News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @11:36AM (#10086223)
Legally stealing includes the concept "taking with the intention to permanently deprive". The concept of stealing revolves around physical goods not intellectual property. What he did is not stealing (and if you attempted to charge him with theft you would lose in court). The crime is copyright violation not theft. Please be accurate when you are being patronising.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by sbuk on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @07:34PM (#10089235)
By taking the license without paying for it, he has permanently deprived AllSIM from the license revenue, ergo it was stolen. And drop the ad hominem. You are attacking me and the manner that you interpreted my statement, it has no bearing on the discussion.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by tripzilch on Saturday August 22, 2015 @08:39AM (#10102334)
> By taking the license without paying for it

What do you think a software license is?

A physical piece of paper or something?

The student didn't "take" a license, if he could have, and did, there would not even have been a case because he would have had a license!

For clarity, not attacking you, just pointing out your completely inaccurate view of intellectual property law, with the intention that other people may not get any ideas this is actually how copyright works.

But don't worry, I won't call you out for being patronizing, not when you're the one being taught.

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @08:06PM (#10089347)
You are assuming that there would have license revenue, that is, that there would have been a sale. In this case that's possible; in many cases that's completely false (maybe even in the majority of cases).

So the "stolen" word is a strange word for an act which leaves the owner with the goods, and does not cost the owner a sale that they otherwise would have had.

What it is, though, is taking the owner's software in violation of the owner's terms. That's immoral (arguably), and definitely illegal. What it isn't, though, is stealing in the historic meaning of the term. (Though that may not be a valid argument, as uses of words change with time and new circumstances...)

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:28AM (#10090261)
Further to this. Theft has a clear legal meaning. For example in the UK stealing a car is technically difficult to prove since proving intent to permanently deprive is not very easy. This does not stop a law against taking a car without the owners consent which is then punished appropriately.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by sbuk on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:28AM (#10096490)
Erm, no.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:50AM (#10096540)
Well a few minutes with google and wikipedia will set you straight on this. Actually that your legally wrong insistence that copyright infringement is theft actually damages your copyright maximalist stance in the eyes of both legal precedent and public opinion. NB I don't argue that copyright infringement should be legal -- merely that is is a different class of crime than theft.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by sbuk on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:14AM (#10098033)
I have first hand experience of your car theft analogy, my car was stolen and, luckily enough for me, recovered along with the thieves. They were successfully prosecuted. You are, yet again, wrong.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:54AM (#10098308)
You are quite slow to grasp simple concepts aren't you.

The car theft example is not an analogy it is a fact. I never said that taking a car is legal. However, the crime is "taking without permission" not "theft" (although it is I admit often referred to as theft in common parlance). This is because theft has a clear long standing meaning which for various reasons is often difficult to establish for cars. Therefore a new type of crime (which happens to have the same punishment) was created.

The point about how stupid you copyright maximalists sound to the general public when about software 'theft' stands. You weaken you position when you do so and make yourselves subject to ridicule.

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:04PM (#10099884)
You're violating the site guidelines egregiously. We ban accounts for this. Please don't do it again.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:42AM (#10101940)
I'm sorry that I violated the guidelines but can you enlighten me as to which part of this post violated which guideline?
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by dang on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:10PM (#10103388)
"You are quite slow to grasp simple concepts" violates "Be civil."
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:14PM (#10103615)
Did you read some of the stuff that she posted to me elsewhere in this article?
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by sbuk on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:56PM (#10098771)
Wow.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:07PM (#10098848)
Did it blow your mind when you understood something for a change?
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by sbuk on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:40PM (#10099047)
Your comment ought to be flagged, but for some reason cannot be done by me. You have gone too far. Not only are you wrong, you are being obnoxious, rude and cowardly. I guarantee that you wouldn't dare speak like that to anyone you were in front of. Just another cowardly nerd hiding behind a screen.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by dang on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:06PM (#10099896)
Users can't flag or downvote direct replies.

You're right that what that user did was not ok. Unfortunately comments like this one just compound the problem. When you can't flag a comment, someone else probably will. Or you can email us at [email protected]. But please resist getting into a personal spat.

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:43AM (#10101944)
Dang. sbuk has repeatedly insulted me and sworn at me during this discussion. I do not understand how what she is saying is OK when what I say is not?

Additionally I have attempted to be reconciliatory during this discussion whereas she has only been confrontational.

I'm sorry that I eventually got slightly annoyed.

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by dang on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:17PM (#10103407)
Everyone in this thread was at fault. You can't post things like "Did it blow your mind when you understood something for a change" here. HN's rules hold regardless of how provocative someone else may have been.

We all lose it on the internet sometimes. On HN the thing to do is recognize that you broke the rules, stop blaming the other person for it, and move on.

The I-merely defense ("I was merely X-ing, but they were Y-ing") doesn't work. You can, and people do, justify anything that way.

Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:16PM (#10103619)
Right but you have warned me with a ban and given her very little rebuke.
Re:Do you have 30k CHF pocket money? by JupiterMoon on Saturday August 22, 2015 @10:25AM (#10102573)
Please re-read my comments on this thread and others on this article you will find that I've actually been very patiently trying to explain some simple concepts -- to someone that repeatedly swore, accused me of criminal activity, wilfully misinterpreted me and raged at me. I said nothing that I would not have said IRL even when I did eventually descend to sarcasm in respond to the personal attacks.

Good luck in your future endeavours.