers are in the dumps for some members.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by ceejayoz on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:10AM (#10109454)
You'd think they'd at least change the "Over 39,470,000 anonymous members!" bit. If nothing else, to avoid being sued for false/deceptive advertising.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by hyperpape on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:57AM (#10109700)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Avenger42 on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:50AM (#10110198)
Mike Masnick of Techdirt also got signed up post-breach: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150820/16523632021/day-s...
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by bradleyankrom on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:31AM (#10110016)
"Internet dating consultancy"

what a world

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by powertower on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:11PM (#10110817)
If I recall correctly, the hackers wrote that they where morally outraged that AM was charging the users a deletion fee, and not deleting their data.

Except by releasing the users data, it clearly shows their motivation is more against the users, then any shady business practices.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by stcredzero on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:38PM (#10111059)
No reason why they can't be against both groups, and are just killing two birds with one stone.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by jahnu on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:44AM (#10110140)
There are now two suspected suicides due to this.

http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34044506

Terribly sad and deeply disturbing.

Imagine what will happen the first time a government's database of all the sites we are visiting is leaked.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by pjc50 on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:40AM (#10110568)
Note that a location tracking database would probably give you enough information to determine who's actively cheating. All the big 3 (Microsoft, Google, Apple) plus the cell phone companies have this data.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by drzaiusapelord on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:28AM (#10109991)
>How have we come to accept this kind of immoral behavior on the large scale

Cheating is legal and doesn't affect me a customer. Its crazy that an entrepreneur forum is obsessed with exposing these men and women. Not too long ago, my dad's generation were saying "A company run by a gay? I'd never do business with such a morally bankrupt pervert!" Meanwhile, my own bosses have said things like, "Hire someone who smokes pot? Well, we don't hire immoral criminals here! Now piss in this cup."

Now here we are, again. Maybe we should just stop moving the goalposts and understand that what people do privately is their own fucking business. I don't care how many affairs you've had. I just care about the value proposition. I hate how cheating makes everyone a moralist and a biblethumper, when they otherwise have secular liberal values. I hate this entitlement and culture of shame it brings out in people who should know better.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Frondo on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:57AM (#10110713)
I care about cheating because it tells me that the person is OK with lying to people close to them. If they're OK lying to their spouse, my concern is that they're also OK lying to a customer.

If people want to have an open marriage or practice polyamory, fine, that's entirely up to them.

The deception is the thing here that is problematic.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by betenoire on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:42PM (#10111100)
And how do you know which is which? If you see a name that you recognize that used AM, do you ask them to clarify which bucket they belong in, or do you just assign them one yourself?
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Frondo on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:42PM (#10112489)
The site, as far as I know, bills itself as a place to find cheating partners.

The poly people I know seem to have their own places for finding potential relationship partners. The poly people I know are also all quite open about their relationship choices.

If I saw a name I recognized on Ashley Madison, I'd assume they wanted to cheat and keep that hidden from their partners.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by betenoire on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:45PM (#10112501)
And that's my point. You get to pick how you judge them, and you do. You don't hire cheaters, I don't hire judgers. To each his own.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by drzaiusapelord on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:59AM (#10110735)
What about closeted gays and others who are forced to be deceptive? I lie about my religious views because you can't be an atheist where I'm at. etc, etc. There's so much white-lying going on that its ridiculous to hold it up to some standard or pretend it means anything.

>my concern is that they're also OK lying to a customer.

This is ridiculous. Do you really think the CEO's sex life translates directly to the product? Do you even understand what a CEO does?

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Frondo on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:25PM (#10110947)
I think very few people would consider cheating on one's spouse or partner to be a form of white lying.

I also do business with a lot more people where I'm doing business with the owner themselves. If I'm looking someone in the eye and shaking their hand to do a deal, and then they turn around and lie to their spouse (someone they ostensibly owe a lot more to than me), that's hard for me to reconcile.

Maybe you don't care, and that's fine. I do. I find it hard to trust people who cheat. Why would I be treated differently or better than a spouse? (Again, open marriage/polyamory/whatever is a different story.)

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by drzaiusapelord on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:11PM (#10111359)
All the CEOs I'd consider "evil" have been faithful from what I can tell. You're making an argument you can't support for reasons that seem 100% emotionally hysterical to me.

"Look at other women?! I'm not buying his product!" This is no different than "A Hindu running a company? No thank you sir! I only go with good honest Christian men!"

In a large company the CEO does little more than attract investor money and recruit senior leadership, if that. The idea that his sex lies are going directly in your software is hilariously puritanical.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Frondo on Monday August 24, 2015 @02:27PM (#10111990)
I do not find people who cheat on their spouses or partners trustworthy. That is my argument. You can feel differently. Calling my argument hysterical or unsupported makes me think you don't know what those words mean.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by stcredzero on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:41PM (#10111097)
I care about cheating because it tells me that the person is OK with lying to people close to them.

Then you should care about marijuana users and people in repressive regimes who import contraband media and news for in the same way for the same reasons.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Frondo on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:54PM (#10112563)
I don't have to, actually.

People who enter into monogamous relationships can get one set of "this is what counts as honesty" rules w.r.t. what they owe their spouses (i.e. don't cheat).

People who are born into and live in repressive regimes can get a different set of "this is what counts as honesty" (i.e. some law is unjust and therefore can be broken).

Funnily enough, though, sometimes I do hear of people breaking laws that makes me think they're less trustworthy, too. Like a guy I know who wants to try and get a handicapped parking placard even though he isn't handicapped. You know, those spots are supposed to be for people who really can't walk that far, and he wants to try and grab one because of the convenience. That's a trivial example, and dumb, but when I hear that I think, there's a guy who wants to rip off the system in a small way, but one that could hurt people who actually need it.

So it's not like "here is one conception of honesty that I have to apply everywhere, mechanically and without human reasoning." Human life is more nuanced than that.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by LesZedCB on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:32AM (#10110028)
As a successful polyamorous person, I find the whole thing kind of amusing.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by iso8859-1 on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:27AM (#10110476)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by logfromblammo on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:46AM (#10110616)
From the article:

" In the United States, laws vary from state to state. Up until the mid 20th century most US states (especially Southern and Northeastern states) had laws against fornication, adultery or cohabitation. These laws have gradually been abolished or struck down by courts as unconstitutional.[138][139][140]"

If the law making it illegal is unconstitutional, it's legal.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by iso8859-1 on Monday August 24, 2015 @05:37PM (#10113057)
Did you see the bit about Michigan? Here is the current law: http://legislature.mi.gov/doc.aspx?mcl-777-16a
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by FireBeyond on Monday August 24, 2015 @07:39PM (#10113494)
The US Supreme Court has ruled that any relationship between consenting adults is legal, and that any laws against the same are unconstitutional. (2003, Lawrence v Texas) This applied in this case to homosexuality, but the Supreme Court's ruling didn't limit the interpretation.

No politician wants to be the one who says "I propose a bill to make adultery legal. It's not an issue for the courts." There have been less that a dozen misdemeanor prosecutions in the last half century in those 21 states combined. So yes, in those states, it's illegal. Unconstitutionally so. Just as in many cases, so was homosexuality, and anal sex.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by 3pt14159 on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:41AM (#10110115)
You need to be far more paranoid. When Ashley Madison's parent company tried to hire me I obviously said "no", but I also became curious about their site from a different perspective (I wanted to check out their technology). But I created a one time use email address to check it out.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by logfromblammo on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:40AM (#10110565)
Sometimes, I even use nonce email addresses with non-vice-based businesses. For anything potentially embarrassing or blackmailable, I believe I would have to create an entirely separate and strictly segregated identity for each one, even just for "evaluation".

Practically everyone has had a data breach by now. It's well past time to start acquiring data-protection habits to practice before going out on the Internet.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by 3pt14159 on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:58AM (#10110729)
I'm going to tell my kids I'm logging everything they do on the internet. I'm also not going to let them get a credit card. If they find a way of buying a VPN with Bitcoins then I'll figure that they are old enough to suffer the ramifications of not being paranoid.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by kzhahou on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:30PM (#10111000)
Indeed. Only a matter of time before reddit and hackernews get dumped. That's be fun (esp. reddit)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by kolinko on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:30PM (#10110997)
that's what mailinator.com is :)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by TeMPOraL on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:32AM (#10109542)
Dealing with media is like dealing with demons - they'll give you great fame and riches beyond belief, but once you're known to them, they'll happily throw you under the bus to further their own interests. Media outlets are not your friends, they don't care about you at all. They have their own agendas.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by gnufied on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:57AM (#10109701)
To be completely fair, internet industry as a whole is hell bent on keeping users in, rather than letting them delete their accounts. The other day, I was trying to delete my Steam account and I couldn't find a way to do that and Valve happens to be one of the most respectable company on earth.

I don't know what will change attitude of our industry. I guess lot of us are still stuck with mindset of real-world brick/mortor shops - if you don't want do anything with Shop X just don't go there! Sadly this does not really work for loads of internet services. Perhaps we need a legislation like Right to Forget (I am not endorsing EU law fwiw).

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Symmetry on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:44AM (#10110139)
That's one of the things I really like about Google, that they have a team that's explicitly working to make it easier to take your data out and move to a different service.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Data_Liberation_Front

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by pjc50 on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:46AM (#10110156)
.. and delete it from Google afterwards?
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by myko on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:27PM (#10110965)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by pjc50 on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:44PM (#10111122)
I can't find on either of those pages specific text relating to deletion?
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by myko on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:56PM (#10111222)
"Said simply, a liberated product is one which has built-in features that make it easy (and free) to remove your data from the product in the event that you'd like to take it elsewhere"

"For example, you can choose to have your data deleted — after three, six, nine or 12 months of inactivity."

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by bitJericho on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:58AM (#10110263)
Not in a million years
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by SXX on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:24AM (#10109956)
Let's say fair you shouldn't expect to have account removal on Steam because it's would be abused as hell: family conflicts, script kiddies, "friends" "jokes", etc.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by akshatpradhan on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:38AM (#10110084)
We shouldn't expect the ability for Steam to honor a request to remove our accounts because that ability could be abused by family conflicts, friends and jokes?
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by SXX on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:13AM (#10110367)
Yes because it's nearly impossible to check if it's actually you request removal and not somebody else. Otherwise Steam would have to keep your account data on servers anyway so there is no point in removal procedure.

Considering Steam don't ask about any of your personal information (and you can pay using PayPal or even "offline" wallet codes) I would suspect that such feature will be used more for harm than good.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by gnufied on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:23AM (#10110444)
Wait, why do we need special requests for Steam account removal? I would login and delete my account (and as a result immediately logged out I suppose). Steam uses two factor authentication for login and unless someone has got hold of your Steam password and email password, you should be safe.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by pjc50 on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:42AM (#10110588)
And what happens when you want to undelete your account, because it was deleted by someone else who had access to your computer? (This will happen)

Would deleting an account enable the associated Steam keys (physical or electronic) to be reused? Or is deleting an account equivalent to putting all your games in a pile and burning them?

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by SXX on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:50AM (#10110658)
Two-factor authentication with email doesn't actually help to average user at all. When Steam account password is stolen then email password is likely too.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Karunamon on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:34AM (#10110522)
Valve is known for asking for PII for things such as recovering accounts that have been hacked (to wit: fax in your driver's license or other photo id and a physical CD key from one of your registered games)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by SXX on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:52AM (#10110674)
In same time Steam support accounts are completely independent from Steam store accounts. Anyway my point is: Steam is not dating website or social network that collect tons of your personal information.

By not having account deletion procedure they don't hurt anyone's privacy, but just save average user from one more possible pain in ass for no reason (because they wouldn't be able to delete accounts for real anyway).

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by gnufied on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:31PM (#10112437)
For majority of users who use any kind of ingame purchase (dota, TF2 hats) - Steam stores credit card information etc. I know one can pay using Paypal but I dunno how many users use that option. So, Steam does store personal information of users period. It is not very different from any other service.

On other hand, allowing users to delete their accounts can help with kicking serious gaming addiction. It usually takes time before you can level up a new account for playing at skill levels you were. Part of me thinks, Valve does not allow deletion of accounts precisely because of this.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Karunamon on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:57PM (#10112593)
Nah.

Valve only runs two games that meet that description, TF2 and DOTA2, and "resetting your progress" is as easy as burning all your items.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by SXX on Monday August 24, 2015 @06:33PM (#10113290)
Saving of credit card information is optional on and it's can be removed with one click. There no big difference between trust service that it's going to remove this data or whole account.

And idea that some people going to remove somebody else account to "help with gaming addition" is good reason to not implement removal.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by sp332 on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:47AM (#10109636)
And the media right now seems to be focused on the contents of the dump instead of the hackers who dumped it, or the ethics of dumping it, or the trouble of AM having all this data in the first place let alone unsecured.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by smtddr on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:52AM (#10109652)
The scandals this data leakage reveal are way too tantalizing for anyone to care how it all happened to begin with. Most of the twitter posts have applied their morals/ethics/whatever, replaced the word "hackers" with "karma" and are happy this happened.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by EyeballKid on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:48PM (#10111668)
That kind of site appears to be soooo easy to get media coverage for. I wrote a blog post a couple of years back covering a similar UK-based site and how good they were at getting stories planted in the papers. Those free-loving libertines at the Daily Mail especially seem to lap it up :-)

http://unsourced.org/blog/illicit-sex-and-free-advertising.h...

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by nsajko on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:14AM (#10109198)
Was that even legal?
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by pluma on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:23AM (#10109234)
Not in the EU.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by inversionOf on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:41AM (#10109318)
No one seemed morally repulsed then.

The single and only reason Ashley Madison got media attention -- and they got plenty (morning radio in the Southern Ontario space just loved bringing them up) is that it was salacious: The whole premise of a site to arrange affairs is just very "click baity", and it's sure to draw attention.

Ashley Madison played those cards brilliantly, turning their entrant in a hyper competitive dating site market into a newsworthy, edgy find an affair site.

But that same gambit also means that if you fail, many want to see you fail big, exactly the same motivations drawing media.

There is no hypocrisy or dual standards here. Site is newsworthy for its market, and it's newsworthy for success, and even more for failures.